Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 20/09/2021 04:31

There's always differentiation, surely?

I asked you several times what you meant by ‘extension work’ - could you clarify what you expect that to be?

Done and dusted. I provided a long list of options upthread, and also how extension work can be assessed and monitored. 'Worksheet' presentation of prompts doesn't mean they are not open ended, btw.

I’ve explained pretty comprehensively now what the reasoning is behind the way we teach reading, and maths. I promise you again, handing them a Harry Potter and asking them questions about it is poor, lazy teaching. But you haven’t explained why you think that would work better?

Deeper diving into the curriculum involves flogging it to death. I wouldn't class it as an appropriate method of achieving any goal, for any of the students involved.

I don't know where you are getting the idea that the alternative to worksheets is foisting Harry Potter on students.

My reference to sustained silent reading includes the following elements:
Child chooses reading material.
Teacher can monitor choices, check for progression.
Teacher can ask child various probing questions about reading material, differentiating as appropriate, with each child receiving five minutes of time with the teacher in the course of a week.
Teacher keeps track of each student's choices, progression, responses.
Teacher can talk about his or her own reading.
Teachers can also set up 'book clubs', groups where students discuss their own reading, recommend books for others, ask others about their books. Discussion prompts can be used in these groups, which can be set up according to reading ability.

But if you understand that six is half of twelve, and three is a quarter of twelve, and one doesn’t mean one unit it means one hour and also one minute and also one second and also 13, you can use all of those numbers and all of that communication for other things. You build skills on top of skills.

Such as? "How long before the bell rings and we can bust out of here?"

How much time would you devote to this mind numbing exercise?

TatianaBis · 19/09/2021 23:27

I’ll just choose another school

Pumperthepumper · 19/09/2021 20:34

@TatianaBis

I dunno, teach?
But you don’t like the techniques I’m using to teach. What do you suggest instead? No worksheets, no peer support. What else?
TatianaBis · 19/09/2021 20:33

I dunno, teach?

Pumperthepumper · 19/09/2021 19:58

@TatianaBis

The comments I read didn’t say that was the best teaching technique, they said they would rather their kid was given a worksheet than obliged to do peer support.

Neither are great tbh.

Ok, so no worksheets and no peer support. What should we do instead?
TatianaBis · 19/09/2021 19:54

The comments I read didn’t say that was the best teaching technique, they said they would rather their kid was given a worksheet than obliged to do peer support.

Neither are great tbh.

Pumperthepumper · 19/09/2021 19:42

And of course, the irony in several people saying the best teaching technique they can think of is handing out worksheets for the child to work through alone.

Pumperthepumper · 19/09/2021 19:41

@limitedperiodonly

It is a terrible idea for teachers to delegate their work teaching the least able in the class to the most able child. It is even worse to dress it up as some form of character building exercise for both children.

There are so many things to unpick that I hardly know where to start.

  • Firstly it's that as a professional, though not a teacher, I expect people to understand that not just anyone has the aptitude or training to do my job. This is a matter of professional pride and the idea that I would say anyone could do it, even a child is bizarre;

  • Children are not at school to be subjected to the whims of the latest theory (as I am writing this I'm thinking: "but that's what happens" but they really shouldn't.);

  • Children are not at school to make the lives of lazy teachers easier. I am not having a go at teachers in particular. I remember wonderful teachers. I also remember some stinkers. In my job there are a few angels, the competent and those slippery bastards who use any angle to evade work. I expect everyone knows one of those;

As a professional I expect to be paid for my work. I do not expect volunteers, however willing, to be allowed to undermine my training and experience and diminish my salary and professionalism by doing it for nothing. I am thinking of the "Mum's Army" advocated by John "Back To Basics" Major's government of 1992-1997. This was doing education for the proles in state schools on the cheap by encouraging mums who had nothing better to do than to think teaching was easy. Consequently loads of people who were completely unsuited signed up. Indeed, @PeaceandDove* said that she tried to be a teaching assistant but realised she wasn't up to it. It was admirable of her to concede that;

  • Children should not be put in charge of other children. We've all read Lord Of The Flies, haven't we?
Again; that’s not what peer support is. Nobody thinks your ten year old is capable of actually teaching anyone anything
limitedperiodonly · 19/09/2021 19:11

It is a terrible idea for teachers to delegate their work teaching the least able in the class to the most able child. It is even worse to dress it up as some form of character building exercise for both children.

