Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
Nomoreusernames1244 · 15/09/2021 09:50

To me, it’s not that far away from porn or sex work.

Just because someone “chooses” it, and is financially rewarded for it, doesn’t mean it’s right.

And that’s without considering the child in this situation.

If you wouldn’t donate a kidney to a stranger, why would you give then a baby? Stranger organ donation is very rare.

I understand the childless issue. I can understand truly altruistic surrogacy, for a close relative or friend, for example. But there should be no money involved.

Lemonsandlemonade · 15/09/2021 09:48

@IamanUltracrepidarian coz they never end well. They become anti donor threads.

CounsellorTroi · 15/09/2021 09:47

[quote Babyghirl]@HermioneKipper
All I will say is put yourself in the shoes of someone that can't have kids naturally and it's the only root they can take to have the family they dream off 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️[/quote]
I am in those shoes and I would not have considered surrogacy.

Babyghirl · 15/09/2021 09:44

@HermioneKipper
All I will say is put yourself in the shoes of someone that can't have kids naturally and it's the only root they can take to have the family they dream off 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

HeartsAndClubs · 15/09/2021 09:42

All surrogacy should be illegal. And it should be illegal for a woman to buy a baby in another country, so no travelling abroad to pick up your baby from and coming back with a baby hoping that it will be a British citizen.

And no, “just because you haven’t been through fertility issues” isn’t a reason to say women can’t hold that opinion. It’s really unfortunate that people have fertility issues and can’t have children. But sometimes that is nature. It doesn’t seem fair, but that doesn’t mean that they have the right to exploit whom so ever or pay whatever price is required for a baby. Sometimes just because something can be done, doesn’t mean that it should.

And yes, the same goes for same sex couples. If you’re in a relationship with someone who is the same sex as you then one of the consequences of that is that you won’t be able to have children. Adoption is obviously different, but if adoption isn’t for you then that doesn’t entitle you to go down whatever other route you need to buy a baby.

I disagree with egg/sperm donation as well as it happens.

It’s interesting that we never hear from the children born of these arrangements. We never have people come on to these threads saying “I was the product of surrogacy and I’m so grateful to the woman who carried me so that my parents could have me.” In fact there are countless forums devoted to the children born as a result of donation who have struggled with their lack of identity all their lives. It is in fact why the law has been changed to enable the children of donation to trace their biological parents when they turn 18.

But as ever it’s always just about the woman’s wish for a baby, with no consideration for that actual baby.

And anyone who thinks that women aren’t paid to be surrogates in the UK is naive. No, officially they can’t be paid, but they can claim expenses of up to £15000. That amounts to payment where I’m standing. No pregnancy costs £15k.

vivariumvivariumsvivaria · 15/09/2021 09:40

Here is a really interesting podcast I listened to recently. It is 3 womens health physios, one was an altruistic surrogate.

It's a interesting listen, particularly the way that covid helped. I don't think this woman was at all consciously coerced (lots of family upset that the sister wasn't a mother though), but I also don't think the experience sounds like it was good for her.

The infant is barely mentioned, other than much wanted etc.

Interestingly, the woman who was the surrogate got pregnant with her own child 12 weeks after delivering her sister's baby.

anchor.fm/atyourcervix/episodes/Ep-12-S1-My-Surrogacy-Journey-with-Katie-Richardson-e13pj8o

IamanUltracrepidarian · 15/09/2021 09:39

@Lemonsandlemonade

God I hate threads like this.
Why?
mustlovegin · 15/09/2021 09:35

There was a case in the US relatively recently where the birth mother died giving birth, leaving her own children motherless. The baby survived and went to its adoptive parents

Surrogacy is relatively new. Perhaps as these incidents become more widely known, women will think twice before becoming surrogates.

I didn't know there is more risk if the egg isn't your own, for instance.

SorryAuntLydia · 15/09/2021 09:33

@Lockdownbear

Did you know - that using someone else’s egg makes it higher risk for you of pregnancy complications? No I didn't know that. But I can certainly see why a couple would prefer to have their biological embryo carried by another woman rather than using the womans own eggs. - that there is a lot of evidence for children removed from their mothers at birth suffering long term health problems? Where is that evidence, 1000s of babies were removed from teenage / single birth mums, in the past. - that surrogacy does not require parental assessment of suitably unlike adoption or fostering, so there is no way of knowing if a baby would be truly loved? Millions of babies are conceived every year without any sort of parental assessment. The surrogate is more than capable of saying No I don't want to work for a certain couple or individual.
But I can certainly see why a couple would prefer to have their biological embryo carried by another woman rather than using the womans own eggs. oh well if that’s what they’d prefer, ok then

Where is that evidence, 1000s of babies were removed from teenage / single birth mums, in the past.
You answered your own question. Do your own research, google is your friend here. Loads and loads and loads of data on how this affects brain development, long term mental health etc

The surrogate is more than capable of saying No I don't want to work for a certain couple or individual.
Go tell that to the women working in the baby factories in eg India and Bulgaria.

Lemonsandlemonade · 15/09/2021 09:32

God I hate threads like this.

MrsColon · 15/09/2021 09:30

On another note - I think the regulations ought to include whether prospective parents would be suitable. In the US there have been cases of paedophiles using surrogates Sad

MrsColon · 15/09/2021 09:28

I have a huge problem with paid surrogacy - it's very wrong that rich people are paying poor women to rent their actual uterus, with all the risks that go hand-in-hand with pregnancy (many, many women are seriously damaged by childbirth, whether that be incontinence, sexual disfunction, pelvic injuries, diastatis recti, hernia, tearing...etc.).

Some of the more serious risks are more likely to occur when a woman gestates a child that is not hers biologically.

There was a case in the US relatively recently where the birth mother died giving birth, leaving her own children motherless. The baby survived and went to its adoptive parents.

Altruistic surrogacy, I'm on the fence. I'd do it for my sister or sister in law if she needed it, even though last pregnancy I had HG. I'd not do it for anyone else though. I think there's the potential for family members to be pressured into it, and it's not highly regulated like, e.g. living kidney donation.

We need more, not fewer, regulations to protect women from exploitation.

Lockdownbear · 15/09/2021 09:25

Did you know
- that using someone else’s egg makes it higher risk for you of pregnancy complications? No I didn't know that. But I can certainly see why a couple would prefer to have their biological embryo carried by another woman rather than using the womans own eggs.
- that there is a lot of evidence for children removed from their mothers at birth suffering long term health problems? Where is that evidence, 1000s of babies were removed from teenage / single birth mums, in the past.
- that surrogacy does not require parental assessment of suitably unlike adoption or fostering, so there is no way of knowing if a baby would be truly loved? Millions of babies are conceived every year without any sort of parental assessment. The surrogate is more than capable of saying No I don't want to work for a certain couple or individual.

Minster2012 · 15/09/2021 09:24

Sorry @SorryAuntLydia I'm afraid you are incorrect. Surrogacy does involve parental assessment. We were assessed by social services & had to be assessed by an independent counsellor (as did the surrogate) as well as further assessments by the ivf unit including going to their ethics committee before we could go ahead.

A much more rigorous process than anyone TTC goes through

SorryAuntLydia · 15/09/2021 09:12

Surrogacy between family members is different to stranger/commercial surrogacy in some ways but still ethically fraught. The potential for coercion is immense.

Indeed.

Thesandmanishere · 15/09/2021 09:07

Yanbu. It's gross.

SorryAuntLydia · 15/09/2021 09:07

@Myusernameisnotmyusernameno

I think I could be a surrogate if it wasn't my egg but I agree to carry and give birth to a baby then give it away straight away would be very difficult. The baby hears your voice first in the womb so I do wonder what effect it has on them. However, if they are being looked after by people who truly love them and care for them I think it would be ok. You are right and brave to raise it.
You think you could be a surrogate? I’m glad you have noticed the op is brave and right to raise this issue.

Did you know

  • that using someone else’s egg makes it higher risk for you of pregnancy complications?
- that there is a lot of evidence for children removed from their mothers at birth suffering long term health problems?
  • that surrogacy does not require parental assessment of suitably unlike adoption or fostering, so there is no way of knowing if a baby would be truly loved?
Calamityhuman · 15/09/2021 09:03

It’s a tricky and very emotive topic. I disagree with it ethically as I don’t believe you should be able to buy another woman’s body. Also pregnancy and childbirth were incredibly difficult for me and it is a really big risk for the surrogate to take.

However i have been fortunate enough to have children so I can look at it from a position of privilege. I’m not sure what I could do it I couldn’t have had any children. I would like another child but can’t due to previous birth complications and definitely wouldn’t consider surrogacy for this.

I was also separated from my child at birth for a prolonged period due to prematurity and I don’t feel that it has caused any attachment problems (yet!) but who knows long term I suppose.

CounsellorTroi · 15/09/2021 09:01

@Sleepyquest

I feel when it is done out of love for example, your sister is your surrogate, then it is ok and lovely.

when it is done for commercial reasons I.e. a gay man wants a baby so he effectively buys one, then it is not ok and shouldn't be allowed.

There seems to be a lot of wealthy gay men having twins lately, and it definitely doesn't sit right with me. I'm sure they will give the babies a good life but human life should not be bought.

Wealthy women and heterosexual couples buy babies too. Don’t make this all about gay men.
Sleepyquest · 15/09/2021 08:59

I feel when it is done out of love for example, your sister is your surrogate, then it is ok and lovely.

when it is done for commercial reasons I.e. a gay man wants a baby so he effectively buys one, then it is not ok and shouldn't be allowed.

There seems to be a lot of wealthy gay men having twins lately, and it definitely doesn't sit right with me. I'm sure they will give the babies a good life but human life should not be bought.

PinkPlantCase · 15/09/2021 08:56

A PP mentioned why are we okay with having pets if we aren’t okay with surrogacy….

You can’t take a puppy away from its mum until 8 weeks, so why is it okay to take a baby from its birth mother almost instantly?

It is a feminist issue, if you’d have posted this under the feminist topic you’d have got different responses.

BBC 3 did a programme about surrogacy recently. There were many uncomfortable moments, including decisions being made about interventions to labour and birth by people other than the woman giving birth.

SorryAuntLydia · 15/09/2021 08:56

[quote backtoschoolagainagain]If Mumsnet was around 300 years ago, the human rights issue of the day would have been slavery.

Can you imagine mumsnet if it had existed then? Lots of stories of how happy people's slaves were, how Mumsnetter saved them from a terrible life by bringing them into their nice houses and how slavery was really a good thing in countries with proper regulations.

This is what's going on, on this thread.

Surrogacy is a human rights issue but people here are falling for the PR. I started from that position too.

But if you look into it, you find women treated despicably, even in countries like the US. (The laws protect largely the buyers, not the mother). And women treatde no better than slaves in baby factories in less developed countries.

And men buying huge numbers of babies, collecting humans. Some with partners, doing it for status symbol reasons, others for bizarre reasons like one single guy who's trying to collect 1,000 children, brought up by nannies, he says, to rig elections locally as he thinks they'll all vote for him. (He's obviously never heard of teenage rebellion).

And, men buying babies to abuse.

We can't stop this while surrogagcy exists.

Please, listen to the audio of this talk (bottom of the page) to understand what it is you're supporting.

filia.org.uk/latest-news/2019/11/8/surrogacy-a-human-rights-violation-filia-conference-2019[/quote]
Absolutely.

@HermioneKipper you are right to be disturbed by surrogacy- it’s a form of people trafficking. The baby is created to be traded, removed from its mother at birth - which is considered animal cruelty when it happens to a puppy.

Women involved in surrogacy face higher risk pregnancies, often suffer birth injuries, and some tragically die. Leaving their own children without a mother.

There are also many documented cases of ‘commissioning parents’ allegedly desperate for a baby - but only a perfect one - so refusing to pay for or accept a child born with a disability.

Being childless but not by choice is of course devastating - but trampling on the rights of babies and abusing women’s bodies is not the solution.

And there’s a special place in hell for the men who choose surrogacy because they don’t have a womb but want a sliver of their own genetic material in baby form to boost their own ego.

Has no-one heard of adoption?

Surrogacy is slavery and should be banned.

CounsellorTroi · 15/09/2021 08:56

I have personal experience of infertility. It’s heartbreaking when someone wants a child and can’t have one - but that desire doesn’t and shouldn’t trump all other ethical considerations.

znaika · 15/09/2021 08:53

[quote backtoschoolagainagain]If Mumsnet was around 300 years ago, the human rights issue of the day would have been slavery.

Can you imagine mumsnet if it had existed then? Lots of stories of how happy people's slaves were, how Mumsnetter saved them from a terrible life by bringing them into their nice houses and how slavery was really a good thing in countries with proper regulations.

This is what's going on, on this thread.

Surrogacy is a human rights issue but people here are falling for the PR. I started from that position too.

But if you look into it, you find women treated despicably, even in countries like the US. (The laws protect largely the buyers, not the mother). And women treatde no better than slaves in baby factories in less developed countries.

And men buying huge numbers of babies, collecting humans. Some with partners, doing it for status symbol reasons, others for bizarre reasons like one single guy who's trying to collect 1,000 children, brought up by nannies, he says, to rig elections locally as he thinks they'll all vote for him. (He's obviously never heard of teenage rebellion).

And, men buying babies to abuse.

We can't stop this while surrogagcy exists.

Please, listen to the audio of this talk (bottom of the page) to understand what it is you're supporting.

filia.org.uk/latest-news/2019/11/8/surrogacy-a-human-rights-violation-filia-conference-2019[/quote]
Great post. It is an unfathomable barbarism and the only arguments in support amount to emotiional blackmail

Myusernameisnotmyusernameno · 15/09/2021 08:49

I think I could be a surrogate if it wasn't my egg but I agree to carry and give birth to a baby then give it away straight away would be very difficult. The baby hears your voice first in the womb so I do wonder what effect it has on them. However, if they are being looked after by people who truly love them and care for them I think it would be ok. You are right and brave to raise it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread