Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Work now tells everyone why you’re off? AIBU to think it’s a bit naff?

212 replies

ContactTraced · 13/09/2021 08:14

At work we’ve recently appointed a new senior manager. They’ve brought with them a new sickness policy…

First; no more emailing in; you have to call his mobile directly and explain why you are going to be off.

Second; and this is the bit I think is a bit crap… and email comes out everyday with a list of who is not in the building and why, it doesn’t go into masses of detail but does say if someone is “WFH” “Meeting” or “Sick” for example.

This is supposedly so we can “support” in places where they might have a lot of people off, but AIBU to think this is a little crap; and is actually meant to encourage presenteeism… which is a bit irresponsible considering the pandemic isn’t over yet!

OP posts:
Notjustanymum · 13/09/2021 11:32

It’s definitely “personal data” OP, so clearly in breach of GDPR, since it also identifies the person(s) to other colleagues. My Employer has even introduced a new “Out of Office” message that we set for Outlook and we aren’t allowed to state any reason for absence ourselves!
You should contact your Company ICO or Legal Team point this breach out.

amillionrosepetals · 13/09/2021 11:28

@godmum56. I think the problem in that particular instance was that my manager was very much a 'by the book' person and often took it to extremes. A colleague who had a lot of health problems used to say 'time for my interview with Dr *Smith' whenever she had been off sick.

prh47bridge · 13/09/2021 11:22

@sirfredfredgeorge

Explicit consent is one of these conditions but there are 9 others that allow sensitive information to be shared without consent

None of those could realistically be used to share information with colleagues though, as you note, so I was being simplistic.

Your view on the ICO is different to mine, and have certainly not imposed any large fines in my mind, but that is of course a matter of degree, but the fines so far have always been less than the profit gained from not being compliant.

The little enforcement they do is to justify their chocolate budget

BA were fined £20M last year. They did not gain any profit from being non-compliant. Similarly, Marriott Hotels were fined £18.4M for breaches that did not gain them any profit. Those were the two biggest fines to date. Before GDPR was introduced 3 years ago, the biggest fine the ICO could impose was £500k. A number of companies were fined at that level.
brittleheadgirl · 13/09/2021 11:19

@HarrietsChariot and how exactly do you know that's true? I'm genuinely intrigued!

My friend has the odd day off and has even been away on a mini break after texting to say she's sick.
She is a well regarded employee and nobody has a clue she does it, how would they?

starfishmummy · 13/09/2021 11:09

To be honest where I work the absence and brief reason would get round quickly enough anyway. I can see it would be useful to know if the absence is going to be for a known fixed time (eg leave) or open ended (sickness). Appointments I'd lump in with leave.

LeafOfTruth · 13/09/2021 10:56

Insisting on you calling in = totally normal

Sending an email about who is out sick = seems ok to me, as is saying whether or not it's Covid consdering it's a pandemic and it helps people who may have been in contact with you. More details than that and I would be upset too.

godmum56 · 13/09/2021 10:55

@amillionrosepetals

Totally reasonable to expect an employee to phone in to say they are unwell. Perfectly reasonable to inform other staff that someone is off sick. Out of order to say that someone is attending a medical appointment. Where I used to work the policy was that when you came back to work after being off sick you had to have a 'back to work' interview where you and your manager discussed your illness and how your attendance record could be improved. The official line was so that they could offer support but unofficially it was seen as a way to make skivers feel uncomfortable. After I had once been off sick for a day with a tummy bug I was asked how many times I had had diarrhea that day, had I taken any medicine, had I rang the doctor for advice.
I used to do those interviews and I would NEVER have asked how many episodes. I worked in the NHS and we had a rule that it had to be 48 hours after the last episode of D orV before you could return to work. What people often didn't realise was that this meant that you could NOT take medicine to suppress the ilness as this meant that you might come back to work infectious. people would say to me proudly "Oh yes I phoned the doctor and they said to take loperamide and here I am ready to work again" and I would have to send them home.
Mantlemoose · 13/09/2021 10:54

@amillionrosepetals

Totally reasonable to expect an employee to phone in to say they are unwell. Perfectly reasonable to inform other staff that someone is off sick. Out of order to say that someone is attending a medical appointment. Where I used to work the policy was that when you came back to work after being off sick you had to have a 'back to work' interview where you and your manager discussed your illness and how your attendance record could be improved. The official line was so that they could offer support but unofficially it was seen as a way to make skivers feel uncomfortable. After I had once been off sick for a day with a tummy bug I was asked how many times I had had diarrhea that day, had I taken any medicine, had I rang the doctor for advice.
Exactly what we do no however the back to work interview is also intended to provide a safe secure one to one space in the hope that opening up a conversation will give the employee an opportunity to bring to the head any issues the employer can help with. Anyone seeing it as anything else pretty much is yep, skivving!
TeacupDrama · 13/09/2021 10:53

