Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this mother's advice to her 10 year old DD faintly disturbing?

107 replies

randocalrissian · 14/09/2021 19:27

My DD is in year 6 and, as is normal, there are the first stirrings of pre-teen romance among one or two kids in her year. All pretty innocent and harmless and we've chatted about it.

She told me yesterday one girl in her class is flirting a bit with a boy - think they're not even at the holding hands stage but its the talk of the town as you can imagine.

DD said the girl had said her mum took the girl aside and gave her some "tips" about how to flirt with this boy.

The one which stuck in my mind was "always be pleasant and smiley around him and laugh at his jokes. Don't say too much and don't hang out too much with the other boys".

I'm not sure whether to be more disturbed that this mum is basically preparing her pre-pubescent daughter for a relationship in such an overt way at this age or the advice that she should turn herself into such a wet discloth.

Is it just me or is this weird and a bit unhealthy?

OP posts:
cookingisoverrated · 14/09/2021 22:10

@Mymapuddlington

It’s a bit grim but there are unfortunately mothers like this. I know one who is super proud because her year 6 daughter had every single boy in her year group as a boyfriend over the course of the year.
Ewww.

That's actually quite horrible.

LizzieW1969 · 14/09/2021 22:05

Oh my god @Reallyhadenough surely that's a form of child abuse??

I think it really is. My DDs (12 and 9) have both started their periods recently and they’re both very embarrassed about it, and about other body changes. They want complete privacy, whilst obviously requiring a lot of reassurance.

That mum’s behaviour is very disturbing.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 14/09/2021 21:50

@prsphne

as far as life advice goes, it's not awful.

'Don't hang around with other boys too much?'

'Don't say too much'?

Don't SAY too much aka either be quiet or don't express an opinion?

Are you fucking kidding when you say it's not bad advice or do you just think women are lesser than men?!

Peteycat · 14/09/2021 21:49

I have come across mums like this. It's usually some sort of issue they have with themselves they project onto the child. I think it's abnormal.

Heartofglass12345 · 14/09/2021 21:48

Oh my god @Reallyhadenough surely that's a form of child abuse??
I started my periods when I was 11 and still in primary school and my mum made a big fuss and told loads of people in my family. Awful it was, I didn't want them to know! She hadn't even told me much about them either!

Bluntness100 · 14/09/2021 21:39

Sounds like a young girls interpretion of how to flirt. I very much doubt that that’s actually what the mother said, and since you’ve heard it third hand I’d urge you to think the same.

Reallyhadenough · 14/09/2021 21:37

My..ex friend was obsessed with her daughter starting her periods.. made the poor girl show be her "buds" weekly. Are girls not allowed privacy now?! I cut contact because the kid needs privacy... but I ALSO DON'T want to see!!!!

CornishPastyDownUnder · 14/09/2021 21:29

could be bullshit,or not..who cares?!there will be much bigger things coming your way soon enough at high school&the kids/you will have much more to occupy your mental energy with than thisHmm.

AnnieSnap · 14/09/2021 21:25

[quote jellybellydancer]@AnnieSnap Year 7 not aged 7…[/quote]
Oops! Still, I can’t imagine many GPS would prescribe easily for an 11-year-old without the child saying she was sexually active. Maybe she went down the ‘needed to settle her periods’ route!

AnnieSnap · 14/09/2021 21:22

@prsphne

Not to be controversial, but isn't that how you flirt...

I mean, so long as she's not teaching her that she needs a boyfriend but I assume the girl "likes" the boy and so might genuinely find his jokes funny.

I was probably pleasant and smiley around my husband when I met him. (and entirely myself, but the most pleasant version of myself!). I don't keep it up all of the time now, but there is a bit of an 'art' to meeting people and making friends and being flirty until you have an established. relationship with someone.

I accept in isolation it's not great advice as it should be top and tailed with 'be yourself' 'don't change for anyone' and 'you don't need a boyfriend to be happy', but as far as life advice goes, it's not awful.

Including ‘don’t talk too much or spend much time with other boys’? As for smile a lot, shouldn’t a person just smile when they naturally feel like smiling?
jellybellydancer · 14/09/2021 21:19

@AnnieSnap Year 7 not aged 7…

SeriouslyISuppose · 14/09/2021 21:13

@prsphne

Not to be controversial, but isn't that how you flirt...

I mean, so long as she's not teaching her that she needs a boyfriend but I assume the girl "likes" the boy and so might genuinely find his jokes funny.

I was probably pleasant and smiley around my husband when I met him. (and entirely myself, but the most pleasant version of myself!). I don't keep it up all of the time now, but there is a bit of an 'art' to meeting people and making friends and being flirty until you have an established. relationship with someone.

I accept in isolation it's not great advice as it should be top and tailed with 'be yourself' 'don't change for anyone' and 'you don't need a boyfriend to be happy', but as far as life advice goes, it's not awful.

No, keeping quiet and smiley, breaking silence only to laugh in girlish glee at his jokes, while avoiding men other than the one who has Anointed Me With His Attention isn’t how I have ever flirted.
AnnieSnap · 14/09/2021 21:11

@YourFinestPantaloons

In the school I work in we had one mother put her year 7 DD on the contraceptive pill because she "fully expected that she was having sex or will be soon" Shockthe girl is very shy and introverted and I can't imagine why her mum would ever think for a second she was sexually active. And yes a safeguarding referral was made.
How did she access the contraceptive pill for a 7 year old. Was she using one she’d had prescribed for herself?
randocalrissian · 14/09/2021 21:08

@FOJN

It's depressing a mother would teach her daughter that whatever happens in her life the approval of a man will be one of her biggest achievements and she must use whatever means necessary to accomplish it.
Exactly this.
OP posts:
FOJN · 14/09/2021 21:06

It's depressing a mother would teach her daughter that whatever happens in her life the approval of a man will be one of her biggest achievements and she must use whatever means necessary to accomplish it.

JeffGoldblumsGlasses · 14/09/2021 21:04

@Grilledaubergines

“I make women work for my attention.”

Awful switched around.

I’m not sure they love the chase. Not anyone worth having a relationship with.

It’s just all sounds a bit, well, TOWIE to me. And disrespectful.

Depends what you are after I suppose. I don't want a relationship, why would I , I'm financially independent, have my own home and do my own thing. I wouldn't want to clutter it up with a relationship.

Online Dating has really changed the game. With multiple choices at your fingertips it's a minefield. I do feel sorry for those who online date actually looking for a relationship because I've no idea how that works! People just literally swipe on to the next person when they fancy a change.

Diverami · 14/09/2021 21:00

In the fifties, I was a teenager and did not have many boyfriends (maybe none), but when I had a "date" one day, my mother made me (though I was absolutely ready to go even before he came) keep him waiting for a few minutes - I think to make sure I did not seem overly keen and also maybe so she could talk to him. This was how it was in the twenties and thirties when she was young, so she was teaching me what she had learned. So I figure that the mother in the posted story was doing the same - passing along her out-of-date wisdom.

Ifeelmuchlessfat · 14/09/2021 21:00

“Didn’t happen of the Year Award”

Grilledaubergines · 14/09/2021 20:57

“I make women work for my attention.”

Awful switched around.

I’m not sure they love the chase. Not anyone worth having a relationship with.

It’s just all sounds a bit, well, TOWIE to me. And disrespectful.

JeffGoldblumsGlasses · 14/09/2021 20:45

@Grilledaubergines

I make men work for my attention, hasn't failed me yet. 😂

Equally as grim.

How so, better than fawning over them and stroking their male egos. You want to talk to me or flirt with me, you come to me, and make it worth while having my attention.

It's far easier for women, we can pick and choose what we want, who we want. No need to fawn over men. They love the chase to be honest. 🤷🏻‍♀️😂

randocalrissian · 14/09/2021 20:37

@UserEmptor

OP, there are so many things wrong with this that I wouldn't know where to start.

Is it really "normal" for children in Year 6 to start this stuff? If so, I'm glad my children went to single-sex schools at that age.

My only comment would be that flirting - of any type - at the age of 10/11 is completely unnecessary. These are still just children.

I'm a bit aghast, really.

It is totally normal for there to be a sort of "dress rehearsal" for romance in year 6. We were doing that when I was that age (in the eary 80s). It's harmless, innocent role play. I don't mean kissing or, God forbid, sex, just pretend girlfriend/boyfriend stuff. No harm in that at all, that's as old as the hills. And its just as likely to go on between kids at single sex schools TBH.

What bothered me about it was a) the very calculating "blueprint" for how to catch a boy and b) the suggestion that the way to do so was to basically erase your personality and needs and be a simulacram of a junior Stepford Wife.

Very damaging signals to send to a girl at that point of her life, I thought. I told my DD that as well.

OP posts:
CaMePlaitPas · 14/09/2021 20:35

Ugh. Stop the world, I want to get off.

Grilledaubergines · 14/09/2021 20:32

I make men work for my attention, hasn't failed me yet. 😂

Equally as grim.

Ionlydomassiveones · 14/09/2021 20:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Susannahmoody · 14/09/2021 20:28

Begs belief