Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I HATE paying Council Tax. It's the bill I hate the most.

391 replies

flashbac · 14/09/2021 09:25

Council Tax is regressive and unfair.

It takes more money from lower income individuals.

It has no link to the actual value of a property.

In addition to linking council tax to value, the bands also need to increase in range in order to reflect the vast difference in property values.

How can it be right that a million pound property in Westminster is the same or (often lower) CT rate than a 2 up, 2 down house in Yorkshire?

OP posts:
HandsOffMyRights · 16/09/2021 08:36

A few years ago I lived in a road with vastly different properties.

Our tiny house, which was worth about 200k 5 years ago, paid the same amount of council tax (band D) as the massive 5 bed houses on the same road for around £350k.

I challenged this, sending recent sale prices etc but it was thrown out on the basis of 1991 figures.

As it was a newish estate in 1991, I figured the valuation office had done a lazy drive by valuation and bunged our property into the same band as those much bigger houses. I had no evidence though of my sale price in 1991.

I spent a day at the library poring over old newspapers from 1991 in the property section. I found houses on our estate of a similar size to ours, along with the much bigger houses. The bigger houses were clearly band D prices but the smaller ones price and size fit band C.

I sent off my research and my house sale prices over the other years post 1991, asking why we paid a higher rate on a property that would so clearly have not been band D in 91, had had no extensions or modifications etc. To no avail.

It's a totally ridiculous, unfair system that needs overhauling.

Xenia · 16/09/2021 08:29

There are certainly an awful lot of taxes people have to pay from council tax, income tax, NI (and soon the new 1.25% social care tax), VAT, on and on and on - even insurance premium tax seems to go up every year.

It is very hard to be "fair" - whatever fair is. I do think having all council income coming from central Government including anything from business rates might be simpler - if we could have fewer taxes even if they were higher that might work better but instead year on year we build more and more taxes and tax complications on the complicated tax edifice that already exists.

Seymour5 · 16/09/2021 08:14

@thegcatsmother

Notcontent CTax is based on a combination of a property element (50%) and two personal elements (25% x2). You get a 25% discount on the personal element, which your neighbours don't.

What should have been done in 1989 was to give a choice between Community Charge and domestic rates, after a revaluation had been done and the rate poundage had been increased. I bet people would have chosen Community Charge.

Community Charge was not that hard to collect ( it used to be my job), but properties don't move the same way people do, so it stopped. I far preferred Community Charge as it was fairer imo. People were paying their share, so 4 adults in a house contributed more than 1 person in terms of paying for the services they used.

I agree. As a couple of very moderate earners when the Community Charge was introduced, we were very much in favour. We prioritised housing, and bought in the nicest area we could afford in the town we lived in. That meant before CC our rates were more than those of an identical house in another part of the same town, where the household income could be far more.

The government of the day lost an opportunity because the publicity around the Community Charge was very negative, even though it was based on individuals, IMO fairer.

I hooe people are aware that Local Authorities pay increasing % of their income from Council Tax on final salary pensions. Staff have secure employment, many roles are equally, if not more highly, paid than the private sector equivalent, and are often jobs for life.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 16/09/2021 07:55

I said above, I'd just increase income tax and have a grant from central government to councils. I'd also streamline councils to have fewer layers of government - where I am we have parish/district/county - I think one unitary authority could probably do it all.

And then punitive local taxes on holiday lets and second/third/multiple homes. and I mean punitive. £1000 a month or similar to "encourage" those landlords to put the houses back into residential use (obviously with exemptions for things like farm buildings which can only be used for holiday lets).

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 16/09/2021 07:52

@simitra

The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.
Not sure my son has sucked up resources, actually. What are you referring to? Schools are the one thing that comes out of the central grant, so council tax doesn't pay for that.

Libraries and leisure centres are for all, and you pay to use leisure centres.

What resources do you think children suck up. What about adults who fly tip and suck up resources when the council has to clear their rubbish up?

Spidey66 · 16/09/2021 07:49

@Dreamstate

They are saying your council tax isn't based on what you use...its cos its in caps it looks like an acronym
Ahh....sorry. I thought it stood for something!
Spidey66 · 16/09/2021 07:47

I still don't know what USE means, but clearly its something to do with not having kids.

I don't have them, but as they're going to be looking after to me when I'm in a nursing home, i accept I need to fund their education, health and safety now. I'm not disabled but still happy to fund their care as well.

Lockdownbear · 16/09/2021 07:27

I agree it would be much fairer to bill it per person in the household rather than on the value of the house had everyone pays no discounts. That would be much fairer than the current house value system as that has no bearing in facilities used

They tried billing per person, called the poll tax / community charge, which certainly wasn't fair, why should a young person on a trainee wage or the office cleaner pay the same as the Chief Exec?
How do you deal with second homes and holidays let's?

BarbaraofSeville · 16/09/2021 07:26

I agree it would be much fairer to bill it per person in the household rather than on the value of the house had everyone pays no discounts. That would be much fairer than the current house value system as that has no bearing in facilities used

You could be on to something there. However, you'd have to take ability to pay into account or else we might see a re-run of the poll tax riots of the 1990s.

Dreamstate · 16/09/2021 07:19

They are saying your council tax isn't based on what you use...its cos its in caps it looks like an acronym

Lockdownbear · 16/09/2021 07:19

@simitra

The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.
And what about the childless people who paid for your schooling?

It's a bit like state pension, the working people pay for those who are retired. The adults pay for the current generation of children, who in turn will pay for the next generation.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 16/09/2021 07:16

@simitra

The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.
I agree it would be much fairer to bill it per person in the household rather than on the value of the house had everyone pays no discounts. That would be much fairer than the current house value system as that has no bearing in facilities used.
Spidey66 · 16/09/2021 07:13

@simitra

The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.
What does USE mean?
cptartapp · 16/09/2021 06:58

Matilda they didn't.
What's the justification for this rule anyway? Does anyone know?

Iggly · 16/09/2021 05:54

@simitra

The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.
Hmm
simitra · 16/09/2021 01:54

The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 16/09/2021 00:07

If you are in the England you should get a 25% discount for single person occupancy.

@Lincslady53 indeed. So I pay 75%. They pay 50% each. So I pay 50% more than each of them does.

jcyclops · 15/09/2021 23:23

Note that only 7% of Westminster's income comes from Council Tax.

This table (xl spreadsheet) is interesting - it shows the number of properties in each band for all councils in England and Wales.
assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/920362/Table_CTSOP1.0_2020.xlsx
The median house in Sheffield is in band A, in Westminster it is in band E.

The 58th percentile house in Sheffield is in band A (£1327 council tax). The 58th percentile house in Westminster is in band F (£1195 council tax).

XenoBitch · 15/09/2021 21:37

I am in a 3 bed house which is Band B.
I hate paying it too. But then I am paying to have my bins collected, pay for the fire brigade and police if needed, pay for upkeep of public areas etc, pay for adult social care etc.

Dreamstate · 15/09/2021 21:35

And thats the problem because he isn't paying his share so essentially getting free services, when he is older and if he never reads council tax and requires social care support from the council he will never have paid into it. Other people will subsidise him and why ahould they when he works and earns, all because he wasnt liable for it.

Thats why the poll tax to a certain extent addressed this imbalance.

Also as two people splitting council tax you still pay less per person than a single person on one income. Yet again if you need social care support you paid in less than a single person who needs it..is that fair? No it isn't.

MatildaIThink · 15/09/2021 20:54

@cptartapp

Matilda maybe we were naive but didn't realise we would be rebanded. It was marketed as a band C, and then moved up to band E on reassessment. Had no idea this was a thing until someone came knocking on the door. We could have bought smaller of course and extended but that's not the point. The fact this process has always been the rules doesn't make it fair. Why wait until sale to reband? What's the justification?
Your conveyancing solicitor should have pointed it out to you if you did not know yourself, they should have made it clear when they checked the extension met building standards and had the relevant planning.
MatildaIThink · 15/09/2021 20:53

@Xenia

Mine is nearly £4000!!! I hardly use council services compared to many. I wish they would just abolish it and use central Gov revenues for things. We have taxes coming out our ears at every turn these days. Highest taxation since the 1950s.
Unless you are one of the top third of earners you still have the lowest rate of income taxation in the EU, one of the lowest effective rates of VAT (note effective rate, not headline rate, because we do not charge VAT on food, we're as most countries charge it at 5-12.5%), our council tax is roughly equivalent to the municipal or regional taxes in other European countries.

Apart from that your "Highest taxation since the 1950s" only applies to higher and additional rate income tax payers, if you are on the basic rate (up to £50k pa) then you have a tax rate low by historical standards due to the large tax free allowance.

Lincslady53 · 15/09/2021 19:22

@MeAndDebbieMcGee

Aye that's true and I'm single so it certainly pisses me off that I'm paying 50% more than each of my neighbours. But if it was only for funding add ons I wouldn't be so aerated about it. I'm more than happy to contribute to things that we as a country need to provide through general taxation. Not quite so happy about paying more just because I happen to live in a region that needs more elderly care than Westminster.
If you are in the England you should get a 25% discount for single person occupancy. www.gov.uk/apply-for-council-tax-discount
cptartapp · 15/09/2021 19:20

Matilda maybe we were naive but didn't realise we would be rebanded. It was marketed as a band C, and then moved up to band E on reassessment. Had no idea this was a thing until someone came knocking on the door.
We could have bought smaller of course and extended but that's not the point.
The fact this process has always been the rules doesn't make it fair. Why wait until sale to reband? What's the justification?

Lincslady53 · 15/09/2021 19:18

Not as unfair as business rates. We had a small, about 800sq ft shop in a small Northern city. Business rates when we closed in 2018 were over £25,000 per year. We were in a covered shopping centre and had another £10,000 to pay the landlord as service charge to pay for the upkeep of the mall and waste removal. Both rose every year by more than the rate of inflation. This was on top of £50,000 rent per year. I wonder why there are so many empty shops in town centres?