Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I HATE paying Council Tax. It's the bill I hate the most.

391 replies

flashbac · 14/09/2021 09:25

Council Tax is regressive and unfair.

It takes more money from lower income individuals.

It has no link to the actual value of a property.

In addition to linking council tax to value, the bands also need to increase in range in order to reflect the vast difference in property values.

How can it be right that a million pound property in Westminster is the same or (often lower) CT rate than a 2 up, 2 down house in Yorkshire?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 16/09/2021 18:53

@Yogsgirl

simitra The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.

Surely families pay more council tax on average because they occupy bigger properties than the average single person?

Of course they don’t. MN is constantly throwing its toys out of its pram about all the old people rattling about in their huge houses. There are lots of couples living in three and four bed houses without a child in sight.
Yogsgirl · 16/09/2021 16:51

simitra
The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.

Surely families pay more council tax on average because they occupy bigger properties than the average single person?

Plumtree391 · 16/09/2021 16:29

@Lockdownbear

If you start arguing about only paying for what you use, where does that leave things like Social Work, many of us never need their help until we hit old age and become vulnerable? The special needs teacher in school, I don't need it my kids don't so I'm not paying?

It just doesn't work like that, in a civilised society we all pay to support the weakest.

I quite agree.

The welfare state, with all its faults, is a marvellous safety net and don't grudge a penny of my income which contributes to it.

ZoBo123 · 16/09/2021 16:28

@simitra

The aspect of CT which angers me most is that it is not related to USE. Parents pay nothing extra for the resources which their children suck up and are heavily subsidised by single person households. A 25% discount simply does not cut it.
Really? The biggest spend on council's budgets is social care. Children and adults in care. Most people will not use children's social care but thankfully it is there to support those children and families who need it. As for adult social care, what about those who have made no provision for their old age? Well we support them as any civilised society should do. A few parks and libraries is nowhere near the cost and charging more fir families would make barely any difference
Yogsgirl · 16/09/2021 16:18

@Belladonna12 I agree- that's what I just said!

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 16/09/2021 16:07

For people on minimum wage, council tax band b in this region is 15% of their take home. So yes absolutely it's a great big chunk of their income.

Belladonna12 · 16/09/2021 15:51

[quote Yogsgirl]@Belladonna12 maybe, but most things are self regulating- if you have less money you choose to us less and the smaller your property the less it costs to heat etc. The user has some control, whereas this is not true of other services such as refuse collection, street maintenance, eduction etc.[/quote]
People with smaller properties are likely to have less money than those with larger properties and/or there are fewer people in them using services.

Dreamstate · 16/09/2021 14:09

Okay if we are going to go down that road of its not up to the taxpayer to assist people who choose expensive houses, well I'm a taxpayer and childless, its not up to be to pay for other people who choose to have children. Yes thats right in majority of cases you choose to have a child. Why should I who through medical reasons not have one assist those who CHOOSE to have them.

Where shall we go next....okay why should I as a taxpayer have to assist those who CHOOSE to not have healthy lifes that leads to problems and need the NHS more

Yogsgirl · 16/09/2021 14:02

exactly @Lockdownbear

Lockdownbear · 16/09/2021 13:59

If you start arguing about only paying for what you use, where does that leave things like Social Work, many of us never need their help until we hit old age and become vulnerable?
The special needs teacher in school, I don't need it my kids don't so I'm not paying?

It just doesn't work like that, in a civilised society we all pay to support the weakest.

Yogsgirl · 16/09/2021 13:55

@Belladonna12 maybe, but most things are self regulating- if you have less money you choose to us less and the smaller your property the less it costs to heat etc. The user has some control, whereas this is not true of other services such as refuse collection, street maintenance, eduction etc.

Belladonna12 · 16/09/2021 13:43

@Yogsgirl

That's because phones, water, food, etc.are provided by private companies, so not a tax- they are profit led services!

Council tax pays for a plethora of things including libraries, roads, refuse collection, street lighting, social care, parks, museums, leisure facilities etc. Hopefully things that benefit society as a whole and support those who are less fortunate. As someone who is lucky enough to be able to afford a nice house in a higher band then I don't begrudge paying a little bit more to allow others who are less well off to pay a bit less!

On the whole the council tax is fairer, unless of course your only view of fair is equal!

It's not because those services are private. Even when they were nationalised people still paid for what they used rather than on the basis of what they earned. Nobody ever argued that they should pay less for gas, electricity, water etc because they earned less before the companies were privatised.
BarbaraofSeville · 16/09/2021 13:02

@Yogsgirl

The assumption is, if you can afford the house you can afford the tax.
This, plus it's not up to the taxpayer to assist people who have chosen to live in a much more expensive house than they can afford the council tax for or, if they're the typical 'asset rich cash poor' pensioner who has benefitted from massive unearned untaxed housing wealth growth, they have options to help them solve the affordability problem, ie downsizing or equity release, neither of which are generally available to younger people who have large mortgages to pay and the costs of raising children.
Yogsgirl · 16/09/2021 12:51

The assumption is, if you can afford the house you can afford the tax.

amillionrosepetals · 16/09/2021 12:15

[quote Yogsgirl]@amillionrosepetals I am assuming you are single. Don't you get a single person reduction?[/quote]
Yes, I do claim it. But I'm retired now so my income has reduced by a fair bit. No reduction in Council Tax though. It just seems to be a choice of a bill per person irrespective of income or a bill per property irrespective of income so no fairness anywhere.

Yogsgirl · 16/09/2021 12:00

@amillionrosepetals I am assuming you are single. Don't you get a single person reduction?

amillionrosepetals · 16/09/2021 11:50

@Yogsgirl

If you think everyone paying the same amount towards council services is a fair tax, when for some it will be tiny percentage of their income and for others a great big chunk of it...bloody hell!
But that is actually what the current system very often does. My neighbours are a couple who both work full time and their Council Tax bill is a much smaller percentage of their income than mine is. So yes, bloody hell!
Yogsgirl · 16/09/2021 10:30

That's because phones, water, food, etc.are provided by private companies, so not a tax- they are profit led services!

Council tax pays for a plethora of things including libraries, roads, refuse collection, street lighting, social care, parks, museums, leisure facilities etc. Hopefully things that benefit society as a whole and support those who are less fortunate. As someone who is lucky enough to be able to afford a nice house in a higher band then I don't begrudge paying a little bit more to allow others who are less well off to pay a bit less!

On the whole the council tax is fairer, unless of course your only view of fair is equal!

Parker231 · 16/09/2021 10:29

Our council tax bill went up 5.9% this year and takes it to over £4K . I looked up what council tax in our area covers - all essential services which we may need at some point in our lives. As much as I hate paying it, I wouldn’t like services to be cut or reduced.

Adult Social Care
Housing
Waste & Cleaning Services
Environment (Parking, highways and transport)
Regeneration, planning and economic development
Culture and communities
Public Health Support Services
Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit
Education
Supporting vulnerable families
Early Years & Young People

Belladonna12 · 16/09/2021 09:56

@Yogsgirl

If you think everyone paying the same amount towards council services is a fair tax, when for some it will be tiny percentage of their income and for others a great big chunk of it...bloody hell!
Other goods and services aren't charged according to income though so it's not really any different. For example you don't pay less for food or services such as your phone, gas, electricity or water rate than a higher earner.
Dreamstate · 16/09/2021 09:51

@Yogsgirl

If you think everyone paying the same amount towards council services is a fair tax, when for some it will be tiny percentage of their income and for others a great big chunk of it...bloody hell!
What most definitely isn't fair is why a single person or parent pays more per person than someone who is lucky enough to found love and either married or living with a partner where more often than not there is 2 income streams coming in.

As always it the single person/parent who is always penalised when it comes to nay type of tax. That is what is most disgusting. And every time they roll out the big budget do you ever see anything for single people...never! There is always helps for all other types but the single person with a sole income stream.

MatildaIThink · 16/09/2021 09:11

@Yogsgirl

If you think everyone paying the same amount towards council services is a fair tax, when for some it will be tiny percentage of their income and for others a great big chunk of it...bloody hell!
That is the problem with "fair", it is always subjective. Why should people who make the least use of council services pay the most? Why should those with a higher value property pay more? Why should those with a higher income pay more? If the everyone nominally uses the same services (bin collection, roads, fire brigade etc.) then why should the cost not be split equally etc.

What you think is "fair", will not be something that everyone else agrees is fair. The reality is that many people will think that any proposed solution is unfair, so instead we have to look at what is practical.

Porcupineintherough · 16/09/2021 08:48

@lockdownmadnessdotcom I'd guess the pp was referring to things covered by children's services eg everything to do with adoption, fostering, services for children in need (that's not the current term I dont think), support services for children w disabilities, child safeguarding. Also council run childcare provision (heavily subsidized) and things like playgrounds. But why parents should pay extra for these I dont know, I think they are things all good societies would provide.

Yogsgirl · 16/09/2021 08:46

If you think everyone paying the same amount towards council services is a fair tax, when for some it will be tiny percentage of their income and for others a great big chunk of it...bloody hell!

MatildaIThink · 16/09/2021 08:44

@cptartapp

Matilda they didn't. What's the justification for this rule anyway? Does anyone know?
Then your solicitors were incompetent.

I do not know if there is any particular justification as such, but there does not need to be, it is what it is. Any rebanding has always taken place on sale and if you want to appeal you only have six months after purchase.