Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed the vicar wanted me dead?

141 replies

emmskie03 · 14/09/2021 23:29

I always knew that that paternal grandparents were not happy about my illegitimate birth (in the 80's). I've recently found out that my mother's vicar (CofE but fairly high church I guess) suggested she would be better off aborting.

I'm fuming. I don't know why but I'm am seriously angry. My OH suggested that there was conflict between my rage and my pro choice beliefs I.e. I said I'm pissed the vicar wanted me dead but he suggested this was a bit iffy in regard to abortion rights.

Am I unreasonable to think that the fact that my mother wanted me (and was pretty vulnerable) means it's sod all to do with that and everything to do with the fact that the vicar didn't like the non traditional parent set up so thought it would be better I didn't exist?

OP posts:
RedMarauder · 15/09/2021 04:26

@Porridgealert

How is is right for you to be pro-choice but not the vicar? Are vicars meant to be pro-life? But then don't women get hot under the collar at religions that preach abortion is a sin? The church can't win.
This

The Church has dealt with pregnant non-married women for centuries. Sometimes being very helpful, in a few cases I personally know, and sometimes not.

starrynight21 · 15/09/2021 04:15

You say you are pro choice - so every time you say "a woman should have the choice of aborting" you are really saying " that woman's baby should be dead "......really ? Because that is what your OP is saying . Someone , 40 years ago, suggested to a woman ( your mother) that she might consider abortion. And now you've translated that into "he wanted me dead". It's a pretty dramatic stance to take !

If he said that ( and how do you know that ) all he was saying was that she might be better off having an abortion. NOT that he wanted YOU dead at all. You need to rethink your stance on abortion if you are taking this so personally .

TreeSmuggler · 15/09/2021 04:02

I agree with your dp. Unless your mother was pressured or coerced to have abortion, a suggestion or discussion of the option of abortion is reasonable.

Yes, you are alive now and glad to be. That's the same for almost every aborted fetus though isn't it? If things had been different and they had been born, they'd feel like you. And same for every pregnancy prevented through conception. I am 100% pro choice and see no problem with admitting this. Fact is, things weren't different so they aren't here, that's just the way it has to be.

Gorl · 15/09/2021 03:58

I don’t think suggesting that someone a woman have an abortion is the same as wanting someone dead. Much as I don’t think it’s any person’s place to suggest a woman should have an abortion unless she’s already raised it, it’s not the same as wishing death on an existing person. At the time the abortion was suggested you didn’t yet exist as a person, so there was nothing personal about it.

That said it’s not a nice thing for you to be contemplating at this time and it’s fair that you have complicated feelings about it. I don’t think anyone would love to know that this was the advice their parent had received while pregnant, so I don’t blame you at all for being upset Flowers

timeisnotaline · 15/09/2021 03:57

@Porridgealert

How is is right for you to be pro-choice but not the vicar? Are vicars meant to be pro-life? But then don't women get hot under the collar at religions that preach abortion is a sin? The church can't win.
Because another woman’s baby is not subject to the vicars choice. It is not pro choice for men to choose for women- I’m assuming a vicar back then was male although could be wrong. The vicar would be pro-choice if they said the mum should decide to do whatever they want to, or if the vicar were female and pregnant then it would be pro choice for them to have the say over their own body and baby.
PurpleOkapi · 15/09/2021 03:56

I could understand your ongoing rage if your mother had aborted you

Grin Grin Grin

Joystir59 · 15/09/2021 03:41

Just get on with your life. This is such a pointless thing to waste your time and energy on. I could understand your ongoing rage if your mother had aborted you, but she didn't did she?

Porridgealert · 15/09/2021 03:15

How is is right for you to be pro-choice but not the vicar? Are vicars meant to be pro-life? But then don't women get hot under the collar at religions that preach abortion is a sin? The church can't win.

PrincessNutella · 15/09/2021 02:57

How old was your mother at the time?
What were the circumstances of your birth? Was she able to be independent? Did she rely on her parents for support? Did your birth impact her opportunities (such as going to university, etc.)? There are plenty of legitimate reasons why it might not be ideal for a young woman to have a baby at a certain time in her life.

PurpleOkapi · 15/09/2021 02:48

I think it would be difficult to be pro-choice without believing abortion could ever, in any situation, be the best choice. And if you believe that it could be the best choice in some situations, then I don't understand why you'd find it objectionable for someone to express that view to someone who sounds like she wasn't in a great situation to raise a child.

QueenBee52 · 15/09/2021 01:39

@PumpkinsGalore

If you're pissed, perhaps you'd be better off waiting until you're sober???

🤣😂

PumpkinsGalore · 15/09/2021 01:27

If you're pissed, perhaps you'd be better off waiting until you're sober???

aprilanne · 15/09/2021 01:26

Honestly you are taking this to far to heart .if you pro choice then what you are saying doesn't make sense
Someone told your mother another option that was it an option. My granddad suggested my 19 year old mum had an abortion in 1970 .because my parents weren't married but they said no and my grandfather adored me to the day he died me in my early 40s him late 80 s .it was just an option he suggested nothing else .

saraclara · 15/09/2021 00:56

Sounds to me like he was a vicar who actually listened to your mum when she wanted some counsel on what to do. Presumably the person who told you wasn't actually in the room either, so who knows what might be behind the way they interpreted what they heard and how many people that information has passed through by then.

Your mum might have told him that your GPs were furious and might throw her out. Back then she'd have been without options if they did. Maybe he talked through her options or maybe she mentioned abortion and he said that he wouldn't judge her, or that yes, it might be a way out of her situation. We don't know, you don't know, and the person who kindly told you this stuff doesn't either.

You have absolutely no reason to be furious with someone you don't know, and with absolutely no factual information behind the story.

Mamanyt · 15/09/2021 00:52

First, you have to remember that the vicar did not want YOU dead. He wanted your mother to have a choice. At that point, YOU did not exist. There would have been no heart, no brain, no central nervous system, nothing that could have been YOU. This was not personal, at all. How could it have been? There was no person for it to have been about. He was supporting your mother, and letting her know that she had a choice. The fact that he acknowledged the difficulty of rearing a child alone as valid is actually a good thing. I would imagine that if you asked him if he thought you would be better off dead NOW, he would be appalled. NOW, you are a person.

My mother's obstetrician actually pushed her to have an abortion when she became pregnant with me. He did not think that she could safely carry to term. She did, but it has never occurred to me to be angry at him about that. He was giving her the best advice that he had, for her situation.

YourFinestPantaloons · 15/09/2021 00:39

I think it's a bit extreme to say the vicar wanted you dead.

At the time they don't picture a human being 30 years later with a life and feelings. They picture the pregnant woman and the difficulties at the time she'd face being an unmarried mother. Abortions are about the mother, not the fetus, don't take it personally

prh47bridge · 15/09/2021 00:39

@EmergencyHydrangea

Also, forty years ago vicars would be suggesting adoption not abortion if they didn't approve of the family set up
This. The Anglican Church was, and still is, against abortion whilst recognising that there are limited conditions in which it may be morally preferable to any of the alternatives. It is, of course, possible that the vicar went against church policy. But there is a huge amount we don't know, including exactly what he said and the circumstances in which he said it. Those saying he was imposing his opinion are making huge assumptions. Maybe he was but we cannot say that for sure on the limited information we've got. And, whatever he was doing, saying that he "wanted you dead" is an extreme interpretation.
NiceGerbil · 15/09/2021 00:37

In the end. Hard I know

Try to focus on how strong your mother was, in the face of such adversity.

Rather than being upset (I mean lingering on it) by those who did not support her.

She sounds amazing.

That's your focus :)

Driftingblue · 15/09/2021 00:35

You say nothing about whether or not your mother was actually in a real position to be a parent. Had she finished school? Was she gainfully employee? Did she have secure housing? Was your father a good man who treated her well?

Perhaps the vicar was worried about your mother and not marital status.

WomanStanleyWoman · 15/09/2021 00:34

Interesting that he works for an institution that calls abortion a sin, but is happy to advocate it when he decides the sin of sex before marriage is worse. Tells you all you need to know about the Church of England.

timeisnotaline · 15/09/2021 00:27

Huge issues with your dh conflating a man in a relative position of power pushing abortion on a woman with being ‘pro choice’. Pro choice is for the mother, not for other men to impose their opinions on women.

Sacreblue · 15/09/2021 00:23

Pro-choice means just that: pro-choice : that a woman has the right to a choice, whatever that choice is, including abortion, adoption or being a mother raising a child.

Any and all people involved or not can have an opinion but imo do not have the right to make that choice for the woman.

What others thought or said to your mother she retained that choice and chose to have and raise you herself.

I see zero conflict in your rage that an outside party tried to influence your mother’s choice and your pro-choice beliefs.

You believe in the right of choice, and are only angry that an outsider tried to influence that very personal, very difficult choice - a choice which would affect your parents - your mother most - and not, in any way, that outsider.

You believe in choice, your anger is that someone may have tried to take that choice away from your mother.

I see no conflict in your anger or beliefs.

NiceGerbil · 15/09/2021 00:20

How old was your mum?
Did she seek his advice? Or her parents made her talk to him? If so could they have been a big driver in what he said?
How far along was she when he said that?

I mean my initial comment that I deleted just said well he's a nasty bastard.

There's a lot of factors here and my total guess is that the conversation will have been instigated by her parents who had already pressed their view.

He didn't want YOU dead. I mean I thought you meant when you were growing up. That interpretation is incorrect and I think maybe it's hit you so hard because of your GPS and the situation of your mum at the time.

me4real · 15/09/2021 00:19

My OH suggested that there was conflict between my rage and my pro choice beliefs I.e. I said I'm pissed the vicar wanted me dead but he suggested this was a bit iffy in regard to abortion rights.

What a weird and unsuupportive attitude for your 'partner' to have @emmskie03 . You can be pro-choice but still not like the idea that someone thought you should be aborted.

Am I unreasonable to think that the fact that my mother wanted me (and was pretty vulnerable) means it's sod all to do with that and everything to do with the fact that the vicar didn't like the non traditional parent set up so thought it would be better I didn't exist?

I don't see why else a vicar would say it IDK. Unless he was some sort of weird progressive liberal feminist vicar that was militantly pro-abortion and there was a career he thought your mum should be focussing on instead, but that sounds unlikely.

His attitude sounds bizarre for sure. I think it'dve been pretty backwards by the 80s (I was born in 77 so was around then) for someone to be that bothered about someone having a child out of wedlock. And what an odd thing for a vicar to suggest someone have an abortion, in those days.

Who told you this? What did the person who told you this hope to achieve?

Was it your mum? If so her point was maybe to emphasize how much she wanted you and was determined to have you whatever people said. xxx

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 15/09/2021 00:08

YABU. You don't know anything about the conversation that happened back then, or the circumstances your mum came to him in.

Also, preventing your life isn't quite the same as 'wishing you dead'.

I'm sorry you're really upset though; it can't have been nice to find out. I hope though that he believed he was acting in your mum's best interests, and not just doing what the church wants.