Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to explain that I don't feel like being recorded

70 replies

Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 15:25

I'm a trustee for a charity and tonight I'm giving a seminar on an area of my expertise for our volunteers. Online zoom.

They were very keen and sweet about it. They said people from other charities wanted to come, I said sure.

Now even more people want to come but they can't make the time and anyway more people might want to watch it later so they want to record it.

I don't want it to be recorded. I do loads of recorded seminars for my paid job and they're a very different dynamic than the informal question-and-answer session I'm envisioning for this evening.

Plus if other volunteers are involved who knows where the recording will end up.

They're all acting surprised that I said no thanks to a recording.

Is this some new professional norm? There's a rebuttable presumption that everything must be recorded?

OP posts:
museumum · 14/09/2021 16:40

I think it has become standard that these things are available for those who can’t attend (esp volunteers) as that’s more accessible to those with caring commitments etc.
I do understand what your objection is. And if it’s Q&A I would tell the organisers not to record it so that participants are not intimidated from asking Qs.

A compromise would be having it available for a week on “catch up” zoom lets you do this and say that it needs to be only a week as the content will date right away.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 14/09/2021 16:35

I am happy to be recorded when giving straightforward lectures on matters. I am not happy to record discussions, seminars, especially on sensitive topics. It discourages others from speaking, and there is a chance they could say something controversial or even criminal, I know of a case where this happened and although no action was taken, it was very stressful.

Recording the 20 min presentation, fine, recording interactions/chat/frank speaking amongst the participants, no I wouldn't want to do that and would happily state this. This is usually our policy at work and outside speakers sometimes request no recording not even of the main presentation if they want to retain intellectual property (e.g. new ideas) or it's on a controversial topic.

Booknooks · 14/09/2021 16:34

I don't think you're being unreasonable, presumably you're doing it for free too, if they want a recording that they presumably wish to circulate (probably without your say so) then they should pay for your time and draw up an agreement.

Keepitonthedownlow · 14/09/2021 16:33

I'm sure it's part of GDPR, everyone has the right to decline being recorded. If someone is desperate they can circulate a transcript, subject to your approval.

TheUndoingProject · 14/09/2021 16:31

I think your reservations are sensible.

I wouldn’t want footage - outside of my control - of me talking about a sensitive area when it could possibly be “held against me” without the benefit of context/ when issues have moved on/ when I was speaking off the cuff.

Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 16:30

Another example, is in an informal live chat you can be more discursive and spontaneous, saying, "Oh there's this one case where the judge said x". Whereas in a recorded training you need to have the actual citation.

OP posts:
Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 16:26

No like I said it's informal seminar for some volunteers.

OP posts:
TheQueenOfTheNight · 14/09/2021 16:24

Just a thought - is this part of a larger event, and if so, is the whole thing being recorded?

Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 16:24

*five

OP posts:
Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 16:24

Well yes and my colleagues could be recording me going to the toilet, because they can.

I'm proceeding on the assumption that an online seminar with fuve colleagues is not recorded because they've asked that it not be recorded. Obviously I'm never "off the record" at work but you have to have a little trust to function! Otherwise I'd just stay at home with my tinfoil hat on.

OP posts:
Fraine · 14/09/2021 16:18

@Coffeetree

Well yes there are a number of ways people can record clandestinely but I'm going to assume they're normal people who wouldn't do that.
Please don’t trust anyone. If people could record you without knowing it, they would record you. They would explain it away to themselves and still feel they are ‘normal’.
Fraine · 14/09/2021 16:16

@MatildaIThink

Could the compromise be that you retain the initial recording and right to edit/remove segments, provided that edit does not change the meaning of what other people say?

Not much of a compromise. OP is doing them a favour, that’s more than enough of a compromise. They’re CFs.

godmum56 · 14/09/2021 16:11

@TheQueenOfTheNight

I am surprised that so many people don't understand your position. Irrespective of how anyone feels about recording seminars, you agreed to do a particular thing under a particular set of circumstances. That's your choice and prerogative. There's a setting on zoom that prevents participants from recording the session. Please stipulate /check that this happens. Yes participants could in theory use a camera to record what's onscreen but the quality should be awful, using a camera to record any onscreen content is usually very poor quality.
I absolutely do understand and would say that if the OP doesn't want to be recorded, as the voluntary presenter then they absolutely should be able to say no. My point was that saying no doesn't mean it won't happen.
Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 16:06

Well yes there are a number of ways people can record clandestinely but I'm going to assume they're normal people who wouldn't do that.

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 14/09/2021 16:04

@TheQueenOfTheNight

I am surprised that so many people don't understand your position. Irrespective of how anyone feels about recording seminars, you agreed to do a particular thing under a particular set of circumstances. That's your choice and prerogative. There's a setting on zoom that prevents participants from recording the session. Please stipulate /check that this happens. Yes participants could in theory use a camera to record what's onscreen but the quality should be awful, using a camera to record any onscreen content is usually very poor quality.
They would not need to use a camera to record the screen, there is a screen/audio recording feature build into Windows (and I am sure Macs as well), which totally bypasses the Zoom block feature, the only difference is that it will not be the build in Zoom record feature.
Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 16:02

Yes I'm providing slides. It's not meant to train people up on how to practise, more like "Let's chat about this area of law".

OP posts:
TheQueenOfTheNight · 14/09/2021 16:01

I am surprised that so many people don't understand your position. Irrespective of how anyone feels about recording seminars, you agreed to do a particular thing under a particular set of circumstances. That's your choice and prerogative.
There's a setting on zoom that prevents participants from recording the session. Please stipulate /check that this happens. Yes participants could in theory use a camera to record what's onscreen but the quality should be awful, using a camera to record any onscreen content is usually very poor quality.

godmum56 · 14/09/2021 16:00

@Coffeetree

Yes of course I realise than anyone can record you anywhere but I'm extending normal human trust to colleagues.
so would they be told that under no circumstances can they make a recording? Will there be notes or screens from the presentation or anything? I would just see it as being of limited use without any kind of backup material, especially if as you say its a complex and arcane subject.
Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 15:56

That gets way too complicated.

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 14/09/2021 15:54

@Coffeetree

I couldn't charge in this format.

Yes, losing control of the material. It's a sensitive subject politically too.

Could the compromise be that you retain the initial recording and right to edit/remove segments, provided that edit does not change the meaning of what other people say?
Coffeetree · 14/09/2021 15:54

Yes of course I realise than anyone can record you anywhere but I'm extending normal human trust to colleagues.

OP posts:
FlumpsAreShit · 14/09/2021 15:52

Do you have a slide deck you could tweak and offer to share instead?

godmum56 · 14/09/2021 15:51

keep in mind that if anybody has got two pieces of kit, they can zoom on one and record the screen on the other and there is zero you can do about it, you won't even know...google recording a zoom meeting without permission

Wilkolampshade · 14/09/2021 15:50

Hmm, just seen your updates.
I think given this you would be well within your rights to refuse, but of course as others have said, I'm not sure there's anyway you can guarantee others won't record you anyway.

Ikeptgoing · 14/09/2021 15:47

@Coffeetree

Yes it's specifically being recorded so that anyone else interested can see it.

It's on a complex and sensitive area of law so yes most likely too boring and arcane for anyone interested but on the other hand could end up being picked up by people who disagree with our work (it happens).

I agree with your reservations

They changed what you agreed to do. You have an informal discussion limited to the audience of those that are attending. Not for recording to be shared to those not attending or other people. Especially as it is a sensitive subject