Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is the competitive under eating on mumsnet harmful?

406 replies

foreverlobsters · 13/09/2021 20:35

Full disclaimer- I have a history of eating disorders myself so am possibly over sensitive to this.

Have been reading through another currently active thread as well as what we eat in a day etc (which I occasionally post on and do find interesting). Why do people feel the need to post about their extremely low calorie days on here, or give potentially harmful advice? What's the incentive exactly- and are these people lying about how much they really eat or is most of the mumsnet population in an extreme calorie deficit? Do these people not see how selfish and damaging these posts can be?

OP posts:
BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 15/09/2021 11:51

My GP has told me that the 1200 I was following is actually the max for me as a menopausal woman and I should be looking to reduce that…. 🤷‍♀️

This is complete bullshit advice. I know lots of active menopausal and post-menopausal women who climb/run/bike regularly, maintain a healthy weight, maintain good levels of muscle, and eat a lot more than 1200 calories a day.

NumberTheory · 14/09/2021 22:49

LindaEllen
Shallwegoforawalk
Everybody burns at least 1500 calories even if they're in a bloody coma.

Well that's shite for a start.

Educate yourself. There's lots of literature online that you can read

There is lots of literature. You could look at the penn state equations for calculating RMR, which do not suggest everyone burns at least 1500 calories in a coma, certainly not someone my size, sex and age. And then you could look at the literature that finds, while they’re some of the best predictive equations out there, they’re still wrong nearly 30% of the time because our bodies aren’t all identical replicas of some average. Some people need more, some people need less.

These statements that we all need something when lots of people don’t are also harmful - setting people up to feel like failures when they find trying to stick to advice based on averages leaves them constantly failing.

Bluntness100 · 14/09/2021 21:19

@PurpleDaisies

The thread on restaurant portion sizes was full of posters judging anyone who could eat a whole meal at one of those with bigger portion sizes.
No it wasn’t. It was full of people taking the piss out of folks who said they couldn’t eat a whole portion 😂
Birdkin · 14/09/2021 21:11

@Neonplant

Yanbu. They're full of the types of people who proclaimed fruit is unhealthy because its full of sugar. I sometimes have a laugh at the food posts on here. It's a running joke with my partner when we are working out how much food to cook. We will say to each other how many mumsnetter's would that feed etc.
And the people who think it’s child abuse to let a toddler have an apple because of the sugar….
Neonplant · 14/09/2021 21:05

Yanbu. They're full of the types of people who proclaimed fruit is unhealthy because its full of sugar. I sometimes have a laugh at the food posts on here. It's a running joke with my partner when we are working out how much food to cook. We will say to each other how many mumsnetter's would that feed etc.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 14/09/2021 21:05

I love the baked beans in the corner of the infograph 😂

TatianaBis · 14/09/2021 20:54

72% in South Yorkshire. Shock

It's a good thing we don't need an army.

lljkk · 14/09/2021 20:52

People lie on the Internet & spout nonsense?!
Who knew?

Fatness by geography can be looked up... no need to speculate on where the fattest kids are.
I'm in London right now. The very striking thing is how young people are. Way younger median age than what I'm used to in the provinces. And weird. I adore all the weirdness. I have found my (weird) people.

I had a brief chat with a very young beggar yesterday. He looked no more than 19. I hope he's ok given the awful weather this morning.

Or is the competitive under eating on mumsnet harmful?
Or is the competitive under eating on mumsnet harmful?
Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:42

@PurpleDaisies

The thread on restaurant portion sizes was full of posters judging anyone who could eat a whole meal at one of those with bigger portion sizes.
Well if the portions are too big, sharing a portion is not undereating is it? You'd need a photo of the portion, to know the people's sizes and what else they've eaten that day to be able to judge.
Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:41

"I am not going to search mumsnet to give you examples of "omg 1 takeaway chinese main course and 4 spring rolls do 4 of us for dinner" type of posts."

Having seen the portions of the Chinese place near my parents, I wouldn't be able to tell that's undereating without seeing a photo. Some takeaway places really do have massive portions, as do fish and chips.

Anyway, you still haven't been able to give me a real example.

PurpleDaisies · 14/09/2021 20:40

The thread on restaurant portion sizes was full of posters judging anyone who could eat a whole meal at one of those with bigger portion sizes.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:39

@Comedycook

Yes in Chelsea and Kensington I'm always struck by how few overweight people you see and the pavements are packed with joggers. Head over to Lewisham or other less affluent areas of London and I can assure you it's a different story
It made me laugh to see all the very thin people running.
Annoyedanddissapointed · 14/09/2021 20:38

@grasstreeleaf

Don't know *@Annoyedanddissapointed* but it would be fascinating finding out!
I have no idea how it crossed my mind. 😂 MyfirePal where the dragon painstakingly logs all villagers and sheep he/she consumed for lunch
TatianaBis · 14/09/2021 20:38

I haven't really seen it on here, but I've definitely met in people in r/l who see over-indulgence as a character failing.

Perhaps the same with exercise. Some people do lots and think it's really important, and others really cba.

I do think some exercise fanatics judge the couch potatoes in a similar way.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 14/09/2021 20:36

@Gwenhwyfar

"There were always plenty..."

Yet, you can't give an example...

I am not going to search mumsnet to give you examples of "omg 1 takeaway chinese main course and 4 spring rolls do 4 of us for dinner" type of posts.
Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:35

@Comedycook

There was thread ages ago about the Duchess of Cambridge and her figure and loads of posters saying how she's not that thin and they have exactly the same body shape as her, and we've all lost sight of a healthy weight blah blah. Other posters who had seen her irl had commented that she was one of the thinnest people they'd ever seen. It was quite interesting.
And everyone is entitled to their opinion aren't they? Unless it's known that she is underweight, people can consider her the right size or too thin according to their own preferences.
grasstreeleaf · 14/09/2021 20:32

Don't know @Annoyedanddissapointed but it would be fascinating finding out!

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:32

"There were always plenty..."

Yet, you can't give an example...

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:32

"The two are in no way equivalent, though. Society prizes thinness, so even someone who is insulted for her thin body has the ingrained knowledge that her body type is generally approved of and sought after. A fat person knows the opposite — that her body type is viewed as evidence of greed, poor impulse control, poor diet, lack of exercise, poverty etc."

Society prizes thinnes and slimmnes, but not skininess so people can be skinny shamed the same as fat shamed. There are plenty of negative stereotypes about those society considers 'too' thin.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 14/09/2021 20:31

@Gwenhwyfar

" The problem with the undereating posts in my view isn't that people say they eat very little, it's that so many of them say everyone should be eating very little, insist they feel revulsion and disgust at the idea of eating more, and that it's presented as a moral issue, with eating more being some sort of character failing. I've never seen that with a post about overeating."

Give an example of such a post.
I read a lot of the food and dieting threads and never see anything like this.

There were always plenty...
Annoyedanddissapointed · 14/09/2021 20:30

How many calories can dragon burn when they create and breath fire🤔 Daily workout of 3 sets of 10 push ups and 3 sets of 10 seconds of fire breathing. 😂

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:30

" The problem with the undereating posts in my view isn't that people say they eat very little, it's that so many of them say everyone should be eating very little, insist they feel revulsion and disgust at the idea of eating more, and that it's presented as a moral issue, with eating more being some sort of character failing. I've never seen that with a post about overeating."

Give an example of such a post.
I read a lot of the food and dieting threads and never see anything like this.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:28

@Kiwiinparis

100% agree! I’ve read some threads where people only eat one proper meal a day plus 2 coffees and a piece of fruit…that is NOT healthy and can trigger people with EDs so easily.
Maybe they're doing the 5:2 or whatever. Maybe their one meal is big enough. Maybe they can eat what they want and people EDs can stay away from the threads.
TatianaBis · 14/09/2021 20:28

Can't bear Jo Malone but even that is less grim than eau de malice.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/09/2021 20:26

"Although calories are a load of outdated bollocks anyway! I can’t believe so many people live by them."

Oh, do they not exist any more?