Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 17/09/2021 11:31

@Witchcraftandhokum

Then don't you do it. But perhaps be a little less judgy about people that do
No, that's not how you build ethical principles. I'll be as judgy as I like about the baby trade.
Plumtree391 · 17/09/2021 11:25

ArabellaScott, I agree with you. Quite honestly I wish surrogacy was illegal!

(She means 'judgemental'; 'judgey' is a horrible, Mumsnet abbreviaton.)

Thesandmanishere · 17/09/2021 11:23

But perhaps be a little less judgy about people that do

Lol no, I'll be as judgy I want about this repulsive practice.

ArabellaScott · 17/09/2021 11:22

@Witchcraftandhokum

Then don't you do it. But perhaps be a little less judgy about people that do
'judgy'?

JFC. You think nobody should 'judge' when babies or a disadvantaged woman is suffering, or exploited?

Have you ever considered the concept of morality, at all?

HermioneKipper · 17/09/2021 11:17

@Witchcraftandhokum

Then don't you do it. But perhaps be a little less judgy about people that do
I’ll be as judgy as I like about people who are exploiting women for their own gain and ripping newborn babies from their mothers arms
OP posts:
HermioneKipper · 17/09/2021 11:14

@OhHolyJesus

The Daily Mail have covered the same story.

www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-9998317/Steps-Ian-H-Watkins-reveals-used-surrogacy-team-Elton-John.html

He spilt with his partner when the twin boys were very young. It's not clear if they had twins as a result of each of them fertilising an embryo and putting both of them in the same women's body, or if it occurred naturally. Based on the fact it is an American agency I suspect the former. It also wasn't the first woman they had do this as the article refers to the "first surrogate", how many women went before the woman who had the twin boys? How many failed attempts and miscarriages did these women go through and why are they not being asked how they feel or how they are?

Ian claims that the adoption teams helping were homophobic, odd then that he didn't challenge this at the time then as that would be discrimination but because of this...

"It's you know there's egg donors I know more about women's menstrual cycles than women it's crazy."

...I'll take it as another wild claim.

I'd actually like to know what Giovanna Fletcher thinks of it, she has several children, would she be a surrogate mother and give up a baby or does she recognise the mother/baby bond?

Oh god yes the bit where he says he knows more about women’s menstrual cycles than women. 🙄🙄🙄 FFS. What an idiot

I also got quite irritated with Giovanna for pandering to him. Especially the bit where he was moaning about how expensive it was and how he wanted to get the babies out of hospital ASAP. And away from their mother. The only person they knew in the world. Not a passing comment about the surrogate who’s just given birth to twins. Entitled, arrogant arsehole

OP posts:
Witchcraftandhokum · 17/09/2021 11:03

Then don't you do it. But perhaps be a little less judgy about people that do

OhHolyJesus · 17/09/2021 11:01

The Daily Mail have covered the same story.

www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-9998317/Steps-Ian-H-Watkins-reveals-used-surrogacy-team-Elton-John.html

He spilt with his partner when the twin boys were very young. It's not clear if they had twins as a result of each of them fertilising an embryo and putting both of them in the same women's body, or if it occurred naturally. Based on the fact it is an American agency I suspect the former. It also wasn't the first woman they had do this as the article refers to the "first surrogate", how many women went before the woman who had the twin boys? How many failed attempts and miscarriages did these women go through and why are they not being asked how they feel or how they are?

Ian claims that the adoption teams helping were homophobic, odd then that he didn't challenge this at the time then as that would be discrimination but because of this...

"It's you know there's egg donors I know more about women's menstrual cycles than women it's crazy."

...I'll take it as another wild claim.

I'd actually like to know what Giovanna Fletcher thinks of it, she has several children, would she be a surrogate mother and give up a baby or does she recognise the mother/baby bond?

RedToothBrush · 17/09/2021 10:58

@FourTeaFallOut

I don't know why posters are humouring the kidney analogy. It's this kind dehumanising bullshit that led to the narrative that women can be reduced to incubators.
Cos obviously some people think you can compare a kidney to a child and a woman and all the rights they have.

Protect kidney rights!

FourTeaFallOut · 17/09/2021 10:57

I don't know why posters are humouring the kidney analogy. It's this kind dehumanising bullshit that led to the narrative that women can be reduced to incubators.

BigGreen · 17/09/2021 10:52

Giving a kidney is a bit different as there's a medical safeguarding process in place. As you have two kidneys you can actually have excess capacity, and it is preferable to take kidneys from those with a high or excess capacity (functioning at 90% or higher, right up to 120% capacity). There's a case by case decision-making process for lower than that and a cut-off point where people are not allowed to donate as it's not in their best interests.

