Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
Lockdownbear · 15/09/2021 16:44

@spicedappledonuts ah, I didn't really understand the thought process either. Smile Didn't make any sense, how was she going to get pregnant as a surrogate other than IVF or IUI which I found more stressful than IVF.

HeartsAndClubs · 15/09/2021 16:43

Some parents may feel they want a baby that is genetically theirs. Others feel they don't want the issues that come with adoption, children with attachments issues who were neglected in the early stages. Very few babies come up for adoption in the UK. I agree with this, but it’s interesting that parents who go for surrogacy are perfectly comfortable doing to a baby, ie.removing it from its parent, for their own gain and yet they shy away from adoption because many children have the attachment issues they are potentially helping to create in their own biological child born of surrogacy.

spicedappledonuts · 15/09/2021 16:41

In particular @Lockdownbear
I was responding to this

  • DontStepOnTheMomeRathz My sister had fertility issues. I’d have been a surrogate for her in a heartbeat. But my husband and my mum were so against it. Husband was concerned about the health risks, the potential impact on our young children etc. My mum just thought it was all too close and too weird.

She’s pregnant now, finally, through IVF. But I feel like I could have saved her from that.*

A wide range of people use surrogates.

Lockdownbear · 15/09/2021 16:25

@spicedappledonuts how is surrogacy avoiding IVF, I'd have thought the majority of surrogate births are an extension of IVF.
You've hardly got a gay man, servicing a woman, to get her pregnant.

spicedappledonuts · 15/09/2021 16:21

I had ivf, I found it a brutal process.
I actually couldn't face doing it more than once.

But it isn't right to ask a newborn baby to undergo a trauma at birth of being removed from their mother to spare another adult the stress of ivf.

An individual child may have the resilience that means they're not significantly impacted by this longer term.
But we shouldn't push our stress and challenges downwards onto new born children we need to own it and manage it ourselves as responsible adults.

Lockdownbear · 15/09/2021 16:16

@HoboSexualOnslow

It annoys me that people don't go for adoption over surrogacy.
I don't think people can comment on that. Not all surrogate parents would even consider adoption.

Some parents may feel they want a baby that is genetically theirs. Others feel they don't want the issues that come with adoption, children with attachments issues who were neglected in the early stages. Very few babies come up for adoption in the UK.

A quote from Banardos "too old at 4"
A high percentage of children looking for adoptive families are older than 4, few people will take children 4 or older.

arield · 15/09/2021 16:10

@DontStepOnTheMomeRathz

My sister had fertility issues. I’d have been a surrogate for her in a heartbeat. But my husband and my mum were so against it. Husband was concerned about the health risks, the potential impact on our young children etc. My mum just thought it was all too close and too weird.

She’s pregnant now, finally, through IVF. But I feel like I could have saved her from that.

Saved her from having her own pregnancy? So arrogant
Thesandmanishere · 15/09/2021 16:05

But our neighbours (male married couple) have a daughter born through surrogacy (in Russia where one of the dads is from) and they are such a lovely family and great parents

Oh aye, and I daresay the surrogate mum was wealthy.

Oh wait.

HoboSexualOnslow · 15/09/2021 16:00

It annoys me that people don't go for adoption over surrogacy.

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 15/09/2021 15:57

I have to say that I find the idea that a life can be bought or procured in this manner extremely disturbing

WildBluebell · 15/09/2021 15:52

Surrogacy should be banned. No one is entitled to a child. If you can't have children, you can't have children. Find something else to do with your life.

To those people saying "I don't think it harms the baby" - it doesn't matter what you think. It has been proven it harms the baby.

Theluggage15 · 15/09/2021 15:26

Completely correct heartsandclubs,
‘In essence, adoption is done for the benefit of the child, surrogacy is done for the benefit of the adult.’

Any type of surrogacy is wrong, whether for money or ‘altruistic’. The baby’s needs barely feature in surrogacy. And for people saying this thread is hurtful, that’s just ridiculous, I’m tired of the attitude these days that because some people may get hurt feelings, subjects should be closed. No thanks.

HeartsAndClubs · 15/09/2021 15:05

I have to say that all this insistence from some that because they couldn’t have a baby nobody should be allowed to question whether the commodification of human beings is acceptable makes me lose a lot of sympathy for some of the infertile.

Not those who recognise the pitfalls and who wouldn’t enter down the route of surrogacy, but those who accuse people of daring to question the practice of being goadie/deliberately hurtful. It’s as if they feel that infertility gives them the right to barge everything and everyone out of the way just so they can get what they want. It’s not an attractive trait.

HeartsAndClubs · 15/09/2021 15:02

who are YOU to create a thread for your own enjoyment, when you are more than aware it will hurt so many people.

What a strange world you live in where you think that raising a topical, and extremely relevant issue is about people’s enjoyment. Perhaps the OP (and myself and many others on this thread) don’t enjoy the prospect of women being exploited for the benefit of others.

You still managed what so many cannot.

And? Not being able to have a baby doesn’t entitle anyone to exploit someone else for their own benefit.

Be grateful for that, and stop making goady threads for absolutely no reason.

And again, just because someone can’t have a child, doesn’t mean there aren’t good reasons why surrogacy shouldn’t be discussed.

I hope purposely upsetting people helps you sleep at night.

Perhaps if you’re so upset by a thread you should think about whether the internet is the best place for you. Or maybe you should use the hide function so that you’re not upset by it.

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 15/09/2021 14:52

@HeartsAndClubs

As for your second point, I haven’t read these studies. However, I still feel that surrogate babies can have a loving and fulfilling life. Plus, you’re also being (by default) very disparaging about adoptive babies/families. it is important to recognise that removing a baby, any baby, from its mother at birth is going to be traumatic for that baby, even if that is for the purposes of adoption. The difference between adoption and surrogacy however is that the baby is removed for its own wellbeing and safety, and the adoptive parent has been put forward as someone who can provide that home for the baby. Acknowledging where the baby came from and the start they had in life isn’t being disparaging of adoption, it’s recognising the reasons behind adoption while still acknowledging the trauma which surrounds it.

Removing a surrogate baby from its mother at birth however is done purely for the benefit of the intended parents, the people who feel that surrogacy is the only way they will have a child. It’s also important to recognise that many parents don’t want to go down the route of adoption precisely because they don’t feel they are equipped to deal with a child with severe emotional and attachment issues, but are quite happy to do the same to a newborn which has been produced to order.

In essence, adoption is done for the benefit of the child, surrogacy is done for the benefit of the adult.

This is bang on

Couldn’t agree more

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 15/09/2021 14:50

I don’t agree with it at all not even having a baby for someone else you love, actually especially having a baby for someone you love.

backtoschoolagainagain · 15/09/2021 14:46

@Blossomtoes

Money and desperation clearly play an enormous part in these decisions

In every case? That’s clear in every surrogate birth? It’s quite obviously not the case with altruistic surrogacy.

So, not only do we deny women bodily autonomy when it suits them, but we infantilise them and tell them they can’t choose for themselves because they’re poor. This just gets worse.

This argument is bollocks and it's used to justify the sex trade, another trade in exploitation of largely poor women.

If a woman is only making a choice because she's so poor the alternative looks worse and she wouldn't make it otherwise, that's not a proper choice.

SorryAuntLydia · 15/09/2021 14:44

[quote lynntheyresexpeople]@HermioneKipper who are YOU to create a thread for your own enjoyment, when you are more than aware it will hurt so many people.

You still managed what so many cannot. Be grateful for that, and stop making goady threads for absolutely no reason. I hope purposely upsetting people helps you sleep at night.[/quote]
@lynntheyresexpeople

who are YOU to tell people to ignore an issue that hurts so many people.

You can choose not to get involved - babies born through surrogacy cannot. Be grateful for that, and stop making goady comments for absolutely no reason. I hope purposely upsetting people helps you sleep at night.

HermioneKipper · 15/09/2021 14:34

@lynntheyresexpeople Oh do go away and hassle people on another thread. You’ve made your point. Although I disagree.

I am allowed to raise valid ethical concerns about the safety of women and children on a parenting forum.

You’re clearly far too precious if you can’t read anything without throwing your toys out of the pram

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/09/2021 14:32

People have every right to start a thread about a topical issue, whether or not people are offended or upset by it. There is a "hide thread" function.

lynntheyresexpeople · 15/09/2021 14:26

@HermioneKipper who are YOU to create a thread for your own enjoyment, when you are more than aware it will hurt so many people.

You still managed what so many cannot. Be grateful for that, and stop making goady threads for absolutely no reason. I hope purposely upsetting people helps you sleep at night.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 14:06

In every case? That’s clear in every surrogate birth? It’s quite obviously not the case with altruistic surrogacy.

It doesn’t have to be in every case to be an enormous ethical problem. But we have to ask ourselves, are privileged women from rich countries, with lots of options open to them lining up to be paid surrogates? No they aren’t.

Altruistic surrogacy has its own issues, I posted about my concerns there earlier in the thread.

HeartsAndClubs · 15/09/2021 14:04

The hypocrisy of some people never fails to amaze me. In any discussion about abortion there are endless posts defending to the death a woman’s right to do what the hell she likes with her own body and everyone else should butt out. Yet here apparently a woman’s bodily autonomy should be removed because other people don’t approve of her choice. The double standards are mind blowing. but this isn’t just about bodily autonomy is it? It’s about bringing another human being into the world, it’s also about women who are exploited for their ability to bear children for the childless, because they live in abject poverty for instance or even because of the pressure on them to “do the right thing.”

Even on this thread anyone who dares to criticise surrogacy is told that they’re being insensitive to the infertile and how dare they have an opinion if they’ve never been through infertility, therefore it’s entirely likely that this kind of pressure follows through families even, where e.g. a woman has fertility issues and knows that her sister can have children, there is almost certainly an unspoken pressure felt by the sister to “do the right thing” and to give that woman the ability to have a child. After all, she doesn’t know what it’s like to be infertile..”

As for abortion, the woman’s right to bodily autonomy is actually removed at 24 weeks because at that point the baby is viable and therefor it is not considered to be ethical to terminate the pregnancy.

So no, this has nothing to do with bodily autonomy and everything to do with the reasons and understanding behind the process.

There are women who are willing prostitutes, yet we still criticise the sex industry because of what it stands for. Women who are happy to star in porn, and again, we criticise that fact because the industry turns women into commodities. Surrogacy is just yet another example of where women are exploited for their ability to provide something, even if they do do it willingly.

longerevenings · 15/09/2021 14:04

Even if you accept that adults have the right to use and sell any part of their body as they wish ( which isn't legally the case anywhere) Selling body parts isn't legal.

It still doesn't address the child protection issues.
The child trafficking which has both moral concerns and practical ones.

Blossomtoes · 15/09/2021 14:00

Money and desperation clearly play an enormous part in these decisions

In every case? That’s clear in every surrogate birth? It’s quite obviously not the case with altruistic surrogacy.

So, not only do we deny women bodily autonomy when it suits them, but we infantilise them and tell them they can’t choose for themselves because they’re poor. This just gets worse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread