Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel if the standard household was single income again?

195 replies

Omydearehert · 15/09/2021 08:01

Not necessarily the man working. How would you feel if a single income was enough to live off of and became the standard again?

OP posts:
onlychildhamster · 15/09/2021 09:17

I would still work. You never know what might happen - bereavement, disability etc and even with insurance, its better to have backup income.

There was a reason why widows were considered vulnerable in the past.

Hardbackwriter · 15/09/2021 09:16

I am surprised at the total number of childless households

Remember that they're counting people who don't have children living with them, not whether they have ever had them. So households without children will always be more numerous as most households with them used to be a household without children and the vast majority will be a household without children again in the future, usually for many years.

MrsColon · 15/09/2021 09:16

I think DH would go part time, I wouldn't just yet because I'm at a tricky career stage and want to progress another layer.

I suppose DH might be a SAHP for a bit when DS starts school, he deals with being at home better than I do.

FedUpAtHomeTroels · 15/09/2021 09:15

It wouldn't change anything, People would just get the bigger house and have it based on the two incomes still.
We both worked and still based our house payment on one income, Dh was the higher earner, the mortgage company and the estate agent tried to push us to loan more against two incomes and get a bigger house.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 15/09/2021 09:14

One thing where I think it would be great would be for charities/associations etc.

I think there'd be a lot more people willing to get involved in running things, or do things like being a Brownie leader, if it wasn't a massive rush to get there for 5.30 from work. Or if you were organising an event, being able to do it "full time" for a few days, rather than squeezing phone calls into your lunch breaks and taking holidays from your job to do it.

MissTrip82 · 15/09/2021 09:12

It’s never been the standard for us.

I’m from a working class family; every generation of women I can trace back has worked.

bunnybuggs · 15/09/2021 09:08

@MorganSeventh

Do you mean the norm for families with children? Because single income households outnumber couples with children quite significantly, although I agree you wouldn't necessarily know it from policy.
that is interesting - it is always about families on the media and in politics - whereas it should emphasise households (could be single, couples, young or old) . I am surprised at the total number of childless households -
Confusedandshaken · 15/09/2021 09:07

I agree that single income has only ever been a middle class thing. My grannies were both cleaners and my mum always worked full time at various low level jobs as did my MIL. The greatgrannies I knew didn't do paid work because it was rural Ireland so there wasn't much around but they all worked very hard on the land growing the family veg and taking care of cows, chickens, grandkids, informal foster kids etc. I am (so far) the first and only woman on mine and DHs side who had the privilege of being a mainly SAHM.

CatTerrier · 15/09/2021 09:07

I, my mother and my grandmother have all been SAHMs, all with husbands that earn enough to make working not necessary.

5zeds · 15/09/2021 09:05

People’s expectations rise with their salaries so I would imagine many “could” live on a single income but don’t. Why don’t they?

CatTerrier · 15/09/2021 09:04

We are a single income household, it makes juggling children easier but also it does all fall down to one person most of the time.

We wouldn't change our set up.

ShortColdandGrey · 15/09/2021 09:04

I am from a working class background and the single income has never been a thing. The single income really is a middle class thing. My grandmothers and their mothers worked. My mum was lucky enough to stay at home for a few years, and my husband has been lucky with my wage to be a stay at home dad while finishing off his degree. I can't wait until he can find a job and we are no longer a single income household. The pressure on one person providing for a family can be a bit much at times.

museumum · 15/09/2021 09:03

A lot would have to change in the world of work. We’d both want to work. I have experimented with part time working 2/3/4 days and found three days to be the minimum I could do and still do my job well and be unstressed.
My dh is in a job in a field which currently would not accommodate any kind of part time working.

So no idea what we’d do.

stackhead · 15/09/2021 09:03

I think maybe if the tide shifted so the expectation was not on the woman staying at home!

We live on one income, mine. My DH does work for 8 hours on a Saturday - only for his sanity. We chose that because I got a new job when my DD was 6 months old and it was too early for me to feel comfortable putting her in nursery.

We don't have many luxuries, but then we don't have expensive taste! We also made the decision to live in a cheaper area with a relatively big commute for me (pre WFH days).

That said, we couldn't do it on the average salary of the area! I'm not majorly high paid, but I earn more than average.