There are so many things to unpick that I hardly know where to start.

  • Firstly it's that as a professional, though not a teacher, I expect people to understand that not just anyone has the aptitude or training to do my job. This is a matter of professional pride and the idea that I would say anyone could do it, even a child is bizarre;

  • Children are not at school to be subjected to the whims of the latest theory (as I am writing this I'm thinking: "but that's what happens" but they really shouldn't.);

  • Children are not at school to make the lives of lazy teachers easier. I am not having a go at teachers in particular. I remember wonderful teachers. I also remember some stinkers. In my job there are a few angels, the competent and those slippery bastards who use any angle to evade work. I expect everyone knows one of those;

As a professional I expect to be paid for my work. I do not expect volunteers, however willing, to be allowed to undermine my training and experience and diminish my salary and professionalism by doing it for nothing. I am thinking of the "Mum's Army" advocated by John "Back To Basics" Major's government of 1992-1997. This was doing education for the proles in state schools on the cheap by encouraging mums who had nothing better to do than to think teaching was easy. Consequently loads of people who were completely unsuited signed up. Indeed, @PeaceandDove* said that she tried to be a teaching assistant but realised she wasn't up to it. It was admirable of her to concede that;

  • Children should not be put in charge of other children. We've all read Lord Of The Flies, haven't we?
bruffin · 19/09/2021 10:28

@expressofthemundane
Its nonsense

Empressofthemundane · 19/09/2021 10:17

@mathanxiety

Putting one child in a position where he has to deal with the emotional and psychological, and perhaps developmental issues facing his classmate, with no support or feedback mechanism, no input from the teacher as to expected results, no specific parameters for a specific project requiring management, co-operation, collaboration, and assessment, and for an extended period of time with the same 'partner' is not peer to peer learning. It is a teacher palming off a difficult child on another because there is a squeakier wheel somewhere else in the overcrowded classroom requiring oil.

I think this is very insightful and well put. A very clever 9 year olds is still emotionally, psychologically and socially a 9 year old.

bruffin · 19/09/2021 09:27

Worth repeating. Couldn't think of the words, this was what I was thinking re the responsibility the 'learning mentor' is put under. It's not fair to either child.
In my experience of my dc and myself it actually builds confidence

Pumperthepumper · 19/09/2021 08:41

[quote mathanxiety]@Pumperthepumper, I see you read the term 'extension work' and mistook it for 'worksheet pages'. Do you give out worksheets to your students who finish work early?

Wrt sustained silent reading, and the monitoring that goes on...Teachers can summon students to their desk individually to ask about the reading material (chosen from anywhere the student has access to books) and ascertain whether the student is passively reading or truly comprehending the book.

Teachers can also assign book reports to assess comprehension and other skills.

Do you stick to reading schemes in your classroom?

Peer tutoring/ peer to peer teaching/ peer mentoring has to be very well planned and amenable to assessment. This is not what seems to be happening in the OP's DS' classroom.

Putting one child in a position where he has to deal with the emotional and psychological, and perhaps developmental issues facing his classmate, with no support or feedback mechanism, no input from the teacher as to expected results, no specific parameters for a specific project requiring management, co-operation, collaboration, and assessment, and for an extended period of time with the same 'partner' is not peer to peer learning. It is a teacher palming off a difficult child on another because there is a squeakier wheel somewhere else in the overcrowded classroom requiring oil.

www.literacyworldwide.org/docs/default-source/bonus-materials/507-chapter-3.pdf?sfvrsn=e166a38e_4
This is peer teaching.[/quote]
I asked you several times what you meant by ‘extension work’ - could you clarify what you expect that to be?

