Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
Oldfestivalgoer · 16/09/2021 16:41

@Lockdownbear

I would be a surrogate, and it would be ridiculous of you to think a grown woman is not able to weigh up the risks of a pregnancy and child birth

The trouble is the risks that they might not think about, like the surrogate who was left holding the baby when the couple split up. What happens with a disabled child, what happens is the parents die, aren't able to come for the baby.
You can guarantee that the risk management in international surrogacy are not in the surrogates favour.
What happens when women a forced into it? Plenty of women end up in abusive relationships in the UK how do we know women elsewhere aren't effectively being pimped?

They are. What is happening to women in india, for example, is appalling. But never mind, as long as rich white people can buy babies, eh.

www.theguardian.com/global-development/2016/apr/01/outsourcing-pregnancy-india-surrogacy-clinics-julie-bindel

OhHolyJesus · 16/09/2021 16:32

Families come in all forms, and the most important thing is the baby is loved.

I'm not sure that's all a baby need tbh. I think we should consider what happens when that baby grows up and becomes an adult wanting to start a family. Children in the U.K. who can find their genetic parents can only do so when they reach 18. As the anonymity ban was lifted in 2005, these children haven't reached the age of 18 yet (thought some have found genetic family through 23andMe and other DNA testing websites). I think we should consider a baby a whole human being and what their needs are at all throughout their life.

fb.watch/836zqaU59D/

I do applaud women who donate eggs or do surrogacy with their own eggs.

stopsurrogacynowuk.org/2021/08/20/egg-donation-and-surrogacy-guest-post-from-kat-howard-radfem_kath-short-read/

I'd always pictured a Western woman getting treated like a queen.

Sadly there are many examples of how this isn't the case. See these:

nordicmodelnow.org/2020/01/29/i-was-an-altruistic-surrogate-and-am-now-against-all-surrogacy/

It isn't against the law, although obviously regulated

I've been wondering about this. Does regulating it sanction the process? (Like Holbeck and 'sex work', look how that turned out).

abolition-ms.org/en/statutes/

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 16:26

It's route.

Had to be said.

FourTeaFallOut · 16/09/2021 16:07

@BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII

You have children. So yes, you cannot really comment. I had years of fertility issues and looked at all options, obviously coming across information on surrogacy. I was fortunate enough to have a child via IVF in the end. I will never forgot the heartache, longing and fears of never becoming a mum. I would be a surrogate, and it would be ridiculous of you to think a grown woman is not able to weigh up the risks of a pregnancy and child birth. Personally, I wouldn't want to use my own eggs, I would want an embryo implanted, but I do applaud women who donate eggs or do surrogacy with their own eggs. A parent is more than biology (if the parent has no biological link to the baby - in the UK at least one of the parents has to have a link), I know, I'm adopted. Families come in all forms, and the most important thing is the baby is loved. There are many kids out there missing out on love and basics, even with biological link!!
Oh God, this is marketing spiel 101. Families in different forms Hmm...yeah, that's just like commissioning a baby via another women's womb. Emotionally charged personal narratives trying to circumnavigate the unease of getting at a baby via sales of goods contracts.
Lockdownbear · 16/09/2021 16:06

I would be a surrogate, and it would be ridiculous of you to think a grown woman is not able to weigh up the risks of a pregnancy and child birth

The trouble is the risks that they might not think about, like the surrogate who was left holding the baby when the couple split up. What happens with a disabled child, what happens is the parents die, aren't able to come for the baby.
You can guarantee that the risk management in international surrogacy are not in the surrogates favour.
What happens when women a forced into it? Plenty of women end up in abusive relationships in the UK how do we know women elsewhere aren't effectively being pimped?

BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 16/09/2021 16:02

@longerevenings

I had fertility issues as well as working in Child Protection.

I understand the deep desire to have dc, but that doesn't make surrogacy ok.

