Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Property might be unmortgageable - what happens now?

242 replies

Welcometomyhouse · 13/09/2021 22:21

Evening.. I was going to post this in the property section but thought there would be more traffic here. Just wondering if anyone has been through a similar situation and what was the outcome?

I’m a first time buyer purchasing a first floor flat on my own. The lady who is selling the property inherited it from her mother who lived there for 20 years. There is a mix of houses and flats on the street, however only my downstairs neighbour and I are leasehold, whilst all the other properties (including the flats) are freehold. When I went to view the property I asked the EA if there were any services charges and they explained that the management/maintenance company no longer existed. In the 20 years that the woman lived there she never had to pay any service charge nor did anyone request any payment from her. The daughter has tried to contact the company multiples times but has not been able to get in touch with anyone, so she believes that it has dissolved. I believe this to be true as all the communal areas are overflowing with weeds etc and it is clear that no one has maintained it for some time now. The gardens are kept tidy, grass cut etc but that’s because the neighbours do it themselves.

All searches have come back and I’ve had my report but my solicitor is still awaiting a response from the other side in regards to this issue. The vendors solicitor didn’t send sufficient documentation in regards to this other than “the sellers mother hasn’t paid any service charges for 20 years and we believe the company has now dissolved”. They’ve told us that they will have an indemnity policy put in the contract to protect me incase someone tries to come after me in the future and demand payment. My solicitor isn’t happy with this and has said she doesn’t think the mortgage lender will be either. I don’t understand all this legal talk but I went into her office today and she gave me a few examples which helped me understand the severity of it.

1.	The management company own the outside of the property and are suppose to insure it. Because the company no longer exists the building is currently uninsured and if both flats went up in flames/flooded etc we’d be screwed. 

2.	The management company are responsible for dealing with any repairs etc. We are suppose to pay a monthly service charge to them and in return they deal with any repairs. Because they no longer exist there is no agreement in place which explains who is responsible for what and who pays for what. I’m on the first floor and if a slate fell off my roof and there was water gushing through my ceiling, technically both my neighbour and I would be responsible for paying for the repairs but they could just tell me to piss off and there’s nothing that I could do about it. If the management company was still active it would be their responsibility to enforce that they pay half the bill. The same could apply if they came to me with an issue, I could just tell them to get lost. 

3.	Similar to the above issue. If my downstairs neighbour was playing loud music until 1am, the only thing I could do is go down there and ask them to stop. Again, If the management company existed it would be their responsibility to enforce this. 

4.	If nobody has paid any services charges for over 20 years, then there might not have been any repairs done on the building in quite some time.

Whilst waiting for the other side to come back, my solicitor suggested that I knock the neighbours door to see if I could find out any more information but the lady downstairs wasn’t in today. I’ve left a note with my phone number on asking her to give me a ring to have a quick chat. My solicitor is doing everything that she can but has been honest with me and said that the property might be unmortgageable unless the vendors solicitor can provide sufficient documentation, however I’m not confident that she’ll be able to if the company no longer exists… it will then be up to the lender to make the final decision. It is out of our control now.

Apologies for the very long winded post. My anxiety is through the roof at the minute and it’s awful being told this after 9 weeks of waiting around. Surely things like this happen all the time and there must be a way around it? Sad

OP posts:
Welcometomyhouse · 16/09/2021 11:00

After some digging I found out that all the flats and even some houses on the street are leasehold. I'm not sure why I was told that they were freehold. One flat even sold last year so I wonder how they got around the issue... just really strange.

Just to let everyone know I've decided to withdraw. I've notified my solicitor and the EA (and given reasons why, the EA didn't realise how serious it was apparently). Feeling really down today but I'm sure in the long run, I'll see that I've done the right thing Sad

OP posts:
Bogeyes · 16/09/2021 08:33

There may be problems when you decide to sell

Strangeways19 · 16/09/2021 08:03

That's rough I'm really sorry, people are shite. Is it all EA's?! No wonder they have a crap reputation... They should definitely be more rigidly regulated. We were purchasing a property recently & it was down a private road, EA was clear that there was parking. No parking rights at all after solicitor dug a bit. We pulled out but now we've found a doer upper.

