Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed when people brag about not having kids

291 replies

Ellerehj · 13/09/2021 17:14

I see it so much on social media and I work with younger people who are very anti children. I completely respect people's decision to not have children. But I feel like they speak about people with kids like we're trapped it stuck with these awful little life suckers? When I don't feel like that at all.
AIBU to think it's really rude

OP posts:
MissTrip82 · 14/09/2021 04:23

By far the most negative stuff I see is by people with children.

It used to make me feel sick but I assumed maybe I just didn’t know anything about it. Still makes me feel sick now I have a child.

Malin52 · 14/09/2021 01:19

I moved to a new country and a friend kindly set up a meet and greet. I started talking to one woman and within a few minutes the conversation moved to where we both lived in the vicinity and she said to me 'oh so do your kids go to x school?' I said 'oh we don't have kids'. She looked at me, smiled politely and then looked around and started talking to someone else. She didn't give me a second glance.

At a house party a few months ago. I was chatting to a friend about general life stuff. Maybe a book we had read or something and another friend came over to join the chat. Within 30 second the topic of conversation had changed to their toddler's bowel movements and potty training. I stuck it out listening politely for about 5 minutes until I could take more (the conversation was entirely two sided not that I have potty based opinions). I excused myself (just need to grab a drink) and I was accused by my friend of being rude and 'just walking off whenever we talk about the children, and it was just a couple of minutes'. Fact is they ALWAYS talk about the children but don't seem to see it.

Lucythewonderdog · 14/09/2021 01:02

I know @Malin52 who paid for their precious darlings education?Not all kids are going to be worthy tax payers.

Malin52 · 14/09/2021 00:55

@Artdecolover

If people don't want kids that's fine. But who do these people think will work and pay taxes to pay for their nhs care, state pension etc? It baffles me that some people are so ignorant of how taxes/social care work. The post war consensus is well and truly dead.
As if any of these things will be available when we retire! My care will be paid for by me by the house that I own and work for or alternatively I'd prefer not to be drain on society by outliving my usefulness

I didn't realise that every parent decides to have children in order to ensure that there is replenishment of tax payers!

We need less people on this planet not more and I will happily do my bit to ensure I'm not a drain on resources as I get older to support reduction in population.

Don't kid yourself you became a parent for anything other than your own personal desire.

Lucythewonderdog · 14/09/2021 00:46

I saw a post on here recently where a poster was saying she has multiple kids with SN and was pregnant with her 4th. I’m thinking she’s batshit or banking on the PIP. Either way I’m happy to be kid free and not deal with that. Even 4 (or 1!) NT kids would drive me insane.

I haven’t RTFT but raising kids looks like total boring drudgery to me. I’d rather my life, sorry if it irritates OP.

dayslikethese1 · 14/09/2021 00:42

Why is that coming up in conversation at work OP? Sounds a bit personal.

SD1978 · 14/09/2021 00:40

It goes both ways. Smug without kids and smug with.

Sweetchocolatecandy · 14/09/2021 00:20

@GoldenPolden

Can't they form NOTAMUMnet.com. Or just f off to Reddit
But if we were to do that then where would all that pent up hatred you have in your soul be directed?
Furries · 13/09/2021 23:56

@GoldenPolden

Can't they form NOTAMUMnet.com. Or just f off to Reddit
Would that mean that dads, grandparents, aunts, uncles, godparents etc should also all fuck off?

Or is it just women without children that you take exception to for being on here?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 13/09/2021 23:44

@MrsSkylerWhite

youvegottenminuteslynn

If people don't want kids that's fine. But who do these people think will work and pay taxes to pay for their nhs care, state pension etc? It baffles me that some people are so ignorant of how taxes/social care work. The post war consensus is well and truly dead“

What a stupid comment. We have children. We have also paid enough tax and NI to cover our/their and several other people’s health care and state pensions for several decades because we are high earners. We would have paid even more had I not taken many years our to care for our children.

I agree! I was quoting another poster in the bold bit of my post!
Draineddraineddrained · 13/09/2021 23:28

Do you feel the same when the actual mums complain about their kids (or other kids)?

Nope. I mean sometimes I don't like the way people talk about their kids, or other people's kids. Sometimes I disagree with the way other parents parent. But there is a difference between taking issue with certain kids behaviour and generally believing them to be inherently shitty and motherhood to be an unedifying waste of time/an insult to mother nature/a failure of feminism etc etc. As parents, their opinions and experiences of parenting (however different from mine) have a place here.

I just don't GET the people who come on here purely to say "so fucking glad I never had kids, sounds so shit and horrible." I mean I don't go onto skiing or golfing forums and join every thread to say what a dangerous/boring waste of time those activities are. Just seems perverse.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/09/2021 23:11

youvegottenminuteslynn

If people don't want kids that's fine. But who do these people think will work and pay taxes to pay for their nhs care, state pension etc? It baffles me that some people are so ignorant of how taxes/social care work. The post war consensus is well and truly dead“

What a stupid comment. We have children. We have also paid enough tax and NI to cover our/their and several other people’s health care and state pensions for several decades because we are high earners. We would have paid even more had I not taken many years our to care for our children.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 13/09/2021 23:09

@GoldenPolden

Can't they form NOTAMUMnet.com. Or just f off to Reddit
No. Because they don't sob and shake over neig ours parking on their drive so it's not fun.

