Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 15/09/2021 19:23

Private schools absolutely do use these techniques. Ofsted are looking for such techniques. It has been done poorly in the OP's example but all these posters expressing their disgust at the practice of peers teaching peers are doing so from a place of ignorance. Studies and professional practice consistently show that there are many benefits, and most people with actual knowledge of pedagogy (rather than a lay opinion) understand this.

For your sake I will ignore the cringeworthy attempt at hauteur.

No private school I ever went to, my kids have ever been to or my siblings’ kids or my friends’ kids. As one off once a term it probably wouldn’t kill anyone - but as standard practice - parents would hit the roof.

We’ve all been the classroom, all experienced different teachers and teaching techniques, and we’re all entitled to our own opinions.

Fwiw my mother is retired head teacher with 60 years teaching experience and she is as opposed to this as I am. Nothing to do with teaching experience, simply perspective.

Artichokeleaves · 15/09/2021 19:20

There are benefits. Including the ones about learning to be kind, and to help others. However as evidenced by many posters here, and like many teaching techniques, when over used or badly used without care and consideration for both children's experience, it can teach boredom, frustration and resistance instead, and turn the more able child wholly off. As seen here, one poster has had to advise her child to pretend to be busy and to give the appearance of not finishing so as her child can avoid this repeatedly unwanted, unrewarding experience which has become an endurance test.

The teacher may have a lot of ideas of what your child is getting out of this, OP. It may be time to talk to them about what your child feels they are getting out of it, and that there's stress and frustration involved which shouldn't be a penalty for more able learners.

DeepaBeesKit · 15/09/2021 19:04

It is common and happened to me repeatedly in primary school. Teachers will justify this as being a learning experience in it's own right, this is often an excuse when it is happening constantly and always to a child in the class who also happens to need extra support.

It's ok to use explaining work as a learning exercise sometimes. How you can spot a teacher using it inappropriately is they always be explaining it to someone much less able. Its just a valid to be explaining to an equally able peer, especially as that equally able peer may be better able to challenge the explanation so that both pupils get a lot from the exercise.

Sadly the national floor type learning measures mean that teachers main aim has to be getting the least able up to a minimum standard - closing the gap, if you will. But to "close the gap" requires the least able to make more rapid progress than the most able. Unlikely long term, given the natural aptitude of the more able, and therefore is basically only possible if the more able make relatively poor progress against their own potential.

Herja · 15/09/2021 18:31

I was this person in school. Consolidation was fine, when the other student was willing to listen/learn and try - doesn't work so well when they won't (as seems the case for OPs child).

I solved it in the end in two ways: just gave them the right answers or pretended to be struggling myself and sat day dreaming. I considerably prefered secondary where there were streamed classes and appropriate extension work...

Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 18:31

Most schools have libraries

No, they don’t. They really don’t.

Coronawireless · 15/09/2021 18:30

[quote MrsSebastianstan]@Coronawireless meanwhile here on Earth, most 9yr olds can’t just get up and get on the computer for a random search, get another set of worksheets/books out and start them, go over to their pal who has a different problem to swap, nip out for a book, or start dissecting a mouse or whatever extends them without the teacher saying they can….

The size of the bollocks spouted is Nicki Minaj’s cousins’ friend level….[/quote]
Don’t be ridiculous - they could just bring in a book of their choice of any topic to read. Most schools have libraries.
Anyway apologies for derailing the OP. I agree that peer teaching can be beneficial but not if it’s abused.

Nellle · 15/09/2021 18:29

Helping the other child IS the extension task.

After a we learn to do something, conveying or teaching that skill to another person consolidates and deepens our learning. The learning is also more likely to embed in the our long term memory when we do this.

I imagine your child's teacher knows this, since they are doing it routinely and with a number of students. In fact, if you email the school I wouldn't be surprised if you're told that this is a whole school policy based on pedagogical research.

Because you know, it's their job to understand how children learn and how to plan lessons...

Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 18:25

If it was due to lack of classroom helpers, wouldn’t it be much easier to fling an easy task at everyone to spare time?

Why do peer learning when they could all just colour in? Who’d know?

