Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
Driftingblue · 16/09/2021 11:41

For my own child, who is like me, exceptionally bright and has ASD, this practice was causing her an inordinate amount of stress. It is now in her formal accommodations that she must be placed with similar abilities for group work. That doesn’t mean she never helps a fellow student. We have been told she has a knack for finding a way to explain concepts, but it’s not allowed to be assigned to her.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:37

@peaceanddove

I suspect in reality if your gifted maths-loving ten year old had proudly showed you her folder of completed maths worksheets at the end of the year you’d raise an eyebrow

If all she had ever done in her maths lessons were endless work sheets, then yes I'd think that was rubbish teaching. But luckily that didn't happen and she happily participated in the general maths lesson alongside the other children, and would often go on to do an extension work sheet. So, overall a nice mix.

What did she do when she wasn’t doing extension worksheets?
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:36

@TatianaBis

I didn’t think you were, I’ve already told you - similar abilities.
Ok. You’re wrong then. It’s better for him to be in a smaller class of mixed abilities.
peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 11:36

I suspect in reality if your gifted maths-loving ten year old had proudly showed you her folder of completed maths worksheets at the end of the year you’d raise an eyebrow

If all she had ever done in her maths lessons were endless work sheets, then yes I'd think that was rubbish teaching. But luckily that didn't happen and she happily participated in the general maths lesson alongside the other children, and would often go on to do an extension work sheet. So, overall a nice mix.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:35

I didn’t think you were, I’ve already told you - similar abilities.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:32

@TatianaBis

So you think it’s better for Jaxxon to learn in a group?

In a (small) class of children of the same ability, where the teacher can give personalised attention to each kid who needs it. If there’s a need for further one on one tuition that should be available too.

I’m not trying to trip you up, I’m interested in what you think is a better situation for Jaxxon: a smaller class of mixed abilities or a smaller class of similar abilities.
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:29

Because that’s rubbish teaching. Ignoring a child who’s gifted at maths and filling their time with worksheets wouldn’t advance them at all. Where’s the active learning?

I agree worksheets for the able are crap and a sign that the teaching method is not working. But I’d much rather do worksheets and focus on my own learning than waste time on Jaxx when I’m not getting paid.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:27

So you think it’s better for Jaxxon to learn in a group?

In a (small) class of children of the same ability, where the teacher can give personalised attention to each kid who needs it. If there’s a need for further one on one tuition that should be available too.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:22

@peaceanddove

So worksheets in the end then?

Yes, I suppose so. Why not?

Because that’s rubbish teaching. Ignoring a child who’s gifted at maths and filling their time with worksheets wouldn’t advance them at all. Where’s the active learning?

I suspect in reality if your gifted maths-loving ten year old had proudly showed you her folder of completed maths worksheets at the end of the year you’d raise an eyebrow.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 11:17

So worksheets in the end then?

Yes, I suppose so. Why not?

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:15

@TatianaBis

Not quite sure what you’re struggling with *@Pumperthepumper*

I’m saying it’s more effective for a teacher to teach Jaxx in a group of similar ability so they can be taught at the same speed (slower than the kids who pick up mathematical concepts fast,) using strategies developed (by the teacher) to help less able kids master mathematical concepts effectively and build their confidence.

So you think it’s better for Jaxxon to learn in a group?
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:11

Not quite sure what you’re struggling with @Pumperthepumper

I’m saying it’s more effective for a teacher to teach Jaxx in a group of similar ability so they can be taught at the same speed (slower than the kids who pick up mathematical concepts fast,) using strategies developed (by the teacher) to help less able kids master mathematical concepts effectively and build their confidence.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:09

@randomlyLostInWales

Can you explain why you think this would be a problem?

I did give example - DH just sees patterns in maths and frequently as a child couldn't grasp that others couldn't (he has a first in maths/physics for undergraduate degree PhD in related field so idea he isn't good is not correct).

With me and spelling - truns out I'm dyslexia- I didn't need people who were natually good at spelling marveling and commenting on how bad I was I needed to be sat down and taught encoding and decoding - as it was I was left to muddle on knowing that others though I was stupid because I struggled.

Also being told to read a lot - I did it didn't improve my spelling and I already was . I was told with our children correct spelling would emerge - a concept that wasn't supported by research as it turned out and they actaully needed to be taught systematically - which in their schools didn't happen. They did get a lot of random spelling lists to learn which again didn't help and there' research that shows it doesn't and peer marking and teaching there just made them feel worse about their issues.

I think peer learning has it's place - but I think OP has a right to be concerned here.

I’m not sure if this is to me, but I’ll reply;

Maths mastery is a completely different thing from being ‘good at maths’ ie your husband having a PhD in maths doesn’t mean he has maths mastery if he can’t use information he already knows in different contexts. What we do in classrooms now is remove the importance of the correct answer and instead look at ways we can manipulate numbers. I gave an example in this thread already so if that’s something you’re interested in there’s an example here. The idea behind maths mastery is children (and therefore adults) get a much wider knowledge behind what they’ve learned - so they don’t only know that 3x4 is 12, they also know what double 3 x half of four is another way of looking at it. They can manipulate numbers and concepts for a true understanding of what they’re doing. And it’s not just maths, but language, social skills, expression, literacy and all the rest.

Missing a child’s dyslexia is rubbish teaching and there’s no excuse for that. Again, that’s something teachers are trained better in too - it’s quite common for dyslexia to be picked up in early years now and we have research to support different techniques and their effectiveness. One massive difference too as we’ve moved towards a more holistic approach to education is to stop focusing on spelling as the important part (much like the answer in maths) and look at phonics, or sentence formation, or digital dexterity. So it should be, I’d hope, fairly unlikely for you now to 1) have undiagnosed dyslexia aged 10 and 2) be paired with someone solely to improve your spelling. Again, I’d say that’s poor classroom management rather than something inherently wrong with peer support.

randomlyLostInWales · 16/09/2021 10:36

Can you explain why you think this would be a problem?

I did give example - DH just sees patterns in maths and frequently as a child couldn't grasp that others couldn't (he has a first in maths/physics for undergraduate degree PhD in related field so idea he isn't good is not correct).

With me and spelling - truns out I'm dyslexia- I didn't need people who were natually good at spelling marveling and commenting on how bad I was I needed to be sat down and taught encoding and decoding - as it was I was left to muddle on knowing that others though I was stupid because I struggled.

Also being told to read a lot - I did it didn't improve my spelling and I already was . I was told with our children correct spelling would emerge - a concept that wasn't supported by research as it turned out and they actaully needed to be taught systematically - which in their schools didn't happen. They did get a lot of random spelling lists to learn which again didn't help and there' research that shows it doesn't and peer marking and teaching there just made them feel worse about their issues.

I think peer learning has it's place - but I think OP has a right to be concerned here.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 10:35

@peaceanddove

Knowing DD2 she would have been happiest working through extension papers on her own so she could go at her own pace. If she had a problem she could raise it with her teacher. It's really not rocket science.
So worksheets in the end then?
peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 10:31

Knowing DD2 she would have been happiest working through extension papers on her own so she could go at her own pace. If she had a problem she could raise it with her teacher. It's really not rocket science.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 10:29

[quote TatianaBis]@TatianaBis

Jaxx and friends can be given patient teaching by an experienced professional who’s developed strategies to help less able kids and build their confidence[/quote]
That’s not mixing with similar abilities, that’s one-on-one taught support. Why would it benefit Jaxxon to be in a maths class only with kids of similar abilities?

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 10:28

@TatianaBis

Jaxx and friends can be given patient teaching by an experienced professional who’s developed strategies to help less able kids and build their confidence

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 10:27

@peaceanddove

But it is your daughter: how do you want me to teach her? Worksheets?

I wouldn't want you teaching her at all, frankly. But if you had to I would want you to set her plenty of extension maths work which she would have happily worked through at her own speed. God knows where Jaxxon would be, but he isn't her problem.

And what should those extension tasks look like? Teacher led? Or pupil led? Ie do you want me to spend that time with her, or let her work through something alone?
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 10:26

@TatianaBis

I will, but can you first answer the question: even in maths, why would it be more effective for Jaxxon to only mix with kids with similar abilities?

I’ve explained why above.

No you haven’t - you asked me why I couldn’t see why it’d be more effective. You haven’t said why it would be.

So what’s your theory? Why would it be more beneficial for Jaxxon to do maths only with kids of similar abilities?

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 10:26

But it is your daughter: how do you want me to teach her? Worksheets?

I wouldn't want you teaching her at all, frankly. But if you had to I would want you to set her plenty of extension maths work which she would have happily worked through at her own speed. God knows where Jaxxon would be, but he isn't her problem.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 10:24

I will, but can you first answer the question: even in maths, why would it be more effective for Jaxxon to only mix with kids with similar abilities?

I’ve explained why above.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 10:24

I think I got good peer teaching when it happened

Don’t use the T word - according to @Pumperthepumper it’s ‘support’.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 10:22

@TatianaBis

We’re talking about maths currently. Having maths lessons with kids of similar abilities doesn’t mean Jaxx won’t spend plenty of time with kids of differing abilities. Can you explain why you think this would be a problem?
I will, but can you first answer the question: even in maths, why would it be more effective for Jaxxon to only mix with kids with similar abilities?
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 10:20

We’re talking about maths currently. Having maths lessons with kids of similar abilities doesn’t mean Jaxx won’t spend plenty of time with kids of differing abilities. Can you explain why you think this would be a problem?

Swipe left for the next trending thread