Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I HATE paying Council Tax. It's the bill I hate the most.

391 replies

flashbac · 14/09/2021 09:25

Council Tax is regressive and unfair.

It takes more money from lower income individuals.

It has no link to the actual value of a property.

In addition to linking council tax to value, the bands also need to increase in range in order to reflect the vast difference in property values.

How can it be right that a million pound property in Westminster is the same or (often lower) CT rate than a 2 up, 2 down house in Yorkshire?

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 14/09/2021 20:58

@Bucanarab

Someone taking home £10k pcm would be paying £7,138 pcm in tax if PAYE, or £4,166 pcm if remunerated entirely in dividend (although that would already have had £41,750 of CT paid on it first.

Someone on £10k a month and on paye would take home approx £6200 pcm, so there's no way they are paying over £7k pcm just in tax.

The take home pay is quite an interesting angle though.

National living wage = £1290 pcm
Real living wage = £1355 pcm
National average wage = £2050 pcm
£100k earner = £5560 pcm
£250k earner = £11970 pcm
£1m earner = £45100 pcm

So that means someone on 100k a year has around £4200 per month more in their pocket than the government deems to be a living wage. And yet here we have you arguing that the rich can't possibly pay any more. Considering the top 10% of the UK have more wealth than the remaining 90% I'd say they can afford to be a fuck load more tax than they currently do.

Er... no, you are wrong.

Take home is net. To take home £10k pcm you need to earn £17,138 pcm (if your income is consistent from month to month) on PAYE.

I am not "arguing that the rich can't possibly pay more", I actually said that they should pay more, but that everyone should pay more.

It seems though that you are part of the problem. In Norway, Germany, Sweden etc. people accept that everyone has to make a contribution and because of that they have much better services and benefits, from higher pensions, to better schools, roads without potholes, better health services and social care. But you and your ilk always want "someone else" to pay more, that someone is never you.

I am prepared to pay more tax for a better society, people like me, people who earn more than me, people who earn less than me, we should all pay more tax. I want a better society and am prepared to contribute to that myself, can you say the same?

SushiGo · 14/09/2021 20:58

@Madwife123

Even more annoying we have to pay an extra charge to have the roads, trees and children’s park on the estate maintained as it’s an unadopted road so the council tax doesn’t cover that. Yet the park is public and used by children not living on the estate and so not contributing to its maintenance. Not that I begrudge that but surely this is what council tax is for?
Developers are required to offer the chance to bid for the maintenance of their green spaces contracts to local councils. The councils want to do them and would absorb the extra costs into their council tax budget so the cost was shared over the whole area. But obviously they have to offer good value to all residents too so they aren't going to bung developers wads of cash to do it.

The developers then give the contracts to private companies who charge the residents a maintenance fee to cover the costs instead.

It's completely stupid and causes a lot of unnecessary resentment that councils can't do anything about because its all in the hands of developers.

hamptonedge · 14/09/2021 20:52

'As it is I'm resenting the thought it's going to cost me mega £££ to sort the lease out if I ever want to sell my flat.'

You must have been aware of the short lease when you bought your flat? Your solicitor would have advised you.

KurtWilde · 14/09/2021 20:40

Absolutely hate it. Of all the bills I pay this one is the one I resent the most.

everythingbutthesink · 14/09/2021 20:39

I hate paying this. I pay £180!! My SIL pays £110 in the same area ? How
Iv never paid so much in my life

amillionrosepetals · 14/09/2021 20:38

@Madwife123

Yep!

I have a new build. How can they possibly guess what it’s value would have been years ago? I’m in the same band as houses 3 times the size and price of mine down the road as a result. But no grounds for appeal as it’s based on guesswork.