Only in your opinion it doesn't make surrogacy ok. I'm my opinion it does make surrogacy ok. It isn't against the law, although obviously regulated. So actually, that makes surrogacy ok, even if you say it isn't 🤷🏼‍♀️
AlwaysLatte · 16/09/2021 16:02

I don't agree with it.

DoucheCanoe · 16/09/2021 16:02

@BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII by that logic you can't comment either as you have a child.

It's ridiculous to say who can and cannot have an opinion on something.

BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 16/09/2021 15:59

You have children. So yes, you cannot really comment. I had years of fertility issues and looked at all options, obviously coming across information on surrogacy. I was fortunate enough to have a child via IVF in the end. I will never forgot the heartache, longing and fears of never becoming a mum. I would be a surrogate, and it would be ridiculous of you to think a grown woman is not able to weigh up the risks of a pregnancy and child birth. Personally, I wouldn't want to use my own eggs, I would want an embryo implanted, but I do applaud women who donate eggs or do surrogacy with their own eggs. A parent is more than biology (if the parent has no biological link to the baby - in the UK at least one of the parents has to have a link), I know, I'm adopted. Families come in all forms, and the most important thing is the baby is loved. There are many kids out there missing out on love and basics, even with biological link!!

Lockdownbear · 16/09/2021 15:56

@Plumtree391

Hermione, I think surrogacy makes most people uncomfortable.
I'll be honest and say until this thread I'd never put much thought into the whole process. Nor did I realise it was big business in certain countries or how exploited those women are.

I'd always pictured a Western woman getting treated like a queen.

Plumtree391 · 16/09/2021 15:51

Hermione, I think surrogacy makes most people uncomfortable.

OhHolyJesus · 16/09/2021 15:43

People saying "you don't have to be a surrogate so don't comment" - completely specious argument. As if you're not allowed to take a moral position on anything that doesn't directly affect you! I'm against human slavery even though I'm not a slave!

I'm against paedophilia but I don't challenge this by not being a paedophile. Heard of safeguarding being everyone's responsibility?

Women who haven't ever been pregnant can have a position on surrogacy. Women who don't want children can have a position on surrogacy. As can men.

I haven't ever been a political dictator but I'd have something to say if I lived under a dictatorship. I haven't ever had cancer but can sympathise with someone who has.

We are not robots, though justifying by this thread, it might be better for some if we were. Robots without thoughts, feelings or morals, who are able to pop out babies for those who want them. Form an orderly queue.

DoucheCanoe · 16/09/2021 15:42

And that's your choice to make @Babyghirl because right now trading human beings is absolutely allowed.

Surrogacy is very much favoured by the privileged.

TheGirlCat · 16/09/2021 15:41

@Babyghirl

And there's no changing that I will go down the surrogacy root to get my much wanted family.
Then you've just shown your selfishness and immaturity when your stubbornness shows that you are not able to consider reasoned arguments against why it is abhorrent and wrong.
RedToothBrush · 16/09/2021 15:36

@Babyghirl

And there's no changing that I will go down the surrogacy root to get my much wanted family.
There isnt much you wouldn't turn a blind eye to then and you'd happily and knowingly harm others to get your child.

Including potentially that child itself.

Cos its all about getting what you want.

FreshApricot · 16/09/2021 15:33

YANBU, paying surrogates is just a polite way of buying human babies. Humans have the right not to be bought and sold. You're correct to compare it to the black market for organs OP but imo it's worse. It blows my mind that people have such a blind spot for it.

Infertility is an awful and distressing experience... but nobody is entitled to a baby.

People saying "you don't have to be a surrogate so don't comment" - completely specious argument. As if you're not allowed to take a moral position on anything that doesn't directly affect you! I'm against human slavery even though I'm not a slave!

TheGirlCat · 16/09/2021 15:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

OhHolyJesus · 16/09/2021 15:25

@Babyghirl

And there's no changing that I will go down the surrogacy root to get my much wanted family.
Exactly.

You will do whatever it takes to get what you want.

Exactly my point.

