Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 15/09/2021 21:59

my egg my baby only thing is someone else will carry for me

And there we have it, the commodification of women to fulfil your desires.

Babyghirl · 15/09/2021 21:58

I really hope for all the ladies on this thread that is ambushing ladies for wanting a baby and it's the only root left to go and have daughters of your own they don't have fertility issues.

Babyghirl · 15/09/2021 21:56

@MayorGoodwaysChicken
I know people who have adopted kids that where taking of there birth mothers and guess what they are a star pupils doing really well and heading towards a great career.
And they will tell you they could not be happier so as long as a child is loved a child well thrive but as I said my egg my baby only thing is someone else will carry for me.
Everyone has an opinion and that's mine and I won't change my mind on it.

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 15/09/2021 21:56

[quote Babyghirl]@DebbieHarrysCheekbones
Why does anyone have kids not for a laugh, but because they Want one so why am I different to anyone else, oh wait because I'm struggling does not make that want any less, yes I might not be the birth mother but I will be it's biological mother. Have you had trouble with fertility and know what one who has is going through 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️[/quote]
I am a mother
I have carried and given birth to three beautiful healthy babies. It is precisely because of that I know that the minutes and hours that followed their birth showed me what the last nine months of my life had been about. There was a bind and a connection that depended entirely on them being with me or around me and not handed to someone else. I was their world. They sought me and I sought them the second they were born.

It is a denigration of the very thing you seek to try and diminish this. And truthfully that terrifies me

bookh · 15/09/2021 21:55

@TakeMe2Insanity I agree. It was just that one comment I couldn't follow. And yes, very similar experience. Fifteen years here, but zero for second. I should have nine.

As I said the only experience I have was entirely positive, wonderfully so In two particular cases which I will remember forever.

GlitchStitch · 15/09/2021 21:51

The twisting people will do to justify appalling things as long as it gets them what they want. The poster who can't have another child because pregnancy will probably kill her, so you're considering using your sister as a surrogate. To get the exact amount of kids you want you would put your sister through something you've acknowledged can be fatal.
And one of the parents of a surrogate child on this thread has previously posted about their story and it was pretty clear their surrogate had mental health issues. But now it's being painted as an amazing success story.
Surrogacy should be illegal in all cases.

crazyguineapiglady · 15/09/2021 21:51

Buying and selling people is fucked up, however young they are.

RedToothBrush · 15/09/2021 21:50

@TheKeatingFive

I don’t know if you could automatically count that as trafficking/buy/sell humans.

But that’s what it literally is. A baby as commodity. Regardless of the relationship.

This.

I'm against it in all circumstances.

If your first act 'as a parent' is to remove it from the woman who gave birth, then yes I find that problematic.

And no, even if its not for money I still think surrogacy reprehensible.

A baby isn't a 'gift' to give/recieve between two adults.

The baby might be genetically not related (and that in itself because of the extra risks involved in that as a process) but that doesn't mean they don't have a link to the woman on their birth certificate.

The denial of this, takes something from the baby.

Emotional abuse / coercive control in altruristic surrogacy is a real risk because of the dynamics of the relationship. It upsets natural and normal power balances.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 21:49

I just know that to ban it isn’t the answer because someone with enough skill/technology will be able to dangle the prospect of a real live baby in-front of a desperate person.

What do you mean?

Babyghirl · 15/09/2021 21:48

@Mickarooni
Thank you very much for your kind words 💐

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 15/09/2021 21:48

[quote Babyghirl]@DebbieHarrysCheekbones
Why does anyone have kids not for a laugh, but because they Want one so why am I different to anyone else, oh wait because I'm struggling does not make that want any less, yes I might not be the birth mother but I will be it's biological mother. Have you had trouble with fertility and know what one who has is going through 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️[/quote]
I’m sorry for what you’re going through but this is yet again another paragraph and YOU and YOUR wants and needs. They’re valid, absolutely, but you haven’t once as far as I’ve seen posted about this from the baby‘a point of view. Do you honestly believe hand on heart that there would be no harm or distress caused to the newborn that is taken from its mother at birth? Honestly?

TakeMe2Insanity · 15/09/2021 21:47

@bookh this isn’t an easy discussion for anyone. I’ve suffered 10 year infertility before my child, then 5 years with secondary. I have one child but I’m missing 5 others. While I am trying desperately to accept my hand, I do feel that people are missing. I don’t know if surrogacy is for me anymore than if it isn’t. I just know that to ban it isn’t the answer because someone with enough skill/technology will be able to dangle the prospect of a real live baby in-front of a desperate person.

EishetChayil · 15/09/2021 21:43

YANBU.

All of this warping and twisting of language to erase female experience (birthing bodies, menstruators, etc) is helping to normalise the use of women's bodies for commercial surrogacy.

Mark my words. In ten years time it will be legal in this country to buy a woman's reproductive capacity.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 21:42

why am I different to anyone else

Because you need another woman to go through the physical risks and emotional pain of pregnancy for you.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 21:41

I don’t know if you could automatically count that as trafficking/buy/sell humans.

But that’s what it literally is. A baby as commodity. Regardless of the relationship.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 15/09/2021 21:41

[quote TakeMe2Insanity]@DebbieHarrysCheekbones But you didn’t read the three other paragraphs.

The vast majority of women on this thread who have been lucky/fortunate/blessed to get pregnant, carry a baby to term and then give birth to a live healthy baby seem the most closed to hearing the positivity surrogacy could bring.[/quote]
Of course they are. Because people who ARE suffering infertility have the motivation to convince themselves there’s nothing wrong with surrogacy, because they’re so desperate for a baby. Women who aren’t going through infertility can be more objective and also gave the benefit of experience. Having seen the instant recognition my newborns had for me from literally the second they were born and the distress they showed when passed to someone else, I feel strongly that conceiving a baby with the full intent to put it through separation from the one thing it knows and brings it comfort, is wrong.

I am aware I am very privileged to have experienced that and my heart aches for anyone struggling with infertility but that doesn’t mean it’s ok to do anything to get a baby at any cost.

Babyghirl · 15/09/2021 21:40

@DebbieHarrysCheekbones
Why does anyone have kids not for a laugh, but because they Want one so why am I different to anyone else, oh wait because I'm struggling does not make that want any less, yes I might not be the birth mother but I will be it's biological mother. Have you had trouble with fertility and know what one who has is going through 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 21:39

I do remember watching a documentary where a woman was virtually given financial advise by the clinic telling her it was a one off job a chance to buy land/home for her family.

That might be true of an organ also. Does that make it ok?

Comedycook · 15/09/2021 21:38

I'm against all surrogacy regardless of circumstances.

TakeMe2Insanity · 15/09/2021 21:37

The only person I know who has been through surrogacy in the uk adores their surrogate. I don’t know if you could automatically count that as trafficking/buy/sell humans.

I think there needs to be clarity: surrogacy in the uk in principle altruistic vs paid commercial surrogacy in Ukraine/US/India etc. Theres certainly a difference between the two. Is any system better than the other?

Re women going into paid surrogacy, they are obviously doing it for the money. I do remember watching a documentary where a woman was virtually given financial advise by the clinic telling her it was a one off job a chance to buy land/home for her family.

nolongersurprised · 15/09/2021 21:37

In the right circumstances it can be an amazing gift to someone

Do you think a baby should be a gift? Created to be given away?

bookh · 15/09/2021 21:35

@TakeMe2Insanity thank you. Appreciate your honest clarification.

Having walked your first paragraph, bar that, it incited a rage I cannot explain. I suppose for me after fifteen years of infertility, loss, horrific loss and let's not go there loss, that was my limit. My second, I accept, whilst unexpected was textbook, despite the history. So I had resigned myself to accept my lot at one. Gratefully.

The surrogacy aspect I only have professional experience in, under uk only agreements. In Scotland if a surrogacy is to go ahead a court reporter, solicitor, is appointed to investigate following birth of baby. I did that many times.

What I would say is that under the laws I was working with here, I never experienced anything but positivity and exceptional love and relations.

Mickarooni · 15/09/2021 21:33

@Babyghirl
Wishing you all the best and lots of good wishes for your treatment. Flowers

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 15/09/2021 21:33

[quote TakeMe2Insanity]@DebbieHarrysCheekbones But you didn’t read the three other paragraphs.

The vast majority of women on this thread who have been lucky/fortunate/blessed to get pregnant, carry a baby to term and then give birth to a live healthy baby seem the most closed to hearing the positivity surrogacy could bring.[/quote]
The positivity?
What taking a newborn baby from its mother to make another feel complete?

Couchbettato · 15/09/2021 21:32

@MrsPsmalls

This is NOT an amazing thing to do for someone. This is not about the women. It is not about fertility problems - and no one has the right to have a baby, however sad that makes them. Its not about the surrogate being magnanimous - no one should get to be magnanimous with someone else's (the infants) life. The only person that matters here is the infant and it is in no babies best interest to be taken from its biological mother at birth.
100% agree with this.

Nobody is owed children. They are not a right. Surrogacy shouldn't be the cure to the problems of people who can't have children at the expense of the child's health and wellbeing.

Surrogacy deprives the child of all it's ever known and already offers a disadvantaged start to life.

Altruistic or commercial, it's just wrong. It shouldn't be done.

Swipe left for the next trending thread