Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is the competitive under eating on mumsnet harmful?

406 replies

foreverlobsters · 13/09/2021 20:35

Full disclaimer- I have a history of eating disorders myself so am possibly over sensitive to this.

Have been reading through another currently active thread as well as what we eat in a day etc (which I occasionally post on and do find interesting). Why do people feel the need to post about their extremely low calorie days on here, or give potentially harmful advice? What's the incentive exactly- and are these people lying about how much they really eat or is most of the mumsnet population in an extreme calorie deficit? Do these people not see how selfish and damaging these posts can be?

OP posts:
BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 15/09/2021 20:38

But that poster didn't say her GP had said 1200 calories was the maximum for her personally (which might have been true if she was small/sedentary). She said that her GP had said it was the maximum for a menopausal woman. Which is utter bollocks.

Gwenhwyfar · 15/09/2021 19:20

@BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand

My GP has told me that the 1200 I was following is actually the max for me as a menopausal woman and I should be looking to reduce that…. 🤷‍♀️

This is complete bullshit advice. I know lots of active menopausal and post-menopausal women who climb/run/bike regularly, maintain a healthy weight, maintain good levels of muscle, and eat a lot more than 1200 calories a day.

Maybe those women are taller than the poster and they're obviously more active.
Lavender24 · 15/09/2021 16:06

I think it varies hugely how much people can eat to maintain a healthy weight. I'm only 4'11 and 30 year old. I'm a size 8-10 and weigh around 7 stone which is a healthy weight for my height and a size I'm not comfortable going above, I'm also very very active and work out nearly every day as well as doing a lot of walking but if I eat more than 1200ish I gain weight quite rapidly. I've also had bulimia for 16 years so my metabolism is probably a bit buggered, as is my stomach so I can't deal with large amounts of food or heavy carbs.

I don't find the food threads triggering for the same reasons as you OP but it does upset me to see people casually talking about eating dead animals so I avoid these threads and if a thread I'm reading starts to bother me for whatever reason then I just stop reading.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 15:53

@Annoyedanddissapointed how do you think it'd go? Only one way for you to find out!Grin

Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 15:51

And I would say, really? We must burn different amounts of calories

Coming back because I wonder how this would go down on the currently running snack thread😂

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 15:47

@NewYearNewTwatName

you are very self congratulating,

Yay, go me! 👏

yet at the same time missing the bigger picture.

Oh, I, um, see....And that would be that you are right albeit with the same opinion as me but you still know more than me, just because.... you're you.

As I said we are actually on the same page, but you seem blind to the overall effect on many women who are less as enlightened as you.

Why thank you for that acknowledgment (re. enlightenment. I'll take it) But no, I'm not blind. If you reread my posts you see I acknowledge this however also acknowledge competing needs and triggers. The nuance is so tricksy to get across. In other words you can't please all of the people all of the time. Most of them don't actually want to be pleased.

The threads need more input from average eaters to help with balance. but many are put off, I've posted the reasons already.

Who is this average person? You see, I actually don't believe they truly exist. People on here tend to recognise 'average' to be people like them. Everyone has a different perception of average, a different tribe they align to.

We could could have a discussion on how best to achieve the goal of how to make these threads less about competitive under eating and more about the difference in bodies and the effects of different foods to different people.

Happy to. Smile

NewYearNewTwatName · 15/09/2021 15:30

@NewYearNewTwatName arguing is a bit strong. I've a moderate, nuanced viewpoint. It can come across as agreeable or disagreeable depending upon how polarised your own viewpoint is.wink

😂 that you are polarising my view.

you are very self congratulating, yet at the same time missing the bigger picture.

As I said we are actually on the same page, but you seem blind to the overall effect on many women who are less as enlightened as you.

the under eating threads do have a detrimental effect on many women not just poster with previous ED who are 'triggered' hate that word

As much as you wish everybody could be so confident in there diet and appearance as you. its simply isn't the case.

Were as I don't believe these food threads should not exist, I am trying to point out why they can be detrimental to peoples healthy relationship with food and their bodies. The threads need more input from average eaters to help with balance. but many are put off, I've posted the reasons already.

not commenting on how big someone else potion is, is a start.

We could could have a discussion on how best to achieve the goal of how to make these threads less about competitive under eating and more about the difference in bodies and the effects of different foods to different people.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 15:14

@BelleOfTheProvince, thanks, certainly one for the list. I've just recently read the incredibly frustrating but entertaining 'Burn' by Herman Pontzer and the less frustrating and but equally enjoyable 'Exercised' by Daniel Lieberman. Smile

BelleOfTheProvince · 15/09/2021 15:09

@grasstreeleaf

And I am a bit obsessed with all things weight, fitness and metabolism because I find it extremely interesting. I don't think that is necessarily dysfunctional. I am just drawn to subjects that to some extent even alludes the scientific community. Controversy is always endlessly fascinating. It's why people love to present polarised viewpoints.
If you haven't read it already you might like 'Why we eat too much'. Lots of science and exploration about how our genes etc. Effect our metabolism.
grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 15:06

The problem is posts are mere snippets of thoughts which continually interrupt each other and it takes a much more lengthy (book's worth) of prose to coherently do the subject matter justice.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 15:02

@NewYearNewTwatName, arguing is a bit strong. I've a moderate, nuanced viewpoint. It can come across as agreeable or disagreeable depending upon how polarised your own viewpoint is.Wink

NewYearNewTwatName · 15/09/2021 15:00

yes we are on the same page apparently, but you keep arguing against it. Your posts are all over place.

BelleOfTheProvince · 15/09/2021 14:59

[quote grasstreeleaf]@Annoyedanddissapointed & @NewYearNewTwatName

Eh?

I'm just saying the solution is to just keep pushing the message that everyone has differing needs. Not silence just about every thread because of a wide range competing triggers around food, weight, health and metabolism.[/quote]
This is the solution.

That and staying away if you have eating disorders.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:56

@Annoyedanddissapointed & @NewYearNewTwatName

Eh?

I'm just saying the solution is to just keep pushing the message that everyone has differing needs. Not silence just about every thread because of a wide range competing triggers around food, weight, health and metabolism.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 14:53

@grasstreeleaf

Oh my god, did you just say eggS as in more than one? Gosh, I would be stuffed. But the again I wouldn't have the toast because I can't eat carbs at all. Few eggwites with dash of -enter obscure spice or sauce- will do me until dinner. No wonder we have obesity crisis.

And I would say, really? We must burn different amounts of calories.

Mate
NewYearNewTwatName · 15/09/2021 14:51

grasstreeleaf

oh for goodness sake, its wasn't about you 🙄

Are you the person who comments on how much more another poster has eaten?
I take it you aren't by everything you said. so what is it you a are defending here?

all I've done is explain how these threads do turn into competitive eating threads, and why the OP worries about them.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:47

Oh my god, did you just say eggS as in more than one? Gosh, I would be stuffed. But the again I wouldn't have the toast because I can't eat carbs at all. Few eggwites with dash of -enter obscure spice or sauce- will do me until dinner.
No wonder we have obesity crisis.

And I would say, really? We must burn different amounts of calories.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:43

@NewYearNewTwatName

grasstreeleaf

you are being disingenuous.

average food intake a cross many people people is very broad, then you have the extremes either side. The threads we are talking about have a hefty amount of one end of the extreme posting on them.
and I have already explained the vicious circle, and society pressure and judgement on women and girls, meaning it can often not take much for an average eater to feel out of sink, and a bit shit after a comment on their potion size or daily intake.

Think on a bit.

No, I've just probably read more of these threads than you. You get the competitive over eaters and the competitive under eaters. Along with the people that accuse everyone else of being disordered or dysfunctional or dishonest if they have a different viewpoint to their own.
grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:40

And I am a bit obsessed with all things weight, fitness and metabolism because I find it extremely interesting. I don't think that is necessarily dysfunctional. I am just drawn to subjects that to some extent even alludes the scientific community. Controversy is always endlessly fascinating. It's why people love to present polarised viewpoints.

NewYearNewTwatName · 15/09/2021 14:37

grasstreeleaf

you are being disingenuous.

average food intake a cross many people people is very broad, then you have the extremes either side. The threads we are talking about have a hefty amount of one end of the extreme posting on them.
and I have already explained the vicious circle, and society pressure and judgement on women and girls, meaning it can often not take much for an average eater to feel out of sink, and a bit shit after a comment on their potion size or daily intake.

Think on a bit.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:36

But healthy bodies shouldn’t have rolls of fat

Hah! I still have an albeit small stomach overhang but am at lower BMI and in the 'fitness' range for fat percentage. I exercise more than most people. I thus maintain that for all my life the usual requirements are either not quite right for me and I am doing it wrong somehow or that bodies all do look a bit different and are made up differently.

grasstreeleaf · 15/09/2021 14:31

I think the answer is to firmly remember what you eat really is not a competition if you read these threads. Whether that is how much you eat or how little. Secondly everybody's bodies really are different with very different needs and composition and weights.

That is the real solution. Otherwise discussion is brought to a standstill because everyone has competing needs and is triggered by different things. I might feel triggered by overeating you might feel triggered by under eating. If you can't do that maybe just step away and keep telling yourself everyone if different and it is stupid to compete over how much we eat.

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 15/09/2021 14:30

@Comedycook

lots of posters chimed in with the usual people just don't know what healthy bodies look like anymore, people are just jealous because you are slim, you sound perfectly healthy to me

Yes I hear this all the time!

But healthy bodies shouldn’t have rolls of fat. I’m not sure why pointing that out is such an issue! Yes bodies are different shapes and sizes. But rolls of fat are rolls of fat and you’ve got them because you’ve eaten too much.

Let’s call a spade a fucking spade eh.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 14:30

@grasstreeleaf

And tbh what I eat would read as normal. I have just carefully adjusted portions for my needs. Fried eggs on toast for breakfast with tea. Chilli with cheese on top and a side of hummus on crackers with a coffee and a chocolate for lunch. Not particularly unusual eating.
Oh my god, did you just say eggS as in more than one? Gosh, I would be stuffed. But the again I wouldn't have the toast because I can't eat carbs at all. Few eggwites with dash of -enter obscure spice or sauce- will do me until dinner. No wonder we have obesity crisis.

Btw I am pretty sure I am that persone with obscure spices and sauce too, no hard feelings. And yes, your food looks absolutely normal and nice to people who aren't trying to make shit up

NewYearNewTwatName · 15/09/2021 14:27

grasstreeleaf

I think you missed my point in the second post.

if it's just a thread about what different people eat its interesting but the food threads are a magnet to weight obsessed people, Who then comment on others intake being far too much for them..... and as there is likely more competitive under eaters already on the thread it swings out of balance.

Add in that as a society young girls and women grow up with the whole weight and appearance issue, for many women reading or posting, a teckless comment can easily make them question themselves and their food intake.

it's good you are happy with you, but I think you can also see my point.