Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed the vicar wanted me dead?

141 replies

emmskie03 · 14/09/2021 23:29

I always knew that that paternal grandparents were not happy about my illegitimate birth (in the 80's). I've recently found out that my mother's vicar (CofE but fairly high church I guess) suggested she would be better off aborting.

I'm fuming. I don't know why but I'm am seriously angry. My OH suggested that there was conflict between my rage and my pro choice beliefs I.e. I said I'm pissed the vicar wanted me dead but he suggested this was a bit iffy in regard to abortion rights.

Am I unreasonable to think that the fact that my mother wanted me (and was pretty vulnerable) means it's sod all to do with that and everything to do with the fact that the vicar didn't like the non traditional parent set up so thought it would be better I didn't exist?

OP posts:
HeartsAndClubs · 15/09/2021 06:55

Strange thread, and I see the OP hasn’t been back.

FWIW I’m guessing the OP is pro life hence the wanting her dead comments. Nobody who is pro choice would look at having a termination as wanting them dead.

In fact I wonder if the fact she’s so angry with the vicar is because she’s actually devoutly religious and this belief goes against whatever religion she practices.

Hoppinggreen · 15/09/2021 06:53

@Fabpinky

Yes, bit dramatic
Agree The vicar did not “want you dead” he (possibly) suggested a termination to a vulnerable young woman
Geamhradh · 15/09/2021 06:52

Also agree with others, you're hardly describing an episode of Call the Midwife or Dublin in the 1950s.

How did you find out the vicar wanted you dead?

Patapouf · 15/09/2021 06:50

Not being born isn't the same as wanting someone dead, don't be dramatic.

I'm pleased a vicar was being so pragmatic back then. And maybe it would have been the easier course of action for your mum so perhaps it was good advice.

pasturesgreen · 15/09/2021 06:50

How did you even find out? It was in the 80s, so more than thirty years ago, possibly closer to 40. People won't reliably recall events and conversations after such a long time.

Does the vicar's opinion even matter now? Your mother didn't have an abortion, you're here.

And yes, I can see your DH's argument about double standards. Saying that the vicar wanted you dead is very emotive language but it doesn't describe what actually went on.

Geamhradh · 15/09/2021 06:48

@EmergencyHydrangea

You can only think he wanted you dead if you think abortion is killing a baby
Yep. I think, given that you are presumably an adult, a "high church" cleric being open to the bodily autonomy of a female who turned to him for help was a good thing.
HelloDulling · 15/09/2021 06:45

In what way was your mum “vulnerable”? There are lots of situations where suggesting an abortion is valid, but it doesn’t mean you are wishing anyone dead, just that you are putting the mother’s welfare first.

drpet49 · 15/09/2021 06:36

* it sounds as if you really don't have enough going on in your life ATM so you're making up a bit of drama. This is a ridiculous thing to be upset by.*

^This. OP loves drama.

iloveeverykindofcat · 15/09/2021 06:35

I don't think you can be pro-choice and also see abortion as killing someone. He was probably trying to be supportive. My grandma told my mum she actively tried to abort her. She was the last of five children, her father was away at war and they were in poverty. My mother never held it against her (why she felt the need to tell her is a mystery, but she was an odd woman all around to be honest).

KateTheEighth · 15/09/2021 06:34

Lots of clickbait thread titles around atm

HumousWhereTheHeartIs · 15/09/2021 06:34

Are you really pro-choice? It could be that is exactly what the vicar was suggesting to your mum - that she had a choice between several options. You sound more pro-life to me since I can't imagine why you would be so angry at this. Your mum had choices and followed her instincts.

peachycream31 · 15/09/2021 06:21

Luckily for you, your mother discounted abortion as an acceptable option, and had you 👌

The vicar was doing his job. I'm sure that had he been pro life, telling your mother abortion is wrong, you would consider this unfair pressure and abuse of his position. He suggested a sensible and socially acceptable solution which does not apparently involve wanting anyone dead.

It's interesting you feel your life retrospectively threatened. Do you think this will change your thoughts about women having abortions? Are they all killing someone, then?

Etc.

The vicar was trying to be modern, I think.

Hattie765 · 15/09/2021 06:20

Sorry hon but it sounds as if you really don't have enough going on in your life ATM so you're making up a bit of drama. This is a ridiculous thing to be upset by.

lljkk · 15/09/2021 06:19

Do you know this vicar personally? Why do you care about their opinions so much. I'm sure your mum had lots of bad advice from many people.

peachycream31 · 15/09/2021 06:14

@EmergencyHydrangea

You can only think he wanted you dead if you think abortion is killing a baby
This.

Your DH sees double standards here, and he's right.

I don't know, but I imagine in your pro choice stance, you'd think anyone saying abortion is 'wanting a person dead' is outrageously wrong.

And yet when the abortion applies to you in your embryonic state, that would have been murdering you.

... ?

...

Draineddraineddrained · 15/09/2021 05:57

My mum's GP suggested abortion to her when she found she was pregnant with me - he knew my dad was an abusive alcoholic and that my mum was planning to leave him. As it was, she chose to keep me and stayed with him for three more years before finally leaving (leaving me and my sister with my dad).

My mum told me this story and I often wished she hadn't. But for me it wasn't anger someone "wished me dead" (odd way to describe abortion if you're pro choice) but guilt that my being born made things so difficult for her, I'd she'd had only one child would she have felt able to take my sister with her, would she have ended up with lifelong mental health problems if she'd left sooner etc.

Did your mum have a difficult time because of her decision to keep you? Is the anger you're feeling actually a reaction to misplaced guilt for having been born? I just can't make sense of it otherwise as vicar, whatever their reasons for advising abortion, did not "want you dead" - unless your view is that anyone who has an abortion " wants their baby dead".

Hekatestorch · 15/09/2021 05:49

In the 1980s lots of people had children out of wedlock, lived together before or instead of marriage and terminated pregnancies (which was legal). I'm over 70 and remember that period well. It wasn't the 1950s

Not sure I would agree with that. 2 of my aunties got pregnant out of wedlock in the 80s. One got married (at 16) to avoid the stigma and one didn't. The one that didn't did get a lot of judgement from people who knew and also didn't live with the father as she didn't want to get married.

Luckily, my grandparents stood by her and her son. But alot of what was said really impacted my auntie.

My own mother marriage broke up in 1984, leaving her a single parent. I still remember remarks made by teachers, and parents of children I went to school with.

It certainly, wasn't common place and I was the only one in my friendship group whose parents weren't married. I don't actually recall another child that I knew, at all, whose parents werent married. Plenty of then miserably, but still married.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 15/09/2021 05:43

I think you're extrapolating way beyond what is reasonable, as others have implied.

Your mother's vicar may have had your mother's best interests at heart, he may have had your grandparents' best interests at heart, he may have thought he was being supportive by being pro-choice and not realised that your mum was determined to have you.

At no point was his comment directed personally to YOU, as he did not know YOU, you were a bundle of cells at the time, not a person.

If he'd suggested smothering you at birth, or leaving you in a bin/on a step, then you'd have more reason to be vexed - but as things stand, no.

Porridgealert · 15/09/2021 05:39

@timeisnotaline
"Because another woman’s baby is not subject to the vicars choice. It is not pro choice for men to choose for women- I’m assuming a vicar back then was male although could be wrong. The vicar would be pro-choice if they said the mum should decide to do whatever they want to, or if the vicar were female and pregnant then it would be pro choice for them to have the say over their own body and baby."

The vicar didn't choose for anyone. If he had, the op wouldn't be here. He gave his opinion. He didn't coerce the ops mother. If, however, he inserted himself into the conversation at the mother's in-laws behest and without the mother's invitation, I think that would be rude.
Hiwever, in general, men are allowed to give opinions about babies. If I were considering an abortion, I would consult with the father, I'd have the final say, but the father is just as invested in his child as I am. As women, how can we complain about men not pulling their weight with childcare if we don't think they even had the right to be part of the decision for it to be born in the first place.

Plumtree391 · 15/09/2021 05:38

It had nothing to do with your mother's vicar.

I also think it unlikely that a church minister would recommend an abortion though he would support anybody who had one. High church CofE priests were generally more broadminded than the middle or evangelical wings, if you look at their history of ministry in very poor areas you will see that. Therefore I think you have been misinformed about that, it was a remark taken out of context or there was a misunderstanding over what he said.

In the 1980s lots of people had children out of wedlock, lived together before or instead of marriage and terminated pregnancies (which was legal). I'm over 70 and remember that period well. It wasn't the 1950s.

What is important is that your mother had and kept you. Good for her.

Hekatestorch · 15/09/2021 05:06

I do think there's a conflict.

You are pro choice, but also think that someone who talks about that choice with a woman 'wants the baby dead'.

I, very much doubt your mother went to discuss with a vicar and his response was 'get an abortion and kill that baby immediately' or 'oh my god, that baby will be the end of humanity you must kill it now' or that it was about you personally.

Fact is, for some women aborting is the best choice. We have no idea what situation was presented. And more likely he was saying 'if you really feel you can't do this abortion is a valid choice/ might be for the best'

Doesn't sound like he tried to force her or tell her she must abort.

Do you know this vicar now? Is he still alive.

When women here post about pregnancy choices or are in the early stages of pregnancy with a terrible dangerous relationship or very young seeking advice, and posters (knowing far less about the situation than that vicar probably did), advise the op to consider an abortion, do they just want the baby dead? Or are they encouraging the op to think about their choices.

Your mother may have wanted you, but unfortunately that doesn't always mean having the baby is right for everyone. Some women choose abortion, even if they would have preferred to keep the baby. Its still a valid choice and 9ne that can be discussed.

And how, likely, is that your mum would ever tell you that abortion was something she considered? Even if it was for a second.

She obviously didn't take what he said on board.

cillacilla · 15/09/2021 04:53

I am a similar age and have a similar background story. I imagine the vicar maybe thought the option was best for your mum. But she didn't chose that and here you are. Your response to this news has nothing to do with your pro choice stance IMO

CallMeRisley · 15/09/2021 04:52

@EmergencyHydrangea

You can only think he wanted you dead if you think abortion is killing a baby
This
DoesHePlayTheFiddle · 15/09/2021 04:43

He'd be thinking 'What's best for the young woman?' and showing her that termination was a valid choice.

The vicar didn't know you, he knew your mother. He tried to show lovingkindness to her, in her position, without judging. And see, you're here and everything is ok.

PurpleOkapi · 15/09/2021 04:34

The vicar would be pro-choice if they said the mum should decide to do whatever they want to, or if the vicar were female and pregnant then it would be pro choice for them to have the say over their own body and baby.

He'd be a bloody useless vicar if "do whatever you think is best" was his answer to every moral quandary put to him. Of course she has the right to make her own decision, and she ultimately did (rejecting his advice in the process). But offering an asked-for opinion on someone else's major life choice is in no way taking the choice away from that person. If a friend asks me whether I think she should marry her boyfriend and I truthfully say "No, I don't think you'll be happy with him because he's a serial cheater," that's not me being anti-marriage. It's also not me being anti-her-choice-about-marriage. It's just me offering my opinion in a situation where it's perfectly appropriate for me to do so.