Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I HATE paying Council Tax. It's the bill I hate the most.

391 replies

flashbac · 14/09/2021 09:25

Council Tax is regressive and unfair.

It takes more money from lower income individuals.

It has no link to the actual value of a property.

In addition to linking council tax to value, the bands also need to increase in range in order to reflect the vast difference in property values.

How can it be right that a million pound property in Westminster is the same or (often lower) CT rate than a 2 up, 2 down house in Yorkshire?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 15/09/2021 19:14

@Xenia

Mine is nearly £4000!!! I hardly use council services compared to many. I wish they would just abolish it and use central Gov revenues for things. We have taxes coming out our ears at every turn these days. Highest taxation since the 1950s.
Where do you think the increased government revenue would come from? Your income tax would go up so you’d still be paying it in a different way.
Xenia · 15/09/2021 19:11

Mine is nearly £4000!!! I hardly use council services compared to many. I wish they would just abolish it and use central Gov revenues for things. We have taxes coming out our ears at every turn these days. Highest taxation since the 1950s.

thegcatsmother · 15/09/2021 19:10

There is an assumption being made that if there are say three adults in a household that all of them contribute to the Council Tax. Dh and I own our home. We are the liable people for the Council Tax so we pay it. Ds who works full time still lives at home. We don't ask him to contribute to the Council Tax bill as he is not liable for it, and as it is based on two people, him being here makes no difference.

Restzol · 15/09/2021 19:02

@Belladonna12 I just stole this explanation from another Mumsnet thread!
‘The VOA is informed by building control of any alterations/extensions, plus planning permission and they also monitor sale prices of houses when they are higher than expected.

If you needed planning or building regs they put a flag next to your house on the VOA website which says it may be rebanded after a sale. You can check this yourself on their website.’

It does rather beg the question of why the review can’t be applied to the original owners. Maybe the thinking is to encourage renovation? Definitely worth knowing about if you are buying.

Belladonna12 · 15/09/2021 18:15

@Restzol

Those have always been the rules for Council Tax, the re-band for an extension takes place upon sale.

Or does it? Theoretically it might be possible but realistically who is monitoring this given the initial valuation didn’t note down the size of the house, it was just based on general impression on a ‘second gear’ drive by? You could have added an extension in 1995 (or not) I’m not sure anyone is really taking this in as, to the best of my knowledge, there is no process to do this during a sale and changes could go back decades.

Our house was reassessed when we moved as the previous owner had extended.
CrackerJack2021 · 15/09/2021 17:58

I think that many of us would feel better if there were a proper, consistent system of auditing the efficiency of local authorities which they are unable to manipulate. The amount of 'managers' i.e. work-dodging bureaucrats in my local council is stunning; they have been on a long 'shirk from home' holiday since the beginning of COVID, leaving office staff to field phone calls with no support whatsoever, and consequently no proper service provision. The culture of our LA (ERYC) is absolutely shocking, and if it were a private business it would have gone bankrupt years ago. This has an impact on the community by failure of service provision, cynicism by local residents and resentment at these ridiculous salaries, job titles and work-dodging. So much money could be saved if local authorities were run in a businesslike way with genuine accountability.

Restzol · 15/09/2021 14:32

Those have always been the rules for Council Tax, the re-band for an extension takes place upon sale.

Or does it? Theoretically it might be possible but realistically who is monitoring this given the initial valuation didn’t note down the size of the house, it was just based on general impression on a ‘second gear’ drive by? You could have added an extension in 1995 (or not) I’m not sure anyone is really taking this in as, to the best of my knowledge, there is no process to do this during a sale and changes could go back decades.

HarrietOh · 15/09/2021 14:28

Definitely agree it should also be more fair across all regions of the country!

Iggly · 15/09/2021 14:09

That’s business rates. Council tax is retained by local authorities
Apologies, you’re correct.

What I mean is that all of the money required to run a council comes from council tax or business rates. A lot of them get topped up by central government grants anyway. But those grants have been cut. As a result, councils are hamstrung as they can only raise rates so far.

Lockdownbear · 15/09/2021 13:53

Essentially council tax is a form of property tax, paid by the occupants.
Having it paid by the owner then means they'll bump rent up to cover it making it even more unfair on single people as they'd be no single person discount, they'd be paying the rent inc the property tax.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 15/09/2021 13:52

Aye that's true and I'm single so it certainly pisses me off that I'm paying 50% more than each of my neighbours. But if it was only for funding add ons I wouldn't be so aerated about it. I'm more than happy to contribute to things that we as a country need to provide through general taxation. Not quite so happy about paying more just because I happen to live in a region that needs more elderly care than Westminster.

HarrietOh · 15/09/2021 13:49

@MeAndDebbieMcGee

Nah, not change it to income tax. Just have it as more of a top up tax. It's crackers that councils have to budget for services they are legally required to provide and that residents of an area have to fund them. If something is required, that should come from general taxation. It would make it a lot more straightforward in terms of discretionary spending and charities too because rn if something's supposed to be funded but isn't - because eg the council doesn't have the money for it - it's really hard to get funding for it elsewhere.

I think we could do with switching it back to being a property tax really. Most other countries have one. Rn council tax acts as a sort of property tax but over a third of households don't actually own their homes. If it reverted to being a property tax those households would still be contributing via presumably rent but it would be the owner that's liable. This would also get a bit from landlords and airbnb etc. There's a lot of money sloshing around in the various types of letting and subsidiary rights to do with land that isn't really making its way to the regions those properties are in.

