Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
Redsquirrel5 · 15/09/2021 00:50

@ArtichokeAardvark

I'll put my head above the parapet. A friend of mine went down the surrogacy route to have her son. She's a cancer survivor but the chemo left her infertile and doctors advised that she shouldn't try carrying her own child even though she had her eggs frozen before starting treatment. She and her DH were desperate for a child and first looked at adopting, but you can't adopt in the UK if you've had cancer.

In the end, they found a surrogate in the US who'd done it once before already. The surrogate also has 3 kids of her own, and became a surrogate because she couldn't afford the extortionate fees to send her eldest to a private school. She enjoys being pregnant and finds pregnancy easy, and it's highly regulated in the US so safe.

I would also like to tell a positive tale. I was against until I met my DDs friend’s mum. They had five children who they loved dearly. Her mum was pregnant with her third surrogacy child a sibling for the first child. She told me that she couldn’t imagine what it would be like if she couldn’t have children and she wanted to help other couples. The one thing they had to agree to was that they would see the child two or three times a year just like an aunty would. Her own children were told at the start and all accepted it. Two of the children were not hers at all and I am not sure about the third I think it was the fathers. They met each year and had outings so all the children felt at ease. She kept photos and a book for each of them so they would be given it later. They’re photos were included with her children. She was only paid for essentials like trips to hospital etc she wasn’t making money out of it at all. As another poster said there are ways around it and some do. I think in the above case and the mum I met then it can work.
YourFinestPantaloons · 15/09/2021 00:49

*having a wank into a cup

Lockdownbear · 15/09/2021 00:48

@DontStepOnTheMomeRathz

My sister had fertility issues. I’d have been a surrogate for her in a heartbeat. But my husband and my mum were so against it. Husband was concerned about the health risks, the potential impact on our young children etc. My mum just thought it was all too close and too weird.

She’s pregnant now, finally, through IVF. But I feel like I could have saved her from that.

If you'd gone down the surrogacy route. How would the baby have been conceived if it wasn't ivf? Surely it's better she carries her own baby?
YourFinestPantaloons · 15/09/2021 00:47

[quote OhGiveUp]@YourFinestPantaloons The same could be said for a sperm donor. Women using the man to gain a baby.
If a woman chooses to become a surrogate, then it's not exploitative nor misogynistic.[/quote]
Not the same at all.

A man donating sperm does not carry a baby. Having a walk into a cup does not pose a serious health risk

HermioneKipper · 15/09/2021 00:47

[quote OhGiveUp]@YourFinestPantaloons The same could be said for a sperm donor. Women using the man to gain a baby.
If a woman chooses to become a surrogate, then it's not exploitative nor misogynistic.[/quote]
That’s hardly the same thing as a woman basically renting her womb for 9 months and then giving up the baby she’s carried for that time. And the baby being taken away from everything it knows. (Not to mention the effects pregnancy and birth have on your body.

Ideally I don’t think women should use sperm donors and go it alone either. Children need two parents if at all possible and people who willingly choose to bring a baby into the world without a father are reckless. And not thinking in the best interests of the child. I know of two women that have done this and both of them have found being a single parent extremely difficult

OP posts:
DontStepOnTheMomeRathz · 15/09/2021 00:44

The same could be said for a sperm donor. Women using the man to gain a baby

I mean I’m generally in favour of surrogacy in a regulated and controlled environment.

But let’s not pretend that this is the same thing.

LobsterNapkin · 15/09/2021 00:43

Totally apart from the issues around the mother, I don't think it's in any way defensible in terms of children's rights.

Neither selling nor giving away children is acceptable, even if they are commission for the purpose.

It's amazing to me that with the real downsides of adoption more and more understood, and regulations and best practices being put into place to try and mitigate them, that we don't see that understanding transferred over to cases of surrogacy.

OhGiveUp · 15/09/2021 00:42

@YourFinestPantaloons The same could be said for a sperm donor. Women using the man to gain a baby.
If a woman chooses to become a surrogate, then it's not exploitative nor misogynistic.

HermioneKipper · 15/09/2021 00:42

[quote OhGiveUp]@IamanUltracrepidarian In that case then, we could say the same for most animals.[/quote]
I agree with that. I don’t eat meat, have adopted pets from animal homes and would never buy a puppy.

OP posts:
longerevenings · 15/09/2021 00:41

There is a difference in creating a world wide trade in babies
And
Removing a baby from its birth mother for their own safety.

Some babies removed at birth will in time in returned to their birth mother and others will be adopted.
It is acknowledged that the removal is a traumatic event for the baby.

The threshold for removal is very high.

OhGiveUp · 15/09/2021 00:39

@IamanUltracrepidarian In that case then, we could say the same for most animals.

IamanUltracrepidarian · 15/09/2021 00:38

That baby wasn’t created with the intention of taking it’s from it’s mother

So, it's staying with its birth mother then?

YourFinestPantaloons · 15/09/2021 00:37

Not to mention separation anxiety a baby will feel when taken from the mother.

There's a right way to do surrogacy, which involves the birth mother sticking around and phasing herself out, and so few people follow this.

My friend was conceived via sperm donor, and has had a world of hell when she accidentally (through Ancestry DNA) found her bio dad's family. Of course back in the 70's people weren't to know this technology would be available, but nevertheless she's very vocal about how she wishes her parents would have considered how SHE felt one day about what they were doing. Because she feels totally shit about never truly knowing where she came from until she found out and had the trauma of her birth family rejecting her for various reasons.

IamanUltracrepidarian · 15/09/2021 00:36

In England Wales the government are looking at/ consulting on changes the law in the UK to allow for a more commercial approach and with more security/ certainty for the commissioning parent/s

I find that chilling and sinister.

DontStepOnTheMomeRathz · 15/09/2021 00:35

My sister had fertility issues. I’d have been a surrogate for her in a heartbeat. But my husband and my mum were so against it. Husband was concerned about the health risks, the potential impact on our young children etc. My mum just thought it was all too close and too weird.

She’s pregnant now, finally, through IVF. But I feel like I could have saved her from that.

YourFinestPantaloons · 15/09/2021 00:33

YANBU, I agree with every word you say. No one is entitled to a biological child and using another woman's womb for the need to have a biological child, is deeply, deeply misogynistic

longerevenings · 15/09/2021 00:32

As early as the second week of pregnancy, there is a two-way flow of cells and DNA between the fetus and the mother. Cells containing DNA from the fetus cross the placenta and enter the mother's blood circulation, while cells from the mother cross in the opposite direction and transfer into fetal circulation.
Birth mother and baby are very connected during pregnancy.

But I don't think trade in humans should be okay just because the person doesn't share dna.
It isn't legal to sell your step children after all.

Adoption happens because it is thought to be the best option for the child, in the UK no money changes hand at any point.

LiamGallagherIsHot · 15/09/2021 00:32

OhGiveUp

That baby wasn’t created with the intention of taking it’s from it’s mother.

I’m not going to comment further, it’s always the same on here, I’ve seen too much to not end up getting deleted. It’s unethical and wrong.

IamanUltracrepidarian · 15/09/2021 00:31

doing it purely for giving the gift of a baby to a family

But babies aren't gifts - commodities - to be given. It's wrong to create a life with the intention of taking it away from its mother.

OhGiveUp · 15/09/2021 00:26

@LiamGallagherIsHot But you could say the same for a mother who gives up her baby for adoption at birth.
At least the baby being given by a surrogate is going to loving parents as a much longed for child.

Rangoon · 15/09/2021 00:21

Most surrogates don't share any DNA with the baby. The idea that we should outlaw this behaviour on the grounds that the women who consent to do this aren't adults who make choices suggests that you, somebody not involved in the situation because it "doesn't sit right with" you, knows better than these women. I wouldn't have ever considered being a surrogate but I don't assume everybody thinks like me or is in my circumstances.

longerevenings · 15/09/2021 00:20

Leaving woman aside, there actual infants here.
Infants who are being traded.
It is considered to be so damaging to remove babies from their mothers that social workers will only get permission to do this in extreme circumstances.
These surrogate babies aren't given this basic protection.

LiamGallagherIsHot · 15/09/2021 00:19

And no one ever seems to mention the baby, created with the intention of taking them away from their mother.

strivingtosucceed · 15/09/2021 00:17

In a society that regulates it properly, I don't see how surrogates (especially when the donor egg and/or sperm come from the intended parents) can be said to have been exploited.

In the UK at least, you can't even pay them and even so, this argument of "pregnancy being dangerous" doesn't hold water. There are many dangerous professions worldwide, but people don't think it's exploitative to do those. You can sign up for a drug trial and get paid, is that exploitative too?

Posts like this infantilising women will never not annoy me, why do you think you know better for people than they do for themselves? Bleurgh

OhGiveUp · 15/09/2021 00:16

@LiamGallagherIsHot There are yes, but equally there are plenty who aren't.
As it's been said up thread, in the UK you're not allowed payment for surrogacy, only expenses incurred.
I can't see many alcoholics junkies kicking down the door to become a free surrogate, nor can I see many people opting for one as opposed to a clean healthy woman.
Not all surrogate's are poverty struck or desperate.