Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is the competitive under eating on mumsnet harmful?

406 replies

foreverlobsters · 13/09/2021 20:35

Full disclaimer- I have a history of eating disorders myself so am possibly over sensitive to this.

Have been reading through another currently active thread as well as what we eat in a day etc (which I occasionally post on and do find interesting). Why do people feel the need to post about their extremely low calorie days on here, or give potentially harmful advice? What's the incentive exactly- and are these people lying about how much they really eat or is most of the mumsnet population in an extreme calorie deficit? Do these people not see how selfish and damaging these posts can be?

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 13/09/2021 22:30

Low Bmi. Not bum.

PurpleDaisies · 13/09/2021 22:29

I don’t think it’s competitive under eating on most threads. It’s more like a pro ana normalising of eating tiny amounts or having a very low bum because we’ve all “lost sight of what a normal weight looks like”.

MrsDThomas · 13/09/2021 22:29

I have never counted calories.

For years i didn’t eat. Looked awful. Mum was the generation of 4 meals a day, at home cooking. I loathed eating.

Now i eat when hungry, i still eat 3 meals a day, but rarely snack. Im a healthy 8st 7lb.

Some days im really hungry, some im
Not. Its no big deal.

NinjaExodus · 13/09/2021 22:29

I like the....if you are 5 foot 7 how much do you weigh

Then a ton of people come on and say ooooh 6 stone 12 but I'm aiming to get back to my goal weight of 5 stone 13.

Numpties.

Ignore em op.

frumpety · 13/09/2021 22:28

I think that MN has a fairly broad demographic when it comes to weight and peoples emotions around weight.

You have people who self regulate their weight well, so go up and down a few pounds for holidays and special occasions, but generally just eat what they need most of the time.

You have people who have to 'be careful' and police their weight quite rigidly without quite crossing into ED thinking.

You have people who have or have previously had ED.

You will have people who are overweight or obese, who try and figure out a way of eating to suit them to reduce their weight. Personally I find processed carbs and alcohol to be my main demons, if I don't eat and drink them I lose weight.
If you are obese your body uses the calories you have already stored if you reduce your calorie intake, so 800 calories isnt 800 calories IYSWIM, it is just the calories and nutrients you are adding to the equation ? If you have body dysmorphia and think you are fat when you don't actually have any of the reserves that an overweight or obese person has, then 800 calories is 800 calories in total give or take a few.

You also have people who are in denial about the number of calories they actually consume and can't understand why they are overweight.

Then you add in the myriad of medications and medical and MH conditions that can have a huge impact on appetite and weight gain.

Think that's covered most people ?

TatianaBis · 13/09/2021 22:26

@Nietzschethehiker

I mean look at this , you specifically posted that you have had ED and some posters are so compulsive they start posting weights and figures despite it being well known these are triggers. Consider the level of mindset that thinks that's OK. When I say avoid the threads, it's not because you shouldn't, it's because they are filled with these compulsive posters.

They may have eating disorders too though. May not be intentionally triggering, rather that they’re being triggered themselves.

Clymene · 13/09/2021 22:24

[quote Sparklfairy]@Mindyourbusiness22 I would say they're more accurate than a keyboard self proclaimed "expert". But its fine, derail the thread some more with your misinformation.[/quote]
Bad data in means bad data out.

OrangutanLibrarian · 13/09/2021 22:24

The response to the competitive under-eating on here is competitive over-eating. That’s just as bad and “triggering” for people with EDs.

TatianaBis · 13/09/2021 22:23

@foreverlobsters

I think if you’ve had an eating disorder you should recognise that there is disordered eating at both ends of the spectrum - over and under. But that there are far, far more people in this country overweight and obese than underweight.

The women here who have low cal days may be overweight.

I see loads of boring threads about dieting which I don’t read. You could just avoid them.

NumberTheory · 13/09/2021 22:22

@Nietzschethehiker

I think some of the comments on this thread describe perfectly the obsessive unhealthy need to talk about their own intake and weight in some posters who are so absolutely defined by it they can't help themselves. It's almost a desperate need to post and be damned if it hurts anyone else, they need their validation.

I mean look at this , you specifically posted that you have had ED and some posters are so compulsive they start posting weights and figures despite it being well known these are triggers. Consider the level of mindset that thinks that's OK. When I say avoid the threads, it's not because you shouldn't, it's because they are filled with these compulsive posters.

It's never good to be around people with this level of compulsion and the absolute self orientation that it is more important for them to post their weight and calorie intake in a post like this than to care whether it harms anyone else. Personally I avoid this level of borderline sinister compulsion because that's more than ED that's trying to actively hurt someone else. So whilst I agree MNHQ should intervene, it's not that I'm suggesting staying away from those threads it's that the people on them an borderline sinister as you can se form some of the behaviours on this thread. Stay away from toxic people , so pretty much anyone that really thought it was remotely appropriate to post their stats and weight on this thread. There is no way that motivation was not about a need to hurt someone else to validate their own needs.

It may be a well known trigger amoungst those who have an eating disorder. But not so much for people who aren't immersed in that. OP posted in a general forum, known for being full of strong opinions, and did so in a combative way. People taking up that challenge aren't necessarily desperate, compulsive or obsessive. They may just be pissed off that someone is posting a "my way or the high way" opinion that doesn't mesh with their own experience.

People come to information on their own food needs through many different paths - maybe because they have an eating disorder, maybe because they have had medical issues that require some attention to diet for other reasons, maybe because they are fitness enthusiasts or just curious.

It's not reasonable to pretend that everyone else must be troubled because you don't want to or aren't able to consider what they have to say.

Hope54321 · 13/09/2021 22:21

[quote Kanaloa]@Hope54321

There’s lots of threads similar. There’s a whole thread at the moment where people are analysing whether or not op has eaten ‘low calorie.’

In my experience if you go onto an online forum and post extremely detailed lists of what you’ve eaten all day including what each thing was cooked in and ask strangers to validate that it is/isn’t low calorie, that is problematic.[/quote]
I don’t think I’ve come across such threads as I don’t usually go to that section of the forum.

OP, I hope my thread hasn’t offended you in anyway. I thought it’ll just be interesting to see what other people eat as I get bored of eating the same thing.

Blackkbird · 13/09/2021 22:17

I've just had a bottle of wine in front of a horror film and now I'm eating cheese on toast in bed if anyone wants to join me.

Laufeythejust · 13/09/2021 22:15

I’ve just read that thread and I’m disgusted, even when the OP posted how it made her feel they carried on. I agree with you that the competitive under eating is awful on here. 1200 calories may be fine for a very small proportion of the population but for the majority it is not enough food and a lot of the time someone is genuinely trying to lose weight or eat better and are trying to stick to unachievable calorie targets because of what they are reading on mumsnet.
I’d definitely try and avoid those threads OP as I don’t think they make anyone feel better- it’s starts a weird competition that only those claiming to live on lettuce and air every 48 hours could win.

Atalune · 13/09/2021 22:15

I don’t think it’s good self care to start a thread about competitive under eating or an unhealthy relationship with food if you’re eating disordered.

op

I don’t think this thread has been very productive at all my own posts included. I apologise.

I think you should ask for the thread to be deleted.

gluteustothemaximus · 13/09/2021 22:13

I avoid those threads.

'Help, to lose weight I need to eat 1200 calories, but I'm struggling as I keep eating over this'

'What do you mean OP? I eat tonnes of lettuce and barely make it to 300 calories a day, I could never in a million years eat 1200 calories!'

'I struggle to eat 200 calories a day, at a real push if I really stuffed myself, could manage 300, but 1200 is just insane!'

Hmm
NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 22:13

The competitive eating threads on MN are frequent and really awful.

I don't think OP said threads about diets/ food etc should be banned?!

Kanaloa · 13/09/2021 22:10

@Hope54321

There’s lots of threads similar. There’s a whole thread at the moment where people are analysing whether or not op has eaten ‘low calorie.’

In my experience if you go onto an online forum and post extremely detailed lists of what you’ve eaten all day including what each thing was cooked in and ask strangers to validate that it is/isn’t low calorie, that is problematic.

KikoLemons · 13/09/2021 22:09

So no-one should post because it bothers O.P.
several million people on here. Someone is always going to be upset (or "triggered" )by something.
Ban / "moderate" diets/spending/sex/TTC/Property/Work etc etc because it's "triggering" - and hey ho we don't have a site any more.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 22:07

Good luck OP! Avoid the topic like the plague.

And remember plenty of posters are lying, have issues, or are on the wind up.

Hope54321 · 13/09/2021 22:07

Are you talking about the thread I created called “what did you eat today?”. No one states how big their or small their portions are. Someone could be eating salad with high calorie ingredients such as avocado and oil and they could be having a big portion. That thread doesn’t actually reflect exactly how many calories one is consuming.

Breastfeedingworries · 13/09/2021 22:07

[quote Redgeraniums]@Breastfeedingworries
You forgot to add you’re only 8st and never eat veg, and drive everywhere. And can’t understand why everyone isn’t like you[/quote]
Haha apart from the fact I’m not! I’m almost 11.4 stone and should be about 9 for my height Grin

LaProcureure · 13/09/2021 22:06

It’s not irrelevant to say 1,200 isn’t that few calories - it’s making the point that saying you eat 1200 calories isn’t “competitive undereating” - it can be perfectly reasonable.

Sparklfairy · 13/09/2021 22:04

@Mindyourbusiness22 I would say they're more accurate than a keyboard self proclaimed "expert". But its fine, derail the thread some more with your misinformation.

Changemaname1 · 13/09/2021 22:03

Agree OP

Someone: I had omelette for breakfast

Oh wow a whole omelette I’d never eat all that , I’d be full allll day from that

Sure you would . Do one

Winnona · 13/09/2021 22:03

I have read quite a lot of different sections of threads on MN, but one area I never visit is the dieting bit. In the other threads eg Style and Beauty I have never noticed under eating.

Swipe left for the next trending thread