Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed the vicar wanted me dead?

141 replies

emmskie03 · 14/09/2021 23:29

I always knew that that paternal grandparents were not happy about my illegitimate birth (in the 80's). I've recently found out that my mother's vicar (CofE but fairly high church I guess) suggested she would be better off aborting.

I'm fuming. I don't know why but I'm am seriously angry. My OH suggested that there was conflict between my rage and my pro choice beliefs I.e. I said I'm pissed the vicar wanted me dead but he suggested this was a bit iffy in regard to abortion rights.

Am I unreasonable to think that the fact that my mother wanted me (and was pretty vulnerable) means it's sod all to do with that and everything to do with the fact that the vicar didn't like the non traditional parent set up so thought it would be better I didn't exist?

OP posts:
Erictheavocado · 15/09/2021 08:13

Well OP, you do sound very angry but I think that is possibly misplaced.
I find it hard to imagine a vicar suggesting abortion. I CAN imagine one supporting, or offering support to a vulnerable parishioner who has said they are considering it.

Given the lack of information you have given, I do wonder how you discovered this? Because it sounds as though the information is second hand or hearsay. Unless it came direct from your mother, it is unlikely that whoever told you was in the room to hear the conversation. Or, knowing your GPS were against the pregnancy, is it possible that they spoke to their vicar about it and conveniently misreported his response?
There are so many possibilities here and you will possibly never know the exact truth, especially as we are now at least 31 years down the line and people's memories do fade.

As pps have said, whatever the truth, YOU were not the target of any comments as at that time they were discussing an abstract idea of a child, not an actual child, not YOU.
You say you are pro-choice - maybe you are conflicted and the anger is because of that.
Flowers

SoloISland · 15/09/2021 07:58

@chocolateorangeinhaler

I'd be bloody angry too. Regardless of religious beliefs or how his parents raised him it's a nasty thing to think let alone say out loud.

Another example of why all religions should be seen as what they are -bullying controlling cults- and all banned. They offer no benefits to modern civilization.

Praying for you. Who hurt you? Not Jesus Christ, Son of God Saviour...

Yes I am a Christian who lives her faith . Never a bullying word or act. ABUSE of religion is NOT faith.

And I do not know any real faith church that fits your description. And I am very old and have had a tough life. Always there have been good folk of true faith to help and support.

I am not staying on the forum today but if you need to talk I am here for you.

Blessings and peace

SoloISland · 15/09/2021 07:50

@Hattie765

Sorry hon but it sounds as if you really don't have enough going on in your life ATM so you're making up a bit of drama. This is a ridiculous thing to be upset by.
Agree. I think the correct term is drama queen.. In spades..
SoloISland · 15/09/2021 07:47

@Fabpinky

Yes, bit dramatic
Agree totally. OP needs to get in touch with reality rather than melodrama. There was no ME involved and you can have no idea what your mother actually said to the vicar.

What a terrible accusation to make against anyone.. Shameful of you frankly

My first thought even before I read your post was... POOR VICAR; who would be a vicar... I mean REALLY..

Droite · 15/09/2021 07:46

@EmergencyHydrangea

Also, forty years ago vicars would be suggesting adoption not abortion if they didn't approve of the family set up
Weird generalisation. Abortion was legalised in 1967, you can't claim that no vicar could have suggested it 13 years later.
Hekatestorch · 15/09/2021 07:44

@chocolateorangeinhaler

I'd be bloody angry too. Regardless of religious beliefs or how his parents raised him it's a nasty thing to think let alone say out loud.

Another example of why all religions should be seen as what they are -bullying controlling cults- and all banned. They offer no benefits to modern civilization.

So you are prolife then?
honeylulu · 15/09/2021 07:44

Other posters have hit on two issues that help me see your point of view.

Firstly, the seeming hypocrisy of the vicar's view that your mother should terminate. (I say "seeming" because I do not know how he expressed his view and reasoning and he may have made the suggestion in an open minded and caring way, though I somewhat doubt it.) I was a regular churchgoer in my youth and one of my friends got pregnant age 18 - not married, no boyfriend, still living with parents - and decided to keep the baby. This was the early 1990s. I was really shocked to overhear one of the church elders (male) quite vehemently expressing the view that "she should have got rid of it quietly and not brought shame on her parents like that". It certainly wasn't motivated by being pro-choice or concern for her or her parents welfare - her parents were really supportive - but rather a case of "she has sinned but as long as she hides her sin so everything looks OK on the surface I'll ignore the moral dilemma that most Christians would have". She had the baby and tragically he died of cot death at a few months old. I couldn't stop wondering if the elder felt guilty about what he'd said or if he just thought "good".

The other point a PP has mentioned is men with power and influence pressurising a girl/woman to have a termination she does not want. Along the lines of "abortion is easily available so you can just go and get one". Just as women can be co-erced to have sex by men, I do think it isn't terribly unusual for women to be co-erced into having terminations by men particularly if they are vulnerable in some way. I am hugely pro-choice by the way, but it should be the woman's choice. I may be projecting because of the experiences of my friend above, and other acquaintances who had terminations because their partners threatened to make their lives a misery if they didn't.

