Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed when people brag about not having kids

291 replies

Ellerehj · 13/09/2021 17:14

I see it so much on social media and I work with younger people who are very anti children. I completely respect people's decision to not have children. But I feel like they speak about people with kids like we're trapped it stuck with these awful little life suckers? When I don't feel like that at all.
AIBU to think it's really rude

OP posts:
LukeEvansWife · 14/09/2021 08:47

It is mind boggling that people have the nerve to call childfree people selfish. If I accused them of being selfish, they would go batshit

LukeEvansWife · 14/09/2021 08:45

And yes selfish

So I didn’t go into higher ed, have been working for over 34 years and paying tax, only cost the country for my own education and healthcare, had no mat leave, have to cover for colleagues who do (and who have to dash off to deal with family obligations), have to be low priority for annual leave…

Most of this I don’t mind (except the annual leave issue). Which of these actions is particularly selfish?

LukeEvansWife · 14/09/2021 08:39

And the gleefully spiteful ‘wait til they have children’ when someone has a wedding and doesn’t invite children. Or in other cases ‘they have forgotten what having young children is like’ - so the default apparently that anyone will or has had children

ArcheryAnnie · 14/09/2021 08:31

I never understand the "if you don't have children you are selfish" thing.

I have a kid, one I gave birth to rather that aquiring him another way, and still think that becoming a parent like this is the most selfish, self-regarding, narcissistic thing any of us can do! Populating the world with our mini-mes! We do it entirely for our own satisfaction and benefit.

CounsellorTroi · 14/09/2021 08:19

I think you are being a little bit ridiculous here. We are never going to get to the stage where no-one has children, so there will always be another generation coming on to pay taxes. Plenty of people didn't have children in past generations because they were unable to - society didn't collapse!

Yes this. And after the carnage of the First World War there was a shortage of men, and many more women remained unmarried than would have done in normal circumstances. And that’s not counting all the women whose sweethearts/fiancés/husbands were killed before they had children.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 14/09/2021 08:10

I agree @hunterhearsthelmsley. I do hace a child but I HATE it when people pass judgement about others. OF COURSE people without children can be tired. OF COURSE people with children can enjoy a hot drink. I despise it.

I have one child, and he's going to stay an only child. Last week one of my colleagues told me that he'd be spoilt and have 'lonely child-itis' if I didnt have another.

Realyorkshiretea · 14/09/2021 08:02

@HunterHearstHelmsley

The OP is so tone deaf.

I remember a woman I worked with years ago, constantly went on and on at me about how basically I was less of a woman because I didn't have children. This went on for months on end, eventually I had a dig back and the cheeky mare raised a grievance. I'd kept a diary of her bullshit so raised one in return. Guess which one got upheld Grin I don't think she spoke to me again after that 🥳

Childfree people are starting to bitch back. I'm sick of having utter halfwits telling me I can't be tired because I don't have children. Seriously. How can anyone be so obtuse? How can anyone be so stupid?

Haha this made me smile and i have a child! Good for you!
Honeyglowx · 14/09/2021 07:56

People who don’t have kids can still come on mumsnet , as mumsnet isn’t just a talking forum where every section is about being a mum and having kids.. there’s section about health , legal matters , relationships etc , you don’t have to have kids to make a post on those forums , you don’t need to have kids to post on any forum js

And I understand the us and them situation with people who have kids and those who haven’t had kids for their own reasons but if your lucky enough to make a decision about whether you want kids or don’t and you always get to live by that decision you wanted then what’s the problem? Why feel a need to talk about the person who doesn’t have kids if your happy having kids.

