Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
TheGirlCat · 16/09/2021 14:53

[quote Babyghirl]@spicedappledonuts
I'm now on the waiting list for ivf but also under a gynecologist who has ordered an mri because I had a scan and a heart shape uterus was seen so he want to c how bad.
So has asked me if my ivf letter comes through to put in on hold to I get the mri.
It's just hurtful when ladies blast other ladies with infertility instead of being understanding and try to see where they are coming from and try at least walk in there shoes.[/quote]
You're going around in circles. We do see where you are coming from, but nothing you have said will ever justify using surrogacy. Full stop.

FourTeaFallOut · 16/09/2021 14:51

Ride

FourTeaFallOut · 16/09/2021 14:51

No, I don't owe you a bleeding heart. Life is shit for people for all sorts of reasons. That doesn't mean we should rude roughshod over the ethics of a situation.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 16/09/2021 14:50

It's just hurtful when ladies blast other ladies with infertility instead of being understanding and try to see where they are coming from and try at least walk in there shoes

Again, there are many people on this thread who DO walk in your shoes but still think surrogacy is appalling and should be banned.

Babyghirl · 16/09/2021 14:49

@spicedappledonuts
I'm now on the waiting list for ivf but also under a gynecologist who has ordered an mri because I had a scan and a heart shape uterus was seen so he want to c how bad.
So has asked me if my ivf letter comes through to put in on hold to I get the mri.
It's just hurtful when ladies blast other ladies with infertility instead of being understanding and try to see where they are coming from and try at least walk in there shoes.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 16/09/2021 14:46

[quote Babyghirl]@TheGirlCat
You really don't know me and what my ability will be like to be a parent so can't judge, I have two furbabies BTW and girl just about to have pups.
But then again you have people having kids that should not be parents, over and over again. So you think it's stops them from having kids.
And to answer your question I would make a dame good mother not that it's any off your business tbh just because I can't seem to carry does not mean I won't make or should not be a mother.[/quote]
I don't doubt your parenting abilities,that's not what's is question.

OhHolyJesus · 16/09/2021 14:37

This is why we don't let people who are emotionally consumed by an issue hold the reins to the legislature and administration around it.

Exactly (and yes humans do it all the time). I think this is why concerns originated around the public consultation, and who is behind it.

The illegitimacy of the ‘Rumplestiltskin’ Surrogacy consultation http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3651968-The-illegitimacy-of-the-Rumplestiltskin-Surrogacy-consultation

FourTeaFallOut · 16/09/2021 14:31

It never ceases to amaze me the level of spin and delusion around your own personal narrative you tell yourself to justify moral and ethical wrongs done to others to get what you want....and try to get others to support you or agree with you

And to be fair, this isn't unique to those who are infertile in looking to leverage their pain to justify the means - humans do it a lot.

If my children came to harm because of -let's say a drink driver- I'd be the first one trying to justify why forming a posse and meating out vigilante justice was perfectly reasonable. This is why we don't let people who are emotionally consumed by an issue hold the reins to the legislature and administration around it.

roarfeckingroarr · 16/09/2021 14:29

After having my baby, I think this kind of surrogacy is SO wrong. My baby needed me; he didn't know his father from Adam and I was the only one he wanted and needed to feel safe. The thought of babies being ripped from their mothers makes me cry:

spicedappledonuts · 16/09/2021 14:24

Not being able to carry a child doesn't mean you wouldn't be a good mother @Babyghirl.

I also understand wanting a baby that is yours genetically, getting to experience all the first with them.
I had all those emotions, it is why I had ivf.

I also get that the soft sell that surrogacy is just the next natural step is desperately appealing when all you want is your own baby.

But it is exploitative and child trafficking. Just because something can be done doesn't mean it should.

OhHolyJesus · 16/09/2021 14:22

@FourTeaFallOut

The surrogate mum doesn’t supply the egg, so she has no biological connection with the infant

No, just every single cell nurtured with her body, the sound of her heartbeat the backdrop to the entity of its consciousness, the sound of her voice your connection to the world outside, not to mention the role of epigenetics...no, no biological connection at all...just a fucking oven.

I understand that mitochondrial DNA is found up to 10 years in a child. It is in minuscule amounts but this argument about it not being the mother's DNA, the baby is being handed back to the genetic parents, and that genetic connections don't matter completely ignores that women who give birth to babies made from donated eggs are considered the mother (they are, they have given birth, is the woman who donated her eggs the mother? No. She remains the genetic mother but there is inconsistency here), the mother growing the baby switches on/off various genetics during pregnancy, and genealogical bewilderment is a real thing, it has been evident for decades. Based on this being a real thing adopted and donor conceived children have built their own networks to find support and connect with others who have similar experiences. If it didn't matter why would these networks exist? There are tv programmes about it, documentaries, studies, a wealth of literary material. Same as attachment theory. It's all just bollocks is it?

It never ceases to amaze me the level of spin and delusion around your own personal narrative you tell yourself to justify moral and ethical wrongs done to others to get what you want....and try to get others to support you or agree with you.

And when they don't agree or pander to the idea that the buying and selling of newborns is all fine and dandy the predictable response is to frame their views as patronising women, suggesting that concerns around exploitation are rooted in not wishing women to have body autonomy and choice.

Babyghirl · 16/09/2021 14:18

@TheGirlCat
You really don't know me and what my ability will be like to be a parent so can't judge, I have two furbabies BTW and girl just about to have pups.
But then again you have people having kids that should not be parents, over and over again. So you think it's stops them from having kids.
And to answer your question I would make a dame good mother not that it's any off your business tbh just because I can't seem to carry does not mean I won't make or should not be a mother.

spicedappledonuts · 16/09/2021 14:17

People who think that a surrogate has no biological connection with their baby have chosen to ignore the science.
Because it makes it easier for them.

But any adult able to put a child's needs first wouldn't have started down surrogacy in the first place.

lifeturnsonadime · 16/09/2021 14:11

should have said fawning not gloating!

lifeturnsonadime · 16/09/2021 14:08

Did Tom Daley really say that? Just shows that the women are just considered as 'rent a womb' and there is money to be made in surrogacy in the UK right now it's just couched as 'expenses' rather than a fee. It's vile.

It really got my goat when everyone was gloating over lovely Tom and his crochet at the olympics with his designer baby back at home, of course he wouldn't have the issues that the breastfeeding mothers had with the controversy over needing to leave babies at home.

RedToothBrush · 16/09/2021 14:06

“The surrogate mum doesn’t supply the egg, so she has no biological connection with the infant. I think that helps,” Daley says.

Bloke needs a biology lesson.

Whats an umbilical cord for?

Also this neglects to highlight how having a foreign egg implanted into you raises the biological risk to both mother and baby.

Of course because this isn't his risk this isn't important.

He wants an increased risk to mother and baby so that the mother has less come back in the future in saying she was the mothet in any way shape or form.

Lets spell this out and be honest about it and who he passes the risk onto and how his promotion of surrogacy which neflects this rather important detail is misleading and gross.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 16/09/2021 14:04

Oh but he's such a lovely man....he knits AND crochets Hmm

TheGirlCat · 16/09/2021 14:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

FourTeaFallOut · 16/09/2021 14:00

The surrogate mum doesn’t supply the egg, so she has no biological connection with the infant

No, just every single cell nurtured with her body, the sound of her heartbeat the backdrop to the entity of its consciousness, the sound of her voice your connection to the world outside, not to mention the role of epigenetics...no, no biological connection at all...just a fucking oven.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 16/09/2021 14:00

@bakingdemon

Another one here with serious misgivings. The sense of entitlement some high profile people who've had children via surrogate have sits very very uneasily with me. It comes across as "of course we can choose to have a child when we want because we will just buy it". I'm thinking of people like Tom Daley and Julia Peyton Jones.

This was from an interview with Daley and made me spit feathers:
Daley says that gay couples are uniquely suited to being parents because they are prepared to endure the daunting surrogacy process. “One of you isn’t going to fall pregnant after a glass of wine on the sofa, that’s for sure,” he says. “You have to want a baby more than anything in the world.
“The surrogate mum doesn’t supply the egg, so she has no biological connection with the infant. I think that helps,” Daley says.

Good God Hmm
bakingdemon · 16/09/2021 13:55

Another one here with serious misgivings. The sense of entitlement some high profile people who've had children via surrogate have sits very very uneasily with me. It comes across as "of course we can choose to have a child when we want because we will just buy it". I'm thinking of people like Tom Daley and Julia Peyton Jones.

This was from an interview with Daley and made me spit feathers:
Daley says that gay couples are uniquely suited to being parents because they are prepared to endure the daunting surrogacy process. “One of you isn’t going to fall pregnant after a glass of wine on the sofa, that’s for sure,” he says. “You have to want a baby more than anything in the world.
“The surrogate mum doesn’t supply the egg, so she has no biological connection with the infant. I think that helps,” Daley says.

floatyfeather · 16/09/2021 13:54

I think it's utterly traumatic for the newborn. Even if they go on to have a lovely life I can't help but think the trauma is inside of you forever. A newborn knows the voice that carried them before they're born. Makes me sad to think about it.

OhHolyJesus · 16/09/2021 13:52

and that's all there is to it 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

I think the issues and examples raised in this thread demonstrates that it's far from 'that's all there is too it', from the ethical questions, laws, costs and payments and errr...the actual human life being created.

It could not be further from "that's all there is to it" but your response goes a long way to support the concerns expressed here, in fact I would go so far to say this is pretty close to the root cause of surrogacy and sums it up nicely.

Babyghirl · 16/09/2021 13:45

@HeartsAndClubs
Hardly f##king vile
And its not a designer baby I want.
And yous don't agree with me where I don't agree with yous everyone can have an opinion you had yours and I had mine.
It's vile knocking someone down who has struggles as I said I will do surrogacy with my egg and oh sperm if I need to and that's all there is to it 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 16/09/2021 13:40

I watched that documentary, that woman was frankly quite odd!