I’ve explained pretty comprehensively now what the reasoning is behind the way we teach reading, and maths. I promise you again, handing them a Harry Potter and asking them questions about it is poor, lazy teaching. But you haven’t explained why you think that would work better?

I’ve also said several times the management of peer teaching is being done poorly in the OP’s son’s classroom.

This is getting very circular now, and again; I feel I’ve explained why we do what we do pretty well.

I’d love to hear why you think your ideas are better, I really would. And what you think ‘extension tasks’ should be, if not peer collaboration or worksheets.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/09/2021 00:06

[quote mathanxiety]@Pumperthepumper, I see you read the term 'extension work' and mistook it for 'worksheet pages'. Do you give out worksheets to your students who finish work early?

Wrt sustained silent reading, and the monitoring that goes on...Teachers can summon students to their desk individually to ask about the reading material (chosen from anywhere the student has access to books) and ascertain whether the student is passively reading or truly comprehending the book.

Teachers can also assign book reports to assess comprehension and other skills.

Do you stick to reading schemes in your classroom?

Peer tutoring/ peer to peer teaching/ peer mentoring has to be very well planned and amenable to assessment. This is not what seems to be happening in the OP's DS' classroom.

Putting one child in a position where he has to deal with the emotional and psychological, and perhaps developmental issues facing his classmate, with no support or feedback mechanism, no input from the teacher as to expected results, no specific parameters for a specific project requiring management, co-operation, collaboration, and assessment, and for an extended period of time with the same 'partner' is not peer to peer learning. It is a teacher palming off a difficult child on another because there is a squeakier wheel somewhere else in the overcrowded classroom requiring oil.

www.literacyworldwide.org/docs/default-source/bonus-materials/507-chapter-3.pdf?sfvrsn=e166a38e_4
This is peer teaching.[/quote]
Worth repeating. Couldn't think of the words, this was what I was thinking re the responsibility the 'learning mentor' is put under. It's not fair to either child.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/09/2021 00:02

because

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/09/2021 00:00

DC school does this in small group situations, getting pupils who finished the work to explain to others the process they used to answer. I think this could be helpful to everyone in different ways, but regularly getting a child to assist a disinterested pupil with their work isn't helpful to either. The former helps pupils learn how to explain, the later became the pupil who is struggling with the work is disengaged can lead to the learning mentor feeling anxious and frustrated themselves and doesn't sound like it's teacher either anything. Helping explain how they did their work is one thing, expecting them to engage a disengaged pupil isn't fair on either child.

I used to help my friends at school in maths and chemistry, but they were engaged students, wanted help, wanted to do the work and just needed someone to explain it and go through the work with them a couple of times before they could work independently. Very different to OPs son's situation.

mathanxiety · 18/09/2021 23:45

@Pumperthepumper, I see you read the term 'extension work' and mistook it for 'worksheet pages'. Do you give out worksheets to your students who finish work early?

Wrt sustained silent reading, and the monitoring that goes on...Teachers can summon students to their desk individually to ask about the reading material (chosen from anywhere the student has access to books) and ascertain whether the student is passively reading or truly comprehending the book.

Teachers can also assign book reports to assess comprehension and other skills.

Do you stick to reading schemes in your classroom?

Peer tutoring/ peer to peer teaching/ peer mentoring has to be very well planned and amenable to assessment. This is not what seems to be happening in the OP's DS' classroom.

Putting one child in a position where he has to deal with the emotional and psychological, and perhaps developmental issues facing his classmate, with no support or feedback mechanism, no input from the teacher as to expected results, no specific parameters for a specific project requiring management, co-operation, collaboration, and assessment, and for an extended period of time with the same 'partner' is not peer to peer learning. It is a teacher palming off a difficult child on another because there is a squeakier wheel somewhere else in the overcrowded classroom requiring oil.

www.literacyworldwide.org/docs/default-source/bonus-materials/507-chapter-3.pdf?sfvrsn=e166a38e_4
This is peer teaching.

