Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
iloveruby · 16/09/2021 00:45

@powershowerforanhour

I need to work with Jaxxon, how should I do it?

Well you're the teacher, you tell us. On the principle that into every life a little rain must fall, I would park Jaxxon beside each of the other 29 children in turn. Not just the OP's child or Peace's maths genius, but his equally uninterested twin Joxxon, Jaxette and dear little Anarchy, who unlike Jaxxon has a passion in life- for roaring sexually explicit jokes at the substitute teacher and setting fire to the desk. At least that's kind of fair.

You mean Anarchy and Joxxon won't be spending their time cultivating their new passion of counting using base 8? 😉
iloveruby · 16/09/2021 00:40

No not had a name change fail.

I'm sure there are plenty of ways in which a good teacher can manage a mixed ability class so that all pupils have equitable opportunities to learn.

I just dont think that peer to peer is the only way to support struggling students and would expect any teacher worth their salt to have alternative methods.

powershowerforanhour · 16/09/2021 00:39

Don’t you think it’s a bit interesting that you, an adult vet, struggled with the concept of relearning what 10 meant?

No. I don't think it's interesting, and like I said, I'm not even curious as to why I find it uninteresting and why I'm not really motivated to try. But like I said, to each his own. One of the joys of being an adult I suppose- if I can't be arsed to learn, that's a-ok. Makes up for the mandatory adult stuff that children don't have to deal with, like VAT returns and booking sodding in-contact covid tests when the class bubble bursts again.

Holskey · 16/09/2021 00:38

@Driftingblue

This practice doesn’t reinforce concepts, teach kids empathy, or perform any of the miracles that some people claim. All it does is reinforce the divide between the high and low performing students. The students who grasp concepts quickly are already frustrated with the slow pace of the class. Explaining easy concepts to students who are the reason the class has to move so slowly is only going to breed resentment.
Effective peer work isn't about smart children teaching academically struggling children. The OP's example is not how it's supposed to work. Many posters have slated the practice based on assumptions or negative experiences. It's great when done properly.
powershowerforanhour · 16/09/2021 00:33

I need to work with Jaxxon, how should I do it?

Well you're the teacher, you tell us. On the principle that into every life a little rain must fall, I would park Jaxxon beside each of the other 29 children in turn. Not just the OP's child or Peace's maths genius, but his equally uninterested twin Joxxon, Jaxette and dear little Anarchy, who unlike Jaxxon has a passion in life- for roaring sexually explicit jokes at the substitute teacher and setting fire to the desk. At least that's kind of fair.

AutumnColours9 · 16/09/2021 00:25

Happened to my son once with a boy with severe behavioural issues. My son would get into trouble for 'not stopping him'. I put a stop to it as it was beyond ridiculous.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 00:24

@Driftingblue

This practice doesn’t reinforce concepts, teach kids empathy, or perform any of the miracles that some people claim. All it does is reinforce the divide between the high and low performing students. The students who grasp concepts quickly are already frustrated with the slow pace of the class. Explaining easy concepts to students who are the reason the class has to move so slowly is only going to breed resentment.
That’s not true.
Driftingblue · 16/09/2021 00:23

This practice doesn’t reinforce concepts, teach kids empathy, or perform any of the miracles that some people claim. All it does is reinforce the divide between the high and low performing students. The students who grasp concepts quickly are already frustrated with the slow pace of the class. Explaining easy concepts to students who are the reason the class has to move so slowly is only going to breed resentment.

opentherm · 16/09/2021 00:23

Are you a teacher then ?

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 00:21

@iloveruby

Tbh I don't really care how you do it.

What I would care about is making sure that my child is no longer being used to manage our dear Jaxx.

I agree that peer to peer work may well have some good outcomes in specific circumstances however, this is clearly not what is happening in the OP.

Have you had a name change fail?

How should I teach the kids who are struggling if not through peer support? Or should I just ignore them and concentrate on the bright ones?

iloveruby · 16/09/2021 00:19

Tbh I don't really care how you do it.

What I would care about is making sure that my child is no longer being used to manage our dear Jaxx.

I agree that peer to peer work may well have some good outcomes in specific circumstances however, this is clearly not what is happening in the OP.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 00:14

@powershowerforanhour

And it won’t be one kid with Jaxxon for every lesson. In the OP's case, it is. It seems that the practice doesn't always follow the theory.

Jaxxon will have his opportunity to ‘teach’ your kid language. Or vocabulary. Or how to climb a rope.
In theory. And sometimes in practice. The mantra is that nobody is good at everything and everyone is good at something. This seems "fair" and a kind and moral universe would ensure that it was so. In practice it's not always the case. A friend who is a teacher notes that some children do seem to have been handed all the goodies and some, none. Like the movie "Twins" - if Arnie's character also had the street smarts and Danny DeVito's character was naive.

In the OP's case, it is. It seems that the practice doesn't always follow the theory.

Classroom management then.

powershowerforanhour · 16/09/2021 00:13

And it won’t be one kid with Jaxxon for every lesson.
In the OP's case, it is. It seems that the practice doesn't always follow the theory.

Jaxxon will have his opportunity to ‘teach’ your kid language. Or vocabulary. Or how to climb a rope.
In theory. And sometimes in practice. The mantra is that nobody is good at everything and everyone is good at something. This seems "fair" and a kind and moral universe would ensure that it was so. In practice it's not always the case. A friend who is a teacher notes that some children do seem to have been handed all the goodies and some, none. Like the movie "Twins" - if Arnie's character also had the street smarts and Danny DeVito's character was naive.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 00:12

@TatianaBis

A teacher.

