Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is the competitive under eating on mumsnet harmful?

406 replies

foreverlobsters · 13/09/2021 20:35

Full disclaimer- I have a history of eating disorders myself so am possibly over sensitive to this.

Have been reading through another currently active thread as well as what we eat in a day etc (which I occasionally post on and do find interesting). Why do people feel the need to post about their extremely low calorie days on here, or give potentially harmful advice? What's the incentive exactly- and are these people lying about how much they really eat or is most of the mumsnet population in an extreme calorie deficit? Do these people not see how selfish and damaging these posts can be?

OP posts:
grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:25

average people without the OPs eating disorder history are still going to feel pretty shit about themselves after reading competitive under eating threads.

But who is average? As I have said I don't feel shit. I might feel sorry for them if for one reason or another they can't eat very much.

Am I less average than you?

foreverlobsters · 15/09/2021 14:24

@Blondebakingmumma

I don’t get it. You have an ED, so instead of leaving the dieting threads well alone, you are going to report them???

Leave the poor people who are trying to be healthy alone. They may have diabetes and have been told by their dr to lose weight and are looking for support. You don’t know their story and you are not their dr so don’t know if they have been told to eat 1200 cal a day.

There are drs recommending fasting and using it in their clinics with patients. Again, it’s none of your business if people choose to eat in a time restricted window. Leave them be and stick to AIBU or relationships boards

I feel this is very unfair.

Firstly with regards to 'leave the poor people alone'- I'm not trying to attack dieters trying to better their health, and have repeatedly said I'm not attacking a 1200 calorie diet either- that's all come from other posters. So please don't insinuate I'm trying to attack a vulnerable group when I've never mentioned anything along those lines.

Secondly, the problem isn't just on the dieting boards, as many people have pointed out now. It eeks its way through to AIBU and chat on a fairly regular basis.

I am sorry about the 'poor people' you mention, and of course they should be able to access support they need to improve their diets, but that doesn't mean that other vulnerable people with present and historic eating disorders should be subject to damaging and disturbing posts that wouldn't be amiss on a pro ana site. Surely a balance of posts is possible with some moderation.

OP posts:
Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 14:22

@NewYearNewTwatName

Annoyedanddissapointed

absolutely and I think it what OP was getting at. average people without the OPs eating disorder history are still going to feel pretty shit about themselves after reading competitive under eating threads.

And yes I think if average people do post its then just a nice thread about what different people eat.

But if when a normal eater posts what they eat, only then to be told "oh my goodness, I could never manage that amount" it again makes that poster feel shit, and other people reading it, then less people post about an average diet. leaving a thread to competitive under eaters. it's like a vicious circle.

You are absolutely correct!
grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:16

And tbh what I eat would read as normal. I have just carefully adjusted portions for my needs. Fried eggs on toast for breakfast with tea. Chilli with cheese on top and a side of hummus on crackers with a coffee and a chocolate for lunch. Not particularly unusual eating.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:12

I don't actually feel bad when I read of posters eating less than me. I just think, well, maybe I burn more through activity than them.

When I was struggling to lose weight, I felt hopeful reading them that I wasn't 'magic' somehow (not needing of much food to an almost miraculous level) and there were others like me and worse off than me that put on weight easily if they ate what other people claim are healthy portions.

I did lose all my excess weight which puts me at the lower end of healthy BMI. But that is my small frame. I've a good body fat percentage now which wasn't the case at higher BMIs I did have to up my exercise and adjust portion sizes to achieve this. I also increased my salad/non starchy veg portions. Once I got used to the difference though I still felt like I was eating the same amount. Takes me the same amount of time to eat my meal as everyone else. It's amazing the physiological cues with appetite (along with physical cues such as sugar levels and heavily industrialised food designed to be extremely more-ish).

I think if you go in with the attitude that everyone has individual needs and copes with them differently then you are less likely to feel bad in comparisons.

NewYearNewTwatName · 15/09/2021 14:11

Annoyedanddissapointed

absolutely and I think it what OP was getting at. average people without the OPs eating disorder history are still going to feel pretty shit about themselves after reading competitive under eating threads.

And yes I think if average people do post its then just a nice thread about what different people eat.

But if when a normal eater posts what they eat, only then to be told "oh my goodness, I could never manage that amount" it again makes that poster feel shit, and other people reading it, then less people post about an average diet. leaving a thread to competitive under eaters. it's like a vicious circle.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 13:58

@NewYearNewTwatName i can see what you mean by that wobble.
I am on a diet and lost 50kilo by now. I eat waaaay more than half of posters on one of these threads together🤷🏻 I absolutely get why it would give someone a wobble!

NewYearNewTwatName · 15/09/2021 13:54

YANBU

I remember the first time I read "what do you eat in a day" thread in chat. I was just being nosey and maybe get some inspiration for different meals.

I found it really weird after reading the first 2 pages and it was just people living on a handful pine nuts and small drop of yogurt Confused I kept reading thinking when are the normal eaters going to turn up? I think all the ridicules diet posts put normal posters off posting.

So although I wasn't going to post as was just being nosey I decided to post to try and encourage some balance, but I think it was too late in the thread and any normal person would have already closed it or were probably feeling shit about what they eat.

My daily diet post looked so extreme to everything else posted and probably looked goady to the undereaters. I don't have a problem with food or my body, but even I had a little wobble after posting wondering if I maybe do eat crap.

Luckily the wobble lasted all of a minute, but I can imagine some other people being more affected by it. if they already have some insecurities about their weight or body.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 13:43

And gain I think bone frame size will affect a lot. I'm almost coming to the conclusion it is a missing link in all things metabolic. I am small framed (small wrists, narrow hip bone to hip bone, narrow shoulders, small waist). I'm probably have the same bodily area as someone shorter but of more average build. It does affect muscle mass and how much fat looks right on your frame and how much food you need to sustain you.

BelleOfTheProvince · 15/09/2021 13:34

And I'm pre menopausal and a normal intake of 2000 pushed up my BMI to 29. That's one point from obesity.
The point is different people's bodies respond differently to different types of food. And your body doesn't respond the same throughout your life either. You might be able to maintain a size ten even with overeating in your twenties, but perhaps your hormones or medication pushes you into a larger BMI in your 40s.

Just because you can get away with xyz doesn't mean everyone can. It actually comes across as kind of fat shaming if people go around saying you can eat 2000 calories and have a great BMI. It implies that those that can't do that are gluttonous and must be overeating.
A lot of our weight is down to genetics and people can't help that. I have nothing but respect for people who have unhealthy bmis and lose the weight through dieting. Especially as they have to entirely change their lifestyle and to some extent ignore their body's (mistaken) signals.
I do, however question the motives of people who feel the need to police those trying to lose weight.
And to be honest, if you are prone to putting on weight a whole portion of fish and chips would impact your BMI if you did it regularly enough. So for those of us that have worked hard to lose weight we might portion it out as an occasional treat, nothing wrong with that.
But I have yet to see these threads in the wild, so I can't possibly comment on that. All I would say is that if you are that effected by others' eating habits then social media is probably not for you.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 13:30

The thing about calories is that individual people do have different requirements. I run, walk and do resistance exercises daily but if I eat more than say, 1800 cals I usually find myself putting on a bit of weight. So I just adjust my portions accordingly and watch my weight. I sometimes go over and am sometimes under. People are different heights, have different muscle mass and even if they exercise might be sedentary for a lot of the day, have different fitness levels. It all affects how many calories are burnt.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 13:25

I think the thing about children's lunch boxes is that so many are policed by the schools. They get notes about not having a yoghurt and fruit as that is classed as 2 desserts or something equally as stupid. Of course many people on here are school staff so will stick up for school policies....

PickAChew · 15/09/2021 13:16

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

My GP has told me that the 1200 I was following is actually the max for me as a menopausal woman and I should be looking to reduce that…. 🤷‍♀️

This is complete bullshit advice. I know lots of active menopausal and post-menopausal women who climb/run/bike regularly, maintain a healthy weight, maintain good levels of muscle, and eat a lot more than 1200 calories a day.

Quite. I'm post-menopausal, now and consume 1800-2000 calories a day and maintain a bmi of 23.5 without being the least bit athletic. My carb tolerance is a lot less than it used to be, though.
Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 13:13

Leave them be and stick to AIBU

That's actually where the problem is @Blondebakingmumma
The weightloss section is still OK compared to some of the crazy stuff out here

Bbq1 · 15/09/2021 13:09

@Nonicknamesforcatapillars

I’m always amazed by the under eating that goes on on mumsnet. It’s almost as if it’s some sort of competition.

I’ve made a mental note not to every post a good thread. One poster asked about her toddlers perfectly normal and acceptable diet and she was torn to shreds!! You’d think she’d been feeding the child mcdonnalds and ben and Jerry’s, mixed with lard, for every meal if you went by some of the comments!

Then there's the dc who only take cous cous and hummus in their lunchbox, they love eating eaw artichokes and as a very rare treat have a hm sugar free flapjack...suppodedly. Or all the faux shocked posters exclaiming that a teenage bowl is actually snacking... Ridiculous
Blondebakingmumma · 15/09/2021 13:04

I don’t get it. You have an ED, so instead of leaving the dieting threads well alone, you are going to report them???

Leave the poor people who are trying to be healthy alone. They may have diabetes and have been told by their dr to lose weight and are looking for support. You don’t know their story and you are not their dr so don’t know if they have been told to eat 1200 cal a day.

There are drs recommending fasting and using it in their clinics with patients. Again, it’s none of your business if people choose to eat in a time restricted window. Leave them be and stick to AIBU or relationships boards

TreeSmuggler · 15/09/2021 12:43

I have yet to see anything about 'thinso' in the diets section. Just people with overweight or obese bmis trying to do better for themselves.

Yes, this is the type of post I see most often, more than both over and under eating posts. It is always an OP that really is overweight, they describe how they are cutting back a bit only to get replies like "noooo OP you are undereating, you are going to be malnourished, that's starvation, you need to eat at least twice that". As if a person 25 kg overweight is going to skip breakfast and fall down dead!

I think the replies are mostly overweight people who don't like the idea that it is healthy to diet. They want to believe that being overweight is one thing, but cutting back calories is very dangerous, and definitely not something to try. Along with a few naturally thin/normal size people who can't understand that some people want more food but need less.

EverdeRose · 15/09/2021 12:41

@Annoyedanddissapointed

Exactly, this isn't people seeking advise on how to lose weight on a dieting board.
Its people asking if they've been fleeced for fish and chips, or if pie and mash is a good choice for a school friend coming for tea.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 15/09/2021 12:39

@BelleOfTheProvince

I have yet to see anything about 'thinso' in the diets section. Just people with overweight or obese bmis trying to do better for themselves.

And I have only just begun to lose weight oh so slowly with a 1200 calorie limit. So thin people telling me it's unhealthy is kinda goady.

It's very easy to preach about being healthy if you are a size ten. And people with eating disorders should have the self control to stay away from weight loss threads.

It sounds increasingly like people would like to pull the support from people who genuinely need to lose weight and rely on those threads for morale support. If I see a recipe I don't like on there, guess what, revelation, I don't use it.

The competitive underrating is rife throughout the site, nothing to do with the specific weight loss section. You only have to read the examples in this thread to see that.

Obviously a weight loss thread will involve calorie restriction, that's expected, the example a few posts above is about someone complaining of the price of fish and chips and all the comments it pulls on how much food that it and stories about how little people eat in comparison. That is harmful.

And that's just one example, many threads on AIBU and Chat have instances of competitive under eating.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 12:36

I think people are missing the fact that these undereating posts are not in the diet section (though there haslve been some very questionable posts in there in past, but that's gone away), but they are on AIBU and chat etc.
I mean feel free to test it and start a thread about whether 1 tin of tuna is a portion or really 2 as can suggests.

DoubleEx · 15/09/2021 12:35

I agree that MN has a very weird attitude to eating. It's either take aways three nights a week and a bottle of wine with a tub of Ben & Jerry's in one sitting, or it's half a can of soup and a massive salad to last you through the day.

It creeps into threads about children's diets as well. All the sugar in fruit! Ridiculous. No one ever got fat eating six apples a day.

The saddest, strangest thing I ever read on here with regards to eating was one poster who said that she had cut sugar from her diet almost completely and if she ever fancied something sweet, she would toast a piece of dry bread and eat it because the sugar crystallised on the outside or something. I think she was talking about the breadcrumbs toasting on the surface, but in her head that was 'sugar'. I just remember thinking fucking hell, life is so short and there she is in her kitchen, miserably munching on dry toast for a cheap sugar thrill, all just to stay thin enough (enough for who? for what?).

I still get depressed thinking about it.

BelleOfTheProvince · 15/09/2021 12:29

I have yet to see anything about 'thinso' in the diets section. Just people with overweight or obese bmis trying to do better for themselves.

And I have only just begun to lose weight oh so slowly with a 1200 calorie limit. So thin people telling me it's unhealthy is kinda goady.

It's very easy to preach about being healthy if you are a size ten. And people with eating disorders should have the self control to stay away from weight loss threads.

It sounds increasingly like people would like to pull the support from people who genuinely need to lose weight and rely on those threads for morale support. If I see a recipe I don't like on there, guess what, revelation, I don't use it.

EverdeRose · 15/09/2021 12:23

I remember one mumsnetter feeling fleeced as her DH was charged nearly 50 quid for chip shop fish and chips for a family of four or something similar. She put her order up, something like 4 chips, 2 fish, 2 battered sausage, large curry large peas.
She was annihilated by mumsnetters claiming 1 portion of fish and chips could feed a family of 4 for a week.

There's also the regular aghastness at serving mash or chips with pie, apparently the crust is carb enough.

In my entire working life the majority of people either take or buy sandwiches for lunch. But the on here it's leftovers from the massive salad at 6 day chicken or 3 almonds and a green tea.

Viviennemary · 15/09/2021 12:04

Some GPs are totally clueless re dietary issues. I think try 1500 without too many carbs or sugar say for a couple of weeks.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 15/09/2021 12:01

@NiceGerbil

It's really hard to avoid threads that are a thing you have issues with yourself.

When I had pnd and anxiety and got irrational about a ridiculous thing, I was like a moth to a flame on threads that looked to be related.

Is it a certain topic? Hide it?
If there's a thread title that hits you hide it and go and do something else for a bit might make you less likely to go looking?

Recognising disordered eating isn't 'irrational' though. Yes OP has specific issues and the threads may also be triggering, but there are many that don't realise that their eating habits aren't healthy, and making posts about not eating for over 24 hours and having others validate it is harmful.

It's like the 'thinspo' movement, very harmful in its influence and social media sites like Instagram work hard to block access to those types of posts. There's nothing wrong with talking about it and making suggestions like some have in this post for MN admins to be a bit more selective with the threads they allow.