Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my DH is lazy WRT his family and I shouldn't feel guilty?

116 replies

ILoveAutumnShowers · 14/09/2021 12:33

A couple of years ago I decided to take a step back from my in-laws. Since I met them 28 years ago they, well MIL mostly and they do what she says, have been very rude and unkind to me. My MIL has constantly told me I am not part of the family, despite being the mother of her only DGC, and has gone out of her way to openly put me down in front of others. She once told me that it doesn't matter what I do, say, or look like because I am nothing to do with her or her family and it won't reflect on her, as everyone knows I am a nobody. One of the reasons why she does this is because she seems to see me as a serious threat to her and her DD's for some reason, which I really don't get.

Luckily I have a wonderful, loving and confidence boosting family of my own so I have not had to revert to counselling as a result Hmm.

After quite a few years of this and trying to get her onside, she'll like me when she gets to know me, etc. I gave up. I have taken small steps back over the years, but about 2 years ago I just decided that I can't be arsed with this anyone and I took league boots steps back. So now I facilitate nothing, I refuse to cancel what I am doing if they want to meet up, I don't buy them presents, I don't do their cards and I no longer facilitate meet-ups or days out or phone calls. I am not rude or nasty, I just resigned from the wifey work. After all, I am not family and I am crap at everything, right?

The AIBU is that my DH does nothing. He doesn't buy cards, presents, etc. He waits for me to arrange Sunday lunches and I don't. He waits for me to offer to host Christmas and Easter etc. and I don't. As a result, we have not seen his sisters for 18 months. That is fine by me, but there is fallout from it. MIL is not happy she rarely sees us gets the opportunity to lay into me, upset if she doesn't get a card and last Christmas she was really upset because I usually buy really thoughtful Christmas presents and do a stocking for everyone, but she asked for some towels and that is what she got, some towels in a plastic bag.

So, AIBU to think that my DH is really lazy when it comes to his family and it is not my problem. I know I shouldn't give a shit, but I am pretty sure that "it's all my fault" and they are blaming me and for some strange reason I feel guilty for treating someone like this. However, I was a nice DIL and SIL and they just threw it back in my face.

FYI my DH also does NOTHING for my family. In fact, I think he may recognise my mum and dad if they walked past him in the street, but they wouldn't recognise anyone else. He hasn't seen my brother, who lives 15 miles away from us, for 5 years.

OP posts:
Djifunrsn · 14/09/2021 17:57

It sounds like a win-win. You don’t need to buy/organise anything for them and your dh can’t be bothered.

Why ever would you go and see them? Just say, sorry dh, I’ve decided not to visit your parents anymore because they aren’t nice to me. Please go without me.

WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld · 14/09/2021 17:51

Yabu to visit at all after the way they have spoken to you. Don't go even if invited
Let DH do it all. They have made their feelings clear why would you put yourself through it?

BananaPB · 14/09/2021 17:48

On a positive note though, I am not doing anything for them at all. I just have the feelings to work on.

Why are you going to visit MIL then? Surely you have better things to do than visit someone who thinks so little of you ?

BronwenFrideswide · 14/09/2021 17:35

I know I have not reached indifference, where I want to be. On a positive note though, I am not doing anything for them at all. I just have the feelings to work on.

Good to hear you are not doing anything for them at all, you don't need to see them or interact with them in any way they are not worth your time.

They are also not worth you spending anytime thinking about them, they really are not, work on those feelings remember you didn't cause this, you are not responsible for it, you've nothing to feel guilty about, don't give them another thought, please. They are reaping what they have sown, I hope they enjoy it.

AryaStarkWolf · 14/09/2021 17:23

Actually it's good he doesn't buy them anything, they don't deserve it after how they treat you. I wouldn't have contact with my own family if they treated my husband so horribly for no reason. Why are you worrying about them at all?

Hopdathelf · 14/09/2021 17:21

Your MIL’s unpleasantness to you is a red herring. He’s an adult and should be sorting out stuff to do with his side of the family regardless of your relationship with them. Otherwise it’s just wife work.

thelastgoldeneagle · 14/09/2021 17:20

You're a saint for putting up with it for 28 years, and your H needs to step up. His family sounds horrific. Are they nice to him?

He should have stood up for you in the past. Shame he didn't, but I can understand the FOG. Has he had counselling?

Keep going as you are, and don't feel guilty! A, why should you do things for your ILs when your h does nothing for yours? And B, they just don't deserve it. Their behaviour means they don't deserve anything at all from you - not just gifts but any kindness or consideration.

Morechocolatethanbarbara · 14/09/2021 17:15

Yes you have a lazy DH and I think it's pretty safe to presume it's down to a combination of bad parenting (he clearly wasn't raised to be a considerate son) and then you taking over the present buying/event organising for so long (as he wasn't stepping up) so him just not thinking about it.

