Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I HATE paying Council Tax. It's the bill I hate the most.

391 replies

flashbac · 14/09/2021 09:25

Council Tax is regressive and unfair.

It takes more money from lower income individuals.

It has no link to the actual value of a property.

In addition to linking council tax to value, the bands also need to increase in range in order to reflect the vast difference in property values.

How can it be right that a million pound property in Westminster is the same or (often lower) CT rate than a 2 up, 2 down house in Yorkshire?

OP posts:
Islamorada · 14/09/2021 17:59

This government love regressive taxes

Council tax has been around for ever.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 17:54

"I've worked abroad and was taxed more. However I didn't feel put out because the money I got after that was all mine. No silly council tax and water rates to pay on top.

Yes it meant I paid more than someone who earned less than me, but then someone else who earned more than me paid more.

In my case taking it of my earnings meant I actually had more money left than I had working in the UK on a similar salary."

It's partly just that you didn't pay it directly. Where I live the local tax is paid from income tax and the only time I think about it is if I have to pay more at the end of the year. You don't make a monthly payment so you're not aware of it.
When I lived in the UK it was my biggest expense after rent and I paid the council directly so obviously I was very aware of it.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 14/09/2021 17:48

I dislike it being linked to property prices. It would be much fairer done per person in the house household as the more people the more services used etc.

MajorCarolDanvers · 14/09/2021 17:48

@NewPapaGuinea

I really resent the annual council tax increase, whilst funding is cut and the councillors award themselves fat pay increases on their already over inflated salaries (£100k - £200k)
Where in the UK is this.

In Scotland the basic councillor salary is £18K although committee chairs get more.

Wales it's £14K

Much of England councillors only get expenses. Some areas it's £18K

NewPapaGuinea · 14/09/2021 17:47

Maybe it’s not councillors I meant, but the Chief Executives and various department heads.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 14/09/2021 17:47

Yanbu it's a shocking amount of money really and most councils are shit and bent.

Also it's just fucking stupid to have a tax that changes from county to county.

Mintjulia · 14/09/2021 17:40

Ours neither.

The only time I've really objected was when Hampshire's PCC demanded a 400% increase. That really was contemptible.

It got him deselected thank goodness. Grin

Blossomtoes · 14/09/2021 17:23

@NewPapaGuinea

I really resent the annual council tax increase, whilst funding is cut and the councillors award themselves fat pay increases on their already over inflated salaries (£100k - £200k)
Ours don’t get paid anything apart from expenses.
NewPapaGuinea · 14/09/2021 17:18

I really resent the annual council tax increase, whilst funding is cut and the councillors award themselves fat pay increases on their already over inflated salaries (£100k - £200k)

MatildaIThink · 14/09/2021 16:56

@CorrBlimeyGG

The massive negative attribute of a tax increasing annually in line with property prices cancels out the positive attributes, at least for me.

Perhaps an opportunity for the government to stop introducing measures that falsely inflate house prices? Increases in normal times would be no higher than the annual council tax rise.

There are two main reasons for the increases in property prices both relate to the core of supply and demand. The population has increased 10% in the last 20 years and the planning laws limit the rate at which dwellings can be increased. Stamp Duty holidays and Help to Buy have an impact, but over time they just average out the trends which were already in place anyway. The other big cause of house price increases over time is more women entering the workplace, this gave families two incomes, allowing them to offer more and more as their disposable income increased.

If we want to see house prices fall we need home building to exceed population growth and we also need people to stop getting into a bidding war over property. Other potentially more controversial measures might include making property a less profitable investment vehicle, but that says more about the wider economy than it does about housing.

OhGiveUp · 14/09/2021 16:51

@Dreamstate No, it wasn't fairer as everyone in that household over the age of 18 had to pay it, and everyone in that household had to pay exactly the same, in their own name. Each person got an individual bill.
So, if you were a sahp for example with no income of your own, you had to still pay it, or be taken to court and possibly even jailed, so if you were lucky then your husband / partner would pay it, so he ended up paying twice.
The same with children living at home over the age of 18, if they were unemployed, remember in the 80s, unemployment was huge, they still had a percentage to pay.
The system was very unfair and very flawed.

MatildaIThink · 14/09/2021 16:50

@CorrBlimeyGG

The "rich" already pay far more tax than the "poor".

It makes sense that those who have more, pay more. If I take home £10K a month, I have far more disposable income than someone who brings home £1K. Why would I not give some of that up to provide better public services?

Someone bringing home £1k a month will pay virtually no income taxation (IT+NI), in many cases their cash benefits would exceed the tax paid. Their likely effective rate of income taxation taxation (tax+benefits) would range from 3% to having negative tax, up to 100% negative tax if their benefits are high enough.

Someone taking home £10k pcm would be paying £7,138 pcm in tax if PAYE, or £4,166 pcm if remunerated entirely in dividend (although that would already have had £41,750 of CT paid on it first.

The "rich" pay considerably more both as a percentage and as an absolute. The disparity between what the "rich" pay is the highest in the EU, the top third of earners have the sixth highest rate of income taxation in the EU, the bottom two thirds have the lowest rate of income taxation in the EU.

CorrBlimeyGG · 14/09/2021 16:42

The massive negative attribute of a tax increasing annually in line with property prices cancels out the positive attributes, at least for me.

Perhaps an opportunity for the government to stop introducing measures that falsely inflate house prices? Increases in normal times would be no higher than the annual council tax rise.

MatildaIThink · 14/09/2021 16:42

@Spidey66

I remember thinking at the time a fairer system would be a certain % of your income, say 5% or something. That to me is the fairest way.

I really, seriously suffered in the poll tax era. In fact I could quite easily have gone to prison, if it wasn't for the fact I kept moving to evade it. Imprisoned for living on the poverty line. That's not right.

Some countries do charge a local income tax, sometimes with a minimum monthly payment, sometimes with minimum allowance, almost always with a cap.
Spidey66 · 14/09/2021 16:40

@Lockdownbear
My parents paid for my education through their rates though. Wink

And before anyone jumps on me I don't actually mind paying for other people's kids to be educated, safe and healthy. I'm getting on, they'll be looking after me when I'm in a care home. I need them to be fit for the job while I entertain them with Spidey66: The Thatcher Years. Grin

CorrBlimeyGG · 14/09/2021 16:39

The "rich" already pay far more tax than the "poor".

It makes sense that those who have more, pay more. If I take home £10K a month, I have far more disposable income than someone who brings home £1K. Why would I not give some of that up to provide better public services?

amillionrosepetals · 14/09/2021 16:39

[quote CorrBlimeyGG]@amillionrosepetals It is one possible model, that would actually result in many people paying less. It is overly simplified, but does have some positive attributes.

Labour didn't propose the above model, they didn't propose one particular model at all. But the media caught on to John McDonnell once belonging to a group that advocated for a similar model, and wrote a heap of misleading articles about it.

Council tax reform is much needed, but it is complex and would need to take into account a whole combination of factors.[/quote]
Thanks for the clarification @CorrBlimeyGG. I just vaguely remembered it being dubbed 'Labour's death tax'. The massive negative attribute of a tax increasing annually in line with property prices cancels out the positive attributes, at least for me.

Lockdownbear · 14/09/2021 16:32

There can't be that many households with 3 or more earners. And the majority which are the 3rd earner is likely to be a low paid trainee / apprentice or just graduated and not earning much.

However given councils get a low percentage of their income from it, a bit of me thinks we should scrap it. However one thing that council tax does discourage is second homes and encourages people to sell or rent rather than see empty property as 'money in the bank'.

If you were to go to a local income tax what happens in areas with a high percentage of holiday / second homes?

I don't buy any arguments about child free adults not benefiting from schools - you went to school yourself and someone paid for it.

I do think it's wrong that water companies are privately owned. They should never have been sold off - in my mind they should be not for profit organisations.
The only reason Scottish Water wasn't sold off is because Loch Katrine was gifted to "the people of Glasgow" so couldn't be sold and it continues to supply most of Glasgow's water.

CorrBlimeyGG · 14/09/2021 16:32

@amillionrosepetals It is one possible model, that would actually result in many people paying less. It is overly simplified, but does have some positive attributes.

Labour didn't propose the above model, they didn't propose one particular model at all. But the media caught on to John McDonnell once belonging to a group that advocated for a similar model, and wrote a heap of misleading articles about it.

Council tax reform is much needed, but it is complex and would need to take into account a whole combination of factors.

AngelDelight28 · 14/09/2021 16:22

It should be based on income, not property value. The current system makes it so hard to move up the property ladder if you want to go from a flat to a family house. We haven't had a pay rise in years and are on slightly below average wages (no luck getting better paid jobs), can just about afford the bigger mortgage but the council tax hike is a killer.

DynamoKev · 14/09/2021 16:21

@Blossomtoes

Is enumerate a bit like eliterate?
And floored like flawed? Grin
Spidey66 · 14/09/2021 16:20

OK Binmen may have been well paid, but student nurses weren't. Maybe my fictional couple should have included a student nurse rather than a binman.

CrackerJack2021 · 14/09/2021 16:17

PissedOffNeighbour22 Here in East Yorkshire we are constantly told that our services are inferior to those of West Yorks due to lower numbers of CT payers. I do not buy that as an excuse. The problem here is the thick idiots who call themselves 'managers' of which there are dozens, and achieve absolutely nothing and derive an easy life from it. When I have challenged several of them about the cr*pness of their provision, several have responded with: "I've worked in WEST Yorkshire" as if it's a badge of honour and makes them 'well 'ard'. I find that hilarious.

amillionrosepetals · 14/09/2021 16:16

This is the alternative to Council Tax that is being proposed:
fairershare.org.uk/proportional-property-tax/
So, a tax that rises every year in line with the increase in property prices. While your income won't be rising at anything like that rate. But don't worry, if prices crash your bill will reduce. Oh please.
No 25% discount for single occupants.
Deferred pyt if you can't afford the increase. Labour once tried this but it was very unpopular and they dropped it, if I remember correctly.