Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
randomlyLostInWales · 16/09/2021 10:19

@Driftingblue

This practice doesn’t reinforce concepts, teach kids empathy, or perform any of the miracles that some people claim. All it does is reinforce the divide between the high and low performing students. The students who grasp concepts quickly are already frustrated with the slow pace of the class. Explaining easy concepts to students who are the reason the class has to move so slowly is only going to breed resentment.
DH 80s school was big on peer support - and he remembers many a time being taken out and being told that some children were just slower and he had to be patient with them and I think it breed resentment and contempt.

I think it was particularly bad with maths - he just "sees it" inate ablity - but I've encountered similar with a few teachers and spelling - they naturally got it so are stumped when my kids haven't. Even my old PE treachers - I think the DC's have been better- who didn't quite "get" some people weren't coordinated sporty and had prior knowlege of sport rules because they weren't that interested.

I think I got good peer teaching when it happened - not always the teacher or one struggling different groups but I was in a village school with smaller class sizes and a floating teacher. So was probably easier to manange the entire class and supervise peer learning properly. I think it's been mixed experince for our DC and sometimes they've just ended up doing the work twice.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 10:16

@TatianaBis

It’s strange you don’t have an idea of how to teach either of them without using peer support

What is strange is that you don’t seem to have a concept of teaching without learning on peer support.

And strange that none of the kids involved have got the memo that this isn’t teaching. I mean it’s not effective teaching, but that’s what the kids involved seem to think they’re doing.

Can you really not see how much more effective it would be to group Jaxx with other kids of the same ability and teach them together, rather than leaving a 9 year old with no pedagogy training to ‘support’ them?

I’m not sure where you’ve got the idea that I’m leaning on peer support, or that it’s a common view in 2021 that peer support is unpaid teaching for ten year olds. I think I’ve explained it pretty comprehensively.

It wouldn’t suit Jaxxon or any of the other kids in a similar ability group to never spend any time with kids of different abilities. Can you explain to me why you think it would?

Movingsoon21 · 16/09/2021 10:15

This used to happen to me all the time as a pupil at primary school and it was awful. I was matched up with a child with bad learning difficulties and behaviour issues. He had no interest in learning and just wanted to hit me/ignore me/play. Total waste of my time and also very demoralising/ frustrating. Just lazy teaching IMO - can’t cope with pupils with higher intellect. (I also wasn’t allowed to sit the higher SATs papers as the teacher couldn’t be bothered to teach us it) Angry

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 10:08

@peaceanddove

It's strange you don’t have an idea of how to teach either of them without using peer support, can you not think of any? Your daughter: if we scrap peer support should I give her a worksheet?

It's actually not strange at all because, you know, I'm not a teacher and haven't trained to be a teacher. So, not my circus and not my monkeys.

But it is your daughter: how do you want me to teach her? Worksheets?
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 10:07

leaning on peer support not learning on ^^

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 10:05

It’s strange you don’t have an idea of how to teach either of them without using peer support

What is strange is that you don’t seem to have a concept of teaching without learning on peer support.

And strange that none of the kids involved have got the memo that this isn’t teaching. I mean it’s not effective teaching, but that’s what the kids involved seem to think they’re doing.

Can you really not see how much more effective it would be to group Jaxx with other kids of the same ability and teach them together, rather than leaving a 9 year old with no pedagogy training to ‘support’ them?

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 10:01

It's strange you don’t have an idea of how to teach either of them without using peer support, can you not think of any? Your daughter: if we scrap peer support should I give her a worksheet?

It's actually not strange at all because, you know, I'm not a teacher and haven't trained to be a teacher. So, not my circus and not my monkeys.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 09:57

@TatianaBis

What works is more teachers, smaller classes and setting. So that *@peaceanddove*’s DD can learn fast and be challenged among kids of similar ability; and Jaxx and friends can be given patient teaching by an experienced professional who’s developed strategies to help less able kids and build their confidence.
I will never argue against smaller class sizes. We should have smaller classes and more teachers and more support staff and more resources, absolutely.

But peer support would still happen within those smaller class sizes. And because we know peer support works, we wouldn’t group them in classes by ability. It’d be age probably, ie luck of the draw.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 09:56

@peaceanddove

I really don't care what happens to Jaxxon or how you approach teaching him (which is why I decided not to be a teacher). All I care about is that my DD2 doesn't have to spend her time feeling frustrated and irritated because she's working as his unpaid TA.
You’re still not understanding peer support: she’s not teaching him.

It’s strange you don’t have an idea of how to teach either of them without using peer support, can you not think of any? Your daughter: if we scrap peer support should I give her a worksheet?

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 09:50

I really don't care what happens to Jaxxon or how you approach teaching him (which is why I decided not to be a teacher). All I care about is that my DD2 doesn't have to spend her time feeling frustrated and irritated because she's working as his unpaid TA.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 09:49

What works is more teachers, smaller classes and setting. So that @peaceanddove’s DD can learn fast and be challenged among kids of similar ability; and Jaxx and friends can be given patient teaching by an experienced professional who’s developed strategies to help less able kids and build their confidence.

HikingforScenery · 16/09/2021 09:38

I used to do this when I was at school. I enjoyed it though.

My DD does the same in class and she’s a similar age. She does loves teaching others so I’m sure she doesn’t mind being asked. She teaches her brother at home too and she’s great at explaining things and more patient than me!
I don’t mind.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 09:34

@peaceanddove

No, she's probably even better - I haven't been able to understand the maths she does for a very long time.
So what would you suggest we should do instead of peer support? You’ve convinced me - we’ll rip up decades of research and try something else.

What works? Should I focus all my attention on Jaxxon and give your daughter that extension worksheet you wanted? Or should I focus all my attention on your daughter, and Jaxxon can leave school numerically illiterate, and that’s just his tough luck?

Or should I pitch everything to the middle? Everyone equal?

What’s your solution?

WishingWell5 · 16/09/2021 09:25

Well, I was a very bright kid at school. There was a girl who was previously home schooled and couldn't read, so the teacher sat her with me to help. I also have a memory of taking a group of kids (same class) to the library to go through spellings. This was reception year. I don't think I enjoyed it at all. I was also very shy. I never remember telling my parents though but it was a different time and probably they would have been proud if anything.
Well I'm not sure if it was a bad thing in the long run. I'm about to complete my PhD and I guess I'm quite good at teaching and explaining things to others.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 09:22

No, she's probably even better - I haven't been able to understand the maths she does for a very long time.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 09:14

@peaceanddove

If you were interested in maths, and were good at it, and ten years old instead of a jaded adult - the idea that Jaxxon thought 4x8 is 33 would be fascinating to you

I can assure you my 10 year old DD2 certainly did not find it fascinating at all. She found Jaxxon irritating and slow.

Maybe she’s not as good at maths as you think then.
peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 09:05

If you were interested in maths, and were good at it, and ten years old instead of a jaded adult - the idea that Jaxxon thought 4x8 is 33 would be fascinating to you

I can assure you my 10 year old DD2 certainly did not find it fascinating at all. She found Jaxxon irritating and slow.

bellabasset · 16/09/2021 08:31

I was the youngest dc in infants school but had a lot of time off with childhood illnesses. When we went to Junior school I was put into the bottom third with the least capable. My dm complained but the HM said I'd missed a lot of school. By the first half term my teacher was giving me additional work as she didn't want me helping other pupils such as my friend who really struggled. It took 2 years for me to be in the top group.

This doesn't sound a good situation for either ds or the other pupil, ds is sitting there not learning whilst his fellow pupil is discouraged and not trying.

MoreAloneTime · 16/09/2021 08:08

Sorry but I agree with PP that this sort of peer learning mixed ability stuff just made me think negatively about some of the people I went to school with. A nice but struggling child might not be so bad but being made to help a problem child isn't reasonable.

LaBellina · 16/09/2021 08:05

I wouldn’t be happy about this.
Your DS is in school primarily for his own development and if he needs extension work then let it be something that helps him develop his knowledge and skills instead of having to motivate another child. He’s not your DS’ problem and I would have a word about this with the teacher/ school.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/09/2021 07:45

@Holskey

I'm a teacher. Getting students to teach each other is pretty much gold standard if done correctly. Your child's teacher isn't doing it correctly because: it's always one way; it's always the same child; the students aren't engaged or on board; and it's always the same, boring routine which is too general ("help Ben finish" is a crap instruction)

It's a lazy application of a very valuable and useful concept. And your child's teacher should ensure your ds knows he is not responsible for this other child's work or behaviour!

Agree. Peer to peer learning is very effective if person A learns about a subject, to teach person B, who then reciprocates. That is a world away from expecting a 9 year old to act as TA to a struggling and demotivated child.
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 07:41

@iloveruby

No not had a name change fail.

I'm sure there are plenty of ways in which a good teacher can manage a mixed ability class so that all pupils have equitable opportunities to learn.

I just dont think that peer to peer is the only way to support struggling students and would expect any teacher worth their salt to have alternative methods.

It’s not the only way. And it’s not to support struggling students.
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 07:40

@powershowerforanhour

I need to work with Jaxxon, how should I do it?

Well you're the teacher, you tell us. On the principle that into every life a little rain must fall, I would park Jaxxon beside each of the other 29 children in turn. Not just the OP's child or Peace's maths genius, but his equally uninterested twin Joxxon, Jaxette and dear little Anarchy, who unlike Jaxxon has a passion in life- for roaring sexually explicit jokes at the substitute teacher and setting fire to the desk. At least that's kind of fair.

I have told you. That was in response to a op worrying about Jaxxon’s numeracy skills when he leaves school. I was hoping all these people who dislike peer learning would have a better idea.

Incidentally, what you’ve described above is peer learning. They don’t work with the same kid every time.

Looubylou · 16/09/2021 06:57

This was reported by my son in year 5 too. I tried to focus on potential benefits for my son, rather than the fact that the struggling child was known to be a bully (I know my son has been a target) and have other behaviour problems. I then found myself having a word my son, when he started making scathing comments about the boy's lack of ability (to me). So not the best situation, I agree.

Driftingblue · 16/09/2021 00:55

@Pumperthepumper

It was true for me as a student. It was true for my DH. It was true for many of my adult friends. We all left school with a distinct feeling that most of our classmates were severely lacking in intelligence. I’m trying to say it politely here because as an adult, I know that the very strong negative feelings about my fellow students I developed as a child were not accurate and that we all possess a wide variety of strengths and weaknesses. That doesn’t change the fact that I had them. It doesn’t change the fact that at least anecdotally, it appears to be very common for exceptionally bright students to develop those very strong negative feelings about their fellow students. Reinforcing the intellectual divide doesn’t help, especially when the school is already failing to meet the needs of the bright students.