Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to request a medical appt NOT with 'dave the paramedic?

87 replies

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 14/09/2021 14:09

Our local GP practice has a pretty efficient triage system... either a phone appts, refer onwards or see you face to face...

Rang in this morning as I've found a boob lump, I asked who was triaging... When I found 'Dave the paramedic' was also triaging said I'd be happy anyone other than him... (several m/f GPs and nurses), because the last time I spoke to him by phone he insisted thrush that I had, coudlbt possibly be thrush and was probably an STDGrin, I did a swab and of course it was thrush (which I knew I did have as its exactly the same as the other dozen times I have had it over the last decade....)

OP posts:
ilovemydogandmrobama2 · 14/09/2021 17:06

Agree with doing an e consult if possible, but have a chat with Dave as it seems he's the gate keeper and in any case whoever is doing the triage should know that breast lumps deserve a face to face.

Hope you're OK Flowers

Soontobe60 · 14/09/2021 17:03

Nope, sorry - wrong link!!!

Soontobe60 · 14/09/2021 17:02

@TooWicked

Ah the old “be grateful, you’re lucky to even be getting an appointment at all”. For a breast lump. Shock

No wonder the NHS is so shite, if these are the standards we are told to hold it to.

The NHS is currently so ‘shite’ as you put it is in part due to a massive reduction in the number of HCPs now working. Recent letters in the Times from GPs point out the difficulties faced by them in this pandemic. (not sure if the link works!)

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/all-religion-is-a-threat-to-democracy-rs8jddkln?shareToken=db41e79a30d34a8085063ffe2ed6c33f

Poppitt58 · 14/09/2021 17:00

If you already knew it was thrush, why did you go to the doctor? Why didn't you just get some Canestan from Boots?

Maybe she’s entitled to free prescriptions and can’t afford £10 on canestan as she needs to eat and keep her electric on. Plenty of reasons people don’t have a spare tenner.

2bazookas · 14/09/2021 16:57

He's only the phone triage; he will of course refer you to a Dr for physical exam and I really don't think he's going to argue about the need to do that.

ALL that matters is to get your lump examined soon. Good luck.

mylovelydd · 14/09/2021 16:53

Utterly ridiculous that GPs aren't seeing people face to face.
When everything else is more or less back to normal I fail to see why in person appointments seem to be so beyond the bounds of possibility.

Soontobe60 · 14/09/2021 16:51

@AlbertBridge

of course it was thrush (which I knew I did have as its exactly the same as the other dozen times I have had it over the last decade....)

If you already knew it was thrush, why did you go to the doctor? Why didn't you just get some Canestan from Boots?

Boom!
ittakes2 · 14/09/2021 16:45

I would just request a female and that would solve that problem!

MrsAvocet · 14/09/2021 16:39

@mumwon

or sepsis after colonoscopy said with deep feeling (we have a dave & he OK with somethings but NOT that) Thankfully this occurred before covid so the patient who landed up in hospital for 6 weeks on 4 hourly double drugs IV didn't have the additional worry that many have at the moment. We are both grateful that this was the case. Trouble is -there is simply not enough GP's & they are trying to cover this lack of GP's by using Nurse Practitioners & Paramedics who are both very skilled but whose training will have gaps
Sounds similar to my experience too. I don't doubt that many non- doctor HCPs do a great job (and indeed doctors miss things too despite their training) but I worry that a lot of this is papering over the cracks. A non doctor at our GPs misdiagnosed my DH's incarcerated hernia as "a bit of an infection" and told me that my post operative wound that felt like it was about to explode "didn't look too bad" to her, whilst she was literally wiping up the pus that was pouring out of it onto the floor. Fortunately on both occasions we decided to ignore her and turned up to A&E where we were admited for emergency operations. She's probably brilliant at other stuff but clearly didn't have the level of experience/knowledge needed on these occasions and didn't seem to get a lot of supervision. Of course "not all paramedics/nurses/pharmacists etc...." but it is difficult not to lose faith when you have bad experiences (and nothing serms to change as a result.)
starfishmummy · 14/09/2021 16:38

@Mum233

I have requested this before. Mainly as usually when I deal with the paramedic he doesn’t know about MS or the complicated stuff that taking the medicine I do entails and then gets me to cal to make a gp call anyway!
My surgery doesn't have a paramedic but until recently used to always have a trainee doctor, fully qualified but in their final year of GP training. DS is very complicated, so if in doubt they'd ring through to their mentor - the senior partner - who would pop in and we would get two for one!
BungleandGeorge · 14/09/2021 16:26

‘Dave’ won’t just be a paramedic but an advanced practitioner with considerable additional training. Suggesting that you need a swab before treating isn’t inappropriate, people do misdiagnose themselves or have multiple problems eg thrush and bacterial vaginosis which can get into a viscous cycle of reinfection.
I presume if you were sure of the diagnosis and it was a one off you’d have just bought your treatment at a pharmacy? The fact you were ringing the GP suggests it was more complex/ recurrent? What part of the treatment did you think was inappropriate?

Kindnessandcourage · 14/09/2021 16:25

Op, I suggest you request for a female gp or nurse as you clearly are not comfortable with Dave. Also when they ask to send pictures you can deny if it's an intimate area or if u r not comfortable. I have done it for my child and myself too. Gp's have always been quite understanding barring a few odd looks. Hope you get this sorted soon.

Standrewsschool · 14/09/2021 16:22

If you feel unhappy with a clinician, whether a doctor, paramedic or nurse, you can request not to see them.

As it’s a boob lump, would the simplest course of action to request a female gp?

Hope it’s nothing sinister.

kwiksavenofrillsusername · 14/09/2021 16:20

YANBU OP. We have a paramedic at our doctors surgery. To her credit, she was fabulous when I suffered gallstones and immediately knew what it was and what to do. But when I went in there with a nasty ear infection that I was seriously worried about, she was very dismissive and recommended an over the counter product. She eventually took a swab and the GP called me a few days later to apologise and tell me I basically had two different types of ear infection at once and needed some serious prescription stuff. I am guessing he goes over her notes from appointments but still, that was a couple of extra days of agony I could have done without.

SpindleWhorl · 14/09/2021 16:16

@lenaperkins, thank you for taking one for the team and reading that Zoe Williams piece. I got about a paragraph in before I gave up.

SpindleWhorl · 14/09/2021 16:13

All very best wishes, @IamtheDevilsAvocado, and please ignore the arseholes who always come out to skew the replies in threads like this. It's about time @MNHQ had a good look at the Health Misogyny on here.

You are at 86% 'ahead' in your poll, btw.

lenaperkins · 14/09/2021 16:12

Can I just say that we should not have to feel grateful for getting an appointment to see a nurse/ doctor? I appreciate that working at a surgery is not the easiest of jobs, but they are not doing us a favour. In France you don't have to go through receptionists (with no medical qualifications)? You phone up, ask for an appointment, don't have to give details about your vaginal boil (or whatever it is) to the receptionist, they give you appointment. And yes, you pay a small fee to see your doctor, but this is not US style healthcare. They pay more for their health service than we do. There is a real issue in the UK with gatekeeping. I am sure it has caused deaths. Am so narked off after reading Zoe Williams in the Guardian today where she snootily mocked 'the raging anecdotalist' moaning about not being able to get healthcare. Only to produce her own anecdotes about been able to get an appointment. www.theguardian.com/society/2021/sep/14/gps-are-full-of-kindness-and-wisdom-so-why-do-they-face-constant-criticism-

SpeakingFranglais · 14/09/2021 16:10

I wouldn’t want to see Dave the paramedic either, unless I’d. It myself badly then I would be very happy to see him.

EmpathyBypass · 14/09/2021 16:09

[quote pigsDOfly]**@maddening

@Fluffypastelslippers

If you'd both read the thread you would see that I pointed out that I was being ironic and my DD is in a similar position with a potentially cancerous mole.

Always helps to read the thread properly.[/quote]

If you have to explain your sarcasm to posters then it probably hasn't worked...

SpindleWhorl · 14/09/2021 16:08

Oh here we go, another thread full of Health Misogyny in AIBU.

EmpathyBypass · 14/09/2021 16:08

@pigsDOfly

That should be, agree with pp, you're lucky to get an appointment at all.

Really?

That's how we support posters who find breast lumps?

maddening · 14/09/2021 16:01

"PigsDOfly

@maddening

@Fluffypastelslippers

If you'd both read the thread you would see that I pointed out that I was being ironic and my DD is in a similar position with a potentially cancerous mole.

Always helps to read the thread properly."

Sorry about your dd but:

A-whilst reading posts I doubt many people are sitting there taking notes as to which posts you have previously made. Eg I only go back looking at names of posters when someone else has quoted them. Your posts are not colour coded and they are not spoken with your voice, when you post don't assume that readers are particularly noting all your previous posts. You need to link them or make reference I'd your post is not in isolation - eg you might write "as per my previous post" or quote it.

B-if your post is meant to be sarcastic that does not come across

C - we are clearly on the same side, no need for the snippy tone thanks.

Hope you dds condition is sorted out soon x

B1rthis · 14/09/2021 15:55

Has Dave the triage got experience in breast lumps including what the difference between cysts, possible cancer mastitis etc is? I would happier go through breast cancer org for advice than Dave the para.

bloodywhitecat · 14/09/2021 15:53

I think it is reasonable to make that request if you don't feel confident with Dave. There is a GP I avoid at our surgery after he gave me the wrong advice for dealing with croup then, more seriously, handled DH's sudden onset, painless jaundice as a non-issue.

mumwon · 14/09/2021 15:44

Oh & pharmacists too