Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I HATE paying Council Tax. It's the bill I hate the most.

391 replies

flashbac · 14/09/2021 09:25

Council Tax is regressive and unfair.

It takes more money from lower income individuals.

It has no link to the actual value of a property.

In addition to linking council tax to value, the bands also need to increase in range in order to reflect the vast difference in property values.

How can it be right that a million pound property in Westminster is the same or (often lower) CT rate than a 2 up, 2 down house in Yorkshire?

OP posts:
longerevenings · 14/09/2021 14:57

We are in a part of the USA with very high property taxes.
Tenants don't pay them but they push up the cost of renting significantly.

Spidey66 · 14/09/2021 14:53

That's what happens in a welfare state, though.

Why should he pay more tax and NI, he's not claiming benefits and is unlikely to use the NHS.

I don't have kids, should I opt out of certain taxes etc on the grounds that I'm not using schools? No of course not. The UK is a welfare state. Charlie and Maggie are poorer as a result of the Poll Tax, Lord Muck is richer.

Dbank · 14/09/2021 14:47

So why should Lord Muck pay more, he's using less council resources than Charlie and Maggie?

Is it just because he's got more money?

Spidey66 · 14/09/2021 14:41

@BrendaBubbles

Council tax is poll tax. Except it’s even higher but you get to divide it up amongst the adults in a household. Why people were so easily fooled is beyond me - the poll tax seemed fairer than this.
There is no way the poll tax was a fair tax.

Lets take Westminster as an example, seeing as they have been used a lot.....

Lats take Lord Muck living in his £3million, 6 bed/3 bath home in Belgravia, who has thousands coming in each month, a nifty sports car, works of art. Under the poll tax he would only pay say £50 a month. But compare him with Charlie and Maggie in their 1 bed council flat on the Mozart Estate. Charlie's a binman and Maggie works part time in the Coop. Combined income of say £1500 a month. They have to pay £50 each in poll tax, so TWICE what Lord Muck does.

OK so Charlie and Maggie may need more in terms of state education for their kids, social care as they get older etc, but that's what happens in a welfare state.

Spidey66 · 14/09/2021 14:32

@GivenUpEntirely
I was definitely only joking, of course I realise the water has to be treated and effectively sent to our taps!!

Though on a day like today when it doesn't stop raining, I do wonder....Wink

Spidey66 · 14/09/2021 14:29

[quote toconclude]@Spidey66
Please tell me you are joking and do not mean you are so ignorant as not to understand that your water supply is so very much more than what ' fell out of the sky'?Shock[/quote]
Yes I was joking!!!!

Pissinthepottyplease · 14/09/2021 14:07

@wedwewerpink

Do you mind me asking What is council tax for?? I'm not in the U.K.
The vast majority is social care so carers for elderly, respite care for disabled children, children who are in the care system, social services etc

There is a breakdown
www.local.gov.uk/sites/default/files/documents/A4%20STATIC%20IMAGE_04_1.pdf

GivenUpEntirely · 14/09/2021 14:00

@Spidey66

I hate the water rates. I mean I pay it and everything but I resent paying for something that falls from the sky.

I live in a flat. If it wasn't the fact the freeholders have not requested the ground rent for the past 20 years, I'd resent paying that. It's such an archaic system. As it is I'm resenting the thought it's going to cost me mega £££ to sort the lease out if I ever want to sell my flat.

To be fair you don't have to pay water rates. You're perfectly welcome to collect your own rain water to use and dispose of excess rain water from your premises and treat your own sewage. If you can prove to the water company you're doing all this they'll close your account.

Water companies don't charge for "something that falls from the sky" they charge for collection, storage, treatment and transport of clean safe water to your home. They then charge for sewerage to be taken from your home and made safe for the environment again.

This is always one of the most puerile "I don't want to pay" statements and really winds me up.

Dreamstate · 14/09/2021 13:22

Excellent post.

annacondom · 14/09/2021 13:19

[quote emmathedilemma]@annacondom unless you live in Scotland that's not covered by council tax, water/sewage charges are paid additionally to the water company. The council is only responsible for road drainage.[/quote]
Yes, they are separate charges. I was replying to the comment about hating to pay for water as it falls from the sky. Sorry, should have clarified.

copernicium · 14/09/2021 13:03

I think it's flawed, and you'll never get a perfect system. Obviously you need some taxation to pay for the services.

I think what makes people resent it is related to the services provided. We had a 5% rise in April and our services are shocking. So far refuse collection has been cancelled several times this year. There are no places in local schools, some children have to catch three buses to get to school. The roads are a mess with potholes - you can see the old cobbles in a lot of the roads. The pavement outside my house is unsafe, and the council quoted me £2k if I wanted it fixing. Local parks are old and ruined, and they have recently started charging £3 to park there. The town centre is run down and most shops are now boarded up, as rent was extortionate and parking £1.60/hr. Police are overstretched and often don't come out.

I think people wouldn't mind paying if their city benefitted from it.

Whammyyammy · 14/09/2021 12:59

A local market town near me protested to get one hours free parking there, which they won, was 60p for an hour

The following year, the council increases council tax to cover this loss. A lot of residents are now complaining that they are paying for the free parking for people that don't live in thst Town.
Council tax doesn't seem fair, but its locally set due to the councils expenditure

Lockdownbear · 14/09/2021 12:55

@TheYearOfSmallThings

I pay more for my 3 bed detached than Buckingham Palace does

Does anyone know how much CT they pay? If I'm paying more I want to have a framed cross stitch of the quote above hanging in my hall!

I bet Buckingham Palace doesn't pay CT but pays business rates instead, since huge chunks of it are offices and really it's a state owned entertainment venue. Is it classed as a Benefit in Kind for HMQ to live in it 🤔
delilahbucket · 14/09/2021 12:54

I wouldn't mind if our council actually spent money wisely. Instead they piss it up against the wall and everything has gone to shit. There's a road near us, a main route into a town, that has been closed for coming up to two years, because there is a crack down the middle of it. It has taken until now for works to commence, and apparently they will take another couple of years. They were warned about the ground shifting under the road for many years prior, but did nothing until the road wasn't safe to drive on. That is just the beginning of their failings. Pot hole repairs, if you're lucky to get them, they do have a job, and within a few months it needs doing again. They shut our recycling and rubbish centre for absolutely no reason during Covid and threatened to shut it permanently, while fly tipping galore suddenly became an issue.
To top it all off, we pay extra for a parish council that we had no choice in getting. So far, in two years, they've painted some railings. They got ripped into when they spent several hundred pounds on USB sticks, and some socks 🤷

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 12:53

Then you have them and Cllrs victim blaming poor people who can't afford the cost or can't get to the dump during a pandemic (what do they expect old Bill who lives alone and has been given 18 months to live to do with his broken bike nobody wants, he can't bring it to the dump, he hasn't the money to pay to have it taken away, he has no PC to book a dump spot and is proud doesn't like to bother others - or Mrs Hancock, she has a gaggle of children to care for, her husband has gone off with his mistress, she has long covid and can just about care for herself and the children if she says she is struggling she will have the abilest sexist bully staff at the children's school trying to wreck life further, she will loose residency to Mr Hancocks Mother because nobody else will have the children, MIL will make everyone's life a misery, her family and friends are selfish, she was always the one to help them and they will not help in return, she can't work, Mr Hancock will not pay maintenance, she can't bring that rug the dog ruined to the dump so it is sat outside - invented scinario to show not everyone with stuff outside is feckless) and them lecturing people on environmental matters, when most of them are the biggest hypocrites like Private jet Harry.

Free ? We have to pay an extra charge for the council to collect bulky items.

Cockle1234 · 14/09/2021 12:52

@CaptainMarvelous

My Band D property in a market town in the North West is just over £2000 a year.

In Kensington a Band D is £1313.

Council Tax is grossly unfair and regressive.

There's only not many band D properties in Kensington, the bulk of properties are in G and H. Whereas Halton as an example has only a handful of G and H with the bulk being in A. A band D in the North West will be equal to a H in Kensington value wise if you picked it up and dropped it in there - and would cost you £2627.
Blossomtoes · 14/09/2021 12:43

[quote zoemum2006]@Blossomtoes

I know what you mean but they won't put me in prison if I don't buy petrol. This is a direct tax.[/quote]
The principle is exactly the same. Everything we buy apart from food has an element of tax and we pay it on already taxed income. We’d all be rolling in it if tax was applied only once. And we’d have no public services.

Lonelylooloo · 14/09/2021 12:43

There is no reason for CT to be linked to value, other than the ‘ooh they have money let’s charge them even more!’ attitude which isn’t any better than the ‘poor people shouldn’t have kids they can’t afford’ attitude.

Realistically council tax should be reflective of the size of property and number of occupants. If your house is massive it takes more time and man power to put it out if it’s on fire. If you have more occupants you produce more rubbish. If you have kids you use schools.

A lot of things people think are ‘free’ and they’re just entitled to are actually paid for by council tax. Why should some rich Chinese investor owner of a 600sqft £5m London flat, who only spends 4 weeks of the year in this country, pay a massive amount of council tax?

I think it sucks for local families who can’t afford houses that investors buy them and only spend 4 weeks of a year in them but that’s a totally different matter. Not sure many low income families would be buying £5m London flats either way!

roarfeckingroarr · 14/09/2021 12:43

@zoemum2006 like inheritance tax

Belladonna12 · 14/09/2021 12:42

@Zeal

You do realise that if the landlord pays they pass on the cost via rent don't you?

Then the tenant passes it on in the form of increasing cost of housing benefits.

Which the government passes on to landlords in the form of increased taxation.

There have been at least 15 subtle tax increases on property investors in the last 10 years. There will be inevitably be more if we have generations who cannot get on the housing ladder. Absolutely inevitable.

Not sure what your point is. I was commenting on a post stating that it is unfair that tennats should pay as in other countries landlords do. My point was that tenants would pay either way as the landlord will add the cost to rent.
zoemum2006 · 14/09/2021 12:38

@Blossomtoes

I know what you mean but they won't put me in prison if I don't buy petrol. This is a direct tax.

MaryMcCarthy · 14/09/2021 12:37

*What I hate about council tax is that it's taken from your already taxed income!

So it's double taxation.*

You have to pay VAT when you buy things too! That's triple taxation!

Not really. These are separate, distinct taxes. This is how the world works. It's how we pay for things such as roads, police and schools.

Blossomtoes · 14/09/2021 12:36

@zoemum2006

What I hate about council tax is that it's taken from your already taxed income!

So it's double taxation.

Every penny is taxed time and time again. You pay two taxes every time you fill your car up.
winnieanddaisy · 14/09/2021 12:36

I'm in a northern town and my band D council tax is £1000 more than if I was band D in Westminster. Ridiculous

Blossomtoes · 14/09/2021 12:35

@Porcupineintherough

If you look at what it pays for it should probably be a flat tax paid equally by all adults. They tried that in the 1980s. Didnt go down well.
It absolutely shouldn’t. The only thing we get for £2.4k a year council tax is roads and refuse collection. I’m happy to pay for other people’s kids’ education, social care, etc but there’s a limit.