FourTeaFallOut · 16/09/2021 15:25

Believe it or not, this thread isn't about you. Nor is it about individuals. It's a conversation about the ethics and principles that we decided to live by and how the surrogacy trade rubs up against them.

Babyghirl · 16/09/2021 15:15

And there's no changing that I will go down the surrogacy root to get my much wanted family.

DoucheCanoe · 16/09/2021 15:05

@Babyghirl I have a few friends and family who are/have been struggling with infertility - through discussion I know that none of them would consider surrogacy because it is ethically wrong.

It's not about "tearing ladies down" it's about realising that taking advantage of others isn't the way to fix things. Having a biological child isn't a human right - being protected from exploitation and harm is.

I'm truly sorry that your in a shit position but there's no changing that.

RedToothBrush · 16/09/2021 15:05

[quote Babyghirl]@spicedappledonuts
I'm now on the waiting list for ivf but also under a gynecologist who has ordered an mri because I had a scan and a heart shape uterus was seen so he want to c how bad.
So has asked me if my ivf letter comes through to put in on hold to I get the mri.
It's just hurtful when ladies blast other ladies with infertility instead of being understanding and try to see where they are coming from and try at least walk in there shoes.[/quote]
For the 100th time. This isnt about your feelings nor how awful infertility is.

Its about how you don't solve infertility by trafficking humans and using women as incubators because its exploitive.

Infertile women in many parts of the world dont have this sense of entitlement. Its equally shit for them. But they don't have the option because they are poor.

Equally many infertile women wouldnt dream of using their infertility to exploit other women because they think its a violation of rights and doesn't put children first.

You are making a strawman argument about how you are being picked on and how unfair your life is because you are infertile.

Its not about you.

Lockdownbear · 16/09/2021 15:04

@Babyghirl there are many on here who've walked the infertility road.
I can certainly see how women are exploited through surrogacy, although I'm not against it, I think the surrogates need better protection. The only way I can see that happening is to ban international surrogacy. International surrogacy will always have the contracts written in favour of the parents.

Thinking of the child.
Its hard enough for adopted kids to meet their bio parents, I know someone who went to meet their bio dad to get told actually I'm not your bio dad, I'm on you birth cert because I didn't want people to know your mother had an affair and I hated the guy. So that guy has his adopted dad, birth cert dad, and a bio dad.

Imagine how blown your mind would be to be told that not only have you a surrogate who gave birth to you, your bio mother is neither the woman you call mum or the woman who carried you.

HermioneKipper · 16/09/2021 14:58

[quote Babyghirl]@spicedappledonuts
I'm now on the waiting list for ivf but also under a gynecologist who has ordered an mri because I had a scan and a heart shape uterus was seen so he want to c how bad.
So has asked me if my ivf letter comes through to put in on hold to I get the mri.
It's just hurtful when ladies blast other ladies with infertility instead of being understanding and try to see where they are coming from and try at least walk in there shoes.[/quote]
No one is blasting anyone with infertility. It must be awful and it’s so very unfair.

But that doesn’t make surrogacy ok because your life is hard.

OP posts:
HermioneKipper · 16/09/2021 14:56

[quote Babyghirl]@TheGirlCat
You really don't know me and what my ability will be like to be a parent so can't judge, I have two furbabies BTW and girl just about to have pups.
But then again you have people having kids that should not be parents, over and over again. So you think it's stops them from having kids.
And to answer your question I would make a dame good mother not that it's any off your business tbh just because I can't seem to carry does not mean I won't make or should not be a mother.[/quote]
Yes because furbabies and a dog about to have puppies is exactly the same thing as having a child 🥴

And you don’t take puppies away from their mother immediately at birth either do you?

Yes there are plenty of people having children that probably shouldn’t be. That just shows life is bloody unfair.

It doesn’t mean you should trample all over the rights of another woman and potential baby just to get whatever you want. Sometimes in life you can’t have what you want all the time. Learn to deal with it like an adult

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread