Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not put the house back to what it was?

728 replies

QuantumDog2 · 13/09/2021 21:55

I've rented the house I live in currently for nearly 9 years. When I moved in it was a new build and we were the first to live here, so obviously a buy to let. The walls were all trade paint magnolia and the carpets were cheap, exactly the way new builds are presented as standard.
Over the years I've decorated it and made some improvements like extending the patio and I spend £1400 on new flooring for the lounge because the carpet was worn out by that stage and looked grotty.
Now I'm leaving as I've bought somewhere with my partner, but contractually apparently I have to return the property the way I found it. I'm 6 months pregnant now and don't fancy donning my overalls and climbing ladders to paint. What would you do? I feel like after 9 years here and the time and money I've spent on the place (although my choice totally) I shouldn't really be penalised, but I expect I will lose my deposit?

OP posts:
RitaFires · 15/09/2021 11:30

I don't think anyone is being a cheeky fucker in this situation. It's obviously been a happy home for you for 9 years and part of that was decorating it the way you liked. I wouldn't let the wrangling about the deposit and leaving the property sour your memories of it. The landlord got the impression you were happier doing things yourself and while that wasn't quite the whole truth it seems like it was just a misunderstanding or miscommunication. Hopefully you can work something out amicably.

I wouldn't go around ripping up the patio, that would be only be causing hassle for yourself in terms of making good the garden, but if you want to put back the landlords curtain poles and light fittings you're well within your rights. Don't get bogged down in negativity about a home that served you well when you're moving on to better things. Best of luck with the move.

melj1213 · 15/09/2021 11:17

I think YABU because the LL gave permission for you to paint it whatever colour you wanted on the provisio it was returned to magnolia before you left. You agreed to this so you need to hold up your end of the agreement or accept that they will try and keep at least some of your deposit to do it themselves.

If you said "I want to paint the house but I have no intention painting it back to magnolia when I leave" I imagine they would not have given permission in the first place.

I live in a Housing Association property, when I moved in nearly 2 years ago it needed painting because the previous tenant had painted the bedrooms a dark plum colour, the bathroom about 3 different colours and she had used pink spray paint to graffiti all over the walls in the hall/living room cant imagine why she was evicted so it was more than just "a touch up" and required a good 3/4 coats of paint in each room. Because they wanted a quick turnover and it was only cosmetic work that was required (although it was extensive) the agent gave me two options - I didn't get the keys for another 2 weeks and they would get their contract painter in and it would all be covered up with cheap magnolia, which would be touched up every 3-4 years on the standard maintenance schedule, or they could give me the keys now and £120 vouchers to the local B&Q to put towards doing the decorating myself but it would be my responsibility for any maintenence of said decoration.

I snatched their hands off at the vouchers, spent £20 on brushes/trays/rollers etc, £50 on a couple of 10l tubs of mid-range but decent quality durable pale grey emulsion just to get the walls back to a neutral colour, £10 on a tin of gloss for skirtings/doors and put the other £40 towards paint for the bedrooms. 2 years later and other than the occasional wipe with a magic eraser if there is a scuff markfrom DD dragging her bag against the wall in the hall and I have not had to do any paint touch up at all. Meanwhile my neighbour (who moved in a year ago and whose previous tenant left the place in a decent state so it was just given the magnolia touch up) is always complaining about the quality of the paint job because it scuffs/marks really easily and she is constantly having to wipe down the walls and they constantly look scruffy and worn. She refuses to spend any money on painting though because then she would be responsible for the upkeep and the HA wouldn't repaint again during her tenancy.

Blossomtoes · 15/09/2021 10:51

@peachycream31

If the people viewing at the moment are seeing the house with coloured walls, I BET they'll check if the new tenant wants it back to magnolia before moving in. ...

If they don't, you really shouldn't have to pay for it.

So after you move out, wait and see if it gets painted. If it doesn't and they try to dock you for it ... good arguing point.

Surely though you just say 'I've dove a wood floor and patio and the repainting and fixing necessary to the walls over the years do I don't think it's at all reasonable to ask now for repainting'. ?

This. As I said earlier, if I agreed to rent the place as it is now and found it had turned magnolia when I moved in, I’d be absolutely gutted. Surely the entire point of a bland colour scheme is to maximise its appeal? If it’s appealing without being beige, why bother? I bet that house stays exactly as it is and the ll will pocket the deposit.

Fight it @QuantumDog2.

friendlycat · 15/09/2021 10:19

Not all LLs are rich bastards leeching off people you know! I've been an accidental one after the death of my parents for a period of time. We were exceptionally kind and helpful and even reduced rent when our tenant was struggling.

If it were me I would definitely take the trade of the upgrade of flooring and patio and the fact that you have been a model tenant and I haven't had to pay additional costs throughout this period as you have been there for 9 years.

I would recognise that the place would need an overall now after 9 years duration. But as with most things communication is key here and it's always best to state your case logically, politely and genuinely and then normally a good compromise can be reached all round.

If you calmly state to the agent the improvements that you have made, that will benefit the property for the future, and surely these can be traded for painting back to neutral this may well be sufficient going forward.

It literally depends what type of LL you have as theoretically you need to repaint to neutral as per the agreement. As you can see some people will understand completely and say no need, others will say yes there is a need.

But as with any form of negotiation best to do this calmly without emotion and don't muddy the waters with perceived grievances etc.

MrsMaizel · 15/09/2021 10:11

@QuantumDog2

I couldn't be bothered with that

Sadly you have got yourself into this position by not taking action when you needed to and your LL has just let you get on with it . You are both in the wrong here - them not doing maintenance etc and you not asking for it but at the end of the day it is the LL's property . Hopefully you will be able to reach a suitable agreement and you know better for future . There are as many CF tenants as there are CF LLs.

MrsMaizel · 15/09/2021 10:06

Take the hardwood flooring and the patio ? Do you know how much it would cost the OP to make good on that ?

HPmagic · 15/09/2021 09:48

I have to say your LL are real CF. I would be as petty as you and if they were insistent on the paint then I would change the floor and all the fixtures as you have said.

Also I think you should highlight that the viewers are looking at the home as it is and so if drastic changes are made such as the floor and fixtures then the LL will be in for a shock when new tenants move in.

I've been very lucky to have a brilliant LL who over the past 8 years has relaxed our carpets for us, even let us choose along with their consent. They have fixed everything we have asked for within a few days and allowed us to repaint but they actually paid for the paint for us. In return we have maintained the house to high standards and it is also a new build. Some LL are scum. I would be standing my ground with yours OP

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 15/09/2021 09:47

I am a landlord, @QuantumDog2, and I see your point entirely!

The only reasons I could see for enforcing the return to magnolia is because they think that's what new tenants would prefer, or that it would make it easier to re-let it; OR that if it's magnolia, then they can get someone in to do a job-lot re-paint in one coat to make it look "fresh" again.

I hope the letting agent has been able to talk to your landlord and to say that actually some of the prospectives have really liked the décor. But that may not help in the long run if the "re-decoration" aspect is the actual reason for the clause.

If they insist on the paint job, I would take the hardwood flooring and the patio extension. They lose good will (which, IMO and IME is more valuable than almost anything else in the home rental business!) and so you take back what you otherwise would have left as a goodwill gesture.

billy1966 · 15/09/2021 09:08

And all these viewings while YOU are paying rent.

CF.

Clearly you are far too accomdating for someone who doesn't deserve it.

QuantumDog2 · 15/09/2021 09:01

@billy1966

OP,

Were there any fittings like curtain poles/light fittings in the house when you moved in?

Because if not, it actually beggars belief at the cheek of that LL.

In my 20's I rented lots of flats/apartments/houses and in the main was very lucky with LL.

But if the house was in as raw a state as it seems, it really is extraordinarily cheeky.

Did you do a job on the garden?

Did you cut the grass?

My LL had my grass cut, we never had to do any outside maintenance on HIS property.

Have you planted plants?

