Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - I have called the GP over 200 times this morning

540 replies

IAmADancer · 13/09/2021 09:12

Just that. I need to get a blood test referral for menopause symptoms but I can’t get through. I started calling at 8am and have called over 200 times. It’s still engaged.

I know that if I call back at 10am when it’s quieter they will tell me there are no appointments and to call back tomorrow. Then you go through the same routine all over again. I just want to access basic care. Feeling very frustrated

OP posts:
LukeEvansWife · 13/09/2021 14:13

That story doesn’t help - person phones 96 times so jams up phone lines only to waste people’s time Shock

girlmom21 · 13/09/2021 14:11

Little story to lighten the mood: when I was 20 weeks pregnant with my first, I had to move GPs as I'd moved out of my hospital trust area so needed to register with the new midwives, health visitors etc.

I needed to speak to my doctors one day, after the baby had been born and I'd returned to work, so I'd say a good year later, about the little one as she was unwell.

I called the doctors 96 times before I managed to get through.
Once I'd finally got through, the doctors were telling me they couldn't find any record of her etc etc.
I was getting quite tetchy at this point as I'd taken her for her jabs, postnatal checks etc.

After a bit of back and forth with the receptionist, I asked which doctors I'd called. It was my old surgery...

Called the new one and got straight through Grin

KingsleyShacklebolt · 13/09/2021 13:58

There was a piece on the BBC news at 1 about this, about how although the NHS stands for national health service, there's not much "service".

starfishmummy · 13/09/2021 13:57

@Bagamoyo1

Can I ask people what the solution is?

At our surgery we have several receptionists and several phones, and they answer the phones as soon as it rings. The second they put the phone down it rings again and they answer.
We have enough consulting rooms in our surgery to house enough doctors and nurses at a ratio of about 1 doctor per 2000 patients (standard quota). All the rooms are used all day Monday-Friday. Every doctor and nurse has a full surgery morning and afternoon.

So we can't employ more doctors/nurses as there aren't any spare rooms. We can't create more rooms as there's no space for them (we've already extended once and lost some car park).
We can't work longer hours as we already work 8-8.

We can't find more doctors even if we had the room (in fact we have actually advertised for an extra doctor, thinking we could use the meeting room as a consulting room, but we haven't had a single applicant).

Our doctor to patient ratio is normal, and has been the same for the 25+ years I've worked there.

The fact that our surgeries are all full means that clearly some patients are able to get through on the phone.

So tell me, if you were given the job of improving access at my surgery, what would you do? I'm especially interested as we have had this discussion countless times, and have yet to find a solution.

I'm sure it's frustrating on both sides. Not sure what the answer is though because even if you had a hundred doctors it probably still wouldn't be enough.

I know one thing the surgery I go to could do is to keep the website up to date. I have heard from a relaiable relative who also goes there, that the hours have changed but there's nothing on the website to tell me that.

Faffinator · 13/09/2021 13:46

@Bagamoyo1 I agree demand is massively more than supply and I don't have an answer. But wouldn't it be a start for there to be multiple ways to access the GP and a variety of prebookable and non-bookable appointments? I know I'd get less of the rage if I could see via an app that there were no appointments available, rather than wait in a phone queue for 50 minutes to be told the same.

Taybz · 13/09/2021 13:41

@IAmADancer it's horrible isn't it? My GP is exactly like this. Lines open at 8 and you get a busy tone from the get go. I called 258 times in a row last week!! It's a joke that you can only get appointments on the day as well. Have you complained to them? Ours also avoid giving face to face appointments whenever they can.

Bagamoyo1 · 13/09/2021 13:31

[quote Faffinator]@Bagamoyo1 There should be a system of booking that exists somewhere between 6 - 8 weeks ahead and on the day only. 3- 4 days perhaps? And all surgeries should have the option to book online or by phone. There's just no reasonable excuse for this not to be possible. In developed countries all over the world you can pick up your phone, book an appointment and see a GP. It needs to be the same here.[/quote]
But tell me, what happens when all the appointments are taken? What then?

Bagamoyo1 · 13/09/2021 13:29

@India92

I sympathize, but what are the point of these GP surgery threads?

The government have failed to recruit and retain GPs despite an aging population. There is a nationwide shortage and GP surgeries are doing the best that they can. What more can they do if there's no GPs to recruit?

Don't bash overworked and over-stressed GPs, bash the government who have failed GP surgeries and the NHS.

What do you honestly expect the surgery to do? Do you think they love having a constant stream of angry patients calling them up?

exactly!
Faffinator · 13/09/2021 13:28

@Bagamoyo1 There should be a system of booking that exists somewhere between 6 - 8 weeks ahead and on the day only. 3- 4 days perhaps? And all surgeries should have the option to book online or by phone. There's just no reasonable excuse for this not to be possible. In developed countries all over the world you can pick up your phone, book an appointment and see a GP. It needs to be the same here.

AnneElliott · 13/09/2021 13:28

For those asking for solutions they way my previous surgery worked was quite good.

They allowed pre booked appointments for routine or regular matters and they were for the afternoon and the evening.

The morning appointments were turn up and wait - and they started at 8am but you could queue outside as early as you wanted to. There were 3 Drs and yuu were generally seen quite quickly unless you only wanted to see a specific one. So although there was a wait, you'd definitely be seen by 12 noon. So you could pick the day that you didn't work, or actually book leave in advance with your job and just turn up and wait. I often turned up at 7:30 and was number 2/2 in the queue and was seen and on my way to work at 8:15am.

randomlyLostInWales · 13/09/2021 13:24

Couple of things. Firstly, Mondays are the absolute worst. I suggest trying again tomorrow or Wednesday. I find Thursdays tend to be quite successful in getting appts.

Mondays and Fridays are always worst here- I assume eveyone's had to wait over the weekend or worry about waiting and getting worse over up coming weekend.

QueenofKattegat · 13/09/2021 13:23

@Knittingupastorm

There are always ways to contact your gp surgery online. It's in the contract.

In order to contact my surgery online you need to register and then turn up at the surgery with two forms of ID so they can give you a login. All reasonable to protect patient information of course.
However, it is currently impossible to do this as the doors are locked and you are only allowed in with an appointment. If you turn up with the ID, and knock on the window to talk to them (the only way to talk to them) they say they aren’t doing that at the moment and won’t look at it. They then slam the window shut.
I know this because it happened to me last week.

I wonder if you live in my town. I had the same experience last week. Our GP use something called PatientAccess which is supposed to allow you to book appointments online. You can't register for it unless you take I.D. to the surgery and then they will give you a code. Can't be done via email, over the 'phone, by letter, you have to turn up. I did. I took time off work, stood outside the locked surgery for 40 minutes and when it was finally my turn, I was turned away as they aren't doing this anymore.
Spidey66 · 13/09/2021 13:20

@PizzaCrust

What is wrong with some of the posters on this thread? Honestly. It’s like reading anti feminist bingo on here:
  • OP is a woman so possibly can’t put her needs first and get a GP appointment
  • OP has a “feminine” ailment so other women are now telling her that she shouldn’t get an appointment for it (if she had a physical injury I doubt the responses would be the same)
  • OP has been told she doesn’t know how to use the phone. I’m sure someone who is at least, what, 35 years old knows how phones work.
  • OP has been called “precious” amongst other names. Again, it would be doubtful that anyone would call someone worried about their child to the point of needing a GP appointment “precious”
  • Other posters have took it upon themselves to (apparently) magically access OPs medical records and diagnose themselves that she “doesn’t need” an appointment, despite OP clearly telling us all that she does due to another condition. If she has been told by someone who is a medical professional and who actually has access to her notes she needs a blood test, I highly doubt nurse Barbara who lives 300 miles away and has never met OP knows any better. Oh, yes. They’re just assuming.
  • People think because what happens in their little world is what happens to all of us. Just because your surgery has a queue system doesn’t mean OPs does. Who knew that people living in different parts of the world would have different circumstances to content with. What a revelation.

Also, if I see any more posts about a “blood bottle shortage” and they’re only doing blood tests if it’s “urgent”- I am going to fucking scream. You don’t know if it’s urgent. You have no bloody clue whether it’s urgent. I don’t care what job you do for the NHS- stop being so fucking patronising. Unless any poster on here knows OP, knows her medical history, knows her surgery and their protocol- you have no right to act like you know fuck all about it. So sit back down.

Similarly, it isn’t OPs fault there’s a shortage. She is fully entitled to ring her GP and request a blood test due to x valid reasons.

This thread is an absolute disgrace. And for all the healthcare workers who have came on here to lambast the OP, shame on you. You should know better than anyone that you don’t make assumptions in healthcare. That’s how people end up misdiagnosed and potentially die.

Shameful.

PizzaCrust I love you.

Drives me mad. MN thinks noone is ever entitled to NHS treatment ever.

Mickarooni · 13/09/2021 13:19

@IAmADancer

Couple of things. Firstly, Mondays are the absolute worst. I suggest trying again tomorrow or Wednesday. I find Thursdays tend to be quite successful in getting appts. Secondly, my GP moved to only phone at 8 am appointments for urgent and routine. I phoned for some blood test results one afternoon and a kind receptionist mentioned they do have some routine appointments! They had absolutely never advised this. I booked ahead of time. It was in 3 weeks but I felt I could wait. Obviously not sure if you can wait but definitely worth asking, :)

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 13/09/2021 13:16

My surgery is the same - no e-consult or email booking. I wanted to see someone about a non-urgent issue (gastric), and phoned at a lunchtime, explained to the receptionist that it was absolutely not a same-day situation, and she actually booked me in for about six weeks down the line. Might that be worth trying, OP?

I had a phone appointment, and then had to go into the surgery for tests later on. The doctor was able to ring a prescription through to the local pharmacy on the same day as the appointment.

ineedsun · 13/09/2021 13:11

@Bagamoyo1

The problem with having pre-bookable appointments is that they all get booked up weeks in advance. We used to have a system of about 80% pre-bookable, and 20% urgent on the day. The problem was that people would then be offered an appointment in 6 -8 weeks. They didn't feel they could wait that long, but equally they didn't feel their problem was urgent. There was nowhere for them to go. So we introduced non-urgent-book-on-the-day, but they fill up by 8.30am. The number of GPs has gone down by about 2000 in the past few years, in the time period that the government promised an extra 5000 GPs! There just aren't enough of us to meet the demand. Meanwhile houses are built and people move in and register with us, and our list size goes up and up.
Yes!!