Also, some of the creative writing exercises here are actually entertaining.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 13/09/2021 23:06

If people don't want kids that's fine. But who do these people think will work and pay taxes to pay for their nhs care, state pension etc? It baffles me that some people are so ignorant of how taxes/social care work. The post war consensus is well and truly dead

Goodness, by that logic are infertile people less valuable members of society in your opinion?

People who don't meet anyone they want to parent with?

My parents adopted me and my brother so they didn't create a new taxpayer in the making. In fact they could have created TWO had they had the same number of children biologically How very selfish of them, eh?

StopThrowingCitrusFruitFFS · 13/09/2021 23:04

@gofg

If people don't want kids that's fine. But who do these people think will work and pay taxes to pay for their nhs care, state pension etc? It baffles me that some people are so ignorant of how taxes/social care work. The post war consensus is well and truly dead.

I think you are being a little bit ridiculous here. We are never going to get to the stage where no-one has children, so there will always be another generation coming on to pay taxes. Plenty of people didn't have children in past generations because they were unable to - society didn't collapse!

I don't agree with that poster you've quoted, but low birth rate (which we do have currently in the UK) is a concern. A lot of experts (not random Mumsnetters) are genuinely concerned about it. But that isn't a reason for people who don't want to have kids to have them anyway. So it's a moot point. It's a bit different if you're avoiding having kids purely for the greater good. Then it becomes a bit more complex, but usually people who decide to do that have (hopefully!) given it a great deal of thought and know what they're doing.

Coercion either way, to have DCs or not, is clearly bullshit.

JorisBonson · 13/09/2021 22:54

@GoldenPolden

Here it's MUMSnet, some PP should really consider who the majority audience is.
TRIPLE HOUSE
HunterHearstHelmsley · 13/09/2021 22:54

The OP is so tone deaf.

I remember a woman I worked with years ago, constantly went on and on at me about how basically I was less of a woman because I didn't have children. This went on for months on end, eventually I had a dig back and the cheeky mare raised a grievance. I'd kept a diary of her bullshit so raised one in return. Guess which one got upheld Grin I don't think she spoke to me again after that 🥳

Childfree people are starting to bitch back. I'm sick of having utter halfwits telling me I can't be tired because I don't have children. Seriously. How can anyone be so obtuse? How can anyone be so stupid?

gofg · 13/09/2021 22:54

If people don't want kids that's fine.
But who do these people think will work and pay taxes to pay for their nhs care, state pension etc?
It baffles me that some people are so ignorant of how taxes/social care work.
The post war consensus is well and truly dead.

I think you are being a little bit ridiculous here. We are never going to get to the stage where no-one has children, so there will always be another generation coming on to pay taxes. Plenty of people didn't have children in past generations because they were unable to - society didn't collapse!

Blackkbird · 13/09/2021 22:46

@GoldenPolden

Here it's MUMSnet, some PP should really consider who the majority audience is.
BINGO ding 🛎 🛎 🛎 🛎 🛎
Blackkbird · 13/09/2021 22:45

@SecretSpAD

I,ah have been a child - but even then, I found children younger than me or the same age as me profoundly irritating.

Those feelings never left me. Children - those below the age of about 16 - still irritate the hell out of me and I don't enjoy, and actively avoid their company. My niece and nephew have been the exception to this, obviously (for those who remember me from other threads) but then, they were never young children, more like miniature adults.

And no, I'm not massively grateful that my parents had me. They had children because it was expected of them in that time and in their class. My father is pretty cool, but my mother was a toxic bitch.

Same.

I didn't enjoy being a child.

I love my parents but I think they would have been happier people without having children.

Not all parents are happier for it or good at it.

Sometimes extremely troubled adults are produced that require years of medication and therapy to live in this world without being destructive or miserable.

GoldenPolden · 13/09/2021 22:41

Can't they form NOTAMUMnet.com.
Or just f off to Reddit

GoldenPolden · 13/09/2021 22:40

Here it's MUMSnet, some PP should really consider who the majority audience is.

Blackkbird · 13/09/2021 22:39

I'll emphasise the WOMEN in that post.

Blackkbird · 13/09/2021 22:38

@Artdecolover

You only need to look at Japan and Italy to see what happens when birth rates drop

Do you think that all middle aged women should be sacrificing their own lives to care for very elderly people?

Staying home and not working to provide palliative care for dying relatives that have no quality of life?

ImTheOnlyUpsyOne · 13/09/2021 22:35

@Hopdathelf

I think there should be a thread on site stuff listing all the non child related topics on MN and people can just be directed there. I’d be willing to bet the majority of the site is about the myriad things that occupy women beyond parenting (or the vast majority based on the sheer number of parking and wedding poem threads).

Sadly for some women life extends no further than children so they can’t conceive why someone might want to talk about other topics some of the time.

By the same token I might run up to people on the train tomorrow and demand to know why they’re reading Glamour magazine when they are decidedly dowdy.

Lol glamour mag Grin