And to further the matter what about people who can’t have kids for whatever reason but want kids and would make great parents or those who have kids but can’t be with them , I think people need to have a abit of compassion and realise it’s not all about them and somewhere out there there’s someone who has it worse , not to say that your problems are not hard too but to be grateful for what you do have in life whether it’s your kids , or other people or pets you love etc

People don’t mean to always be insensitive I guess ,it’s just easy to get wrapped up and self absorbed in our own lives and not think of those who in some aspects have it harder than ourselves

Heatherjayne1972 · 14/09/2021 07:52

On a societal level the default has always been that ‘women want babies’

I reckon there’s still a subtle assumption that all women want a baby and those that don’t are ‘selfish’ and those that can’t must be pitied

flippertyop · 14/09/2021 07:47

Well we are ... there are pros and cons both ways but we are indeed trapped with little life suckers

SquirryTheSquirrel · 14/09/2021 07:45

@Annoyedanddissapointed

I didn't realise that every parent decides to have children in order to ensure that there is replenishment of tax payers!

Yeah. Considering that like 99% of pregnancies are apparently a surprise here, it's very disingenuous from that poster to try to turn it into "who will pay for your pension". No parent ever decided to have kids for that reason. And if they did, god help them children (and I am not even religious).

One poster once said that people spend more time thinking it through when they decided not to have kids, than when they decide having them.

Imho, that's simply because we need to be able to justify the decision at all times, not just sometimes when bad situation arises

I agree. I really doubt it's a consideration for most. From what I read on here, many people get an 'urge' to have children, in the same way I suppose you might get an 'urge' to find a partner if you are single, and then they obey that urge. Nothing wrong with that (unless a woman feels pressured into the choice) but don't let's dress it up as a socially conscious choice.

I agree as well that it takes effort to deliberately remain childfree if you are in a relationship and still fertile. Always being careful with contraception, never taking a chance, 'doubling up' if there's a chance your normal method might be compromised ...

You can become pregnant accidentally but you can't remain childfree 'by accident'.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 14/09/2021 07:43

@Confiscatedpopit

Wow, some of you have massive chips on your shoulders. Offended over nothing really. I suggest the issues are yours…
Wow.

Women, and it is women, have been chastised throughout history if they choose not to have children. Way back when, they were often suspected of being a witch. Their time is often not valued as much in the workplace, they are told they are lacking in empathy, they are expected to never take leave at popular times.. Its not nothing.

NeilBuchananisBanksy · 14/09/2021 07:42

@Annoyedanddissapointed

I don't mean you personally. You in general😁
Hehe, I got it!! Grin
Annoyedanddissapointed · 14/09/2021 07:41

I don't mean you personally. You in general😁

Annoyedanddissapointed · 14/09/2021 07:40

@SquirryTheSquirrel

Teresa May when she was PM (don't like the woman) but the press were awful about her not having had kids (I think it was not by choice too). How on earth did it make any difference to her job?

Yes - when the party leadership contest was underway, one of her rivals said TM wouldn't make a good PM because, not having children, she wouldn't be invested in the future of the country. I believe she later apologised, but that was a shocking thing to come out with.

Even when you weren't fan of her politics, this was something we all should be disgusted by.
Annoyedanddissapointed · 14/09/2021 07:36

I didn't realise that every parent decides to have children in order to ensure that there is replenishment of tax payers!

Yeah. Considering that like 99% of pregnancies are apparently a surprise here, it's very disingenuous from that poster to try to turn it into "who will pay for your pension". No parent ever decided to have kids for that reason. And if they did, god help them children (and I am not even religious).

One poster once said that people spend more time thinking it through when they decided not to have kids, than when they decide having them.

Imho, that's simply because we need to be able to justify the decision at all times, not just sometimes when bad situation arises

Confiscatedpopit · 14/09/2021 07:23

Wow, some of you have massive chips on your shoulders. Offended over nothing really. I suggest the issues are yours…

KaycePollard · 14/09/2021 07:23

My taxes pay for people to have maternity care, give birth and then to send the kids to school at the moment.

This. And people with children tend to be nett takers from the social pot, while people without children tend to be nett contributors.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 14/09/2021 07:21

Teresa May when she was PM (don't like the woman) but the press were awful about her not having had kids (I think it was not by choice too). How on earth did it make any difference to her job?

Yes - when the party leadership contest was underway, one of her rivals said TM wouldn't make a good PM because, not having children, she wouldn't be invested in the future of the country. I believe she later apologised, but that was a shocking thing to come out with.

Toodlydoo · 14/09/2021 07:13

Tbf I moan about my toddler quite a lot, it’s hard and I’m knackered. So wouldn’t be surprised if the people I moan to without children are like “YAY FOR ME I DON’T HAVE KIDS”. I’m downright envious of childfree people atm.

People feel differently about things, I wouldn’t get offended. It would be rude to bang on about it though.

NeilBuchananisBanksy · 14/09/2021 07:13

It's retaliation.

I have been told on MN that I can't have met the right person yet as if I had I'd want his babies. Hmm (I'm very happily married).

Women seem the worst for it too - my husband doesn't get half the judgement and comments than I do.

Teresa May when she was PM (don't like the woman) but the press were awful about her not having had kids (I think it was not by choice too). How on earth did it make any difference to her job?

The ageing population argument gets thrown about a lot (as it has on this thread). Should we just have exponential growth then?

One reason I'm chlidfree is the environment- yet parents don't want to accept that overpopulation is a huge issue. The tax and social structures around ageing populations won't matter one jot when the planet is on fire/flooded. Ovid is nothing in comparison to the future we face as a species. But I get told it's ok because as parents they recycle and I must enjoy multiple flights because of my shallow childfree lifestyle.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 14/09/2021 07:06

I mean... that's true there is Reddit for child haters...

You don't have to 'hate' children not to want any of your own. I don't hate horses but I wouldn't want the hassle of looking after my own horse.

PandemicAtTheDisco · 14/09/2021 06:58

Some people seem to have an issue whenever someone else makes a different choice to them. When someone is forceful about stating their different choices, there is often a background story.

I always hear the word 'brag' and think of a past friend who constantly got her knickers twisted about someone on facebook 'bragging' about getting their A 'levels, getting into their university of choice, passing their qualifications, getting their first job, getting their first paycheck and treating themselves, getting her driving license, first car, getting engaged, getting her first home, puppy etc.
For me, the word brag makes me think of this killjoy, being jealous of her friends achievements rather than happy for her.

LubYouMaow · 14/09/2021 05:17

OP I understand what you are saying and I absolutely love children to bits although we decided to be childfree for environmental reasons- I absolutely do not begrudge anyone for deciding to have children.
My sister has children and she only calls me when she wants me to babysit and does not include me in her children’s Birthday parties by saying it’s for ‘families only’ ie- people with children. It hurts alot to be excluded when I do so much for her and my nieces/nephews.
I would love to have a wider social circle with women my own age but as soon as they hear that I am childfree they want nothing to do with me.
I am not the only childfree person that this has happened to.
I think after being treated like a leper for so long, childfree women are fed up and voicing their opinions to try and even the playing field.
Not saying it’s right, but it’s a given really.
It takes a village to raise a child and childfree people are part of that village. We pick up the slack whilst you are on maternity leave, we work during religious holidays so you can be with your children, we work late so that you can pick your children up from school. We cover you so you can care for your sick children who are home from school and we are rarely thanked for it.
Again, Village.
It wouldn’t be so Us vs Them if Mother’s and Father’s could acknowledge us once in awhile and not exclude us for making different life choices to their own.

ED81 · 14/09/2021 04:47

It really is sad. I’ve always been ambivalent about having children. My friends having children and seeing what it takes has put me off. Then the biggest mistake. Joining Mumsnet. It is all doom and gloom re parenthood. Again, more so put me off.

I’m actually devastated that I won’t have children. But it’s a choice. You can not have children through choice but still be sad. I’m certainly not living some crazy wonderful life.