Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that these job adverts are being unreasonable?

33 replies

Keke94LND · 13/09/2021 18:49

So I was browsing job ads, just out of interest, I have no plans on applying for these jobs but, am I being unreasonable to think that these ads are being unreasonable?

Both jobs are PA roles, they both offer 'flexible' working, some days from home and some days from the office which is in the boss' house, and apparently there will be some need to sometimes get to the office quickly, meaning that the applicant must live in central London and this is non negotiable. One job is part time paying circa £30k and one is full time paying £30k.

AIBU to think that the non negotiable must live in central London part of the ad is totally unreasonable and out of touch? In my head central London is like... zone 1? And if they require this they should be paying way more than £30k?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BarbaraofSeville · 15/09/2021 08:06

It's also unreasonable because it's on a self employed basis when the job description wouldn't pass the HMRC self employment test.

Sounds like they should employ a proper full time PA and then contract additional help from a virtual PA if there is occasionally too much work for one person to handle.

I also suspect that the person will be anything but 'a joy to work for' and will have the 'part time' PA running round servicing all sorts of ridiculous requests like sorting their books by colour, schelping across London to find some must have item that is sold out everywhere but might be available in an obscure store miles away or searching round whichever neighbour their parcels got left at when the 'while you were out card' is unreadable.

SpeedRunParent · 15/09/2021 06:11

[quote Keke94LND]@SpeedRunParent for that pay though? [/quote]
Thus is a job for someone who doesn't need to work but wants to do something useful here and there.

Floogal · 14/09/2021 21:52

Thinking about Lynne from Alan Partridge.

Covered in the unemployment thread recently about employers still being too picky and unrealistic. About time people calling this out

Keke94LND · 14/09/2021 21:31

@SpeedRunParent for that pay though?

OP posts:
SpeedRunParent · 14/09/2021 19:32

@Keke94LND

So I was browsing job ads, just out of interest, I have no plans on applying for these jobs but, am I being unreasonable to think that these ads are being unreasonable?

Both jobs are PA roles, they both offer 'flexible' working, some days from home and some days from the office which is in the boss' house, and apparently there will be some need to sometimes get to the office quickly, meaning that the applicant must live in central London and this is non negotiable. One job is part time paying circa £30k and one is full time paying £30k.

AIBU to think that the non negotiable must live in central London part of the ad is totally unreasonable and out of touch? In my head central London is like... zone 1? And if they require this they should be paying way more than £30k?

Not really, I've had PA jobs like that before ( usually high net worth individuals if they are being that demanding) and I stopped doing them when I moved out to a commuter area. There are PA jobs... and then there are PA jobs.
SW1amp · 14/09/2021 17:00

[quote PinkFootstool]@Xenia would your au pair be able to drop things and run off though? Most students would struggle with that as well. It's this expectation that you'll drop your life in Central London and run off to help a "successful artist" (whatever that means) by popping chilled champagne / milk / cheese in the fridge because the poor wee mite has been travelling and is a "perfectionist who is very organised". But only get paid £20/hr, be SE and no guarantee of hours. Weird.[/quote]
Art students, humanities students, 3rd year students, have very few contact hours for some courses
Mine was only 8h per week for my 2nd and 3rd years
It’s a bit of pocket money each week for half the hours of working in a bar on min wage

elbea · 14/09/2021 16:43

Presumably it’s a PA for an UHNW/HNW with flexibility like that required. I have done it but was provided accommodation (own house, bills paid) and £30k for 20 hours per week. I don’t do it now I have children because I can’t be that flexible. It was a drop everything type of deal if they needed something. I was in my mid twenties at the time and pretty happy with the arrangement.

GladAllOver · 14/09/2021 16:13

Supply and demand. If the jobs are unreasonable they won't be filled. But they are likely to suit someone.
I'd be more concerned about the legal/ tax implications of being 'self employed' but only having one boss. That's frowned upon these days.

Xenia · 14/09/2021 16:05

Good point(and it's my adult daughter''s au pair I was thinking a bout so no idea what her contract says).

i can understand someone's butler or full time PA having a contract where they are available as required whenever but for 16 hours a month they may find it hard to get somenoe other than a lonely old person with nothing to do who loves art and even chats to the postman because they get out so little and are very bored. (A lot of people like that do exist)

PinkFootstool · 14/09/2021 15:59

@Xenia would your au pair be able to drop things and run off though? Most students would struggle with that as well. It's this expectation that you'll drop your life in Central London and run off to help a "successful artist" (whatever that means) by popping chilled champagne / milk / cheese in the fridge because the poor wee mite has been travelling and is a "perfectionist who is very organised". But only get paid £20/hr, be SE and no guarantee of hours. Weird.

Xenia · 14/09/2021 15:55

Yes would work for a student or even an au pair such as my daughter's au pair who does indeed live right in the centre of London works part time hours and has housing provided by employer. In other words quite a few people might do it including someone retired or even council tenants in inner London would qualify presumably.

SW1amp · 14/09/2021 15:49

@Wheresmrpenguin

"This is a part-time role and we are looking for candidates who are able to dedicate at least 16 hours per month but willing and able to be flexible as the hours are not set in stone and could increase in time. "

Flexible as possible but only 4 hours a week and so what, can you get another full time job? What if the 'employer' needs you whilst you're at your other job. Doesn't pay enough for me for some possible unreasonable demands.

Good for a student though

Not every job has to be the sole means of support for an independently living adult

Comefromaway · 14/09/2021 15:48

When she first moved there in the summer she only had 10 days notice before her new job started so she sub-let a room in Clapham. Now she wouldn't class that as Central but it was literally a 30 minute cycle from there to Charing Cross.

Keke94LND · 14/09/2021 15:44

@Comefromaway

I wonder if the ad was written by someone not from London. I could understand if it said must live within easy access to central London. What are they actually classing as Central?

My daughter lives in Ealing. It takes her between 40-50 mins to cycle and tube into her job in Central.

She was staying further out near Lee but it only took her 30 mins to travel in from there.

Yeah I agree, I would understand if it said preferably lives in London or within easy commute to so and so location, but they haven't specified where the boss's house is, and central London to me is like.. Westminster, Islington etc, most people can't live in these locations especially working 16 hours a month, which surely just means only an already wealthy person can get the job
OP posts:
Keke94LND · 14/09/2021 15:41

@Wheresmrpenguin

"This is a part-time role and we are looking for candidates who are able to dedicate at least 16 hours per month but willing and able to be flexible as the hours are not set in stone and could increase in time. "

Flexible as possible but only 4 hours a week and so what, can you get another full time job? What if the 'employer' needs you whilst you're at your other job. Doesn't pay enough for me for some possible unreasonable demands.

Yeah I agree, plus it's technically on a self employed basis so it won't offer any sort of benefits like pensions, and usually if you're self employed you can pick your hours but it doesn't sound like the candidate would be able to. It sounds like this person would be better of hiring a 'virtual assistant' tbh
OP posts:
Comefromaway · 14/09/2021 15:35

I wonder if the ad was written by someone not from London. I could understand if it said must live within easy access to central London. What are they actually classing as Central?

My daughter lives in Ealing. It takes her between 40-50 mins to cycle and tube into her job in Central.

She was staying further out near Lee but it only took her 30 mins to travel in from there.

Wheresmrpenguin · 14/09/2021 15:33

"This is a part-time role and we are looking for candidates who are able to dedicate at least 16 hours per month but willing and able to be flexible as the hours are not set in stone and could increase in time. "

Flexible as possible but only 4 hours a week and so what, can you get another full time job? What if the 'employer' needs you whilst you're at your other job. Doesn't pay enough for me for some possible unreasonable demands.

Keke94LND · 14/09/2021 15:29

@PinkFootstool

16 hours PER MONTH....
Oops my attention to detail is failing me this week 🤣🤣
OP posts:
PinkFootstool · 14/09/2021 15:28

16 hours PER MONTH....

Keke94LND · 14/09/2021 15:27

[quote herculesoffline]@keke94LND

Do you have links to the adverts?[/quote]
www.secsinthecity.co.uk/job/3941420/part-time-private-pa-to-successful-artist-/

This is the ad, apologies that I got completely mixed up in my original post, this one is actually £20 per hour for 16 hours a week, so it's probably more like circa £40k. It's only the non negotiable must live in central London that I find bizarre, because central London is.. the majorly expensive part.. I live in zone 3 and wouldn't consider it central

OP posts:
Keke94LND · 14/09/2021 15:20

@WhatATimeToBeAlive

YABU. It's what a PA does. Part of your role is to be at your boss's beck and call - it's what your're paid for in your working hours. It's likely you can work from as much as you can, but you would need to be available to pop to his house to collect papers, get something signed, etc. I would do a part time PA role at £30k and be available to go to the boss's house at short notice, but then I'm a PA, it's what we do!
Couldn't disagree more.. I'm a PA as well, in corporate working in Piccadilly Circus, my boss can be very demanding but she doesn't expect me to live round the corner, thankfully because I could only rent a studio flat round the corner from my office for £1,700 per month. What if my partner also needed to be near his office in Greenwich? This kind of requirement doesn't bode well for employee retention as people may want to be able to get on the property ladder (so would have to move out of central London) or start a family, (so would need more space than a studio flat) If you want someone to be at your beck and call, either pay someone the salary or a 24/7 beck and call PA, hire a live in PA where accommodation is paid for, or don't offer the flexibility of working from home, for example, I go into the office everyday 9-6.
OP posts:
WhatATimeToBeAlive · 14/09/2021 12:30

YABU. It's what a PA does. Part of your role is to be at your boss's beck and call - it's what your're paid for in your working hours. It's likely you can work from as much as you can, but you would need to be available to pop to his house to collect papers, get something signed, etc. I would do a part time PA role at £30k and be available to go to the boss's house at short notice, but then I'm a PA, it's what we do!

ssd · 14/09/2021 12:18

So they want a dogsbody...

herculesoffline · 14/09/2021 12:01

@keke94LND

Do you have links to the adverts?

PinkFootstool · 13/09/2021 19:59

Screams "The Devil Wears Prada" to me....