Empressofthemundane · 18/09/2021 23:36

@Coronawireless
You speak as if bright children are a resource we can dispatch. They aren’t a means to an end, they are human beings and as such should be treated like ends, not means.

limitedperiodonly · 18/09/2021 21:51

@peaceanddove

*That’s actually laughable - you brought up the league table. You did. Because you wanted to have a go, and it backfired.

When did I say a poster’s DH wasn’t as good at maths as they thought they were? Could you quote that? I’ll wait.

I absolutely did say that about your daughter, and I meant it. If she sat and listened to a teacher and then filled in a worksheet for the entirety of her education - which you said was true - she’s not nearly as good at maths as you think she is.

Slag off Jaxxon as much as you like then. Go ahead. Let’s hear more about how the Jaxxons of the world are holding your daughter back*

I think I will leave this here. You are deliberately mis-reading and misinterpreting my posts to the extent that I don't think you're perhaps entirely rational on here. I'm not the one who has had numerous posts deleted because of their offensive content.

So, I'm slowly backing away from you and the thread without making any sudden moves or any eye contact. Bye.

Hey peaceanddove nice to see you again yakking about the same old things you always used to. I've recently returned too. I was never banned though.
Pumperthepumper · 18/09/2021 21:27

@thenovice

That's wonderful. What a great idea. We need more initiatives like that.
It does work really well, it’s no longer just reading a book but understanding what reading is, it’s great.
bruffin · 18/09/2021 21:23

Its not new, i was a reading monitor and helped less able readers back in the early 70s when i was 8 or 9.
My dc who are in their mid 20s also did similar.

thenovice · 18/09/2021 21:12

That's wonderful. What a great idea. We need more initiatives like that.

Coronawireless · 18/09/2021 21:11

@Driftingblue

Where we live the kids take a skills assessment test 3 times a year. DD’s math score has been static for years. Well above her grade level and holding steady. She has come to hate math class all while her teachers blathered on about a deeper understanding and extension within the curriculum. This year she finally got placed in a new curriculum model. They refuse to call it advanced or honors or anything so potentially offensive. The reality is that they will be covering 2 years of curriculum in 1 year. To join kids had to agree to potentially more work, being removed from the class for failure to keep up with content, failure to do homework, or significant behavioral issues. Dd is in heaven. She is engaged in her work for the first time. She wants to know why all her classes can’t be this way. She is only a month into the new curriculum and her fall assessment score that stayed static for years went up 100 points. So whether you use my definition of success, which is engagement, or the governments definition of success, which is that assessment score, the class is so far a massive success for her.
This is streaming which is academically a success for the brightest. Whether it is a success for the less bright or, as a result, for the community as a whole (including, ultimately, the brightest) is imo very doubtful. And I speak as the parent of a child who is top of her class. The behavioural issues are an exception and ideally specific management should be aimed at minimising that. Skimming off the bright, engaged learners is one way of dealing with it…at a terrible, terrible cost to the academically less able child.
Driftingblue · 18/09/2021 20:43

Where we live the kids take a skills assessment test 3 times a year. DD’s math score has been static for years. Well above her grade level and holding steady. She has come to hate math class all while her teachers blathered on about a deeper understanding and extension within the curriculum. This year she finally got placed in a new curriculum model. They refuse to call it advanced or honors or anything so potentially offensive. The reality is that they will be covering 2 years of curriculum in 1 year. To join kids had to agree to potentially more work, being removed from the class for failure to keep up with content, failure to do homework, or significant behavioral issues. Dd is in heaven. She is engaged in her work for the first time. She wants to know why all her classes can’t be this way. She is only a month into the new curriculum and her fall assessment score that stayed static for years went up 100 points. So whether you use my definition of success, which is engagement, or the governments definition of success, which is that assessment score, the class is so far a massive success for her.

VestaTilley · 18/09/2021 15:33

Not come across it as my DS is too young, but it’s not fair on the brighter children - if they’ve finished their work the teacher should be giving them extra to do, not using them as unpaid mentors.