But people aren’t interested in the bigger picture, generally speaking they just want to complain when they can’t get what they want and direct that at the closest person

BlackTee40 · 13/09/2021 13:11

@IAmADancer

Just that. I need to get a blood test referral for menopause symptoms but I can’t get through. I started calling at 8am and have called over 200 times. It’s still engaged.

I know that if I call back at 10am when it’s quieter they will tell me there are no appointments and to call back tomorrow. Then you go through the same routine all over again. I just want to access basic care. Feeling very frustrated

I did that for 3 months straight, every working day, until I managed to get an appointment once.

Fucking joke.

user1497207191 · 13/09/2021 13:09

@India92

I sympathize, but what are the point of these GP surgery threads?

The government have failed to recruit and retain GPs despite an aging population. There is a nationwide shortage and GP surgeries are doing the best that they can. What more can they do if there's no GPs to recruit?

Don't bash overworked and over-stressed GPs, bash the government who have failed GP surgeries and the NHS.

What do you honestly expect the surgery to do? Do you think they love having a constant stream of angry patients calling them up?

Lack of GP's today is also partly the fault of Blair/Brown who didn't increase medical school/training places by anywhere near enough during their 13 years in power either. The current government "could" double or treble medical school places, but that wouldn't "cure" the GP shortage until another 10 years or so! You can't train GPs in a few months!
ineedsun · 13/09/2021 13:07

I gave up after two pages, but re the shortage of blood vials, I’m really shocked that some surgeries are still doing routine blood tests.

My dad needs a blood test for cancer (secondary in his spine, to see if the medication to control it is working) they needed a request from the regional medical director for cancer services in order to agree to it. Took mum days of phoning around to get it.

AnneElliott · 13/09/2021 13:05

I feel for you op - it's completely unacceptable.

And as for posters confidently telling op what her GP surgery does and does not so please read the thread! Why does MN attract these types- keen to tell you that your own experience isn't right despite knowing nothing about you or where you live!

My advice is to complain to the practise manager about the fact that they don't offer ore booked appointments and that you need to be seen. That sometimes produces results.

The GP system definitely needs reform (I used to work for a big practice). They know the phone system is crap but have no incentive to change it. I'd charge GPs surgery for every patient that turns up at urgent care after not being able to get an appointment- hitting them in the pocket is the only way to drive the improvements.

bellabasset · 13/09/2021 13:04

I was sent a text saying I needed to book an annual health check to take bloods and then see the nurse 2 weeks later. The day after I go for my appointment I get a letter to say I need to have my bloods taken. As there was a shortage of blood tubes they were only able to do one test. I saw the HCA, who was lovely but she didn't tell me that. There were only 2 of us in the waiting room as our doctors are doing telephone consults. OP should be offered one of those and then the dr could book her blood test with the HCA, her blood test might be nothing more than anaemia for example which she could get treated. Doesn't mean she's not feeling unwell.

On our local BBC news the commentator said that for every covid patient in hospital 6 or 8 procedures, depending on the surgery, were cancelled. I think we're expecting mask wearing and working from home to continue now.

India92 · 13/09/2021 13:02

I sympathize, but what are the point of these GP surgery threads?

The government have failed to recruit and retain GPs despite an aging population. There is a nationwide shortage and GP surgeries are doing the best that they can. What more can they do if there's no GPs to recruit?

Don't bash overworked and over-stressed GPs, bash the government who have failed GP surgeries and the NHS.

What do you honestly expect the surgery to do? Do you think they love having a constant stream of angry patients calling them up?

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 13/09/2021 12:57

You wait until you lose someone needlessly….because you will

This was my MIL a few years ago

LivingInABuildingSite · 13/09/2021 12:56

@Bagamoyo1

The fact is that the NHS has been chronically underfunded for decades, despite the ageing population being known about. It's been hanging by a thread for years, and Covid has tipped it over the edge.

As a population we are getting older, with more complex needs, and higher expectations of duration and quality of life. Meeting these needs costs money, and the money wasn't spent when it should have been.

This is very true.

And I take all your responses to my suggestions, I just don’t know what else to suggest. You’d have thought of it already anyway I’m sure.

The long term answer is more: more doctors, more nurses, more all levels of staff involved.

And maybe not move houses built everywhere that’s already full!

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 13/09/2021 12:56

Pre covid

You could ring the surgery at any time of the day…you may be in a queue….you could make an appointment in advance (usually you had no choice, quite often appointments would be 6 weeks in advance!)…if you felt it was urgent you could speak to the triage nurse who would give you advice or make a same day appointment with them or make a same day appointment with a doctor or make a future appointment

Now

You ring at 8am….if the queue is too long it will hang up on you….you can only make a same day appointment IF there are any appointments left