FoxgloveSummers · 15/09/2021 18:25

Totally agree @TatianaBis. I've got clear memories of being bored stiff in some classes having completed the work. I wasn't allowed to pop to the library or - I dunno - bring up a flipping opera on YouTube or start teaching myself Czech. I was firmly expected to sit down and shut up until the teacher told me what else to do. Some teachers let me read (either openly or under the desk) when I'd finished if they didn't have another activity or time to suggest something, that's good too.

Holskey · 15/09/2021 18:25

@TatianaBis

The reason schools are adopting this imo is because the classes are too big and there aren’t enough TAs. They give it poncy labels like peer to peer teaching but that’s the bottom line.

Teaching is a skill and it has to be learned and refined over time. Just because a child understands a topic doesn’t mean he will be particularly good at explaining it.

A child should never be made responsible for teaching another child, it’s too big a burden, it could be stressful and upsetting. And of course it takes precious time away from their own learning.

You don’t see private schools doing this - rightly so because the parents of both children would complain. Parents are not paying good money for their child to be taught be another child, or for their child to have to teach another child.

Personally, I’d tackle the school and if that doesn’t work change schools.

Private schools absolutely do use these techniques. Ofsted are looking for such techniques. It has been done poorly in the OP's example but all these posters expressing their disgust at the practice of peers teaching peers are doing so from a place of ignorance. Studies and professional practice consistently show that there are many benefits, and most people with actual knowledge of pedagogy (rather than a lay opinion) understand this.
toystoyseverywhere · 15/09/2021 18:23

I would definitely not be feeling comfortable with this happening.

When my oldest was in primary other children were expected to help her with her classwork. One in particular. It was not helpful for anyone as my oldest didn't understand the work and it can obviously be frustrating for the child expected to help and to be expected to be able to break things down and essentially help the child needing help to learn.

It had been happening due to the massive reluctance for additional classroom helpers and the obvious issue of not enough funding to provide additional help such as another PSA or even to provide one in the first place.

I don't feel it should be happening as it can and does cause issues between children which is to be expected.

Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 18:14

@TatianaBis

A lot of schools are now adopting a Mastery approach in maths where the aim is for the more able children to explore each topic deeply and widely rather than racing to the next thing as soon as they’ve grasped one topic at a superficial level

Students don’t need to teach other children to consolidate their learning. All teachers should consolidate topics before moving on to the next, and regularly review topics already covered. There are many ways of refining and applying knowledge that doesn’t involve teaching another child.

Helping Jaxxon with long division is of no benefit if you already know how to do long division.

It is though - helping Jaxxon helps you understand how he uses numbers, which chances are is different to yours. For example: some people add 26 + 37 by making both up to the nearest 10, then subtracting the additions. Some round down. Some add 6+7, then 20 + 30.

That’s mastery in maths - not just getting the answer but understanding all the ways to get to the answer, and understanding what the numbers actually mean. It’s a really brilliant thing, and I’d love to see it adopted in more schools.

MrsSebastianstan · 15/09/2021 18:09

@Coronawireless meanwhile here on Earth, most 9yr olds can’t just get up and get on the computer for a random search, get another set of worksheets/books out and start them, go over to their pal who has a different problem to swap, nip out for a book, or start dissecting a mouse or whatever extends them without the teacher saying they can….

The size of the bollocks spouted is Nicki Minaj’s cousins’ friend level….

TatianaBis · 15/09/2021 18:07

But most bright children and their parents won’t expect the teacher to divert attention away from the other kids to spend time “extending” them

Well they should. And if they’re not getting it it’s not the right school for them.

Akire · 15/09/2021 18:06

I would tell your child to take their time and never look like have finished earlier. Doesn't help the other child if they sit there for 20min because can’t understand the work then try do all their work in last 5min of the lesson. Imagine doing this in office everyday, get your work done then have to try sort someone else’s out.

TatianaBis · 15/09/2021 18:06

A lot of schools are now adopting a Mastery approach in maths where the aim is for the more able children to explore each topic deeply and widely rather than racing to the next thing as soon as they’ve grasped one topic at a superficial level

Students don’t need to teach other children to consolidate their learning. All teachers should consolidate topics before moving on to the next, and regularly review topics already covered. There are many ways of refining and applying knowledge that doesn’t involve teaching another child.

