Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 15/09/2021 22:44

I imagine the majority of people who are surrogates or use a surrogate are doing it purely for giving the gift of a baby to a family.

Well no, they're not giving a 'gift'. They're being financially compensated, either directly or indirectly ('expenses').

When rich women start having babies for poor women then maybe just maybe I'll consider it a 'gift'. But they won't.

Nonamenolabel · 15/09/2021 22:42

It is considered to be so damaging to remove babies from their mothers that social workers will only get permission to do this in extreme circumstances

Perhaps that is true of today, but it wasn't true, then.

I was taken away from my mother at two hours old.

I never did meet her. It has left a huge hole in my life that I can feel but I cannot explain.

The hollowness is excruciating.

But I have empathy for those who desire a child..but not as much than I would have for that child, because I am that 'child'.

Putting aside the safeguarding reasons why a mother and child could not be together, most children would want to be with their bio mum.

Not having her in my life has made life so fucking unreachable. And please don't don't tell me, I've known no different. Trust me, I know what's missing. And that's my mother.

I hope I haven't offended anyone.

spicedappledonuts · 15/09/2021 22:41

I did have fertility issues not that I think it is really relevant to the discussion.

IVF is very difficult and emotional, I hope you are successful with the process @Babyghirl

WoolyMammoth55 · 15/09/2021 22:33

Hi all, I realise that this is one of those arguments that no can win :) No one's mind is changed by a MN thread, after all!

But I've got genuine knowledge on this so I'll weigh in anyway.

A decade ago I worked for a very highly-regarded ethical trade consultancy in the UK. We were asked by clients to to a fully data-driven, statistics-led analysis of human surrogacy and the conclusion was: only ever ethically acceptable when surrogate is an unpaid friend or family member who 'donates' their services.

It was honestly very clear cut when you looked at the data. Lots of PTSD and suicide even with educated, western, paid surrogates in the USA.

Absolute carnage in Asian countries where the mother's SURVIVAL rates were

Comedycook · 15/09/2021 22:22

I will say I no longer express my anti surrogacy views in real life after a conversation with friends went like this...

Me...I'm against all surrogacy
Friend...what about when gay men use a surrogate?
Me...well I'm against all surrogacy
Friend...even gay men who use it
Me...well I'm against all surrogacy... the person's sexuality is irrelevant.
Friend...so you're against gay men using surrogates?
Me..I'm against all surrogacy

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 15/09/2021 22:16

[quote Babyghirl]@DebbieHarrysCheekbones
Well aren't you lucky to have a family just because I have to do things abit differently to get there does not make me a bad person 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ but you know what when I do get to hold a son or daughter that child will know how much I fought and went through to get them and know that they will be loved until the end of the earth and back again.[/quote]
It doesn’t make you a bad person
But it doesn’t change the biological facts of what I wrote
If you don’t experience that it isn’t going to change them

SaladDayz · 15/09/2021 22:16

@NiceGerbil

I agree with you OP.

This thread will kick off. And there's unlikely to be any accord at the end. Very contraversial topic.

You're very brave!

This made me chuckle. You’ve not been on MN very long I’m guessing! It’s far ‘braver’ to stick your head above the parapet and state that surrogacy, when properly regulated, is a wonderful thing. MN is notoriously anti surrogacy. Though it’s refreshing to see a range of views on the first page for once :)
lifeturnsonadime · 15/09/2021 22:15

I am very sorry that you are experiencing all of that but ultimately it is not a right to have a child.

Many women experience what you experience but still do not think they have the right to obtain a baby through surrogacy.

I was extremely ill after I gave birth to my firstborn and he has attachment issues because I couldn't care for him due to emergency surgery. He suffers as a result of that now at the age of 15. Removing a child from their birthing mother is KNOWN to cause potential problems for babies. This is a human being you are proposing to bring in to the world you could be causing the child as well as the woman whose body you put under strain to give birth to that child harm. Why is your suffering more significant than theirs. I had no choice over being ill after giving birth and the subsequent issues my child has suffered despite me providing a loving and stable home you are making choices which put this baby you so desperately want at risk of harm. That's the truth.

So no I have no experience of infertility but I DO have first hand experience of attachment issues with my own birth child. I am qualified to have an opinion.

Comedycook · 15/09/2021 22:14

Well I think dying from kidney failure is very sad but I don't believe you have a right to purchase an organ from a living donor. So whilst I'm sure infertility is very upsetting, my view on surrogacy being wrong doesn't change.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 22:14

I hope you find peace and get your happy ending, I really do.

I second this

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 15/09/2021 22:12

@Babyghirl no one is for one second minimising the horrific experience of infertility. They’re just saying that surrogacy is not an acceptable solution. I hope you find peace and get your happy ending, I really do.

Babyghirl · 15/09/2021 22:10

@lifeturnsonadime
Im not most infertility people thou.

Because I have to go a different root to have my family does not make me a bad person, do you know what it feels like thinking your a failure and the embrassment you have because your body let's you down, not doing what it's made to do.
Waken up when you really don't want to day in and day out putting a smile on your face to let on your OK when deep down all you want to do is crawl in to a hole and not come back out again.

Well it's heart breaking and I mean heart breaking I avoid people only go to work and home again so I'm sorry if I'm being selfish

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 22:09

Well you see it from my point of view swings both ways.

I do see it from your POV, infertility is incredibly hard. But you going through something very tough doesn’t give you the right to treat other women and babies as commodities. I’m sorry but that’s the truth.

You can die or suffer lifelong health problems as a result of pregnancy and childbirth. It’s not okay to put that risk onto others. No matter how willing they are.

Snugglepumpkin · 15/09/2021 22:08

I find the talk of the apparently lower quality babies & children available through adoption to be some of the foulest & most despicable attitudes towards other human beings that I've ever read.
But then that applies to anyone who takes part in such a horrific practice as surrogacy.
You are talking about human beings here.

It's proof that people who think renting (or getting their new accessory a free squat in some friend/relatives body) a womb is reasonable don't actually want a child so much that they will love any child.
It's all about wanting one with the right attributes, just like any other product they buy.
I think exactly the same about people who don't actually pay for it.
There is no love or care for the child in this process.
It's monstrous.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/09/2021 22:06

[quote Babyghirl]@theKeatingfive
Well you see it from my point of view swings both ways.[/quote]
Everyone CAN see your point of view. Women are commodities and your right to have a baby outweighs the health and wellbeing of the surrogate mother and the child.

Child trafficking is fine because your need for a child usurps everything else.

HeartsAndClubs · 15/09/2021 22:06

Frankly I’m sick of this argument that if you haven’t been through infertility then you can’t have the right to an opinion on whether buying and selling babies is wrong.

Let’s turn it around then. Would it be ok to say to someone “you can’t possibly know what it’s like to be pregnant so you are not entitled to an opinion on what it’s like to carry a baby, feel it move, give birth to it and then give it up purely because you feel you should, either because you’re a friend of someone who feels you owe them the chance to be a parent, or because you know that this is the only way you can buy a better life for your children.”

If someone said that to an infertile woman on here they would be lynched. yet infertility apparently trumps every other right and feeling. You shouldn’t be allowed to celebrate a pregnancy because “what about the infertile who are struggling.” You can’t expect everyone to be happy re your pregnancy because “some people are infertile.” People shouldn’t be expected to be near your children because “they might be infertile,” and “you can’t possibly know what that’s like so keep your mouth shut.”

There are plenty of women who have fertility issues who aren’t comfortable with the idea of buying a baby purely because they feel they should be able to.

And frankly the argument made by someone on here asking another poster whether she was sure she really wouldn’t go down the route of surrogacy if she’d been struggling is nothing more than a line to justify their own decisions.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 15/09/2021 22:05

[quote Babyghirl]@DebbieHarrysCheekbones
Well aren't you lucky to have a family just because I have to do things abit differently to get there does not make me a bad person 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ but you know what when I do get to hold a son or daughter that child will know how much I fought and went through to get them and know that they will be loved until the end of the earth and back again.[/quote]
Ok you tell yourself that but the reality is you’re choosing to ignore the harm the baby will face, never mind the birth mother’s risks, to get what you want. Dress it up how you like but that’s the truth. The truth is that the newborn you hold in your arms will of course not know any of that - the only thing it knows will have been deliberately taken from it. You’re completely idealising the whole situation. Much as I sympathise beyond words with your infertility, your statements about surrogacy are just hideous.

Hopeisallineed · 15/09/2021 22:05

I have ‘friends’ that went through the whole surrogacy debacle. It did not go well. They chose to go to Asia because it was cheaper and was legal ( at the time) although it’s not now I believe. The surrogate turned out to be very poor and demanded more money from them, she ended up carrying twins, one of which died in childbirth. There were massive complications as you can imagine. They were close to the surrogate initially but things went wrong very quickly, even before the baby died. It was a complete shit show and so badly managed by the surrogacy agency who were basically just pumping out these women. Most of whom were making these type of choices only because they were truly desperate and couldn’t think of another way out of their circumstances. Everyone involved was devastated and traumatised by the whole experience, not surprisingly.

merrymelody · 15/09/2021 22:05

When my SIL was diagnosed with MS, I offered to be a surrogate for her but she decided against it, worrying she'd be unable to care for the child properly. I see nothing wrong with surrogacy under the right circumstances.

Babyghirl · 15/09/2021 22:04

@theKeatingfive
Well you see it from my point of view swings both ways.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/09/2021 22:02

@Babyghirl

I really hope for all the ladies on this thread that is ambushing ladies for wanting a baby and it's the only root left to go and have daughters of your own they don't have fertility issues.
I hope that my daughter doesn't have fertility issues but I also hope that she will see that having a baby is not a right and that surrogacy is treating women like commodities and has neither the best interests of the woman who carries the baby and gives birth (the mother) or the baby at heart.

Many infertile women choose not to use surrogates.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 22:01

I know people who have adopted kids that where taking of there birth mothers and guess what they are a star pupils doing really well and heading towards a great career.

That’s wonderful.

If doesn’t negate the trauma of taking a baby from its mother. Which on most cases of adoption is the least worst option, but not in the case of surrogacy.

Babyghirl · 15/09/2021 22:01

@DebbieHarrysCheekbones
Well aren't you lucky to have a family just because I have to do things abit differently to get there does not make me a bad person 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ but you know what when I do get to hold a son or daughter that child will know how much I fought and went through to get them and know that they will be loved until the end of the earth and back again.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 15/09/2021 22:00

[quote Babyghirl]@MayorGoodwaysChicken
I know people who have adopted kids that where taking of there birth mothers and guess what they are a star pupils doing really well and heading towards a great career.
And they will tell you they could not be happier so as long as a child is loved a child well thrive but as I said my egg my baby only thing is someone else will carry for me.
Everyone has an opinion and that's mine and I won't change my mind on it.[/quote]
This is staggeringly naive and tells us just how much you have really looked into these issues Sad The vast majority of adopted children have significant issues with attachment etc. Just read some of the adoption boards on here, it’s eye opening. You may know one or two who are ‘star pupils’ Hmm but implying that love is enough and everyone is fine if they’re just lived enough…well I have no words for how wrong that ridiculous statement is. As has been said upthread, taking a child from its birth parents is a ‘least worst’ option when the child is otherwise at significant risk of harm. It isn’t done lightly precisely because of how much is known about the issues it causes the child. Setting out to conceive a baby with the express intent of causing it that harm is quite another thing.

TheKeatingFive · 15/09/2021 22:00

I really hope for all the ladies on this thread that is ambushing ladies for wanting a baby and it's the only root left to go and have daughters of your own they don't have fertility issues.

If they did, it wouldn’t make surrogacy okay.

No one has a right to a child.

I find your inability to see it from anyone else’s point of view (the child/the birth mother) quite something.