Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
randomlyLostInWales · 16/09/2021 13:18

Maths mastery is a completely different thing from being ‘good at maths’ ie your husband having a PhD in maths doesn’t mean he has maths mastery

DH as a child struggled with the concept that others perceive the world differently to him - a concept many adults clearly struggle with.

Only on MN would I then be told his first class degree in maths and physics, Phd which apply maths to real world situation,research papers applying maths to new situations, his work creating models of biolgical systems using underlying maths is completly irrelevant becuase he hasn't "mastered" maths.

What we do in classrooms now is remove the importance of the correct answer and instead look at ways we can manipulate numbers

I was taught that our working out were as important as the correct answer in the 80 and 90s but the right answer also mattered in my exams - got most points by doing both.

I suplimented our kids maths learning with mathsfactor - were they got clear explinations, worked examples and practise with the concepts demostrated their understanding of concept and how to manipulate numbers by getting the "right" answer and parental input if they struggled to get the right answer to work out why they were getting the wrong one.

I think they found noisy busy class room and group work hindered their early maths understanding and then they were trying to build on shaky foundations because their lack of real understanding wasn't picked up in school.

Again, I’d say that’s poor classroom management rather than something inherently wrong with peer support.

I agree and said that but there can be problems with peer support as well - clear frusrations with or even teasing over difficulties - that do seem to be overlooked or dismissed.

JudgeJ · 16/09/2021 12:37

@Smartiepants79

Having to teach something to another person can actually be very helpful in improving your own understanding and clarifying your thought processes. Having to explain your thinking is a learning tool used in lots of areas. The only reason I’d have a serious problem with this is if it’s preventing my child from completing his own work or the other child is being horrible.
This is so true, as an A level Maths teacher I did a period of supply in a Primary school and I learned so much about my subject! Being of a generation that was taught how to do something, I now found out why it worked! However I would be unhappy if too much time was spent helping another child, especially an unpleasant one, your child needs some breadth in his work rather than ploughing on ahead.
Rinoachicken · 16/09/2021 12:36

I would be annoyed on behalf of BOTH kids - your son deserves extension work to challenge him further. The struggling child deserves an actual qualified teacher to help him, who knows his difficulties, and SEN etc and can take those things into account.

This is doing a huge disservice to both children and if I was the parent of either I would not be happy.

Horst · 16/09/2021 12:31

I don’t like using other pupils to teach others. Funny how it only happens in primary too.

Secondary they are set it sets due to ability no top set child is teaching a bottom set child to consolidate their learning as they are both learning totally different levels of maths.

It’s just lazy teaching in primary’s making all children so the same work regardless of ability.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 12:13

@iloveruby

www.tes.com/news/exclusive-mixed-ability-classes-more-effective-sets

The quote was from an article in TES.

There was also another guide about best practice when implementing mixed ability groups which states:
"
Don’t over-rely on high attainers explaining to others
Explaining learning to others can be very effective, but be careful not to depend too often on using high attaining students as explainers, as this can be frustrating for high attainers and patronising to students at other attainment levels."
www.tes.com/news/nine-dos-and-donts-mixed-ability-classes

To be fair, I think that you @pumperthepumper have been clear that pupils shouldn't be teaching when doing collaborative learning but I do think from the OP it would appear that it is clearly being misused (and has been misused in other situations as recalled by PPs).

Thank you. I don’t that article is particularly contradictory to what I said either.
iloveruby · 16/09/2021 12:07

www.tes.com/news/exclusive-mixed-ability-classes-more-effective-sets

The quote was from an article in TES.

There was also another guide about best practice when implementing mixed ability groups which states:
"
Don’t over-rely on high attainers explaining to others
Explaining learning to others can be very effective, but be careful not to depend too often on using high attaining students as explainers, as this can be frustrating for high attainers and patronising to students at other attainment levels."
www.tes.com/news/nine-dos-and-donts-mixed-ability-classes

To be fair, I think that you @pumperthepumper have been clear that pupils shouldn't be teaching when doing collaborative learning but I do think from the OP it would appear that it is clearly being misused (and has been misused in other situations as recalled by PPs).

underwhelmed1 · 16/09/2021 12:04

YANBU but this is common practice in my experience

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 12:02

@TatianaBis

Setting means grouping kids by ability.
I apologise. I thought you meant classroom setup.
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:59

Setting means grouping kids by ability.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:57

@TatianaBis

But that’s not the same as mixed ability groups.