You could use this www.nationwide.co.uk/house-price-index to work out what, based on house price movements, a house that you paid £X for when you bought it would have been worth on 1/4/91. You would have to start by guessing at a 1991 value and refining it till you get the right answer. You could then work out your band from this www.gov.uk/guidance/understand-how-council-tax-bands-are-assessed. No idea if this would be grounds for appeal but might be interesting.
MrsMaizel · 14/09/2021 20:27

@GobbleHobble

The way council tax is calculated means some people aren't paying their fair share for local services.

There's us (2 adults and 1 DC In a small house) paying more than a neighbour along the road who's the owner of a 6 bed detached house with several acres of land and 5 children in the household (yet their breadwinner is a self employed business owner who takes his pay in dividends, wife as the ltd company secretary).

Now their kids are teens, the amount of landfill into the community bins, road use with several cars, etc, it's ridiculous that council tax is intended to pay for local services yet due to the bizarre valuations from years ago we pay more every year.?!

How is that even close to being rational or reasonable?!

It needs a massive overhaul.

I once tried to get us rebanded but it was about 2 months after the deadline to challenge it - apparently you can only challenge it within 6 months of moving in and I was a few weeks too late.

Another batshit reason / process that I have to comply with or face jail.

I'm a law abiding, tax paying citizen but the council tax system is a fucking joke.

I once tried to get us rebanded but it was about 2 months after the deadline to challenge it - apparently you can only challenge it within 6 months of moving in and I was a few weeks too late

I just challenged ours and we have been living here two years. We got a refund. Write to the valuation office.

NewPapaGuinea · 14/09/2021 20:19

@GobbleHobble we successfully challenged years after moving in and got rebranded and nice rebate. There’s a good article on Money Saving Expert we used.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 14/09/2021 20:16

Who the fuck knows what council tax is for though really? Our council gets loads of money off us and seems to spend it all on fucking bollards. It's a mystery to me.

And yes like you our very small 10 year old flat is apparently worth more than a period property with far more space due to them, as far as I can tell, pulling a valuation figure out of their arsehole.

GobbleHobble · 14/09/2021 20:13

The way council tax is calculated means some people aren't paying their fair share for local services.

There's us (2 adults and 1 DC In a small house) paying more than a neighbour along the road who's the owner of a 6 bed detached house with several acres of land and 5 children in the household (yet their breadwinner is a self employed business owner who takes his pay in dividends, wife as the ltd company secretary).

Now their kids are teens, the amount of landfill into the community bins, road use with several cars, etc, it's ridiculous that council tax is intended to pay for local services yet due to the bizarre valuations from years ago we pay more every year.?!

How is that even close to being rational or reasonable?!

It needs a massive overhaul.

I once tried to get us rebanded but it was about 2 months after the deadline to challenge it - apparently you can only challenge it within 6 months of moving in and I was a few weeks too late.

Another batshit reason / process that I have to comply with or face jail.

I'm a law abiding, tax paying citizen but the council tax system is a fucking joke.

Madwife123 · 14/09/2021 20:12

Even more annoying we have to pay an extra charge to have the roads, trees and children’s park on the estate maintained as it’s an unadopted road so the council tax doesn’t cover that. Yet the park is public and used by children not living on the estate and so not contributing to its maintenance. Not that I begrudge that but surely this is what council tax is for?

Madwife123 · 14/09/2021 20:08

Yep!

I have a new build. How can they possibly guess what it’s value would have been years ago? I’m in the same band as houses 3 times the size and price of mine down the road as a result. But no grounds for appeal as it’s based on guesswork.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 19:42

@MeAndDebbieMcGee

You do here. People who are on the dole pay 15% here.
Yes, you pay some of it.
MeAndDebbieMcGee · 14/09/2021 19:18

You do here. People who are on the dole pay 15% here.

Kitkat151 · 14/09/2021 19:16

@wedwewerpink

Do you still pay council tax if you are unemployed?
No
Bucanarab · 14/09/2021 18:52

Someone taking home £10k pcm would be paying £7,138 pcm in tax if PAYE, or £4,166 pcm if remunerated entirely in dividend (although that would already have had £41,750 of CT paid on it first.

Someone on £10k a month and on paye would take home approx £6200 pcm, so there's no way they are paying over £7k pcm just in tax.

The take home pay is quite an interesting angle though.

National living wage = £1290 pcm
Real living wage = £1355 pcm
National average wage = £2050 pcm
£100k earner = £5560 pcm
£250k earner = £11970 pcm
£1m earner = £45100 pcm

So that means someone on 100k a year has around £4200 per month more in their pocket than the government deems to be a living wage. And yet here we have you arguing that the rich can't possibly pay any more. Considering the top 10% of the UK have more wealth than the remaining 90% I'd say they can afford to be a fuck load more tax than they currently do.

YourFinestPantaloons · 14/09/2021 18:47

@Gwenhwyfar

"Why should some rich Chinese investor owner of a 600sqft £5m London flat, who only spends 4 weeks of the year in this country, pay a massive amount of council tax?"

Because he's contributing to a housing crisis by taking a flat out of reach of people who need somewhere to live. He should be paying much more for a second home.

Brava!
LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 14/09/2021 18:41

The London CT might also be lower because councils get revenue from tourism, no? It makes sense, if you live in London you have to share your local infrastructure with tourists/visitors and they will pay a share (hotels must contribute to waste disposal for ex).
Having each council set the rate also means autonomy (relatively), if it was set at national level it would just be another black hole tax, everybody would complain it was mismanaged, no inventive for councils to be efficients etc

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 18:31

"Why should some rich Chinese investor owner of a 600sqft £5m London flat, who only spends 4 weeks of the year in this country, pay a massive amount of council tax?"

Because he's contributing to a housing crisis by taking a flat out of reach of people who need somewhere to live. He should be paying much more for a second home.

CornishGem1975 · 14/09/2021 18:28

YANBU. My council tax bill is almost £3k. Our household income is about £40k max. It's a huge dent for us.

YourFinestPantaloons · 14/09/2021 18:28

Well said OP. Not to mention if you miss 2 payments (easily done if you've suddenly found yourself on a lower income for whatever reason) the balliffs are banging on your door the next day and they have legal powers to take your car.

purplesequins · 14/09/2021 18:28

also, in a city will be a lot more households in a area than in less densely populated areas.
makes sense that way that an inner london borough has lower ct than a more rural one.

MissConductUS · 14/09/2021 18:27

Just as a point of comparison, I have a detached house on two acres of land in a nice suburb north of New York City, and I pay about $8000 per year in school taxes and another $3500 in town property taxes. The town taxes cover police and fire protection, rubbish and recycling collection, libraries, town services for building inspections, snow plowing, parks maintenance, etc. Water is charged by usage.

Commercial properties also pay school and town taxes, which helps lower the burden on homeowners. Taxes are higher in some other nearby towns because they have fewer commercial properties in the tax base. The school system here is really good, so I've never minded paying the school taxes.

Wandawide · 14/09/2021 18:09

Councils that are more efficient are able to give better value than others. Wandsworth used to have a low rate and they are a more typical London Borough than Westminster.
Everyone wants decisions taken locally, so you cant complain on SM about it. Complain to your councillors and don't vote for them.
The old rating system was worn out and the idea of each person paying (Poll Tax) led to riots. What system would you like?
Charge everyone except you? They tried that in Brighton. It is actually Labour Party & Green Party policy.

Crikeyalmighty · 14/09/2021 18:09

I live in Copenhagen- we don’t have it here, I kept asking about it when we moved and couldn’t understand they didn’t know what I was talking about — personal tax is higher generally but we don’t have council tax and services are way higher, also great childcare at around £200 a month for full time care for those with little ones. Utilities are lower too . They don’t have national insurance either- tax and NI is rolled into one. Overall it kind of evens out but the big difference is minimum wage of £14 an hour and a lot of fairly average jobs pay £40k plus