OP, your fury sounds very emotive and I think it is stopping you seeing straight. If you are pro-choice, there is a disconnect with that view. The vicar didn't want "you" dead because he didn't know "you"/who you would become. He thought a termination was best and expressed that opinion. We don't know the reasons for that. They might have been loving and caring or they might have been pompous and hypocritical (I suspect the latter and if that was the case I would feel angry and disgusted too).

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 15/09/2021 07:43

So a vicar said that he thought it wasn't such a terrible sin and it wouldn't be murder if a woman were to choose a termination in some circumstances? Possibly giving many religious women the reassurance that they wouldn't go to Hell if they took that option at a time where there was loads in the press about restricting availability even more and reducing time limits?

What an evil bastard. How dare a man be so compassionate towards women.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/09/2021 07:41

I've recently found out that my mother's vicar (CofE but fairly high church I guess) suggested she would be better off aborting

Was this conversation with a young and vulnerable underage girl in the 80s, an adult capable of supporting herself in the 80s, after you were born? There isn't enough info here and from your OP you don't seem to have the vicar's version of events, just something second hand.

There is also an inconsistency between being pro choice and "the vicar tried to kill me". Surely you see that?

Truthlikeness · 15/09/2021 07:36

My mum had me at 17 in the 1970s, after a hastily arranged marriage. I've always known if I was in the same position I would have aborted me. That doesn't mean I wish I'd never born, simply that, that's the choice I would have made at that age. As it happens I had a very good childhood and loving parents (they stayed together).

sandgrown · 15/09/2021 07:29

My mum came from a strict Catholic family . In the 1950s I was her second illegitimate child and mixed race too. I am sure a some of her family wished I didn’t exist. Her aunt never spoke to her again but my mum was a strong woman. Let it go and live your best life. Maybe the vicar was offering your mum a choice without disapproval.

LukeEvansWife · 15/09/2021 07:28

I'd be bloody angry too. Regardless of religious beliefs or how his parents raised him it's a nasty thing to think let alone say out loud.

Wow. What have the vicar’s parents got to do with it. And why is it a nasty thing to think or say? Young woman gets pregnant, she has a right to have the options presented to her. He didn’t march OP’s mother down to the abortion clinic!

Bluetrews25 · 15/09/2021 07:26

Was the vicar your father?

LukeEvansWife · 15/09/2021 07:23

He didn’t want you dead. That is over dramatic.

As a teen in the 1980s, most young girls would have had abortion suggested to them as there wasn’t the support or moral acceptance that there is now.

And yes, if you are pro choice, you have to accept that people are entitled to have the option suggested to them

Walkingalot · 15/09/2021 07:23

Your way of thinking means that there is an awful lot of people on this planet that probably had someone wish them dead at some point! Most of us will never know as it's not something generally talked about. In your case it's a third party, not even your DM.
The vicar didn't know you, it obviously didn't happen (you are here) so why so angry? Is there more to it that you haven't shared here?

Geamhradh · 15/09/2021 07:20

And what in the name of fuck have the vicar's parents got to do with it? Confused

Atalune · 15/09/2021 07:20

he wanted me dead sounds extremely pro life and not pro choice at all. It’s the kind of emotive, non factual hysterical comments the hardline prolifers bandy about.

Geamhradh · 15/09/2021 07:19

@chocolateorangeinhaler

I'd be bloody angry too. Regardless of religious beliefs or how his parents raised him it's a nasty thing to think let alone say out loud.

Another example of why all religions should be seen as what they are -bullying controlling cults- and all banned. They offer no benefits to modern civilization.

What did he say then? Do you know?

Did he say
"Oh Edna, you slut! Get thee without my parish! And only come back when your baby has been aborted"
Or:
"Oh Edna, you have a choice. It's your body".

spotcheck · 15/09/2021 07:17

You have no idea how the conversation went. The vicar could very well have been responding to something your mum said.
Come on- as pp said- save your rage

ThorsLeftNut · 15/09/2021 07:12

He didn’t ‘want you dead’ though did he? That’s quite a dramatic spin on things.

Subbaxeo · 15/09/2021 07:11

If abortion had been legal in 1963, I wouldn’t be here. So you could say my mum wanted me dead! Save your rage and be grateful to your mum.

10yearwarranty · 15/09/2021 07:08

You weren't there. You didn't hear the conversation and the context of what was said. So you're being pretty daft. Yes, if you think you're pro-choice even more so.
I know that my grandma spoke to my mum about her choices when Mum got pregnant in the 60's. I'm sure her intentions were good and she was being sensible.

BlueberrySugar · 15/09/2021 07:01

Alright Rocky, take a breathe.

I think you're over reacting with this.

peachycream31 · 15/09/2021 06:59

@chocolateorangeinhaler

I'd be bloody angry too. Regardless of religious beliefs or how his parents raised him it's a nasty thing to think let alone say out loud.

What's 'nasty' about talking through options with a young pregnant woman? Isn't that being respectful of her choices?

chocolateorangeinhaler · 15/09/2021 06:56

I'd be bloody angry too. Regardless of religious beliefs or how his parents raised him it's a nasty thing to think let alone say out loud.

Another example of why all religions should be seen as what they are -bullying controlling cults- and all banned. They offer no benefits to modern civilization.