There were very cheap curtain poles and light shades in every room, yes. I removed them when I moved in and saved them all in the garage, just incase. The garden was just grass and dandelions up to my knees. I've planted it over the years, mostly with roses because the soil's boggy here, and it looks nice now.

I'm going to give the agents a call shortly and see what's happening, if they spoke to the LL etc. I've got a bunch of viewings this afternoon.

OP posts:
nanbread · 15/09/2021 08:56

I think the LL is a total piss taker. 9 years of no repairs or maintenance, they've had such an easy ride and should be grateful you've kept the place in good condition.

billy1966 · 15/09/2021 08:49

OP,

Were there any fittings like curtain poles/light fittings in the house when you moved in?

Because if not, it actually beggars belief at the cheek of that LL.

In my 20's I rented lots of flats/apartments/houses and in the main was very lucky with LL.

But if the house was in as raw a state as it seems, it really is extraordinarily cheeky.

Did you do a job on the garden?

Did you cut the grass?

My LL had my grass cut, we never had to do any outside maintenance on HIS property.

Have you planted plants?

CuriousaboutSamphire · 15/09/2021 08:27

@GetOffThatPhone That piece also includes

The industry guidance would suggest that if a tenant has lived in a property for five or more years (and they are not required by a contract to carry out redecoration themselves) there is little prospect of success in a claim for costs where the tenant hasn't caused the need for redecoration. and OP says her contract includes a "return to magnolia clause"

All she can do is dispute the claim and see what they decide at arbitration.

ConsuelaHammock · 15/09/2021 08:25

You sound like a lovely tenant. My husband is a landlord and he would let the paintings go.
We had long term tenants once who wallpapered both reception rooms and replaced the carpet with laminate. The paper wasn’t to everyone’s taste but it was neat and tidy and when they left we didn’t insist they change it. The next tenants liked it.
I would offer a trade, your solid floor, curtain poles etc for the walls? I think you’d get your deposit back tbh
Only a real dick would insist on returning walls to magnolia which weren’t even properly painted in the first instance.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 15/09/2021 08:22

[quote BungleandGeorge]@CuriousaboutSamphire
Have you ever seen one of those fire doors in action? They are extremely heavy (as they’re fire doors) and swing shut with some force, they’d break your fingers with no bother. So yes tricky if you’re renting but there is a very good reason to cut them! I’m not sure of the need for a self closing door in a normal family home, but obviously it’s required by building regs[/quote]
Yes. I see them regularly. Many HMOs and properties of 3+ floors.

The 'heaviness' of the closure is adjustable, to account for the various weights of fire door. There shouldn't be a need to cut anything. Especially if you are renting and the bloody thing doesn't belong to you!

Iamthewombat · 15/09/2021 08:21

The issue isn’t whether you “felt proud”, which is irrelevant. It’s your determination to present yourself as a plucky bottom rung striver (not like those rich bastard landlords!) who now deserves to do as she pleases to somebody else’s house because…er…you supposedly “pulled yourself up by your bootstraps” and anyone who didn’t, in your assessment, should just suck up changes you made to their property which you agreed to reverse and now won’t.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 15/09/2021 08:18

[quote fucketyfuckwit]@CuriousaboutSamphire I'm glad we agree! 😁

Have we spoken in the past? A few years back?

I did speak to someone who used to be a teacher and then changed to be an inventory clerk.[/quote]
Yes! We did didn't we? Grin

QuantumDog2 · 15/09/2021 08:07

@Iamthewombat

The only conclusion I can reach is that on the one hand we have property owners who can see it from the landlord's perspective. And on the other hand we have people like me (property owning or not) who have pulled themselves up by their bootstraps and lived on the bottom rung. In my 20s I owned a lovely farmhouse that featured in a national interiors magazine. I've since fallen on hard times it would seem

Eh?

You “owned a lovely farmhouse in your 20s” but simultaneously claim that you “pulled yourself up by your bootstraps”? Owning a farmhouse featured in an interiors magazine in your twenties tends not to be a feature of the lives of people struggling their way out of poverty, which I assume is what you mean by ‘living on the bottom rung’.

