Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give son "his" savings

114 replies

Comingup · 14/09/2021 16:54

17 year old and is currently trying to find a part time job to fit round college. I have saved a few thousand pounds towards a car or travel etc for him. He's been taking it out in dribs and drabs increasingly regularly and has nothing to show for it. I've found out he's smoking weed. He is aggressive and demanding Igive it to him when he asks as it his " his" money, and I havent restricted his siblings access to theirs ( who have used it for legit things). Why on earth should I facilitate his habit? Or should I just let him squander it and hope he learns a lesson when there's none left.

OP posts:
flippertyop · 14/09/2021 19:02

I also didn't do a Junior Isa for this reason. I don't intend to hand it over until they are 21

MouseholeCat · 14/09/2021 19:01

It's in your name so ultimately you control it. 17 is old enough that you can talk plainly to them. Tell him you worked extremely hard to save money for your children in difficult circumstances and you did that so it could go towards something constructive.

Be clear that your hard work does not go towards funding a weed habit.

Mindymomo · 14/09/2021 18:59

One thing I wished I had not done, was to tell my Son I had savings for him, not that he squandered it, but he kept on about it all the time. Money my parents gave when they died went into their savings, but again, I wished I’d given it when I wanted him to have it, like you I saved for over 18 years and he just took it for granted that he could spend it however way he wanted. In the end he got a new PS and I used the rest of the money to pay for his first car.

Harryfrog12 · 14/09/2021 18:52

If its in your name transfer it into one of them accounts you cant touch for 5 years and tell him he can have it all then not before

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 14/09/2021 18:51

I save money for my DS and when he's asked for some of it to buy some random crap thing saying 'it's my money' I've made it perfectly clear that it's not. It's money I saved for something valuable for him. It's mine until he decides what he wants to do with it.

NoSquirrels · 14/09/2021 18:50

If it’s truly in an account in your name - not a savings account with his name on it that you are a trustee of - then it is your money to do as you wish with.

I’d be really clear - DS, this is money I have saved for you to spend on driving lessons or something I can see the benefit of. It’s not ‘yours’ to do 100% what you like with. If I don’t approve I won’t transfer the money.

Tough if he doesn’t like it.

KingdomScrolls · 14/09/2021 18:50

DSs savings are in my name for this reason and he won't be told about them. When he reaches the right age, and he needs a first car the money will be there, rental deposit it will be there, wants to go traveling a bit etc (unlikely to be enough for a house deposit), but that's our money we've saved for him and I'm not having it pissed away by a teenager.

shapes1 · 14/09/2021 18:47

@Ihopeyourcakeisshit oops I meant 1 not 51 lol

QueenBee52 · 14/09/2021 18:46

Remind him that it's not his money.... it's your money you saved to help Him purchase things in the future... oh and You've changed your mind about helping him now.

You have no Savings Kid.. Your Mum on the other hand....

SpilltheTea · 14/09/2021 18:45

I wouldn't give him any more. It's not his money and you have every right to change your mind. I wouldn't feel bad in the slightest.

User57327259 · 14/09/2021 18:43

When parents and grandparents etc put money away for a young child there is no knowing how that child is going to turn out, whether they will be studious and sensible or wild and frivolous. They could even be under the control of a grabby partner and friends.
If they are showing a lack of money sense the best thing to do is not to allow them access to the money set aside for them. I am a strong believer that money should be earned even if it is in the form of a gift from parents and grandparents. Everyone works too hard and saves for someone else to fritter that money away. Another issue is that having money makes them a target for unscrupulous people. The young people also have to learn to treat family money as a confidential matter and not tell friends.
It happens in a lot of families. Often when a person is vulnerable such as a single parent, elderly or ill pressure is put on that person to give large sums of money.

NewlyGranny · 14/09/2021 18:41

This is a heartbreaker. You scrimped and saved and slaved and he hates you for not letting him blow it on dope. 🤦🏼‍♀️

I would turn off the supply immediately and set some conditions. Tell him you are thinking of the future him and how he will blame you for letting him squander it and have nothing lasting to show for it. Ask him where he sees himself in 5 years and how those funds could help.

Tell him that money is your sweat and blood and you can't bear the pain if watching him dribble it down the drain.

Why not call a 3 month moratorium while he seeks a job and sorts himself out and tell him that every single time he asks you for any money for any purpose or even so much as mentions the money in that account, you will transfer £100 from it to your own separate savings, because it's yours and you worked for every sodding penny of it. Get angry, get tough, get fierce.

He will thank you, I promise. Could you rally the older ones round to talk about how they used theirs and the difference it made to them?

CyclingIsNotOuting · 14/09/2021 18:39

No way would I let him have it.
I wouldn’t even feel bad.

Lockdownbear · 14/09/2021 18:30

@DeletedByAccident I'll stand correctedSmile

Apparently they can take control at 16 but not withdraw until 18. Still too young in my opinion. I knew another young adult who blew his savings (not sure if it was a child trust or JISA) on Xbox games.

Fraine · 14/09/2021 18:29

Tell him the money is in my name, I earned it and it belongs to me and that it is completely up to me if I want to give my children any money.

OddBoots · 14/09/2021 18:28

This is not me saying you should give him the money, I agree you have every right not to and I wouldn't in your shoes but it's worth at least trying to have a good conversation with him about the drugs, to get a feel for if he is likely to turn to criminal behaviour to obtain them without this money, and if he is already in any kind of debt for them.

Notaroadrunner · 14/09/2021 18:22

@Comingup

Thanks all. Yes just to clarify, I have absolutely gone without to try and save for them, and was so proud of myself. If I'd have known he would behave this way I'd never ever have told him. Its iny name, he can't get it at all without me transferring it and the amounts are getting ridiculous, like £100 in a week, on nothing ( except of ourselves now I know its weed). I could cry, as I've been a single mum on a low wage, and thought it was amazing that I'd done this, but it's made him hate me. I did say it was his money, but ffs not to fund a drug habit.
Ungrateful brat! It's your money - you just had it in your mind to give it to him. You are entitled to change your mind about that. I'd tell him that you have decided to spend the money on yourself now and let him sod off. Then either do spend it on yourself or hang on to it until such time as he will spend it wisely.
diamondpony80 · 14/09/2021 18:20

It's YOUR money that you earned, and you had some specific ideas about what the money was for. So no, I definitely wouldn't be giving it to him.

DS17 has an account where he's saved a few thousand of his own for a car and to go abroad next year. He worked hard for it and while he still goes out and enjoys himself, he respects the money more because he earned it himself and looks after it.

Hold on to the money you've saved for him for when he comes to his senses - like for a house deposit or something else he needs money for down the line. If you withdraw access to your money he might work harder to find a job, and once he's working hopefully he'll realise money for things like weed isn't that easy to come by.

CantBeAssed · 14/09/2021 18:17

I was actually doing the calculations (3 from 51=48) now that's an age gap...🤣🤣🤣

Marcee · 14/09/2021 18:16

Yup.
I'm not getting a junior Isa for this reason.

All their savings in my nam3

Notaroadrunner · 14/09/2021 18:15

@Comingup

Its in my name, he has to ask for it to be sent to his account.
No way would I give him another penny until he's older and in a more responsible position. He doesn't get to 'demand' anything from you.
Anordinarymum · 14/09/2021 18:13

Definitely no money if he smokes weed. Not now, not ever. Can't say it any other way. Weed is a killer of young men especially if they smoke skunk. It ruins young lives and destroys families.
Be strong.

mellicauli · 14/09/2021 18:12

I guess you've got to talk him through it. Computer says no won't wash.

He doesn't understand how hard it is to save a substantial amount of money and pay for the basics in life: talk him through every penny of your household expenditure, what's left and changes happen when he leaves education (e.g no child benefit etc) which means he will have to work.

He doesn't understand how he will need large sums for - talk him the future and the things he'll want to do: drive, travel, flat deposit an

He also doesn't understand the personal and societal problems that drugs bring - lots of good films about that

Tell him you'll review the decision again when he's 18.

Melroses · 14/09/2021 18:04

The only savings my DC had access to were the accounts where they had saved birthday money and pocket money.

The money I had saved to cover the uni fees (ha ha - they were tripled twice over so pissing in the wind there) I gave them after A levels to make sure they didn't have any cash-flow problems with loans/rent etc.

Fingers crossed this will pass.

There are lots of jobs around atm and he needs to try for one.

MrsScrubbithatescleaning · 14/09/2021 18:02

My 2 step sons inherited money but it was in a trust until they were 25. The oldest could have had it at 18 and would have been sensible with it but the youngest would definitely have blown the lot on crap.

Thankfully, by the time he was 25, the youngest had grown up a lot, had ditched his loser buddies, and got himself a job with a large company and has worked his way up and now earns a 6 figure salary.

I think you need to tell your DS that you’ve decided to invest the rest of the money into a long term savings account that can’t be touched for 10 years and wait for him to mature. He’s only 17 and he might be a nightmare for another few years but I bet he’ll be a completely different person by the time he’s 25.