Right I’m off to bed.

He has a teacher. How should his teacher teach him, if not using peer support?

Don’t flounce now, you’ve convinced me! I need to work with Jaxxon, how should I do it?

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 00:11

A teacher.

Right I’m off to bed.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 00:10

@TatianaBis

So - when you read the OP:

the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc

You think ah bless, that’s Jaxx learning maths. Effectively.

In which case it’s hardly surprising that so many children leave school numerically illiterate.

No, I hear: Jaxxon is not engaged in this lesson, we need to work out why.

What would you suggest instead for Jaxxon? What works better than peer support?

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 00:09

So - when you read the OP:

the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc

You think ah bless, that’s Jaxx learning maths. Effectively.

In which case it’s hardly surprising that so many children leave school numerically illiterate.

Justajot · 16/09/2021 00:08

In my DD's school they switch who they sit with every few weeks, so they aren't over reliant on any one individual supporting another.

Probably the best comment in my DD's report last year was that she "effectively scaffolds her peers learning". That involves higher level thinking skills, to break something down and then offer gradual support to help another child reach a final goal, rather than just give them the answer. It also means that she's thinking about the misconceptions that other children have, which is a step beyond just being able to get something right yourself.

That said, if she thinks her partner isn't bothering to think for themself or listen to the teacher, she's pretty tough and will tell them that they need to pull their finger out. If they are distracting, she has also occasionally moved away to a spare desk and her teachers have accepted this.

The system seems to work well for my DD, but she's an assertive child so doesn't get left in crappy situations.

BoredZelda · 16/09/2021 00:07

This was standard in DD’s primary school. It helps them learn. I would only be upset about it if it was hampering DD getting her work done.

It seems your son has the wrong end of the stick with it, if he thinks it will be his fault if the other boy doesn’t work.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 00:04

@powershowerforanhour

It’s 20. I don't really care a) that it is 20 b) why it is 20 and thus didn't read your explanation thoroughly enough to understand it. But that is no reflection on your mastery of base 3, or your ability to teach it.

If Jaxxon says to OP's child - in words or deeds- "Excuse me dear boy, I rather think you have mistaken me for someone who gives a crap" then as you say- management issue. The OP wanted to know if this was a) normal and b) reasonable.
The gist of the thread seems to be that
a) yes*
b) no

*"normal " in the sense of "common"
(As when some of my vet clients protest that a smashed face effect is normal for a pug. It is "the norm" for a pug but not normal for a dog).

Ok. You seem quite engaged for someone who didn’t care, sorry for the unwanted explanation.

Don’t you think it’s a bit interesting that you, an adult vet, struggled with the concept of relearning what 10 meant? That’s a concept that a lot of very young children would find unbelievably easy, that groups of 10 can change value. But it’s so much harder to relearn things as an adult.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 00:01

@TatianaBis

But if you read the OP, no-one is learning anything. Son isn’t able to use him as a tool to explore his knowledge as he won’t write anything and gives up; and Jaxx needs to learn maths in a maths lesson, not vocabulary or communication, or he will end up among the 20% of London kids who leave school at 16 without having mastered basic numeracy.
I’m not really sure how I can say this any other way: Jaxxon is learning maths. Jaxxon may never reach the heights of A* kid, but he’s still learning maths. Jaxxon, under this method, will leave school with basic numeracy skills, maybe even slightly higher! He also gets loads of additional skills that he absolutely would not get from his teacher making him rote-learn the 8 times table.

If there’s an issue with classroom management, or if the OP’s son thinks he’s there to teach Jaxxon then the OP should head up to the school where they’ll explain all of this to her. If he doesn’t want to work with Jaxxon any more, I’m sure they’ll accommodate that. But he’ll definitely have to work with Sarah, in that case.

powershowerforanhour · 15/09/2021 23:57

It’s 20.
I don't really care
a) that it is 20
b) why it is 20
and thus didn't read your explanation thoroughly enough to understand it.
But that is no reflection on your mastery of base 3, or your ability to teach it.

If Jaxxon says to OP's child - in words or deeds- "Excuse me dear boy, I rather think you have mistaken me for someone who gives a crap" then as you say- management issue. The OP wanted to know if this was a) normal and b) reasonable.
The gist of the thread seems to be that
a) yes*
b) no

*"normal " in the sense of "common"
(As when some of my vet clients protest that a smashed face effect is normal for a pug. It is "the norm" for a pug but not normal for a dog).

TatianaBis · 15/09/2021 23:56

But if you read the OP, no-one is learning anything. Son isn’t able to use him as a tool to explore his knowledge as he won’t write anything and gives up; and Jaxx needs to learn maths in a maths lesson, not vocabulary or communication, or he will end up among the 20% of London kids who leave school at 16 without having mastered basic numeracy.

Pumperthepumper · 15/09/2021 23:53

@opentherm

What is, or isn't , a boring activity is vey subjective,
Not in a classroom. They need to know stuff, if it’s boring then the lesson has been planned poorly or it’s been pitched too low, or too high. Its rare to see bored kids in primary school these days.
opentherm · 15/09/2021 23:52

What is, or isn't , a boring activity is vey subjective,

Swipe left for the next trending thread