In any case, you seem determined to claim that landlords are the opposite of the brave bootstrap-pullers like you. None of them have ever lived on this bottom rung of yours, in your version of the world. I get that you are upset with your landlord but it undermines your argument when you claim that all landlords are rich bastards out to screw over the poor bootstrap pullers and bottom rungers, including those who once owned luxury farmhouses.

It wasn't a luxury farmhouse. It was a derelict mess inhabited by squatters. We worked hard and saved and picked it up for a pittance. So yeah, I do feel proud of that. We did it with no help from anyone else.
OP posts:
StoneofDestiny · 15/09/2021 07:56

Crikey, if I was your landlord and you'd put in hardwood flooring and extended my patio at your own cost aid be grateful! After 9 years the carpets would have to be replaced anyway. As for the paint - I'd let that go as a 'trade'.

JollyAndBright · 15/09/2021 07:50

@QuantumDog2

DP suggests taking the floor up and installing it in our new house. The carpet in the new house is tired and would be replaced by us anyway, so we could do a direct swap. He thinks we should take the patio and everything else I've put in to the house, including nice light fittings and curtain poles (which I would have left) and even digging up the planting I've done in the garden. Then he says he'll get a friend in to paint the whole house white for us. White will be easier according to him because the woodwork and ceilings are white.
Definitely do this.

Your landlord sounds awful and they definitely shouldn’t benefit from your things.

peachycream31 · 15/09/2021 06:51

If the people viewing at the moment are seeing the house with coloured walls, I BET they'll check if the new tenant wants it back to magnolia before moving in. ...

If they don't, you really shouldn't have to pay for it.

So after you move out, wait and see if it gets painted. If it doesn't and they try to dock you for it ... good arguing point.

Surely though you just say 'I've dove a wood floor and patio and the repainting and fixing necessary to the walls over the years do I don't think it's at all reasonable to ask now for repainting'. ?

Iamthewombat · 15/09/2021 05:06

The only conclusion I can reach is that on the one hand we have property owners who can see it from the landlord's perspective. And on the other hand we have people like me (property owning or not) who have pulled themselves up by their bootstraps and lived on the bottom rung. In my 20s I owned a lovely farmhouse that featured in a national interiors magazine. I've since fallen on hard times it would seem

Eh?

You “owned a lovely farmhouse in your 20s” but simultaneously claim that you “pulled yourself up by your bootstraps”? Owning a farmhouse featured in an interiors magazine in your twenties tends not to be a feature of the lives of people struggling their way out of poverty, which I assume is what you mean by ‘living on the bottom rung’.

In any case, you seem determined to claim that landlords are the opposite of the brave bootstrap-pullers like you. None of them have ever lived on this bottom rung of yours, in your version of the world. I get that you are upset with your landlord but it undermines your argument when you claim that all landlords are rich bastards out to screw over the poor bootstrap pullers and bottom rungers, including those who once owned luxury farmhouses.

WineInTheBlood · 15/09/2021 02:00

@QuantumDog2 Oh no! Don't! Moving house is the most stressful thing after divorce and death (or something like that 😄) so this is an added complication you don't need. You're definitely not a fool.
The thing is you've mentally written off your deposit so what's the worst that can happen? Personally I think you'll get your deposit back, but regardless, don't pay any more attention to anyone on here being twattish towards you.

WhoIsPepeSilva · 15/09/2021 01:53

I'm not a LL, have never and probably never will own property OP I can totally see things from your perspective. I'm not sat in my ivory tower FWIW.

QuantumDog2 · 15/09/2021 01:46

[quote WineInTheBlood]@QuantumDog2 True - and so take it with a big pinch of salt. You could post on AIBU about wanting to donate a kidney and someone would call you entitled.
You'll be fine - don't stress any more about it. Good luck with the move. [/quote]
Ahh, you've made me bawl again! So much going on in my life at the moment, I could literally have 30 threads going on here. But this stupid paint thing is the hill I choose to die on... I'm a fool.
Thank you for your kindness, I'll try and remember that posting on AIBU only ever ends in tears. x

OP posts: