Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surrogacy makes me very uncomfortable

795 replies

HermioneKipper · 14/09/2021 23:34

I was listening to Giovanna Fletcher’s podcast with H from Steps and hearing them talk about him using a surrogate for his twins made me feel very uncomfortable.

It’s essentially renting a woman’s body to buy a baby.

I understand the woman must’ve consented but she was paid and it doesn’t take into account the risk she was putting her body through. Pregnancy and childbirth is a huge strain on a woman’s body and she risks serious injury giving birth that she’ll have for life.

Even more so as she had twins which is even more dangerous.

And the babies taken away from their birth mother immediately. Who knows what harm it does to them.

It feels akin to the black market of buying and selling organs.

I know I have children so perhaps don’t have the right to comment but it doesn’t sit right with me.

OP posts:
phishy · 16/09/2021 01:33

[quote WoolyMammoth55]Hi all, I realise that this is one of those arguments that no can win :) No one's mind is changed by a MN thread, after all!

But I've got genuine knowledge on this so I'll weigh in anyway.

A decade ago I worked for a very highly-regarded ethical trade consultancy in the UK. We were asked by clients to to a fully data-driven, statistics-led analysis of human surrogacy and the conclusion was: only ever ethically acceptable when surrogate is an unpaid friend or family member who 'donates' their services.

It was honestly very clear cut when you looked at the data. Lots of PTSD and suicide even with educated, western, paid surrogates in the USA.

Absolute carnage in Asian countries where the mother's SURVIVAL rates were

phishy · 16/09/2021 01:31

Surrogacy is now mostly exploitation of poor BAME women in the developing world like India now, so most people don’t care.

Delphinium20 · 16/09/2021 01:15

@Guardian12
Plenty of mothers do understand the pain of infertility, going years through invasive, risky and devastating procedures, as well as miscarriages and stillbirths. Just because some are lucky to eventually get pregnant and give birth, does not mean mothers have no idea the pain of infertility. You can call me smug all day long, but I will still work to protect women and their babies from the risks of surrogacy.

Plenty of people who have not given birth find surrogacy abhorrent and an awful thing to ask a woman to do.

Thesandmanishere · 16/09/2021 00:37

You really have no idea of the pain of infertility and childlessness do you.

Do you have any idea of what it is to go through pregnancy, birth and then giving up a baby?

RedToothBrush · 16/09/2021 00:26

[quote Guardian12]@Delphinium20 posts like yours are just so unbearably smug. “Nobody has the right to a child” followed by mention of your multiple newborns. You really have no idea of the pain of infertility and childlessness do you.[/quote]
Someone childless and who hasn't given birth can't know and will never know just what it is that they are asking a woman to do and the emotional and physical toll of doing so.

Precisely because they never give birth.

Only women who give birth are able to talk about the impact on their bodies and minds.

Thats not being insensitive. Thats saying their reality.

There is nothing more misogynist than saying women must not speak about the reality of child birth because it offends them.

Its just a variation on Bewilderness's rules:

2nd rule of misogyny: Women saying no to men is a hate crime.
3rd rule of misogyny: Women speaking for themselves are exclusionary and selfish.
5th rule of misogyny: WATM! [What about the Men] Women and Feminism must be useful to men or they are worthless.
6th rule of misogyny: Women who go around being female AT men by menstruating and breast feeding babies deserve punishment.
11th rule of misogyny: Basic pattern recognition skills are cruel and evil when they hurt men's feelings.
12th rule of misogyny: whatever women suffer from, men suffer from more.

This matters.

No infertile woman can give up her baby for the satisfaction of another strangely enough, and yet there is this expectation that another woman should no matter what the cost because 'infertility'.

Its an abhorrent selfish and inward looking way of the world where someone doesn't want to hear the reality of what they are asking for.

RedToothBrush · 16/09/2021 00:14

@Talkwhilstyouwalk

I agree with you for the most part, but I think that it might be a case of each to their own on this one. Live and let live. You can disagree with things without it being controversial, we all have our own opinions.
Erm no.

Because its not live and let live.

Its exploit others and ignore it or cover it up.

Would you say the same about other forms of human trafficking? I doubt it.

Of course we should damn well make a point about human exploitation and trafficking and say no its not ok in order to stop it.

Not just turn a blind eye and say 'oh ok then'.

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 16/09/2021 00:04

[quote Guardian12]@Delphinium20 posts like yours are just so unbearably smug. “Nobody has the right to a child” followed by mention of your multiple newborns. You really have no idea of the pain of infertility and childlessness do you.[/quote]
Without meaning to be harsh some might say that likewise those saying surrogacy is not morally wrong because it’s their only route to motherhood have zero idea of what women who’ve given birth are sharing.

Describing biological phenomena associated with the immediate post birth period is not smug. It’s fact.

Waferbiscuit · 16/09/2021 00:03

Used to think it was fine. Now I feel it's unethical to borrow someone else's eggs or body for procreation.

We seem to be relaxed about the ethics of this and justify it because the infertile couple really really wanted a baby, as if their desire somehow erases the ethics of it.

It's horribly sad when infertile couples struggle with infertility but their desire for a child doesn't make surrogacy right. I feel similar about egg and sperm donation too.

Lockdownbear · 16/09/2021 00:01

@Nonamenolabel
Do you think you'd feel differently if you were a surrogate baby who was genetically linked to your parents?
How old were you when you were placed with your parents?

Guardian12 · 15/09/2021 23:58

@Delphinium20 posts like yours are just so unbearably smug. “Nobody has the right to a child” followed by mention of your multiple newborns. You really have no idea of the pain of infertility and childlessness do you.

OhWhyNot · 15/09/2021 23:49

But it’s a controversial subject

Such an emotive subject will raise strong opinions

The bond between mother and baby is so so powerful, that our boobs leak even before they cry (i had the sensation months after I stopped bf), that I felt twinges of pain unlike any other when ds had colic, that I needed to burp when he was windy, that my heartbeat soothed him, that I would wake up just before he did when he was little so I could comfort him

This is all biological

fluffyatemycake · 15/09/2021 23:48

I understand where you are coming from. As a mother, knowing the bond you have during pregnancy I can't actually imagine carrying a child and then giving them up.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 15/09/2021 23:41

I agree with you for the most part, but I think that it might be a case of each to their own on this one. Live and let live. You can disagree with things without it being controversial, we all have our own opinions.

Cam001 · 15/09/2021 23:39

[quote WoolyMammoth55]Hi all, I realise that this is one of those arguments that no can win :) No one's mind is changed by a MN thread, after all!

But I've got genuine knowledge on this so I'll weigh in anyway.

A decade ago I worked for a very highly-regarded ethical trade consultancy in the UK. We were asked by clients to to a fully data-driven, statistics-led analysis of human surrogacy and the conclusion was: only ever ethically acceptable when surrogate is an unpaid friend or family member who 'donates' their services.

It was honestly very clear cut when you looked at the data. Lots of PTSD and suicide even with educated, western, paid surrogates in the USA.

Absolute carnage in Asian countries where the mother's SURVIVAL rates were

Delphinium20 · 15/09/2021 23:34

It seems that even semi conscious I was the only person that could help Dd at 2 hours old. She knew me you see. She knew my heartbeat. She knew my voice

Oh, this is beautiful, and so, so true. My newborns knew my voice, and the little one the voice of her big sister.

Delphinium20 · 15/09/2021 23:32

I hate surrogacy - it's exploitative and, unless the very rare case of sisters helping sisters or mom helping daughter, it can be nothing but an awful thing to expect someone to do for you. I harshly judge anyone who'd hire a surrogate, especially when the surrogate clearly is doing it because she needs the money. Nobody has a right to a child.

RedToothBrush · 15/09/2021 23:30

I don't see how surrogacy can pass any ethical test. I believe future generations will be shocked that it was ever allowed to happen.

We will have the Irish Adoption Scandal updated for a new generation in different countries out of surrogacy.

I do wish surrogate supporters would stop hiding behind the the 'your so homophobic' trojan horse.

No i dont have a problem with gay couples having families. I have a problem with surrogacy.

Mumoftwoinprimary · 15/09/2021 23:29

I was pro surrogacy - thought it was a beautiful thing - until I gave birth to my first child.

The birth went very wrong and I was very ill afterwards. I was lying in the hospital bed, linked up to machines and drifting in and out of consciousness when Dh realised that Dd was struggling. She was making little moans and appeared to be struggling to breathe. The midwife immediately got Dh to put her on my chest. And Dd lay there listening to my heartbeat and her breathing relaxed.

It seems that even semi conscious I was the only person that could help Dd at 2 hours old. She knew me you see. She knew my heartbeat. She knew my voice.

To take that away from a child - no matter how much you want to love and care for them - seems a very cruel thing indeed.

RedToothBrush · 15/09/2021 23:28

Certainly in the UK there is no exploitation and in fact it is the intended parents who have less rights through our outdated system. That's why celebrities go to the US

Ah the US. That country well known for its progressive views of women and women's birth rights.

Thats the same American were birth control isnt covered by medical insurance in many cases. Neither is birth. And of course if you don't have insurance you are screwed so just give birth anywhere and hope you don't die. Remembering at this point how much worse the stats for non white women giving birth in the US are. And thats without even mentioning access to abortion. The same American with its oh so amazingly crap maternity leave allowances.

That progressive America where giving birth is deemed an inconvenience or should be forced against a woman's will.

That progressive America.

Yeah I'll buy into that claptrap alright. Hmm

IcedPurple · 15/09/2021 23:19

@fluffyatemycake

Is it just same sex couples you have an issue with or surrogacy as a whole? I have never had fertility issues but there are plenty of people out there who do and surrogacy gives you the option to biological children when you can't carry your own. I commend anyone who wants to carry children for other couples. A lot of people do it for people they know personally like family members or friends. Don't presume everyone who does it is desperate and does it for the money. You can't charge for it here.
Speaking for myself, I am against surrogacy in all its forms, including 'altruistic'.

Surrogacy is an ethical minefield. So many things can go very badly wrong for the mother, her baby, her other children and so on. On the other hand, the worst that can happen if surrogacy is not allowed is that someone doesn't get to have their 'own' biological child. That's sad, but having your 'own' child is a privilege, not a right.

I don't see how surrogacy can pass any ethical test. I believe future generations will be shocked that it was ever allowed to happen.

fluffyatemycake · 15/09/2021 23:13

Is it just same sex couples you have an issue with or surrogacy as a whole? I have never had fertility issues but there are plenty of people out there who do and surrogacy gives you the option to biological children when you can't carry your own. I commend anyone who wants to carry children for other couples. A lot of people do it for people they know personally like family members or friends. Don't presume everyone who does it is desperate and does it for the money. You can't charge for it here.

IcedPurple · 15/09/2021 23:13

@Minster2012

Ahhhhh brilliant thread as ever

I'm in the UK & have a child through surrogacy. He was not "taken away from his mother at birth" he was, in all of our words "handed over to his mother".

The risks are well covered in agreements but you would only know that if you are open to finding out the ins and outs of it.

Certainly in the UK there is no exploitation and in fact it is the intended parents who have less rights through our outdated system. That's why celebrities go to the US.

So the woman who gestated your son fo 9 months, forming every cell of his body (other than the genetic material) from her own body, and who then pushed him out of that body... who was she, if not his mother?

Of course you have raised your son and are now his mother, but at the time of birth, he will have recognised the woman who gave birth to him as his mother. English law does too, and long may that continue. You are advocating a system whereby 'celebrities' go abroad to purchase a baby, knowing that the birth mother has almost no rights, as 'outdated' when surely what is outdated is reducing women to the status of brood mares.

That is why surrogacy in all its forms is outlawed in most of Western Europe. Again, long may this 'outdated' system continue.

CounsellorTroi · 15/09/2021 23:08

It wasn’t unusual in the past that if a couple had more children than they could afford to feed, and relatives had none, or just one, for children to be “farmed out”. But the child would not have been conceived for the purpose of giving them away but through lack of contraception.

RedToothBrush · 15/09/2021 23:02

As WoolyMammoth55 says don't let inconvient things like ethics get in the way of rich infertile westerners whose trauma of not being able to have their own child is the worst thing in the world.

Snugglepumpkin frames it very well. Its people who have everything else they've ever wanted in life and think they have the right to their own child because of their own fertility problems or practicalities. Strangely enough no one thinks of the poor woman with infertility issues or the poor gay couple who don't have the means to surrogacy who just have to suck up the fact they can't have everything they want in life. The advocates of surrogacy are merely people who have never heard the word no or throw a tantrum when someone does. Or when someone holds a microscope to the adhorent nature of surrogacy and the massive can of worms it opens to the abuse of women and commodification of babies.

Not only that, but many of the most high profile people who have had surrogate babies aren't infertile at all! And yet the whole debate hides behind the 'infertile' or 'gay' banner to justify it.

I find even altrustric surrogacy appalling in its own way. Someone offers to put their life on the line to give you a baby and you say yes??? Like wtf. Its something you can't ask someone else to do and say you aren't massively selfish. This is someone you are supposed to really care about or respect for being selfish. And yet, your happy to snatch that and go 'yes please'. Its just so wrong. There's something going on there in existing relationship or for people who don't previously know the surrogant parent thats not entirely healthy that causes that dynamic.

Its just awful and its driven by rich people who have the ears of government and money to line pockets - and the mothers and babies don't have a voice.

Time and time again when you see stories in the press about how wonderful surrogacy is, its massively one sided, with NDAs all over the place or simply women written out of the story. And the kids... well we know all these stories about adopted kids who feel the need to find their roots even though they've had happy lives, and we are starting to hear the stories of kids born with donor sperm and how important it is to track down their genetic roots - its a human need and desire to understand where we come from and help us form our own identity. And yet we now have a new batch of children who will be denied some of the means to track this down by being trafficked abroad or use of implanting embroyo so there is no DNA link. Worse still we know that there are cases of dodgy surrogate agencies passing off kids as being genetic children but turn out not to be further down the line. And then theres the hidden 'sale or return' type stories where things don't go quite to plan and the 'goods' are rejected for being 'faulty' in some way.

Dreadful. There is nothing 'good' or right about surrogacy.

Just PR and excuse and a massive load of cash being waved in the faces of everyone in the pursuit of getting what rich people want.

The actual children are the afterthought in it all.

nolongersurprised · 15/09/2021 22:54

are doing it purely for giving the gift of a baby to a family

Should a human baby be created to be given away, as a gift?