Comedycook · 17/09/2021 08:14

@Lockdownbear

I'll bite on the kidney donation. Actually my thoughts are similar.

Should only be done with in the UK. And the donor should be over 40 at least, no young people being talked into giving Granny a kidney. Definitely no international trade in kidneys.

Laws need to be in place to protect donors or people will end up being exploited.

Why would anyone living voluntarily donate a kidney to a random person? I'd suggest anyone who wants to do that needs serious psychological help. Oh and you can bet your bottom dollar, people most likely to do that will be women. #bekind
RedToothBrush · 17/09/2021 07:56

Well a kidney won't grow up and then have issue with it's identity and start searching for its biological owner for starters, and there may be a few other reasons why its different (and can also be highly problematic in its own right)...

... But do crack on with the ridiculous straw man arguments.

Lockdownbear · 17/09/2021 07:42

I'll bite on the kidney donation. Actually my thoughts are similar.

Should only be done with in the UK. And the donor should be over 40 at least, no young people being talked into giving Granny a kidney. Definitely no international trade in kidneys.

Laws need to be in place to protect donors or people will end up being exploited.

ANameChangeAgain · 17/09/2021 07:18

For those people who disagree with surrogacy, how do you feel about kidney donation? this comment sums up why the tabloids love MumsNet on slow news days. Grin

Hamsteronrollerblades · 17/09/2021 06:45

Thanks lockdownbear and arabellascott.

CounsellorTroi · 17/09/2021 05:42

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor

Nastiest post I’ve ever, ever seen on MN

No,it's not nasty, it's straight to the point. If it upsets you you need to ask yourself why it's hitting a nerve. I speak as some one with experience of adoption and 'not having the family I originally hoped for.'

I agree. It’s blunt but not nasty. And I say that as someone who has been through infertility and never had a child.
habibihabibi · 17/09/2021 04:06

Another atrocity in Ukraine is that the babies of failed surrogacy , where the baby was the "wrong" sex, colour, had disabilities etc or the people who "ordered it " didn't show up , end up in orphanages. Where like other developing nations there are already 1000s .
I would like to hear the opinion of any one who has used these "clinics" and how they think it is ok .

Lockdownbear · 17/09/2021 01:29

@Hamsteronrollerblades I'm sorry you went through that and I'm glad society has changed that young single mums are no longer forced to give away their babies.

I'd never seen the parallels to surrogacy before.

I certainly don't think it's right for young women who haven't completed their own family to be surrogates.

I'm really uncomfortable about the idea of young women being targeted for egg donation. Egg retrieval is the most undignified thing ever, and I say that as someone who had been through smear tests, childbirth and IUI. It's really not something a young girl should ever be put through for a few quid. Not to mention the hormone treatments to develop the eggs for retrieval.

No that should be internationally outlawed. And that's before you think about the impact on the babies imagine growing up to be told you bio mum was exploited at the age of 15. FFS!

Delphinium20 · 17/09/2021 00:33

It's bad enough that they manipulate 18-year-old young women to donate their eggs (and in my country, girls as young as 15 are targeted for advertising for egg donation), but to expect an 18-year-old girl be a surrogate? That makes my blood boil. Thanks to Posie for covering this topic.

Redyellowpink · 16/09/2021 22:54

There will always been women who 'chose' to be prostitutes, just like there are women who chose to be surrogates. Doesn't make either right. Doesn't mean both industries aren't harmful and exploitative to women

Plumtree391 · 16/09/2021 22:40

Hamsteronrollerblades Flowers

Plumtree391 · 16/09/2021 22:39

Last but one sentence, I should have removed the 'what'.

Plumtree391 · 16/09/2021 22:37

It is very worrying. Babies are not commodities to be passed around just because somebody who cannot have a baby wants one (I realise there are some who have to be separated from birth parent and others who are orphaned but they are the exceptions).

We cannot always have what we want, that's a fact of life!

Nobody is really thinking about what the baby's needs, it's all about the adult would-be parent.

I wish surrogacy, and some other things, had never started and was never even thought of.

FannyCann · 16/09/2021 22:30

The thread about obstetric injuries.

Guest post: "Women are expected to go home with life-changing injuries after giving birth and jus... www.mumsnet.com/Talk/guest_posts/4302468-Guest-post-Women-are-expected-to-go-home-with-life-changing-injuries-after-giving-birth-and-just-get-on-with-it