That still wouldn't solve the fact a person living on their own only gets a 25% discount, when 4 adults in a house next door pay less per person for those same services. It should really be based on individuals all paying a fair share.
MeAndDebbieMcGee · 15/09/2021 13:18

Nah, not change it to income tax. Just have it as more of a top up tax. It's crackers that councils have to budget for services they are legally required to provide and that residents of an area have to fund them. If something is required, that should come from general taxation. It would make it a lot more straightforward in terms of discretionary spending and charities too because rn if something's supposed to be funded but isn't - because eg the council doesn't have the money for it - it's really hard to get funding for it elsewhere.

I think we could do with switching it back to being a property tax really. Most other countries have one. Rn council tax acts as a sort of property tax but over a third of households don't actually own their homes. If it reverted to being a property tax those households would still be contributing via presumably rent but it would be the owner that's liable. This would also get a bit from landlords and airbnb etc. There's a lot of money sloshing around in the various types of letting and subsidiary rights to do with land that isn't really making its way to the regions those properties are in.

Lockdownbear · 15/09/2021 13:02

@MeAndDebbieMcGee
If you changed it to an income tax, how do you deal with business owners who get paid in dividends and how do you encourage landlords to keep their places occupied, and should air bnb people get off free?

Lockdownbear · 15/09/2021 12:43

@Blossomtoes

I definitely think some sort of rate per m2 makes more sense and less arguments

How would that help the people mentioned in your first paragraph?

I'd increase the discount for single people. But at the same time holiday houses / air bnbs should have an premium on them as the owners aren't contributing all year round to the local economy.

I'm definitely anti the idea of it being replaced with some sort of income tax as second home owners are likely to end up paying less. And they'd be no incentive for landlords to ensure their place is occupied.

HarrietOh · 15/09/2021 12:40

I see others have mentioned it, but council tax is a very unfair tax. I live alone and only get a 25% discount on my council tax bill. Next door there are 4 adults, so they are getting it cheaper per person than me. I feel it should definitely take into account number of people in a house.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 15/09/2021 12:33

I agree it would be better for councils to get money allocated for services they have to provide and for that to come from general taxation eg income tax which at least is not regressive.

Maybe it would also help avoid the situation where certain things are supposed to be provided by the public sector but in fact often are not because the council has run out of money?

MatildaIThink · 15/09/2021 12:26

@cptartapp

It galls me massively that we pay more than next door, simply because when we moved in the house was rebanded as it had been extended by the previous owners. Next doors has been extended too, but won't be rebanded until they sell. Doesn't seem fair.
Those have always been the rules for Council Tax, the re-band for an extension takes place upon sale. You could have bought a smaller house and then extended it yourself, if the few hundred to maybe a thousand pounds extra in Council Tax really would bother you that much.
cptartapp · 15/09/2021 12:02

It galls me massively that we pay more than next door, simply because when we moved in the house was rebanded as it had been extended by the previous owners.
Next doors has been extended too, but won't be rebanded until they sell.
Doesn't seem fair.

amillionrosepetals · 15/09/2021 11:52

@Lockdownbear

How did they calculate rates back in the day?
It was based on what rent your property would attract. I think that it's still the basis on which water rates are calculated.
amillionrosepetals · 15/09/2021 11:34

@Iggly and @MatildaIThink. Agree with you both about it being better to fund certain things out of general taxation and just leave Councils to deal with local things. Income tax up and council tax down, this would far better reflect people's actual ability to pay.

MatildaIThink · 15/09/2021 11:00

@Spidey66

PS my £1k figure was simply to compare it to income tax, not council tax.

I have not said it should be directly related to house price, though this is better IMO. I still think the fairest way is by a local income tax as a certain % of your income.

Some other countries do operate a local income tax, it is almost always capped though, so say 2-8%, but capped at a maximum of say £5k per year total payment. That of course also functions in a poll tax way in that two people living in a household on the same salary pay more than one person living in a household on the same salary. Those countries also tend to have lower standard income taxes, much in the same way the USA has federal, state and municipal taxes (although not all states have the latter two).

In reality it would make more sense for all of the statutory provision which councils have no choice over and which make up the majority of the costs being funded from central taxation. This would be things like social care, education, children's services etc. as the council has no real control over these, they can not choose not to provide them. Then council tax should be charged to equally (but at a reduced rate compared to current levels), with a two part per dwelling and per occupant component which goes towards spending in the council area which the council can choose to spend on based on the priorities of the local electorate, this would be things like frequency of refuse services, road maintenance, upkeep of public areas and the pet projects councils waste money on.

Spidey66 · 15/09/2021 10:42

PS my £1k figure was simply to compare it to income tax, not council tax.

I have not said it should be directly related to house price, though this is better IMO. I still think the fairest way is by a local income tax as a certain % of your income.

Blossomtoes · 15/09/2021 10:41

I definitely think some sort of rate per m2 makes more sense and less arguments

How would that help the people mentioned in your first paragraph?

Spidey66 · 15/09/2021 10:32

@MatildaIThink
It wasn't. I remember it being about £70 per month, and that was in 1990 prices so probably about ? £130 a month in todays prices. This was in several London boroughs. OK my £1k was an exaggeration but was just to demonstrate the unfairness of it.