Of course it’s not the same as mixed ability groups - it’s similar ability groups.

No. Setting does not mean mixed ability, or similar ability.
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:56

@TatianaBis

I’m not in that classroom but I suspect something has gone wrong in the management of that paring.

It’s more what’s gone wrong with with pairing 9 year olds as a concept.

They are many posters contributing that the ways it went wrong for them - so it going wrong is fairly standard.

It isn’t though. Peer support works. It just needs to be managed properly, which is why we call it ‘classroom management’.
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:56

But that’s not the same as mixed ability groups.

Of course it’s not the same as mixed ability groups - it’s similar ability groups.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:56

@iloveruby

"Steve Higgins, a professor at Durham University’s School of Education and lead author of the toolkit, said the updated analysis “shows us that the impact of attainment grouping is dependent on the type of grouping used”.

He added: “Based on the evidence we have, setting or streaming pupils in different classes by prior attainment appears, on average, to have had a small negative effect. In contrast, grouping pupils by attainment within classes had a positive overall impact in the studies we reviewed.”

This was published in 2018 and shows that the research supporting mixed groups is clearly not unanimous.

Could you please link to this study?
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:55

[quote iloveruby]@Pumperthepumper

Are mixed ability groups good for all children though or do they just lead to better outcomes for children who are of middle / low ability?[/quote]
All children.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:54

I’m not in that classroom but I suspect something has gone wrong in the management of that paring.

It’s more what’s gone wrong with with pairing 9 year olds as a concept.

They are many posters contributing that the ways it went wrong for them - so it going wrong is fairly standard.

iloveruby · 16/09/2021 11:54

"Steve Higgins, a professor at Durham University’s School of Education and lead author of the toolkit, said the updated analysis “shows us that the impact of attainment grouping is dependent on the type of grouping used”.

He added: “Based on the evidence we have, setting or streaming pupils in different classes by prior attainment appears, on average, to have had a small negative effect. In contrast, grouping pupils by attainment within classes had a positive overall impact in the studies we reviewed.”

This was published in 2018 and shows that the research supporting mixed groups is clearly not unanimous.

iloveruby · 16/09/2021 11:51

@Pumperthepumper

Are mixed ability groups good for all children though or do they just lead to better outcomes for children who are of middle / low ability?

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:50

@TatianaBis

There is equal long term evidence that setting works. That is also a fact.
Absolutely. But that’s not the same as mixed ability groups.
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:50

There is equal long term evidence that setting works. That is also a fact.

Driftingblue · 16/09/2021 11:48

For group work or is whatever group work is happening. It could be peer to peer learning. It could be a science lab. Once they were making a short movie about an historical event.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:43

@TatianaBis

How’s it working the OP’s DS and his Jaxx?
I’m not in that classroom but I suspect something has gone wrong in the management of that paring. Again, a classroom management issue rather than a peer support one.
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:42

@TatianaBis

Ok. You’re wrong then. It’s better for him to be in a smaller class of mixed abilities.

That’s simply your opinion. I think you’re wrong.

It’s not my opinion though. It’s the result of a lot of evidence that it works. Decades of research. It’s not an opinion, it’s a fact.
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:41

How’s it working the OP’s DS and his Jaxx?

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 11:41

@Driftingblue

For my own child, who is like me, exceptionally bright and has ASD, this practice was causing her an inordinate amount of stress. It is now in her formal accommodations that she must be placed with similar abilities for group work. That doesn’t mean she never helps a fellow student. We have been told she has a knack for finding a way to explain concepts, but it’s not allowed to be assigned to her.
What does she do within those groups?
TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 11:41

Ok. You’re wrong then. It’s better for him to be in a smaller class of mixed abilities.

That’s simply your opinion. I think you’re wrong.