Just a thought, if the other flats are freehold could there be a way of altering the lease to a freehold? Then you could insure it etc

Ann30567 · 16/09/2021 01:26

I am in a situation where I share a freehold with other flat owners. But they don’t do anything. As in, they don’t want to pay any money for fire alarm checks, building insurance and maintenance. So I can see how this has happened in the building that you would like to purchase your flat in. I have been forced to do everything and have to chase them constantly for the money. As a result I am selling as I didn’t sign up to be an unpaid property manager. So I know it is awful but I would advise you to not buy as it will cause you no end of grief.

HalzTangz · 15/09/2021 23:56

@Welcometomyhouse

I know something else will come up one day. I think I will have to take a break for maybe a year or two and try and save a bit more so I have more options. The flat was only 80k (valued at 90 by the mortgage lender). Flats are around 100k upwards around here. I only have a 5% deposit and earn 20k. It doesn't sound like much but it's been hard to save that much whilst renting at the same time. They will only lend me 79k. I've used 3k of my savings to pay off my car loan as the lender wouldn't lend to me unless I paid that off first. Paid it off two weeks ago because I thought everything would be ok and found out a week later that the flat might not even be mortgageable. Just absolutely gutted.
The positive you could take away from this (should the flat fall through) is you could pay what was your car payments on top of what you were paying into your savings account (so say car was £200, and monthly savings was £150, you'd be putting £350 each month into savings. That will soon build up
RedToothBrush · 15/09/2021 23:36

I think the experience of having bought a house before is that its not easy.

Many of us will see a house, think its the one only for there to be complications and it all to fall apart. Its devastating and you start to imagine your whole life around it.

But once youve been through that and then found the right house, its almost as if the other house you had your heart set on doesn't matter. It just wasn't meant to be. And there's not a lot else you could do. And actually its probably for the best anyway.

It does sound like you are too emotionally invested in this on. Take a step back and listen. You are being told to run for the hills by everyone.

Singlebutmarried · 15/09/2021 23:31

For instance 95% ltv 3.69% 85% ltv 1.79 = interest payments per month of £307 vs £149 (interest only but can’t be arsed to work out the C&I repayments on £100k) so £158 per month at least better off by saving that extra deposit

Singlebutmarried · 15/09/2021 23:23

You’re in a good position. You’ve paid off your car loan, now put those payments into savings. If you’ve not already done so set up a LISA as it’ll give you an extra boost to your deposit (there’s a minimum time period you need it for). Get your deposit to 10-15%. You’ll end up paying almost half the interest rates that you will on a 95% mortgage.

For the sake of a years more savings you’ll own another 5-10% of your flat straight away and pay a LOT less for the privilege.

MaggieFS · 15/09/2021 23:04

It fucking sucks and I'm sorry it happened to you. People aren't saying walk away as if it's a simple or easy option, they are saying walk away because if you proceed (if the mortgage lender would even still lend) then the costs you could end up with could be much much more than the £1k you've already spent on the solicitor.

OnTheBoardwalk · 15/09/2021 22:46

I took a gamble on a house and spent 14 years regretting it and having no money. Some things that needed doing I could see many were hidden and came as a lovely surprise

Sorry OP but this house just screams run away as fast as you can

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 15/09/2021 22:33

[quote Welcometomyhouse]@DameFanny I have nothing in writing. They told me about the indemnity policy when I first phoned up to arrange a viewing, it was actually the first thing they said oddly enough. They mentioned it at the viewing too [/quote]
It does truly suck...its a horrid situation and one that MANY people have gone through. It won't always feel this raw.

Anongsr MANY house disappointments over the years... For me and my pals...

We had three sales fall through over a year... It was pants... But now? I just don't move in mentally.... It's just sooo bloody frustrating and upsetting when it falls through for whatever reason. I try and outlay the minimum of money now.

A pal had 4 houses fall through last year...

It really really isn't unusual. Upsetting but mot unusual.

The English system does stink though.

2bazookas · 15/09/2021 22:14

It's not unusual for properties to be unmortgageable; EA adverts sometimes mention that. Sometimes, the reason its unmortgageable also makes it virtually uninsurable.

  Even a cash buyer would  be very reluctant to sink their money into an uninsurable   multiple-occupiers property  in the circumstances and condition  you describe.    The risks  are far too high. 

   When you've found a property you want,  and have begun to imagine living in it, it can be very disappointing to have the deal fall through/go bad (for whatever reason)   But trust me, there are times when you just have to  walk away  to save far worse  grief and  future problems/ disruption.    Learn from it.

     One of the saving graces   to take away from this is that you have found a trustworthy solicitor  who is doing all the right things  for their client.  Patient explanations,  answering questions., good advice.
NoSquirrels · 15/09/2021 22:09

@Welcometomyhouse

Thank you Thanks

@NoSquirrels only last week. The sellers solicitor has been really slow through this whole process and only sent the documents over 6 weeks ago, after my solicitor chased them. I did mention to my solicitor in the beginning about what I'd been told in regards to the indemnity policy but she said she'd have to look at the paperwork once it had come through. I honestly didn't realise it was so serious as the estate agents were so blaze about it and stupid me believed them but I guess they'd sell their mum for a tenner!

In that case I think this is just a case of chalking this up to experience, and doing a lot of research now on how leasehold abc share of freehold that’s work.

If you’d known, you’d have been able to walk away quicker. But if the estate agents stressed it and you went ahead they’ve technically done all they had to in making you aware.

I’m really sorry. Next time will be better.

(PS Stop thinking of rent paid out as ‘paying someone else’s mortgage’ - it’s not 100% accurate. When you buy your own place on a mortgage you’ll still be paying ‘rent’ to the bank in the form of the interest payments, and you’ll be liable for all the expensive bits of home ownership like maintenance and repairs and all the hassle with that. Try to reframe it as your landlord taking the strain for you at the moment! Your time will come and you’ll be prepared when it does.)

Kdubs1981 · 15/09/2021 22:02

Run

whynotwhatknot · 15/09/2021 21:57

Sounds like anightmare but just wondering why you didnt have asurvey done-i know its not a legal requirement but it would have probably brought up all the problems and who knows maybe more

ChargingBuck · 15/09/2021 21:15

@Welcometomyhouse

It's easy for people to say pull out when their not stuck renting and paying off someone else's mortgage! I despise renting and I'm fucking depressed here. Sorry, but I don't think people realise how heartbreaking it is to walk away from something that you've had your heart set on from day 1. All the leg work that my solicitor and I have done and to get to the very last stage and have this happen just fucking sucks. 1k might not be a lot to some people but it is to me. I'm not a cash buyer with thousands in the bank.

I know you're all just trying to be help but sometimes it's just nice to be told that fucking sucks and I'm sorry it happened to you

Hey, PP do understand, & yes - it really sucks.

Paying rent, at a cost that absolutely compromises your ability to save for a deposit is frustrating, & it's no wonder you are disappointed after chasing what looked like a solution to that problem.

But this flat could cost you way more than the £1k you have already shelled out. It could even cost more than a few year's extra rental - property lawyers are not cheap, & 20 years of unpaid leasehold expenses could end up in your lap.

It's good that you are asking your solicitor for a brutal assessment tomorrow. In the example I referenced upthread, I eventually asked the surveyor - "if I were your niece, would you let me buy this house?"
He said "absolutely not, & there would be a family conference if you didn't listen."
I am so glad I listened.

You have every right to feel angry, especially at the estate agents & everyone concerned with making a sale who've been telling you this is do-able. But this is temporary set-back. I've had times in my life when I've taken on evening work in addition to the full time job, in order to scrabble enough cash together to service a mortgage. Are you able to channel all your disappointed energy into any extra work, to help you save up a bigger deposit? It's unfair, but it's real life - you can buy a flat in a few months or years, by coming up with ways of reducing expenditure & increasing income.

Take care, keep looking forward, & you are right - this thwarted purchase experience sucks, but you really are best off out of it.

Lifethroughlenses · 15/09/2021 21:13

Walk away. It’s not worth the financial uncertainty and stress however much you love it.

sgtmajormum · 15/09/2021 21:00

I'd walk away from this purchase.

If the management company is no longer operating then the freeholder is responsible for maintaining the building (although you will most likely be liable for 50% of the costs) and should be arranging buildings insurance which again you should pay your share of.

As it looks like no repairs have been undertaken in a long time then you could end up with large bills as there will be no pot built up as no service charges are being collected.
If you are a first time buyer I would not proceed unless you will be able to afford future unknown bills.

Welcometomyhouse · 15/09/2021 20:49

I know something else will come up one day. I think I will have to take a break for maybe a year or two and try and save a bit more so I have more options. The flat was only 80k (valued at 90 by the mortgage lender). Flats are around 100k upwards around here. I only have a 5% deposit and earn 20k. It doesn't sound like much but it's been hard to save that much whilst renting at the same time. They will only lend me 79k. I've used 3k of my savings to pay off my car loan as the lender wouldn't lend to me unless I paid that off first. Paid it off two weeks ago because I thought everything would be ok and found out a week later that the flat might not even be mortgageable. Just absolutely gutted.

OP posts:
Marleymoo42 · 15/09/2021 20:49

The system is awful. We had to pull out on a house after all sorts of legal issues were revealed. We had paid legal costs, survey etc. We had school places for our kids.

We made the difficult decision to go ahead with the sale of our old house as it has taken so long to get a buyer. We are currently living with family praying this next purchase will go through.

You dont always hear about peoples house buying drama but it's pretty common. Just imagine trying to sell this flat while wanting to buy somewhere else in the future. The person buying it would get 9 weeks in before most likely pulling out. That would be a worse situation than you're in now. Sorry you're going through this.

Vixyboo · 15/09/2021 20:48

I bought a ground floor flat last year. I own it but I pay service charges. This ensures the grounds and buildings are maintained. Let me give you one example: recently they have had all internal doors checked for fire safety. My front door may need replaced following on from this check. It is not something I would have known had they not been involved.

Also, I renewed the lease on my flat at a cost of £15k when I bought it. Otherwise I could have ended up in a few years time with no mortgage company wanting to know about it. You have to be so careful not to end up with a property with no value. You'll be stuck with it.

I appreciate you have emotions towards the property and have called if your flat in your posts, but please don't let emotions override what is happening.

I found a different flat initially, brand new, huge inside but it fell through. I was so gutted. However, where we now live has worked out so much better for us.

Without maintenance for 20 years there are so many problems that building could have not least damp or structural issues. However, fire safety following on from Grenfell would be in my mind first. When they checked our doors recently they explained the Grenfell fire had changed what checks need to be done.

Please seek some advice.

AngelDelightUk · 15/09/2021 20:47

Are they definitely leasehold? I have a maisonette which is a block of four, but my one and the one above have joint freehold on our side, and the other two have joint freehold for theirs. It’s a nightmare in that you have to sort out joint building insurance, but from what I can work out ground rent etc was never paid prior to that

altiara · 15/09/2021 20:43

Are you solicitors bills already £1k?
Mine said they’d only charge for the searches done if I didn’t get to complete on the house. I think that would’ve been a few hundred. (Although they didn’t have leasehold stuff to look into).

Swipe left for the next trending thread