Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed when people brag about not having kids

291 replies

Ellerehj · 13/09/2021 17:14

I see it so much on social media and I work with younger people who are very anti children. I completely respect people's decision to not have children. But I feel like they speak about people with kids like we're trapped it stuck with these awful little life suckers? When I don't feel like that at all.
AIBU to think it's really rude

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IllegibleSquiggles · 15/09/2021 11:42

[quote EatYourVegetables]**@KaycePollard* one of my fellow PhD students said something about his wife doing all his footnotes*

OMFG!! Angry

Apparently this was rife in the 50s and 60s academia. Wives and secretaries who did a good chunk of research for men who got all the glory. Hmm[/quote]
My brilliant MA supervisor, by then a professor and eminent in her field, used to reminisce about how, when she was in her first job, already a prominent voice in feminist criticism, the women academic staff were instructed to bring in home-cooked food when the external examiners came.

AudacityBaby · 15/09/2021 11:28

@KaycePollard

Thing is, I totally get how difficult it is for women to maintain careers after children. I work in a pretty high demanding and quite competitive profession which is staffed by high achievers (you need a PhD as a basic qualification). So I generally try to assist and be collegial. My sympathy disappears however, if my experiences, struggles, opportunities, and workload are deliberately affected simply because I have no children.

Both @AudacityBaby and @HunterHearstHelmsley** have put up with far more than I would. I’d be on a personal work-to-rule campaign by now in their situation.

I think in part this is how it perpetuates itself, because it's considered a feminist issue. Which it is, there's no denying that - but the solution to solving one feminist issue isn't to throw another bunch of women (and men albeit that there are far fewer single childless men in my organisation than single childless women) under the bus. @HunterHearstHelmsley's thread was full of comments about the importance of maternity rights, with no recognition that what was being asked to uphold those rights was that other women suffer.

The answer of course is that there needs to be more staff or less work (or both) but I'm in the public sector working on vital services, so that's never going to happen. Until then it is just 'us vs them'.

KaycePollard · 15/09/2021 09:50

I did my PhD in the mid 80s. All by myself. But clearly not all my colleagues (also my competitors in getting scarce jobs) did the same!

EatYourVegetables · 15/09/2021 09:48

@KaycePollard one of my fellow PhD students said something about his wife doing all his footnotes

OMFG!! Angry

Apparently this was rife in the 50s and 60s academia. Wives and secretaries who did a good chunk of research for men who got all the glory. Hmm

KaycePollard · 15/09/2021 09:35

Totally @EatYourVegetables

In my mind, I’m assuming that mostly this discussion is about women. It’s generally women’s lives and situations which are cause for comment and criticism.

And your description of your colleague reminds me also of the huge advantages men with wives have over single women . I remember when I was doing my PhD and whinging about how I’d had to go back and dig out and correct references, one of my fellow PhD students said something about his wife doing all his footnotes.

It’s a form of cheating!

KaycePollard · 15/09/2021 09:31

Oops that message sounds like I think I’d manage a shit workplace better than other posters. I doubt I would - I get into a storm of impotent anger. But then I get stubborn and passive-aggressive.

Strength you both.

EatYourVegetables · 15/09/2021 09:30

Happens more the other way.

But when a childless male colleague with a stay at home wife tells me he is tired I want to punch him in the face. It’s his way of saying “I work 80h a week even though we are both paid 40, do you only do 40? Shame.” Angry

KaycePollard · 15/09/2021 09:26

Thing is, I totally get how difficult it is for women to maintain careers after children. I work in a pretty high demanding and quite competitive profession which is staffed by high achievers (you need a PhD as a basic qualification). So I generally try to assist and be collegial. My sympathy disappears however, if my experiences, struggles, opportunities, and workload are deliberately affected simply because I have no children.

Both @AudacityBaby and @HunterHearstHelmsley have put up with far more than I would. I’d be on a personal work-to-rule campaign by now in their situation.

AudacityBaby · 15/09/2021 09:25

@HunterHearstHelmsley No, sadly. The union was as useful as a chocolate teapot, having suggested the policy in the first place (or at least heartily agreed with it when it was suggested). The parents outnumber us and a number of them kicked up such a fuss that it was pointless trying. I'm getting to take my leave at the end of this month.

I'm really glad you managed to stick to your guns - I remember your thread and the situation you were in was awful!

Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 07:42

It's been discussed for years and years. I think it was 2018 when up some research showed to 40% of singles or people without kids feeling like they are picking up slack and don't really have a choice.
I genuinely hope someone will sue soon to stop this spiraling even more. Covid really did a number on this as well.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 15/09/2021 07:31

@AudacityBaby

I didn't think there was an 'us vs them' but I've been burned by the pandemic - my employer created a policy which essentially threw all of the childless workers under the bus to ensure that parents could halve their working hours with no pay consequences. It turned out that our union had suggested the idea, as a way of demonstrating how family friendly my organisation is. "Family" friendly so often means "parent" friendly only, and everyone else gets hung out to dry.
Did you manage to sort any of the issues you were having at work? I managed to keep my leave. I did waver a little but there was one too many comments about how I didn't need the leave, they needed it more blah blah that I really dug my heels in.
SquirryTheSquirrel · 14/09/2021 17:53

am always told that's a terrible thing to say and that I'd be a brilliant mum. I wouldn't, I'd be shit

Yes, I've been told a couple of times I'd be a 'brilliant mum' on the strength of vaguely successful interactions (i.e. I thought of something to say) with children. I wouldn't, though. I'd just resent the constraints they put on my life, and I'd be constantly embarrassed by them talking like me and generally resembling me - like having to see myself on a video 24/7 but being unable to escape it.

KaycePollard · 14/09/2021 15:16

@Crankley those kinds of comments always make me think that the person commenting must have a pretty shallow or underdeveloped emotional and/or imaginative life if they only had deep feelings after having a child.

KaycePollard · 14/09/2021 15:15

That should read

Never ever cover for any parent

Crankley · 14/09/2021 14:56

I'm childless, couldn't have any. I've read so many comments onb here over the years that effectively if you don't have children then you must live barren, empty lives. Even if they don't actually say the words, they infer it. It's obviously bullshit and I wonder sometimes if they are a bit jealous.

LookAtMoiPloise · 14/09/2021 14:54

@GoldenPolden

Can't they form NOTAMUMnet.com. Or just f off to Reddit
Ooooh, so bitter 😘
Bexxe · 14/09/2021 14:53

do you know how many times my friends have said 'i dont want to sound patronsiing but you wont understand it until you have kids'

honestly - people with kids are worse then those without

KaycePollard · 14/09/2021 14:45

Never ever overcome any parent who insisted on that crazy working arrangement @AudacityBaby and maybe also put in for TOIL for all the extra hours you worked and weren’t paid for, when parents were paid and didn’t work.

The pandemic was tough on EVERYONE, but your employer totally took the piss.

AudacityBaby · 14/09/2021 14:33

@kaycepollard Kids are back at school now so parents have kindly deigned to allow the rest of us to take our leave now. Which is something. I'm still job-hunting though.

KaycePollard · 14/09/2021 13:58

@AudacityBaby I remember your thread about your shite employer. Is that situation still going on? I hope not. Or maybe your union rep has found his/her common sense and understanding of fair employment practices?

Hardbackwriter · 14/09/2021 13:36

Yup. I have (half jokingly) told my friends who have gushed about the "love like no other" that 'yes that's your hormones, you are evolutionarily set up so your brain has a flood of drug like chemicals to ensure you think your child that looks like a potato is the most beautiful thing in the world so you don't walk away when shit gets tough. That love? Its just evolutionary drugs to ensure you keep replicating. Like a virus'

Or like romantic love?

Hardbackwriter · 14/09/2021 13:34

@ConsulTremas

To be honest, both sides need to get the fuck over it. Having no kids isn’t something special and having kids isn’t something special. It’s just two lifestyle choices, neither of which is wrong and neither of which is necessarily better than the other. Live and let live.
This. It is SO BORING to have this conversation either way - whether you're going on about how clever you were to have children or how clever you were to not have them, the actual truth is that you're making yourself sound pretty thick.
Veronika13 · 14/09/2021 13:26

@Hopdathelf

I’m shocked we’re nearly at the end of page 2 and no one has asked what people without children are doing on Mumsnet Grin
I was looking for a relationship forum 8 years ago, and mumsnet was the busiest one with the most responses to topics. I still don't have children but sit on here everyday.
slashlover · 14/09/2021 13:14

@leftovercoffeecake

When you say you don’t want children, people never just accept that. They start prodding, claiming you’ll change your mind or you’ve not met the right man yet or you’re being selfish. They prod and prod, but when you finally explain your reasoning for not wanting kids, they take it personally and claim you’re insulting their life style.

Also the whole idea that child free people are evil makes me Hmm I don’t like being around children but I’ve seen endless comments on here from parents who proudly claim they don’t like any children except from their own. Hardly different

I always say I would be a terrible mother. I don't have the patience, I need alone time etc, and am always told that's a terrible thing to say and that I'd be a brilliant mum. I wouldn't, I'd be shit.
leftovercoffeecake · 14/09/2021 12:50

When you say you don’t want children, people never just accept that. They start prodding, claiming you’ll change your mind or you’ve not met the right man yet or you’re being selfish. They prod and prod, but when you finally explain your reasoning for not wanting kids, they take it personally and claim you’re insulting their life style.

Also the whole idea that child free people are evil makes me Hmm I don’t like being around children but I’ve seen endless comments on here from parents who proudly claim they don’t like any children except from their own. Hardly different