Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel if the standard household was single income again?

195 replies

Omydearehert · 15/09/2021 08:01

Not necessarily the man working. How would you feel if a single income was enough to live off of and became the standard again?

OP posts:
lockdownmadnessdotcom · 15/09/2021 10:03

No need for government funded childcare so no need for NI and tax increase to fund social care

Government funding for childcare is very limited - it doesn't scratch the surface of social care and the NI rise is also for the NHS.

Rollercoaster1920 · 15/09/2021 10:03

As a single income, but 2 adult and 2 children family it is already possible, but not easy. But we bought a house 10 years ago, we could not do that today.

I'd really like to see a return to family taxation. The lack of transferable personal allowance and high earner child benefit charge really hurt us. The alternative is all of the second parent's wages being spent on childcare and not seeing the children.

Also housing costs are just too high. I'm hoping the Chinese housing crash will ripple across the world. It'll be painful, but a correction is needed.

thecatsthecats · 15/09/2021 10:03

@LiamGallagherIsHot

I doubt many women would want to be stuck at home as bored housewives anyway.

OP did say not necessarily the man working. I’ve never been a ‘stuck at home bored housewife’ despite not working. There lots of things to do and get involved in.

Yup. I'm currently unemployed, and though job-seeking is consuming a certain amount of my time, I'm having a cracking time, and my husband is enjoying it too, because I love cooking, and am ready to go at the drop of a hat for things he wants to do.

For example, when I'm working, I'm more bothered by him, say, watching the football at home because I only have so much free time. But because I can do whatever I want whilst he's working, I'm happy to sit through it.

It's a cliche, but only boring people get bored. At least regularly, anyway.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 15/09/2021 10:02

I wouldn't like it - we're not in the 1950s anymore and we don't need (mainly) mothers being dependent on (mainly) fathers.

It's better for both parents to work part-time than one not to work at all and the other to work full-time.

leavesthataregreen · 15/09/2021 09:59

@MsPavlichenko

It’s a myth that has been used to both keep women’s wages down (pin money) and encourage the narrative re women’s role providing the bulk of domestic labour. From the Industrial Revolution onwards women worked outside the home as well as within it.
And of course long before the Industrial Revolution women ran cottage industries and farms etc. Women have always worked.
52andblue · 15/09/2021 09:59

I think it would be infinitely better for Society if 1 person could run a household on 1 income or 2 or more on part time incomes, yes.
Far more balanced.

YouMeandtheSpew · 15/09/2021 09:54

It’s an interesting question but definitely moot because we’re heading for a period of major price inflation. I think a lot of people will be concerned about whether two incomes can support their households.

godmum56 · 15/09/2021 09:53

@user1497787065

Sounds good to me. No need for government funded childcare so no need for NI and tax increase to fund social care!

My DC are in their 30s so there was no funding for childcare when they were young. Unless you had a high income and were able to fund 100% of childcare out of income or had family to provide childcare you didn't work. It wasn't a bad thing.

oh yes the SAHP DID work if they could! Historically across the UK there were all kinds of cottage industries and jobs that (mainly women) did at home. making lace, tweed, buttons, mending and altering clothes, various kinds of other piecework, providing cheap childcare, going out to work at jobs in the evening when the main breadwinner was at home. I can't really comment on the 90's...I know that the childcare market has changed. Its more regulated than it was and parent expectations have changed which has put the price up.
thepeopleversuswork · 15/09/2021 09:52

@diddl

When my Mum & Dad married her income wasn't counted towards the mortgage.

A Winter coat had to be saved for.

Bought cake was a treat!

I think people expect/want more now.

2 cars, phones, wifi, Netflix etc-it all obviously adds up.

Obviously people spend more on non-essential consumer goods now than they did 40/50 years ago. But the idea that it all goes on phones/Netflix/cars etc is a bit of a fallacy and quite a damaging one.

It's just not true that if we spent less on consumer goods we could live more comfortably on one income. This whole narrative to me has unpleasant overtones as it's a quick jump from that to saying working mums are only doing it out of greed (I'm not saying you're saying this but its an unhelpful piece of rhetoric).

I'm a single parent (and a relatively high earner) with high outgoings but the vast majority of this goes on housing and costs relating to my DD's childcare and education. I'm fairly sure that would be the same for most double income families. It's housing that's the real killer. And yes, you pay more for housing in big cities and in the South East but not all of us can decamp somewhere rural and cheap.

As a general rule women don't decide to work because they want to buy mobile phones and clothes, they do so either because they need to support the household finances or because they want financial independence.

Caffeinefirst · 15/09/2021 09:51

It’s a class thing and it amazes me that some young people now think there was a time when the great mass of women stayed at home. I grew up in the 70’s and most women in my lower middle class Manchester suburb worked. Teachers, cleaners, shop workers, quite a few secretaries, admin. Looking at my family tree all the women worked in factories, mills, in kitchens. We were latch key children. By the time we left to walk to school our parents had both left for work. We left the key in the empty washing machine in our back porch and whoever was home first let themselves in. Parents got home about 17.30-18.00. I knew a couple of people at school whose mothers didn’t work but they were ends of a scale. Very poor or would be considered very well off.

Lovelydovey · 15/09/2021 09:50

I’d love it - we’d both be part time and have a better work life balance.

KeyboardWorriers · 15/09/2021 09:45

DH and I would still work, it's about far more than the money. In fact we could live fine on a single salary now.

diddl · 15/09/2021 09:44

When my Mum & Dad married her income wasn't counted towards the mortgage.

A Winter coat had to be saved for.

Bought cake was a treat!

I think people expect/want more now.

2 cars, phones, wifi, Netflix etc-it all obviously adds up.

audweb · 15/09/2021 09:42

That would be great as a single working parent who doesn’t receive any maintenance from the dad.

If I was in a relationship though I would still work. He could give up work I guess, but I never aspired to be a stay at home mum, it’s not for me.

Mumoblue · 15/09/2021 09:38

I’m a single parent and quite frankly I don’t want another relationship so I’d be happy if I could live comfortably off of one income.
I want to be able to provide nice things for my son as he grows up, but I have no desire to be in a relationship.

godmum56 · 15/09/2021 09:37

@Pemmican

As PP have said, my working class foremothers have always worked. My dad's wage as a factory hand would never have been enough to feed, clothe and house two adults and two children and I'm frankly bemused at how many people seem to assume differently.
This. I think there were times post both wars when the social drive was to get women out of the workforce so that there would be peacetime jobs for men, but people who do family history research will see the proof on the birth and marriage certificates and census information. If you were working class, then both parents worked.
tunnocksreturns2019 · 15/09/2021 09:35

@onlychildhamster

I would still work. You never know what might happen - bereavement, disability etc and even with insurance, its better to have backup income.

There was a reason why widows were considered vulnerable in the past.

And so many widows are still vulnerable - more so since the government did away with Widowed Parents Allowance
namechange786578 · 15/09/2021 09:30

Unless you had a high income and were able to fund 100% of childcare out of income or had family to provide childcare you didn't work. It wasn't a bad thing.

Not a bad thing? For women, let's face it, it was mostly women, to be forced out of the work place if not rich enough? You really don't think that's a bad thing? You can't see the pitfalls there for women or society at large?

MatildaIThink · 15/09/2021 09:25

It depends on circumstances. When my husband and I first lived together, first got married, we would not have been able to afford much at all on a single income, maybe a room in a shared house between us, we needed two incomes. Now we both have reasonable incomes and in reality we would be very comfortable even with just a single earner, but we both love our careers and neither of us would want to give them up.

A two income household also gives a lot more security, if one partner gets ill, loses their job, or even dies, they still have the second partner's earnings to fall back on. My husband and I both having careers gives us far more security as a family, even if I hated my job I can't see me being willing to give that up.

I do also know some women who would very much like to not have to work, to be a "lady who lunches", I am sure we all know a couple or two where the woman married for money and a comfortable life rather than love. There are also some men who sponge off a successful wife, although they are fewer of them as most women are far less tolerant of that kind of behaviour.

SW1amp · 15/09/2021 09:25

Both my grandmothers work, as much out of choice as necessity
One was a farmer, so not working in some capacity wouldn't have been an option, but my other grandmother did it for the enjoyment of working, despite it meaning she suffered constant racial abuse. I don't really know enough about their finances to know if the money was necessary or nice to have.

I'm not sure there was ever truly a time when one middling income was enough to comfortably support a family though. Yes, people got by, but I doubt it was an active choice for so many women to be SAHM, so much as the consequence of no childcare options, deeply sexist workplaces, and a societal expectation of them doing all the domestic drudge

Waxonwaxoff0 · 15/09/2021 09:22

@user1497787065

Sounds good to me. No need for government funded childcare so no need for NI and tax increase to fund social care!

My DC are in their 30s so there was no funding for childcare when they were young. Unless you had a high income and were able to fund 100% of childcare out of income or had family to provide childcare you didn't work. It wasn't a bad thing.

Er, what about single parents?
malificent7 · 15/09/2021 09:21

Great tbh. .less pressure to "have it all."

user1497787065 · 15/09/2021 09:21

Sounds good to me. No need for government funded childcare so no need for NI and tax increase to fund social care!

My DC are in their 30s so there was no funding for childcare when they were young. Unless you had a high income and were able to fund 100% of childcare out of income or had family to provide childcare you didn't work. It wasn't a bad thing.

Asdf12345 · 15/09/2021 09:19

It would be brilliant as with two reasonable incomes we would be very comfortable indeed.

RobinPenguins · 15/09/2021 09:18

@MissTrip82

It’s never been the standard for us.

I’m from a working class family; every generation of women I can trace back has worked.

Yes same, I’m the first that would have been able to stay at home (and chose not to). The SAHM ideal we get sold now isn’t the historical norm.