LaetitiaASD · 15/09/2021 09:00

@MadeOfStarStuff

I would be fucking delighted as a single adult household

Never going to happen though

Seriously, why not? In the 1960s / 70s it was very normal from what I understand and we are much richer now? It is simply a question of whether the bottom 99% are willing to vote to make the top 1% a bit poorer.

We have chosen to give all of the benefits of growth to a tiny minority and we can choose a different path.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 15/09/2021 09:00

Hmm. Agree with PPs about it being a middle class thing, no women in my family have ever been a SAHM. All worked, even my great grandmother was a seamstress.

Also as a divorced mother would that absolve my ex husband of child maintenance?

Bluntness100 · 15/09/2021 08:58

Isn’t this the same as asking if your spouse earned enough you didn’t need to work?

As said, millions of people live off a single income.

rougemouse · 15/09/2021 08:57

Lots of people saying "it's already a single parent" but assume by single income OP means one income supporting 2 grown adults plus children?

If this did happen I'd worry for all those halves who didn't work because of the precarious financial instability. We'd go back to the days of women being forced to stay in abusive or unhappy relationships.

tunnocksreturns2019 · 15/09/2021 08:57

Yes another single working parent here, widowed, nearly 5 years doing it all totally on my own, 3.5 years before that with a sick DH. If I had the option I’d still work - it’s one of the few things that keeps me (partially) sane

minatrina · 15/09/2021 08:56

@Pemmican

As PP have said, my working class foremothers have always worked. My dad's wage as a factory hand would never have been enough to feed, clothe and house two adults and two children and I'm frankly bemused at how many people seem to assume differently.
See this is puzzling to me, as my grandad was a miner and his wage was enough to support my nan and their four children in the 60s.

I wonder if location comes into this? We're from a rural village, and maybe the cost of living was a lot lower for these areas? I know my nan and grandad always and still to this day grow so much of their own food, even in their little garden. My nan loves to tell me how much more of a community the village was years ago too, and how everyone would help everyone else with hand-me-downs for clothes, toys, furniture etc, so they didn't buy much.

Maybe this plays into it? I'm sure someone else will have more insight Smile

TheGrumpyGoat · 15/09/2021 08:56

@Bumblenums1234

Well I would hate it as it would mean either, I had to give up my career that I love. Or, dp would be at home everyday whilst I grew resentful that he was chilling out on the money I made. I would still put DS into nursery as I think socialising with other children is really important so dp would just be playing PlayStation and scratching his bollocks all day. This house will remain a two income family I think.
Of course you wouldn’t ‘have to’… you could still both work, you’d just have more disposable income. We could technically live off either one of our salaries, but we still choose to both work.
BungleandGeorge · 15/09/2021 08:54

It’s possible to live on a single income but with a much reduced standard of living. Loads of people live alone. Expectations are way higher now, people have to work to afford it. It’s not necessarily a bad thing and many people enjoy and want to work.

LiamGallagherIsHot · 15/09/2021 08:54

I doubt many women would want to be stuck at home as bored housewives anyway.

OP did say not necessarily the man working. I’ve never been a ‘stuck at home bored housewife’ despite not working. There lots of things to do and get involved in.

Meruem · 15/09/2021 08:51

I’ve been single for years on and off so have had to live on one income. Luckily I have a HA house so the rent is manageable. Could never afford to buy on one salary where I am. I did have a partner once who earned roughly the same as me. We lived together for a spell. We could have managed on one salary, it would have been tight but doable. But we both worked and so the second salary paid for all the luxuries. Regular meals out, trips away, expensive tech, etc.

When I was a kid people rarely ate out, usually it only happened if it was a big celebration, they didn’t go off for weekends in Europe. It was a holiday once a year at most. No tech, no spending money on lots of clothes etc. No gym membership, cleaners etc. So that’s why it was possible for people to manage on one salary. The cost of living has gone up. But so have people’s expectations. Everyone wants the “extras” so that requires 2 salaries. I think there are certainly plenty of families that could manage on one if they lived a basic lifestyle but no one wants that.

idontlikealdi · 15/09/2021 08:50

We could afford to have one of stay at home but it would be pretty boring, I like our lifestyle that the two incomes allow.