Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not text him on his birthday?

154 replies

Canunothanks · 14/09/2021 19:38

Been seeing this guy for 5 months ish. He’s gone to see his parents because it’s his birthday (different city).

I was on a shitty work shift last night and he was texting me about it. Didn’t reply to my last text at 1am. Which is fine obviously, but it’s 930pm the next day now. No reply.

It’s his birthday tomorrow.

If he doesn’t text me back do I even say happy birthday? Seems so pathetic to double text

OP posts:
FaceForRadio1973 · 15/09/2021 11:25

I can see why you might be confused as to the sudden lack of texting. I used to be in a long distance relationship, and it was unusual to not hear from my partner for an extended length of time.

However, I was more worried that they were okay, and probably text again later. It was never a requirement of my turn - your turn.

Please do text him a Happy Birthday. It's not a criminal offence to double check.

As an aside, maybe he is upset because his girlfriend couldn't be bothered to spend a few seconds messaging him?

ChargingBuck · 15/09/2021 11:14

@Canunothanks

It wasn’t a 8.5 hour gap 😂 it was a 20 hour gap. 1am to 930pm, not am
Apologies, OP. I misread that entirely.

Texting aside - he's not mature enough for you.
Even a FWB relationship should be about adding to the sum of your happiness, not making you worry & doubt yourself.

Don't set yourself up to be hanging on for crumbs from a game-player - let Mr 15 Years Old go, you don;t need to settle for this.

ChargingBuck · 15/09/2021 11:10

He’s extremely immature, younger than me by a few years.

Honestly he’s done things that a 15 year old would do. The ignoring text thing is one of the many games he plays

That is a mighty dripfeed OP.

If you'd mentioned this, & the info about his boringly unoriginal Grand Commitment-phobe speech, you would have had some very different responses.

Now you've wished him a happy birthday, I think your part in this is done. You've spent 5 months (I hope a lot of it was fun) dating someone so immature he acts like a 15 year old. Maybe spend some time wondering why you would tolerate that, & stop overthinking what the texting/not texting means.
You don't need to put your life on hold for a wannabe teenager. Get out there & find someone who doesn't make you second-guess whether you should text him or not.

If you have to spend this much time analysing a new relationship - it's not worth it.

ChargingBuck · 15/09/2021 10:59

@Savoretti

But you didn’t text him all day either? Why is it up to him to message first? Just because you messaged last last night? That’s bonkers - this is an adult relationship
Exactly this! Somewhere on Blokesnet, an OP is worried that his g/f is ignoring him, because he's gone away to see his folks ...
ChargingBuck · 15/09/2021 10:56

This distant texting has been going on since he went home Friday and so I just put it down to him wanting to see friends etc. He was taking hours replying which was fine because he was busy... but now it’s gone to 24 hours so maybe he’s just generally lost interest,

Oh stop catastrophising!
Why would you instantly jump to "must have lost interest"?
Does he need to be in constant text-tennis with you to 'prove' something to you? Let the guy have a life, & wish him a happy birthday while you're at it.

If you are fixed on measuring the value of your relationship by absurd rules of texting, you are using the wrong measurements. Spontaneity & respecting each other's space are great ingredients for a successful relationship. Communication styles are allowed to evolve & adapt within a growing relationship. You don't need to keep tabs on a man in order to keep him. Make sure you have your own stuff going on outside of work - just like he does - be a whole person, not just someone who needs to feel validated by constant, strictly turn-taking, texting from her b/f.

Canunothanks · 15/09/2021 10:50

It wasn’t a 8.5 hour gap 😂 it was a 20 hour gap. 1am to 930pm, not am

OP posts:
Wole · 15/09/2021 10:47

If you want to wish him a happy birthday then do so, forget the double texting thing. Or maybe ring him? But if you don't he will probably assume you've gone off him. So up to you.

ChargingBuck · 15/09/2021 10:44

@Canunothanks

Can someone please explain why it’s unreasonable to be slightly confused/upset that someone you’re seeing randomly disappeared during a text conversation and nearly 24 hours later still hasn’t replied?

When it’s usually a continuous conversation throughout the day?

Honestly struggling to understand how that means I need to grow up

Because your OP reads as if you are worrying about an 8 & a half hour gap between texts:

Didn’t reply to my last text at 1am. Which is fine obviously, but it’s 930pm the next day now.

Maybe just text him or even ring the man, ask him how his day has been - how hard is that? You are communicating with a loved one, not keeping a tally & timesheet for billing purposes ...

Inthesameboatatmo · 15/09/2021 10:41

I would completely ignore him now op and I personally would block if no response in a few days, you deserve better it's hard I've had it done to me but keep your dignity and move on

Canunothanks · 15/09/2021 10:34

@Wishimaywishimight

Does anyone over the age of 15 believe that a man can be so scared and overwhelmed by his feelings that he backs off from someone he claims to really like??

I'm pretty old (50's) and in my experience a man who likes you shows he likes you. My DH, when we met, was really shy and reserved but I was never in any doubt as to how much he liked me and enjoyed my company right from the start. We got close pretty quickly, engaged after 14 months and have now been married 16 years. All delightfully bullshit free.

He’s extremely immature, younger than me by a few years.

Honestly he’s done things that a 15 year old would do. The ignoring text thing is one of the many games he plays

OP posts:
Wishimaywishimight · 15/09/2021 10:18

Does anyone over the age of 15 believe that a man can be so scared and overwhelmed by his feelings that he backs off from someone he claims to really like??

I'm pretty old (50's) and in my experience a man who likes you shows he likes you. My DH, when we met, was really shy and reserved but I was never in any doubt as to how much he liked me and enjoyed my company right from the start. We got close pretty quickly, engaged after 14 months and have now been married 16 years. All delightfully bullshit free.

ChargingBuck · 15/09/2021 10:01

@theresroomonmybroom

Unpopular opinion apparently but I know what you mean OP. It's hurtful to feel like you didn't cross his mind once all day for him to think to text you but everyone thinks you should jump at the chance to text him.

Maybe wish him happy birthday, but a quick message later in the day with something like "you seem busy so just a quick happy birthday from me, enjoy the rest of your day" and leave the ball in his court.

Ignore the nasty comments OP, I knew what you meant x

For goodness sake, "didn't cross his mind all day"??!

The guy was up til 1am, texting OP about her horrible work shift.
OP posted at 9.30am.
Is her b/f not allowed to get 8 hours kip without jumping to his phone to reassure his g/f he is thinking about her?

I would find this attitude bloody suffocating.

Looubylou · 15/09/2021 09:56

I'm glad you said happy birthday OP- I would now retire gracefully. Your first message made you sound very childish, but your later post sheds a whole new light. He is almost certainly a commitment phobic, emotional abuser, who can't handle problems. You were comfortable enough to share problems late at night - he may struggle with anything other than good times. No loss 💐

Honeymare · 15/09/2021 09:50

I'm on your side here OP. It's been five months but five shaky months. If things were solid and you felt secure then you wouldn't have even noticed double texting. I say eff him. You've messaged happy birthday. Don't contact him again and let his next message go unanswered. Maybe he is just not relationship material if he's always disappearing, backs off when he likes someone etc. He can step up and prove you wrong.

scoopgalore · 15/09/2021 09:44

You must be joking

Canunothanks · 15/09/2021 09:38

@HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend

Seriously, you need to give your head a wobble!
In what way?
OP posts:
HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 15/09/2021 09:30

Seriously, you need to give your head a wobble!

DressBitch · 15/09/2021 09:28

Yeah, he's over it.

Move on now, OP.

sonjadog · 15/09/2021 09:26

I would leave it up to him now.

Canunothanks · 15/09/2021 09:12

Thanks for some of the kind messages.

He posted on social media at 1230am ish last night, so I sent a nice message saying happy birthday.

He has also ignored that message

OP posts:
Coronawireless · 15/09/2021 08:05

YANBU. Yep, nasty comments on here for whatever strange reasons.
You sound insecure about your relationship, and his behaviour, both with the failure to respond and previous discussions you’ve had with him, is not helping. After 5 months it’s worth establishing with him where you both stand. If he is evasive, bin him and find someone less flaky (if you do want a secure, mature relationship).

JaffaCake70 · 15/09/2021 05:26

[quote Redgeraniums]**@HalzTangz
What a random comparison, it’s not someone she lives with that she’s going home to.
It’s a fledgling relationship of a couple of months and he’s left if 24 hours. When they usually text everyday. So it’s out of character.

The OP probably wasn’t written that well, and wasn’t clear and seemed a little bit immature with regards to birthday text.

But yes I would be a bit miffed, though I would give him a break as he’s at home. And yes I would send him a happy birthday text[/quote]
I agree with everything you've said @Redgeraniums. @HalzTangz is in a completely different situation and obviously doesn't have the same text habits as the OP.

OP is used to texting numerous times every day with her OH, hence the reason for her concern.

The comparison doesn't make any sense as the relationships are completely different.

MN really brings out the mean side in a lot of people. There's a lot of unnecessary nastiness in the comments here. Why can't people either offer constructive advice or just not comment? Why would you purposely type something horrible to a stranger who's come here looking for advice?

Redgeraniums · 14/09/2021 22:35

@HalzTangz
What a random comparison, it’s not someone she lives with that she’s going home to.
It’s a fledgling relationship of a couple of months and he’s left if 24 hours. When they usually text everyday. So it’s out of character.

The OP probably wasn’t written that well, and wasn’t clear and seemed a little bit immature with regards to birthday text.

But yes I would be a bit miffed, though I would give him a break as he’s at home. And yes I would send him a happy birthday text

Hont1986 · 14/09/2021 22:35

Was your message something that needed to be responded to? Like he has left a question unanswered? Or maybe he just saw it as the end of the conversation.

Stop playing games, just text him.

PaddleBlue · 14/09/2021 22:35

Sorry you’re getting such bitchy comments here OP. I can see how you could feel insecure especially if you say relationship isn’t established. I personally would still say happy birthday but be wary if you don’t think he’s as keen