Now you have (quite rightly) stepped back, it's up to him to step forward and if he doesn't then it's really not your problem.

If I were you I would revel in it, rather than feel bad and agree with any detrimental comments they may make about the poor gifts etc.

"Yes, DH is terrible at present buying and card sending, but it's a family trait, so what can you do?" Shrug your shoulders and move on.

ILoveAutumnShowers · 14/09/2021 17:13

Yes, they said they would like some towels and DH bought some crappy ones and they were handed over in the bag with all the prices on. They usually get a lot more gifts and nice things in a stocking, but no more.

I usually buy my family thoughtful gifts and do a stocking. So, e.g. my Dad may get some nice smellies, some small golf items, a book, and chocolates, and my DH will ask why I didn't buy 2 of them so his mum and dad had the same. It was quite hard to say no to that and also a lot of our earlier years as parents, he was the main breadwinner and paying for my parent's Christmas presents so I felt I couldn't say "get your own".

It is very different now.

I know I have not reached indifference, where I want to be. On a positive note though, I am not doing anything for them at all. I just have the feelings to work on.

OP posts:
GoWalkabout · 14/09/2021 16:56

I presumed that dh bought the towels?

Tilly18101 · 14/09/2021 16:29

Oh god OP, she sounds awful and you did well to put up with that for 28 years. I know I certainly wouldn’t (or couldn’t!)

We have a unwritten rule in our house, I organise my family including visits, gifts etc and he does his. If he forgets that’s his fault not mine! Doesn’t matter who it is.

We see my family more as I organise it, DH does organise with his but definitely not as much so we see them less. He has the same opportunity as I, I do think DH’s are a little lazy but it’s not malicious they just don’t think the same way we do int erma of effort and organisation!

noirchatsdeux · 14/09/2021 16:16

As someone who has similar problems with her FIL (I call him that for the sake of brevity, we aren't married but have been together 12 years) I can understand why you still feel guilty...we are constantly bombarded in the media how family relationships 'should' be and if they aren't...that can trigger the guilt.

I did much the same as you after FIL thought he could tell my partner, that my behaviour at a family gathering (wasn't even his family, but my MIL's) was 'rude'...what had I done? Apparently it was because I didn't stay up all night getting drunk ...the excuse that I went to bed at midnight because I was ill wasn't 'good enough' - even though it turned out that I had double pneumonia and ended up in hospital 2 days later... He told my partner off afterwards like we were a pair of 12 year olds - I was 42 at the time...

That was the final straw for me. I told my partner that I wouldn't take that type of bullshit from my own parents, so I definitely wasn't going to take it from his! I've not seen them now in 7 years. Most of the time I couldn't care less, I live 200 miles away and we don't have children. I have no family in the UK so sometimes (Christmas is a bugger for this) I do feel sad that my 'in laws' are such horrible people...luckily my partner is totally on my side and knows that his father's behaviour towards me has been totally unacceptable.

As others have said, one of the great things about being an adult is that you don't have to have a familiar relationship with ANYONE you don't want to.

rogueone · 14/09/2021 15:59

So you havent withdrawn completely if you still bought your MIL towels for xmas. You need to decide to back off completely and leave all his family stuff to him or dont. Going from buying nice presents and doing stockings to a pack of towels in a plastic bag is a statement isnt it. I would have rather gone from nice presents to nothing so when they complain you direct them to your DH. It sounds like you have just backed off but not had a conversation about what that means with your DH and doing shitty presents is a bit passive aggressive. Not a chance in hell would i be buying anything or doing anything for inlaws who treated me the way they are treating you. Your guilt is not yours to own...redirect your anger to your DH who has clearly enables his family nasty behaviour towards you for years

workwoes123 · 14/09/2021 15:47

I think you are still quite far from indifference: you wouldn’t feel guilty about this if you were indifferent.

I don’t think you’ve got a DH problem - he actually sounds more indifferent than you do!

Tbh I think you need to explore why you have such a great desire to please or placate such awkward people who clearly do not care about you? Where is that coming from?

Stop analysing your MILs behaviour and take a look at your own: that’s the bit you have some control over.

DameFanny · 14/09/2021 15:42

'You're both as bad as each other' is the sort of thing people say when they don't want to look at the actual dynamics going on. It's like 'it takes two to have a falling out' which is also bollocks - in situations like these it's one person being actively nasty, and one wondering what the fuck just happened.

Maybe your H doesn't want to recognise what a horrorshow his family is because he's also a victim, maybe he just doesn't care enough, who knows. It doesn't actually matter right now, because the important thing right now is you getting free from any obligation to your ILs, and you'll need to understand there's no help right now from your H.

But. You also don't need any permission from your H either. You are absolutely allowed to tell him right now you can't see your ILs next week - maybe you're planning a treat for your birthday, maybe you're planning nothing at all. But you're allowed to not spend precious time with people that don't like you. And you don't need to justify it. H might try to change your mind - probably will - but you don't even need to persuade him to agree with you, You. Can. Just. Not. Go. And nothing bad will happen. Well, nothing worse than being stuck in a room with people who actively dislike you for hours on end anyway...

LowlandLucky · 14/09/2021 15:23

Your Husband obviously takes after his Mother.

Artdecolover · 14/09/2021 15:20

I hear you op
Just done similar myself after 26 years
It took mil spouting her bigoted bullshit at my child's birthday that finally made the scales fall from my eyes
She really messed up. She usually saves such comments for when we are alone.
Witnesses make things more complicated 😀
It's so great! I should have done it years ago years ago like you my kids are older now so it's easier.
Dh is worried about Xmas (?) but I'm not
They can see dh and the dc but I'm not playing happy families.

billy1966 · 14/09/2021 15:10

You know gaslighting is abusive OP?

So you have a horrible abusive husband too?

You poor woman surrounded by that awful shower.

Again, get counselling and have nothing to do with them.

Have a hard look at that husband of yours, he sounds awful.

Flowers
Dozer · 14/09/2021 15:07

Also, ditch the internalised sexist stereotyping (‘bitch’, assumption that changing things / setting some boundaries after many years of shit treatment by the in laws and poor response from your H makes you somehow unreasonable).

BeanyBops · 14/09/2021 15:05

You are acting appropriately by cutting them out but I understand it isnt nice knowing there are people out there who have it out for you. I'm sorry your DH didn't do more to support you, he should have done a lot more.

Have you heard about neural pathways? I'm going to butcher this explanation probably but basically our brain has habitual thoughts and feelings that are like reflex actions on response to a stimulus. This is the pathway. Over the years it's possible you have created a neural pathway that says 'MIL is upset, i have done something wrong, her upset is my fault' and once you have that pathway it becomes your default response.

You CAN change your neural pathways to more appropriate responses like 'MIL is upset, and that is not my problem, I won't let it bother me' by spotting the thinking and over-writing it with your new thought. Takes a bit of practise but you can get there. I think this is what you need to do.

Dozer · 14/09/2021 15:05

So this IS at least partly a DH problem. ‘You’re as bad as each other’ Angry

Agree with PPs that you’re not - yet - ‘indifferent’, eg the guilt. Sounds like your DC are indifferent, perhaps take a leaf out of their book!

IrisLilyRose · 14/09/2021 14:54

Look at it that you are withdrawing not "plotting" or anything so dramatic.

You are looking after yourself which is as important as looking after other people. One of the least egotistical people in my life gave the advice: "put yourself first!" I think they had learned the hard way.

randomlyLostInWales · 14/09/2021 14:49

I think you just have to accept your place is in the wrong - they will never be happy and try and avoid thinking about them much and ditch the guilt.

I stepped back from wifework when IL were being a bloody pain with young kids - DH did step up though and has little to do with my family.

27 years I still get your not our family mainly now from FIL - anything thought to be suggested or coming from me is strongly resisted. We can manage to be polite to each other when we see and the are decent GP to the kids. I don't like feeling pushed out my own family but as the kids get older having less and less to do with them actually appeals.

Doomscrolling · 14/09/2021 14:46

Aw feck, sorry about the nonsense cut and past in the final paragraph! Phone and I are Not Getting On today.

Final paragraph:

FWIW, I did this about 15 years ago when MIL was being rude. I wasn’t rude or unkind, I just stopped doing the running. It didn’t take long for her to realise that left to himself, her son almost never got in touch, arranged visits, sent updates about the grandchildren. So perhaps good relations with her DIL was smart…

ILoveAutumnShowers · 14/09/2021 14:44

To answer a few questions.

Mil not from different culture.

DH is generallyConfused a good husband and father. However he is scared of his mum snd has FOG. He’s gaslighted me in the past over her too. Told me she doesn’t really mean it, it came out wrong, must have misheard her snd my favourite, we are both as bad as each other. Confused

It was quite hard to stand up to her when she, FIL, SIL’s are telling you that it’s you with the problem, snd then my DH not backing me up. Now I’m older I know it’s them and not me. I did tell them this to their faces but it was again met with gaslighting so now I just don’t bother. I’ve taken some steps back and I now want to take more steps back but it still feels uncomfortable. I’ve never actively plotted against someone. I don’t have the bitch gene. I’m too bloody nice for my own good.

OP posts: