Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
BFCfairy · 15/09/2021 20:36

If it everytime that's not great for either child. Both need extra support in different ways so talk to school. Make sure your ds is challenged.

My ds gets the extra challenges if finished early but also takes pride in helping others. Will help with his ability to understand and explain rather than just doing it if that makes sense. He is in y5 also.

Makes me proud too that he wants to help... so it's a balance

hibbledibble · 15/09/2021 20:36

Yanbu. I had this at school, and in reflection it was because the teacher couldn't be bothered to teach either the most or least able. It's easy to 'pair them up' and forget about them.

My daughter also had this at school. While she is very able, she doesn't have the patience to teach another child. I asked gently for it to be changed.

Brevet1000 · 15/09/2021 20:34

*effect

Brevet1000 · 15/09/2021 20:34

I was used by the teachers in this way at secondary school.
I learnt things very quickly so got put in groups with considerably less able children than myself.
I was expected to teach them e.g. doing group science experiments. Unfortunately they required so much additional explanation / help that I ended up:
(a) not actually understanding or hearing what all of what we were supposed to be doing
(b) not finishing the experiments because they were so slow
(c) doing it on my own and not teaching them because of (b)
(d) still having problems because there was more than one persons' work to do
This went on for months.
Coupled with other children bullying me to answer their classwork and homework, it made school utterly miserable.
Oh and one of my 'pupils' kept not bringing any pens, pencils, paper etc to school so the teacher made me share mine. Everytime the child tried to take my stuff home, so eventually my parents made up a bag of stationary to give the child, which I did.
The next week, all the stuff had gone, child turned up with nothing. Teacher told me to share and I refused.

The solution was to move schools so I could actually learn rather than teach. So although I understand in prescriptive and clearly defined ways, this could be useful, I would be worried about the affect it is having on your child.

Nellle · 15/09/2021 20:34

@TatianaBis

After a we learn to do something, conveying or teaching that skill to another person consolidates and deepens our learning. The learning is also more likely to embed in the our long term memory when we do this.

Not necessarily. It may already be in your long term memory if you know it thoroughly. There are many things that if you already know, teaching someone else won’t help, like times tables or a language or a practical skill.

What consolidates learning is memorisation, review, and using and applying it in different ways.

That last bit - I agree and I absolutely think peer teaching requires you to repeat (which helps to memorise), review, use and apply what you've learnt in a new way.
Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 20:33

@peaceanddove

helping Jaxxon helps you understand how he's using numbers

Well, presumably Jaxxon is using numbers incorrectly so best not to learn anything from him really.

We had this when DD2 was in Yr5, constantly being used as an unpaid TA during maths lessons. She resented it and found it boring having to explain the same stuff several times over. In the end I had to speak to her teacher who told me that 'teaching' others was a useful skill to learn. I pointed out that DD2 didn't want to learn to be a teacher, she wanted to learn how to do more challenging maths. It didn't go down well [shrugs]

I actually think that her Yr5 teacher wasn't that confident at doing more challenging maths with DD2, because soon after DD2 attended some lessons at a neighbouring school to prep for the maths SATs because they had a teacher there happy to teach Level 6 maths (and beyond).

Surely if she wanted to do more challenging maths then learning why people couldn’t do something she found easy would be a good place to start? She could have relearned it (mastery, remember?) which is an incredible skill to learn.

Why couldn’t you learn anything from fake Jaxxon? You might learn he counts in base 8. Do you know how to do that?

Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 20:31

@TatianaBis

It’s a studied method for consolidation. We have evidence to show it works. It’s not an opinion if it works or not.

Of course it’s an opinion - if you actually listened to the posters on the thread roped into it - they are saying it didn’t work for them - or by extension the kids they taught.

How do you think children in private schools learn in 2021? Rote?

Seriously? You think it’s rote or p2p teaching??

Missed the first bit - it does work though. The people who say it didn’t work for their kid don’t understand what was happening. They think their kid was drafted in to play teacher, and that’s not correct.
peaceanddove · 15/09/2021 20:30

helping Jaxxon helps you understand how he's using numbers

Well, presumably Jaxxon is using numbers incorrectly so best not to learn anything from him really.

We had this when DD2 was in Yr5, constantly being used as an unpaid TA during maths lessons. She resented it and found it boring having to explain the same stuff several times over. In the end I had to speak to her teacher who told me that 'teaching' others was a useful skill to learn. I pointed out that DD2 didn't want to learn to be a teacher, she wanted to learn how to do more challenging maths. It didn't go down well [shrugs]

I actually think that her Yr5 teacher wasn't that confident at doing more challenging maths with DD2, because soon after DD2 attended some lessons at a neighbouring school to prep for the maths SATs because they had a teacher there happy to teach Level 6 maths (and beyond).

Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 20:30

@TatianaBis

It’s a studied method for consolidation. We have evidence to show it works. It’s not an opinion if it works or not.

Of course it’s an opinion - if you actually listened to the posters on the thread roped into it - they are saying it didn’t work for them - or by extension the kids they taught.

How do you think children in private schools learn in 2021? Rote?

Seriously? You think it’s rote or p2p teaching??

Yes. I think it’s rote learning - which we know doesn’t result in understanding. Or methods like peer support that we know does.
Holskey · 15/09/2021 20:28

@TatianaBis

Private schools absolutely do use these techniques. Ofsted are looking for such techniques. It has been done poorly in the OP's example but all these posters expressing their disgust at the practice of peers teaching peers are doing so from a place of ignorance. Studies and professional practice consistently show that there are many benefits, and most people with actual knowledge of pedagogy (rather than a lay opinion) understand this.

For your sake I will ignore the cringeworthy attempt at hauteur.

No private school I ever went to, my kids have ever been to or my siblings’ kids or my friends’ kids. As one off once a term it probably wouldn’t kill anyone - but as standard practice - parents would hit the roof.

We’ve all been the classroom, all experienced different teachers and teaching techniques, and we’re all entitled to our own opinions.

Fwiw my mother is retired head teacher with 60 years teaching experience and she is as opposed to this as I am. Nothing to do with teaching experience, simply perspective.

"Hauteur" 😂 And what are you ignoring?

But of course you're right: you've been to school, people you know have been to school, and someone you know has even taught at a school! I bow down to your expertise 😂

I agree you're entitled to your opinion. Your lay opinion.

a8mint · 15/09/2021 20:27

Normally , if a kid is struggling then i think this works well and they both get something out of it.In your DS's case though it seems like its less teaching the other kid and more about trying to keep the other child on task, which is a pretty grim situation and will turn the other boy against him.

TatianaBis · 15/09/2021 20:22

It’s a studied method for consolidation. We have evidence to show it works. It’s not an opinion if it works or not.

Of course it’s an opinion - if you actually listened to the posters on the thread roped into it - they are saying it didn’t work for them - or by extension the kids they taught.

How do you think children in private schools learn in 2021? Rote?

Seriously? You think it’s rote or p2p teaching??

Hankunamatata · 15/09/2021 20:18

If your that fissed send dc with a book and let him.read that when he is finished

HarrisMcCoo · 15/09/2021 20:09

Teaching kindness to a fellow pupil is something that should be encouraged. Peer to peer support surely is a great way to practice this?

mumwon · 15/09/2021 20:06

@TatianaBis this was what I was thinking - school budgets = cutting back on TA's many have been "let go" so it seems to me that dc who have got behind (probably because they either didn't for whatever reason get support or do work - could be parent working from home/younger siblings they have to care for/no internet or computer or using phone or sharing with parents or other siblings/behind anyway & struggling even before/ et al) would have had this extra help but it is not available

HarrisMcCoo · 15/09/2021 20:03

Yes, one of my DC has had to be a helper with a child less able sitting next to him. Fine occasionally, but not all the time. I agree with others on this thread about that. Peer to peer support does have its merits.

Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 19:59

@TatianaBis

Private schools absolutely do use these techniques. Ofsted are looking for such techniques. It has been done poorly in the OP's example but all these posters expressing their disgust at the practice of peers teaching peers are doing so from a place of ignorance. Studies and professional practice consistently show that there are many benefits, and most people with actual knowledge of pedagogy (rather than a lay opinion) understand this.

For your sake I will ignore the cringeworthy attempt at hauteur.

No private school I ever went to, my kids have ever been to or my siblings’ kids or my friends’ kids. As one off once a term it probably wouldn’t kill anyone - but as standard practice - parents would hit the roof.

We’ve all been the classroom, all experienced different teachers and teaching techniques, and we’re all entitled to our own opinions.

Fwiw my mother is retired head teacher with 60 years teaching experience and she is as opposed to this as I am. Nothing to do with teaching experience, simply perspective.

It does happen in private schools, of course it does. It’s a studied method for consolidation. We have evidence to show it works. It’s not an opinion if it works or not.

How do you think children in private schools learn in 2021? Rote?

poptartsRUs · 15/09/2021 19:58

They try this periodically with my 9 year old DS. I complain and then it stops. He doesn't enjoy it, finds it distracting and is there to be taught not teach.