Helping Jaxxon with long division is of no benefit if you already know how to do long division.

Coronawireless · 15/09/2021 18:01

Honestly, if your child just sits there and expects someone to hand them something to do instead of moving ahead themselves they are firmly in the middle.

MsTSwift · 15/09/2021 18:00

A lot of these words sound like jargon (collaborative learning🙄) and a way of lumping on the more able kids 🙄.

We had this with a child with anxiety ok happy to help but ended up massively affecting dd2 she was missing lessons and other activities she enjoyed to sit with this child - daily! Child’s mother was extremely assertive and school were utterly focussed on her and her child’s needs dd2 was collateral. I went politely mental and school immediately backed down and apologised. I feel sorry for the kids with unaware parents - you need to go into bat for your own child in these situations.

Coronawireless · 15/09/2021 17:59

But most bright children and their parents won’t expect the teacher to divert attention away from the other kids to spend time “extending” them.
The exception is children whose home environment won’t allow them to learn. I would hope a teacher would pick this up but I don’t think that’s what the parents n this thread are complaining about.

TatianaBis · 15/09/2021 17:59

The reason schools are adopting this imo is because the classes are too big and there aren’t enough TAs. They give it poncy labels like peer to peer teaching but that’s the bottom line.

Teaching is a skill and it has to be learned and refined over time. Just because a child understands a topic doesn’t mean he will be particularly good at explaining it.

A child should never be made responsible for teaching another child, it’s too big a burden, it could be stressful and upsetting. And of course it takes precious time away from their own learning.

You don’t see private schools doing this - rightly so because the parents of both children would complain. Parents are not paying good money for their child to be taught be another child, or for their child to have to teach another child.

Personally, I’d tackle the school and if that doesn’t work change schools.

Coronawireless · 15/09/2021 17:58

@AGreenerShadeofKale

Why not stay home and learn off the internet if self extending is that obvious? I mean who needs teachers, right?😏
Teachers are needed to teach the national curriculum and to help children with aspects of it that they find difficult. Very bright children with no learning disability won’t find most of the curriculum difficult. So in fact yes they could learn at home if their social circumstances permitted it. Most bright children I imagine would still prefer to learn at school because that’s where they make friends, play sports, do drama etc
simonthedog · 15/09/2021 17:51

I never felt this was helpful to my DD. She did not need to consolidate her knowledge of the work, it was way too easy for her. Especially every lesson. She was bored.

TheWinterSmoulder · 15/09/2021 17:46

I had this as a child too, put next to a girl who didn’t speak English because I was the bright one at English. Found concentrating very difficult with the constant interruptions from her and trying to explain things in the middle of lessons so therefore missing the next bit myself.
She was a lovely girl from China, anxious to do well but totally bemused and unable to keep up. I also had the fun of her trailing after me at breaks/lunchtimes as it was obviously hard for her to make friends - and hard for me to see my own friends.
Agree wholeheartedly that ‘see one do one teach one’ is great and can be really helpful, I’m sure I did learn about her culture, English etc but it’s not good when it’s all the time.

If OP’s DC can change seats and do this once a week then that would probably be very positive for him. This sounds too onerous, and the learning objectives unclear, the task ill-defined. I’m sure he’s learning about how not to do delegation….

Maverick197 · 15/09/2021 17:43

This happened to my dd. She was asked to sit next to a ds who was struggling and the teacher expected my dd to help him with his work. At first dd was flattered, but as time went on she felt that it was an energy suck. DH and I raised this with the school. They changed the seating arrangements and dd could get on with her own learning.

SilverGlassHare · 15/09/2021 17:43

@PaperDolphin

Peer learning is a tried and tested way of consolidating the learning of both children. It deepens the learning of the child doing the teaching, putting it in their long term memory. Lots of research done on it. His teacher is trained in pedagogy to at least a post-graduate level so it's quite safe to assume the same can be said of all strategies they use in the classroom. In the nicest possible way, I would focus on your job and let them focus on theirs.
She is focusing on her job - her job as a mother is to make sure her child is happy and not miserable and strained by doing a thankless task with an unwilling peer. Peer-to-peer learning is fine as an occasional thing with willing children, and this isn’t it.
Swipe left for the next trending thread