Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Ds expected to “help” another pupil with work in class

736 replies

LostFrog · 15/09/2021 12:36

Ds is 9 years old, just started Year 5, first year of new school (middle school system here).

He tells me that when he has finished his own work in class, he is required to help a boy who sits next to him. This happens every single lesson, and he says that the boy is reluctant to work, won’t write anything, gives up quickly and mutters all the time that he doesn’t get it, etc. From asking around, this seems to be the standard on every table in the class - there is one or two pupils who are “learning mentors” who have to teach the less able ones.

Is this a) normal, and b) reasonable? It’s not like ds volunteered for this role. If he has finished, Shouldn’t he be offered an extension task whilst the teacher or TA (there is one, I checked) help the ones who are struggling? I have emailed the teacher to ask them to clarify what’s expected, but has anyone else come across this?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:44

@peaceanddove

So Pumperthepumper how do you feel about corporal punishment and caning still being used in Singapore schools today? Or the fact that Singapore has one of the highest rates of school pupil suicide in the world?
Thanks for asking! What a civil question!

I’m obviously completely against corporal punishment. And actually, I’m not wild about the Singaporean school system in general, I think they push them too hard. Being the top of the league table is really just ‘learning for the exam’ for grown ups.

But I do also think there’s a lot we can learn from them too. Mastery, obviously (which I’m sure I don’t need to say again is different from maths ‘ability’), but also the importance of education and knowledge, the positives it brings to your life and the pride they take in their education.

Interestingly, would you like to know one of the main differences between Singaporean school kids and British ones? It’s attendance. Britain has one of the worst attendance stats in the world. So obviously that feeds in to lots of other social issues, like poverty, parents, environment - but it’s interesting to think how we can get higher up those world league tables if we can’t even get them in the building.

traumatisednoodle · 16/09/2021 18:43

What the Jaxxons of this world need is almost certainly more small group or one to one support, revisiting concepts, possibly visual aids. What he doesn't need is clever cloggs Dd saying " but WHY don't you understand? it's easy, look I told you before, why can't you remember?"

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:40

You’re the one who brought up Jaxxon needing 12 hours of school. I was demonstrating that’s not true

Well, God knows it sounds like he needs a damn sight more than your average school day.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:38

So Pumperthepumper how do you feel about corporal punishment and caning still being used in Singapore schools today? Or the fact that Singapore has one of the highest rates of school pupil suicide in the world?

WTAFhappened123 · 16/09/2021 18:37

WTAF!! That is lazy teaching right there! If he finishes work with enough time to then tutor (Confused) another child then the teacher your be setting your son more work to help challenge him!

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:37

@peaceanddove

So, if you agree it's not mine or my Dad's problem then why are you constantly asking me to provide suggestions and solutions to it?
You’re the one who brought up Jaxxon needing 12 hours of school. I was demonstrating that’s not true.
Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:36

@PurpleOkapi

I wouldn't alter my practice because of the opinion of an anonymous mnetter who went to school decades ago and has decided peer collaboration has no value in general.

The situation being described isn't peer collaboration, or any kind of collaboration. It's the teacher ordering one student who understands the material to teach it to another who doesn't. The only thing they're "collaborating" on is the completion of the second student's worksheet that he was supposed to be doing himself in the first place.

No. You’ve misunderstood what peer collaboration is.

It’s not for the benefit of the one being ‘taught’, it’s not to help the lower ability kids. It’s to help the kid doing the ‘teaching’ - because it helps them consolidate knowledge, it helps them reframe knowledge and it helps them reimagine known concepts. It also has loads of other benefits, like increased vocabulary, communication skills, empathy, community spirit.

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:34

So, if you agree it's not mine or my Dad's problem then why are you constantly asking me to provide suggestions and solutions to it?

MouseholeCat · 16/09/2021 18:34

I can absolutely see the benefit of planned peer to peer learning. But I think there also has to be some kind of mutual accountability to the task for it to be worthwhile, which is why it's probably better as a more ococasional and specificially planned exercise than the default way of operating a class.

Having been put in this position far too often at school I really feel for your son, OP.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 18:34

@Holskey

I don’t think anyone’s expecting you to alter your MO because of MN, but you’re quite happy to dismiss students and ex students on here.

How much have teachers/schools listened to the posters on here with negative experiences of peer support I wonder?

What seems to happen is parent objects, their kid is excused and is replaced with another whose parents don’t complain.

BritMommyAbroad · 16/09/2021 18:34

No. You are definitely not being unreasonable. This doesn’t seem like a simple classmate helping classmate scenario. Your child is 9 and shouldn’t be dealing with the complex emotions and what seems like learning difficulties of his classmate. That’s not his burden to shoulder. I’d be really pissed off to be honest if my child was expected to do this and it led to them feeling anxious, exasperated and confused.

PurpleOkapi · 16/09/2021 18:33

I wouldn't alter my practice because of the opinion of an anonymous mnetter who went to school decades ago and has decided peer collaboration has no value in general.

The situation being described isn't peer collaboration, or any kind of collaboration. It's the teacher ordering one student who understands the material to teach it to another who doesn't. The only thing they're "collaborating" on is the completion of the second student's worksheet that he was supposed to be doing himself in the first place.

opentherm · 16/09/2021 18:32

Well, thank goodness for that.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:32

@peaceanddove

This might be the best of Jaxxon’s ability. It might not be. How do we find out?

Again, as I said before, that's not my problem and it certainly wasn't my 10 year old DD's problem either.

No. And at no point did anyone say it was your problem, or your daughters.
peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:31

And let's not forget that caning is still widely used in Singapore schools. Presumably why they don't have much in the way of discipline issues or bad behaviour.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:31

@TatianaBis

Mine were deleted for quoting yours though, you can see the pattern

Nope, some were deleted for being rude, not even to me.

This is very circular and odd. This is the last time I’ll reply to you.
pollymere · 16/09/2021 18:30

I would suggest to your son to think how he can best use the time given for a task. Perhaps he should write more? Or maybe he needs to go back over his work? I would suggest thinking how he can improve vocabulary choices, add varied punctuation and if it suits figurative language... This is better than asking for extension work which is often just more questions. It also means he'll have less time to encourage another student. If it's maths, explaining method is often useful for consolidation but he could check his answers first.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 18:29

Mine were deleted for quoting yours though, you can see the pattern

Nope, some were deleted for being rude, not even to me.

Holskey · 16/09/2021 18:29

@TatianaBis

It’s really interesting to hear teachers be so dismissive of the experience of students.
I will listen to MY students' feedback about specific practices and experiences. I wouldn't alter my practice because of the opinion of an anonymous mnetter who went to school decades ago and has decided peer collaboration has no value in general.
peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:28

This might be the best of Jaxxon’s ability. It might not be. How do we find out?

Again, as I said before, that's not my problem and it certainly wasn't my 10 year old DD's problem either.

TatianaBis · 16/09/2021 18:28

The hours that Chinese and Singapore children work are extraordinary. And the degree of discipline maintained in schools - I don’t know how pervasive that is.

They find our general ramshackle free for all classes puzzling.

A Chinese friend, educated there, his children are being educated here, wondered how they learn anything, and came to the conclusion that they don’t learn that much, comparatively.

traumatisednoodle · 16/09/2021 18:28

So what's the problem? Nobody wants to help nobody no more! Maybe that other child has sleep apnea I had sleep apnea even as a child and had problems in school and the grade school teachers just thought I was lazy and stupid be willing to help somebody and thank your lucky stars and God that your son is it's blessed to be smart don't be so reluctant to help somebody nobody wants to help nobody know more again maybe there's something wrong with that boy that other student and not just reluctant to do the work or lazy or whatever you don't know! Only the Good Lord knows!

The lad Dd was assigned to support certainly had issues (in foster care, both parents were in prison- I can only assume for drug related offences). I did and do have every sympathy for the boy, but honestly I don't think Dd sitting there day after day trying to get this lad to tell the time helped either of them frankly.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:26

@peaceanddove

because of peer support, Singapore is brilliant at it but not because of mastery, no, because of long hours because your friend’s DS said so, but you want Britain to be higher up that list, but you don’t want to adopt the practices of Singapore

Not just because my friend's DS says so. I thought it was common knowledge that Singapore school children put in far longer school hours and do far more extra curricular tuition than any Western pupils? The agency my friend's DS works for can't keep up with the demand for TEFL and maths tutors.

And where did I say I didn't want to adopt the practices of Singapore? Frankly, if poor Jaxxon wants to attain any kind of ability at maths then he probably would need to spend upwards of 12 hours in a school setting.

What do you class as ‘ability in maths’? Jaxxon has ability in maths, he just doesn’t have the same ability as other kids. Jaxxon knows what numbers are, he knows what they look like. He understands his age, for example. He knows his house has a number. He knows a passcode to open a locked phone.

This might be the best of Jaxxon’s ability. It might not be. How do we find out?

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2021 18:24

[quote TatianaBis]@Pumperthepumper

I think your deleted posts tell a different story

So do yours if you look back. I don’t report as I don’t offend easy.[/quote]
Mine were deleted for quoting yours though, you can see the pattern. I can ask mumsnet to update the deletion message if you like?

Are we done? What are you hoping to get out of this conversation?

peaceanddove · 16/09/2021 18:23

because of peer support, Singapore is brilliant at it but not because of mastery, no, because of long hours because your friend’s DS said so, but you want Britain to be higher up that list, but you don’t want to adopt the practices of Singapore

Not just because my friend's DS says so. I thought it was common knowledge that Singapore school children put in far longer school hours and do far more extra curricular tuition than any Western pupils? The agency my friend's DS works for can't keep up with the demand for TEFL and maths tutors.

And where did I say I didn't want to adopt the practices of Singapore? Frankly, if poor Jaxxon wants to attain any kind of ability at maths then he probably would need to spend upwards of 12 hours in a school setting.