Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to request a medical appt NOT with 'dave the paramedic?

87 replies

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 14/09/2021 14:09

Our local GP practice has a pretty efficient triage system... either a phone appts, refer onwards or see you face to face...

Rang in this morning as I've found a boob lump, I asked who was triaging... When I found 'Dave the paramedic' was also triaging said I'd be happy anyone other than him... (several m/f GPs and nurses), because the last time I spoke to him by phone he insisted thrush that I had, coudlbt possibly be thrush and was probably an STDGrin, I did a swab and of course it was thrush (which I knew I did have as its exactly the same as the other dozen times I have had it over the last decade....)

OP posts:
mumwon · 14/09/2021 15:43

or sepsis after colonoscopy
said with deep feeling
(we have a dave & he OK with somethings but NOT that)
Thankfully this occurred before covid so the patient who landed up in hospital for 6 weeks on 4 hourly double drugs IV didn't have the additional worry that many have at the moment. We are both grateful that this was the case.
Trouble is -there is simply not enough GP's & they are trying to cover this lack of GP's by using Nurse Practitioners & Paramedics who are both very skilled but whose training will have gaps

FlowersinJune · 14/09/2021 15:39

@SherryPalmer on that logic you shouldn't have junior GP/nurses triaging because they don't have experience either.

Paramedics are trained in basic healthcare in a range of settings. Most do primary care rotations in their degree. They then have additional training in emergency settings.

Triaging is about assessing and get someone the right help: self-help, appointment with nurse/paramedic, GP or onto A and E. A qualified paramedic can do that.

I know the OP has had a bad experience with this person, but their background does not automatically make them inappropriate for the role they are doing.

YouMeandtheSpew · 14/09/2021 15:33

I don’t think that the OP objects to Dave the Paramedic because he’s a paramedic. I think she objects to him because he gave her patronising and inaccurate advice the last time she spoke to him.

Lunde · 14/09/2021 15:33

Well to be fair my GP was convinced that my thrush was an STD as well but the swab came back as ... thrush

SherryPalmer · 14/09/2021 15:29

Has a degree in paramedic science. Spent several years being the first person on scene.

Not likely to have experienced much thrush or breast lumps doing that though is he.

FlowersinJune · 14/09/2021 15:23

YABU to assume just because someone is a paramedic they are not appropriately trained to triage appointments at a GP.

There is a paramedic at our surgery. Has a degree in paramedic science. Spent several years being the first person on scene. I would say as qualified as say a practice nurse to triage. He's moved to the GP as he had a back injury and so can't work in ambulances any more.

LondonJax · 14/09/2021 15:18

@StoneofDestiny

Paramedics are very highly trained - you are lucky to get one
Well they're obviously not if they can't recognise thrush...
pigsDOfly · 14/09/2021 15:15

@maddening

@Fluffypastelslippers

If you'd both read the thread you would see that I pointed out that I was being ironic and my DD is in a similar position with a potentially cancerous mole.

Always helps to read the thread properly.

CheshireChat · 14/09/2021 15:02

An incompetent HCP can be worse than not seeing anyone at all so I'd avoid him as well. And I used to avoid one of the GPs at my former practice as she was a menace and my common sense was safer than her rather dubious medical knowledge.

At my current practice I prefer one of the GPs, mostly for her attitude really, but will see the other one as well who is still perfectly competent and professional.

StoneofDestiny · 14/09/2021 14:57

Paramedics are very highly trained - you are lucky to get one

girlmom21 · 14/09/2021 14:54

@AlbertBridge

of course it was thrush (which I knew I did have as its exactly the same as the other dozen times I have had it over the last decade....)

If you already knew it was thrush, why did you go to the doctor? Why didn't you just get some Canestan from Boots?

If you have recurring thrush you're supposed to see a GP.
Fluffypastelslippers · 14/09/2021 14:54

@maddening

"pigsDOfly

That should be, agree with pp, you're lucky to get an appointment at all."

Talk about a race to the bottom.

Yep. What an awful attitude.

maddening · 14/09/2021 14:53

"pigsDOfly

That should be, agree with pp, you're lucky to get an appointment at all."

Talk about a race to the bottom.

enragedhedgehog · 14/09/2021 14:53

After reading the responses to the woman trying to speak to a GP about an underlying condition and possible menopause be told it's not urgent, to do a,b,c and d even after she said a million times her surgery does not offer a, b ,c and d I'll not be surprised if the replies here don't go the same way and you're told how lucky you're are that Dave is available for you and to ignore any concerns,uncomfortableness or even trauma you might have around Dave telling you the wrong thing again and to stop moaning and just be greatful.

Dave is probably a lovely bloke and will hopefully not tell you you've probably just hit your tit on a door frame and it's just swelling and to wait a few weeks to see if it goes down and instead triages you to a GP appoint for referral. But YANBU to request someone else, esp for something this serious, when he's already made a mistake with you.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 14/09/2021 14:53

@Ozanj

Be grateful you can see someone. My GP surgery advised me to go through our Bupa cover for my boob lump as it would be quicker.
No. That's not acceptable.

The OP has the right to ask to see who she wants, within reason. This putting up with shit service because it's the NHS and shall not ever ne criticised has to stop.

Hope you see someone of your choosing soon, OP.

PermanentTemporary · 14/09/2021 14:52

GP surgeries have been told to employ non-medics as much as possible in order to hide the national lack of doctors. Of course in a lot of areas they can't get paramedics or physios either. Their finding is st risk if they don't do this kind of stuff.

They should supervise the non medical staff or not allow them to triage though.

pigsDOfly · 14/09/2021 14:50

I see several people have reacted to what I posted, as I said I was being ironic.

Of course I don't really think the OP is lucky, or should be grateful to get an appointment.

DearFatties · 14/09/2021 14:50

@marioduck

I disagree that people should be grateful for receiving so-called care from someone ineffectual and patronising who fails to listen to or respect their patient.

If we want a decent NHS then that begins by holding it to the standard everybody deserves, not telling people to shut up and be grateful for shit care.

Absolutely this!!!
MrsAvocet · 14/09/2021 14:49

I don't blame you. There is one member of staff at our surgery that I refuse to see given that they've made 2 serious errors on members of my family in the past. Don't suppose they want to see us either mind you, given the history!
I also try to avoid seeing any of the practice nurses with my son who has a rare condition. They are nice enough, and I'm sure they are very knowledgeable on run of the mill stuff but they can't do anything to help with DS's condition and always end up saying that he needs another appointment to see a doctor. All it does is waste everyone's time and take up an appointment that would be useful for someone else.
Not all HCPs are equally skilled at everything and patients often do know who they are best seeing. An appointment with the wrong person can be as bad as no appointment at all.

pigsDOfly · 14/09/2021 14:48

@growinggreyer

Clearly you missed the point that I was being ironic.

If you'd read my post above that comment you would understand the point I was making.

My DD has a condition that she needs to talk to a nurse about and, as I said, she has been refused an appointment to talk, not to see, a nurse for a prescription.

She now has a mole that could also be potentially cancerous, but again has been told she can't see anyone because it's not an emergency.

Of course the OP shouldn't be fobbed off. Of course she should get the care she needs.

The whole bloody situation is horrendous.

Patients are being ignored and left untreated.

Trust me, I don't actually, think the OP should think herself lucky to get an appointment.

TheOrigRights · 14/09/2021 14:40

When I had a breast lump a few months ago, I completed an e-consult, GP called me the following day, and referred me straight to the breast clinic and they are best placed to check any lumps. I was seen within 2 weeks (and it was nothing sinister).

I don't think Dave the paramedic or indeed any paramedic will be qualified enough to know whether a lump needs to be referred to the breast clinic so best to refer straight away.

growinggreyer · 14/09/2021 14:38

@pigsDOfly

That should be, agree with pp, you're lucky to get an appointment at all.
Not really, the OP is clearly concerned about breast cancer and should be seen by either a Dr or a nurse who can refer directly to oncology. Why is it "lucky" to be given access to medical care?
MissyB1 · 14/09/2021 14:37

@marioduck

I disagree that people should be grateful for receiving so-called care from someone ineffectual and patronising who fails to listen to or respect their patient.

If we want a decent NHS then that begins by holding it to the standard everybody deserves, not telling people to shut up and be grateful for shit care.

This!!!
TooWicked · 14/09/2021 14:35

Ah the old “be grateful, you’re lucky to even be getting an appointment at all”. For a breast lump. Shock

No wonder the NHS is so shite, if these are the standards we are told to hold it to.

RoundRainbow · 14/09/2021 14:31

I don’t blame you! I’ve had a nightmare, I want my implant out the clinic I normally go to we’re rude on the phone and said my GP should do it, call my GP ask for a removal to end up with a phone call appointment over 2 weeks away…I don’t need a phone call I just want my implant out what a waste of time for all involved!