Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my DH is lazy WRT his family and I shouldn't feel guilty?

116 replies

ILoveAutumnShowers · 14/09/2021 12:33

A couple of years ago I decided to take a step back from my in-laws. Since I met them 28 years ago they, well MIL mostly and they do what she says, have been very rude and unkind to me. My MIL has constantly told me I am not part of the family, despite being the mother of her only DGC, and has gone out of her way to openly put me down in front of others. She once told me that it doesn't matter what I do, say, or look like because I am nothing to do with her or her family and it won't reflect on her, as everyone knows I am a nobody. One of the reasons why she does this is because she seems to see me as a serious threat to her and her DD's for some reason, which I really don't get.

Luckily I have a wonderful, loving and confidence boosting family of my own so I have not had to revert to counselling as a result Hmm.

After quite a few years of this and trying to get her onside, she'll like me when she gets to know me, etc. I gave up. I have taken small steps back over the years, but about 2 years ago I just decided that I can't be arsed with this anyone and I took league boots steps back. So now I facilitate nothing, I refuse to cancel what I am doing if they want to meet up, I don't buy them presents, I don't do their cards and I no longer facilitate meet-ups or days out or phone calls. I am not rude or nasty, I just resigned from the wifey work. After all, I am not family and I am crap at everything, right?

The AIBU is that my DH does nothing. He doesn't buy cards, presents, etc. He waits for me to arrange Sunday lunches and I don't. He waits for me to offer to host Christmas and Easter etc. and I don't. As a result, we have not seen his sisters for 18 months. That is fine by me, but there is fallout from it. MIL is not happy she rarely sees us gets the opportunity to lay into me, upset if she doesn't get a card and last Christmas she was really upset because I usually buy really thoughtful Christmas presents and do a stocking for everyone, but she asked for some towels and that is what she got, some towels in a plastic bag.

So, AIBU to think that my DH is really lazy when it comes to his family and it is not my problem. I know I shouldn't give a shit, but I am pretty sure that "it's all my fault" and they are blaming me and for some strange reason I feel guilty for treating someone like this. However, I was a nice DIL and SIL and they just threw it back in my face.

FYI my DH also does NOTHING for my family. In fact, I think he may recognise my mum and dad if they walked past him in the street, but they wouldn't recognise anyone else. He hasn't seen my brother, who lives 15 miles away from us, for 5 years.

OP posts:
SpiderinaWingMirror · 14/09/2021 13:39

I did the same with my bil and sil. (Dhs brother). 15 years and counting

Rumplestrumpet · 14/09/2021 13:39

YABU to give them a second thought. Don't expect a card, don't send them cards, and leave it up to DH to manage his own relationship with them.

Don't spend energy thinking about them and certainly don't go and visit them. I can understand why you did make an effort while the kids were young but really you shouldn't be hurting yourself over them any longer.

I do think it's poor of your husband not to stand up for you but family dynamics can be very strange and hard to turn around.

Move on, enjoy spending your bday with people who do care for you and don't you dare feel guilty about cutting them out - MN opinion has been unanimous!

BlackIsQueen · 14/09/2021 13:33

Sounds like your kids have the measure of the in laws, op. Chuck the guilt in the fuck it bucket and concentrate on the people who love you.

PercyPiginaWig · 14/09/2021 13:29

I want to stop feeling guilty, but I do. I don't think you should treat your MIL like this, but honestly, some of the things she has said to me are just cruel.

Well I don't think you should treat your DIL like shit but she does, so you can let go of that guilt.

Your DH should have stepped in a long long time ago.

DH and I are both fairly low contact with his family, and we back each other up.
I wouldn't facilitate anything for your DH, if he doesn't care why should you.

Abouttoblow · 14/09/2021 13:28

Step back completely and don't engage. At all. Tell your DH if they are commenting on you that you don't want to know. Start thinking that their lack of interest in your birthday means you can have a lovely day without even thinking about them. Don't feel guilty, feel free of their toxicity.

DomPom47 · 14/09/2021 13:19

Well done to you for saying you will step back and let your husband lead and sticking to your guns. No point doing all those lovely thoughtful things like presents and stockings if his family can’t be decent towards you and respectful. For your birthday I would have an extra sweet or alcoholic treat so eat or drink when you think of their negativity. Happy birthday in advance !

Holly60 · 14/09/2021 13:19

@Dozer

YANBU.

Wouldn’t have been unreasonable to stop the ‘wifework’ even if your in laws were perfect!

Your DH’s family: his relationships to manage.

Has HE argued or implied that you should have continued to do X, Y and Z for him/his family? If so, would address that with him.

What has he decided as regards his family relationships?

Wouldn’t worry about what the in laws think of you.

But of course if your in-laws are perfect, then it’s not really wide-work, it’s just buying presents and organising get togethers with people you like.

That is what it’s always been like with my in-laws- I’ve bought nice presents for my MIL because I love her and she’s always done the same for me.

I totally agree there is no duty towards your in-laws. If they are unpleasant to you, there is no obligation to go the extra mile for them.

whynotwhatknot · 14/09/2021 13:18

I honestly dont know why youve bothered for so long-even dc can see how badly they treat you

Let him get on with it if they dont get presents refer them to their relative which as theyve made clear isnt you

BronwenFrideswide · 14/09/2021 13:16

The reason I posted here is that it is my birthday next week and I end up getting stressed out about it because I know I will not get a card and it kind of spoils it for me that someone is actively being PA towards me on my one fucking day I get to have a nice time IYSWIM. I am a bit sensitive!

Don't let it spoil your day, the sentiments in the card wouldn't be genuine even if they bothered to send one. Enjoy the cards you will get from people who do actually value you.

I don't think my DC are going to join in on going up to see them sitting on their sofa for 6 hours whilst MIL talks about herself and it will just be me and DH and what I want to do now is to be able to say to my DH that Ia m busy and he should go see HIS parents on his own, as I do.

Don't go to their house at all, why would you? They don't want you there. Your children have seen through them, take your cue from your children they don't think their mother should be treated so badly so don't subject yourself to it.

Please stop feeling guilty, you've done all you can they've thrown it in your face, do nothing for them at all - no cards, presents, etc., don't speak to them or visit them, don't waste your precious time on people who are not worthy of it.

Your husband's relationship with his parents is his to manage.

00100001 · 14/09/2021 13:13

Don't go on the next visit for her Ladyships birthday.

DH can sort himself out.

DefineHappy · 14/09/2021 13:11

Would you let your family (parents, any siblings, etc) treat your husband the way his family have treated you? Of course you wouldn’t, as it is disgusting and cruel.

Why does your DH even have contact with them if they treated you this way? The first time they said something so callous and spiteful as “you aren’t family”, would have been the last time I had anything to do with them at all.

Your guilt is wasted on them - do you imagine they have felt one drop of guilt for all the hatred and toxic cruelty they have dumped on you?

Do not waste another second of your life even thinking about them, let alone feeling guilty. You deserve better.

Feedingthebirds1 · 14/09/2021 13:07

FYI my DH also does NOTHING for my family. In fact, I think he may recognise my mum and dad if they walked past him in the street, but they wouldn't recognise anyone else. He hasn't seen my brother, who lives 15 miles away from us, for 5 years.

I'd be looking sideways at the DH too. It sounds like he's all me, me, me. You are being totally reasonable to say no more when it comes to his family. Why should you do more for his than he does for yours? You wouldn't BU to have stopped doing things for them even without what you said about DH and your family, but nah. Leave him to it. It sounds like he and his family deserve each other.

I'm guessing he never, ever stood up to his mother when she was belittling you.

dayslikethese1 · 14/09/2021 13:05

Sounds like the DH is avoiding them too (don't blame him from what OP has said they're like)

Chikapu · 14/09/2021 13:04

What does your husband do when his family are saying things like that to you? If he doesn't very actively tell them to STFU then I'd be having a problem with him as well.

girlmom21 · 14/09/2021 13:02

You don't need to have anything to do with them so have absolutely no reason to feel guilty.

Your DH sounds pretty useless if he makes no effort with your family either.

What's he like with you and the kids?

ILoveAutumnShowers · 14/09/2021 13:00

No we don't spend my birthday with MIL. She just doesn't acknowledge it, but makes a massive fuss of everyone else's.

They all actively go out of their way to tell me I am not family.

For example. My MIL was really angry that her relatives saw things on my Facebook that she doesn't know about. Some of her nice relatives have FB friended me, and I accepted. However, MIL and SIL's do not want me included in their social media as, and i quote, I am "not family, not blood. I am nothing to them so why would I be on their SM?"

When I was younger I used to get really confused about the stuff they said and there was a lot of gas lighting. So, whenever I pulled them up I was told that I was twisting their words and trying to cause trouble. Now I don't argue. I just can't be arsed. I have reached indifference. I just still feel guilty and I wish I didn't. I don't treat anyone else like this in my life.

OP posts:
MyCatEatsPrawnCrackers · 14/09/2021 12:59

Why are you going to see them on your birthday?

LittleOwl153 · 14/09/2021 12:56

Time to just expunge them from your life. That way you won't need to get upset /disappointed. Just decide they are no longer part of your life. Remove yourself from any conversation about them.

LittleOwl153 · 14/09/2021 12:55

I think it is reasonable to give up visiting someone who thinks you are a nobody . I especially wouldn't want to sit there for 6hours (or do the required travel that implies!) Heck 2hr visits to my MIL were enough and she was pleasant and made an effort!!

Definitely do not do this on your birthday - of course you have other plans.

forrestgreen · 14/09/2021 12:54

He has a crap family that he can't be arsed with. That's ok, and you definitely don't have to do it instead.
But does he put effort in for your birthday?? And don't expect a card off the il's and you won't be disappointed

CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson · 14/09/2021 12:50

Cross posted...

Sorry, the plan for your birthday is that you and your dh visit your MIL???? FUCK. THAT.

If your dh chooses this on your birthday you have most definitely got a DH problem

CMOTDibbler · 14/09/2021 12:48

She told you that you aren't, and will never be, part of the family right? So all you are doing is going with what she said and behaving like it. Because you wouldn't do all that stuff for random people that don't even like you would you?
And if your dh doesn't like them enough to want to do cards/presents etc, then thats his choice to rightfully make to not be that bothered about people who are nasty to someone he loves.
So put that woman guilt in the F**k it bucket and move on

burritofan · 14/09/2021 12:48

I don't think you should treat your MIL like this
Stop thinking of her as your MIL and start thinking of her as “that rude cunt parent of my lazy-as-fuck husband”.

dayslikethese1 · 14/09/2021 12:48

Are they that horrible to everyone who joins their family? Sound like weird people. Definitely don't do the wife work, your DH can if he wants to.

LittleOwl153 · 14/09/2021 12:48

It seems a very odd way to live to me. But as you say it is entirely of her own making. I do t think you should feel guilty for leaving DHs family to DH to organise - independently of their opinion of you, so given their opinion it just confirms the thought really.

Maybe she'll come to the realisation that you are needed - but maybe she won't. But even if she does you don't need to respond.

She once told me that it doesn't matter what I do, say, or look like because I am nothing to do with her or her family and it won't reflect on her

You have your answer there... it doesn't matter what you do. Therefore maybe she will start to see your DH as useless?

How do your DC handle that side of the family. I'm assuming they are perhaps grown up now?