DS is a helpful, earnest little thing and happy to help those that are willing but not manage the learning of those that aren't. And not should he.

Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 19:57

@powershowerforanhour

seriously doubt whether it is sensible to assume that children have the skills to teach others adequately.

Do the "teacher" children get some instruction on how to teach, oversight on how they're doing it and feedback at the end to help them improve their teaching skills, leadership skills, "dealing with frustrating people skills?"

Like a quick 10 minutes on:
How to teach the bored, reluctant student
How to teach the resentful student
How to teach the functionally illiterate student any subject that isn't "How to read"
How to teach a non English speaking student a subject that isn't English, in English, when the teacher child cannot speak the student child's language
How to teach the student with undiagnosed dyslexia/ADHD/any other sort of problem that could be holding them back

Or do the 9 year old "teacher" children just get chucked in the deep end beside their non swimming student, and get expected to teach them to swim well enough so neither child drowns before they reach the shallow end?

This is bizarre - the kid isn’t an actual teacher. The teacher will have explained the work to everyone, then will put them together to do the task. If one kid doesn’t get it, nobody is blaming the kid who does.
TatianaBis · 15/09/2021 19:46

After a we learn to do something, conveying or teaching that skill to another person consolidates and deepens our learning. The learning is also more likely to embed in the our long term memory when we do this.

Not necessarily. It may already be in your long term memory if you know it thoroughly. There are many things that if you already know, teaching someone else won’t help, like times tables or a language or a practical skill.

What consolidates learning is memorisation, review, and using and applying it in different ways.

Tigger1895 · 15/09/2021 19:37

It’s not unusual for this to happen. The teacher obviously knows your child is capable of understanding the work and often children explain things in a more general way. This helps the children struggling to get a better grip on the problem.
However if it’s because the teacher is filing her nails and can’t be arsed then there’s a problem

MrsColon · 15/09/2021 19:30

@TatianaBis

Private schools absolutely do use these techniques. Ofsted are looking for such techniques. It has been done poorly in the OP's example but all these posters expressing their disgust at the practice of peers teaching peers are doing so from a place of ignorance. Studies and professional practice consistently show that there are many benefits, and most people with actual knowledge of pedagogy (rather than a lay opinion) understand this.

For your sake I will ignore the cringeworthy attempt at hauteur.

No private school I ever went to, my kids have ever been to or my siblings’ kids or my friends’ kids. As one off once a term it probably wouldn’t kill anyone - but as standard practice - parents would hit the roof.

We’ve all been the classroom, all experienced different teachers and teaching techniques, and we’re all entitled to our own opinions.

Fwiw my mother is retired head teacher with 60 years teaching experience and she is as opposed to this as I am. Nothing to do with teaching experience, simply perspective.

This. Brava.
MrsColon · 15/09/2021 19:29

@Coronawireless

And if they lack the ability and motivation (which is part of being intelligent) to self-extend then they really aren’t that bright, they are in the middle, like the other people the teacher is aiming at.
This is a shitty comment to make about children. No, not all bright kids will self extend. Some of them are too shy or worried about being picked on to do anything to call attention to the fact that they're bright.

I was bullied mercilessly at school for being bright. I tried to shrink into myself as much as possible and never say I'd finished work, never shared test results, didn't put my hand up in class.

I can't even describe how amazing it was when I got to uni at Cambridge and realised that I didn't have to pretend any more. It felt like I'd been carrying around a heavy weight and could suddenly put it down.

Mudandrain · 15/09/2021 19:29

By explaining a task, you are consolidating your own knowledge and gaining a solid understanding of the topic.

powershowerforanhour · 15/09/2021 19:24

seriously doubt whether it is sensible to assume that children have the skills to teach others adequately.

Do the "teacher" children get some instruction on how to teach, oversight on how they're doing it and feedback at the end to help them improve their teaching skills, leadership skills, "dealing with frustrating people skills?"

Like a quick 10 minutes on:
How to teach the bored, reluctant student
How to teach the resentful student
How to teach the functionally illiterate student any subject that isn't "How to read"
How to teach a non English speaking student a subject that isn't English, in English, when the teacher child cannot speak the student child's language
How to teach the student with undiagnosed dyslexia/ADHD/any other sort of problem that could be holding them back

Or do the 9 year old "teacher" children just get chucked in the deep end beside their non swimming student, and get expected to teach them to swim well enough so neither child drowns before they reach the shallow end?

Swipe left for the next trending thread