I see nothing wrong with

Fred on annual leave until 17th September
john working from home
Susan annual leave till 14th September
jane off sick until 17th September
Pamela doesn't work Mondays
james away until 2pm

I do see something wrong with
Jim hospital appointment until 2pm
Jane on holiday in maldives until 20th September
Susan has covid isolation ends 19th September
John emergency leave for his three kids
David working from home !!!!!!
Pete dentist appointment at 3,30
Ann off sick and won't say with what it's personal

anniegun · 13/09/2021 10:53

Given the number of people that complained that they were not told when colleagues had tested positive with Covid I can completely see why communicating this is a good thing

amillionrosepetals · 13/09/2021 10:46

Totally reasonable to expect an employee to phone in to say they are unwell.
Perfectly reasonable to inform other staff that someone is off sick.
Out of order to say that someone is attending a medical appointment.
Where I used to work the policy was that when you came back to work after being off sick you had to have a 'back to work' interview where you and your manager discussed your illness and how your attendance record could be improved. The official line was so that they could offer support but unofficially it was seen as a way to make skivers feel uncomfortable. After I had once been off sick for a day with a tummy bug I was asked how many times I had had diarrhea that day, had I taken any medicine, had I rang the doctor for advice.

godmum56 · 13/09/2021 10:42

The only one I can see a problem with is "medical appointment" because that does open the door to speculation about private matters, but phoning in and publicising the reason for not being at base in very general terms is normal and acceptable, especially with WFH in the mix

sirfredfredgeorge · 13/09/2021 10:39

Explicit consent is one of these conditions but there are 9 others that allow sensitive information to be shared without consent

None of those could realistically be used to share information with colleagues though, as you note, so I was being simplistic.

Your view on the ICO is different to mine, and have certainly not imposed any large fines in my mind, but that is of course a matter of degree, but the fines so far have always been less than the profit gained from not being compliant.

The little enforcement they do is to justify their chocolate budget

FirewomanSam · 13/09/2021 10:37

That sounds really normal for every place i’ve ever worked. If you know they’re sick rather than WFH then you know they’re not available for calls etc. My last workplace had a webpage where you could look up people’s availability and it would tell you if they were sick, WFH, not working that day (if they were part time), on holiday, travelling for business etc.

SunLovingMum · 13/09/2021 10:34

Going against the grain here but I see nothing wrong with this.

Notifying your manager by phone if illness is not unreasonable

Indicating whereabouts and availability of staff seems reasonable. For those who are listed as sick, I would expect them not to be called or expected to work that day whereas those listed as WFH or Meeting should be expected to reply / be contactable during the day albeit delayed response from those in a meeting.

saraclara · 13/09/2021 10:33

It makes perfect sense for people to know if someone is in a meeting/WFH/ or sick. That enables colleagies to know whether or not thay're going to be available shortly or not, and whether to bother them with something or not. And as PP said, removes the need to be asking around constantly.

As long as the reason for sickness/medical appointment isn't revealed it seems fine to me. It's just the digital equivalent of the grapevine that's always happened when people are off.

LindaEllen · 13/09/2021 10:33

I can understand needing to know who is off each day, BUT, there shouldn't be a reason next to it. That is an invasion of privacy.

Bluesheep8 · 13/09/2021 10:30

We have to call in, on the grounds that anyone could send an email or text, and they need to make sure it is you.

Snap. And I completely agree with this reasoning.

Tumbleweed101 · 13/09/2021 10:29

Those on early shift will message our group chat if they can't make it in to open up so the next person in knows and can try and get in sooner but otherwise we are meant to call the boss/deputy with detail. If they are going to be in work after us we also call the building to let the staff already there know so staff deployment can be managed easier.

With a phone call you know someone is aware you are going to be off rather than wondering if the text or email has been seen in time.

We are a small team so we will always know why someone is off- ie if its holiday or illness.

prh47bridge · 13/09/2021 10:18

@sirfredfredgeorge

Sigh. Why do people (even the ones who say they don’t know) spout GDPR for everything. Telling an office who is in or out doesn’t breech GDPR

The only grounds for processing sensitive personal information is consent, sickness is sensitive personal information, therefore consent is required.

The ICO won't give a shit, because they never give a shit about the law, it came from the EU.

Data concerning someone's health is indeed sensitive. However, it is completely wrong to say it can only be processed with consent. Any of the lawful reasons for processing non-sensitive data can still be used. However, the data controller also needs to identify one of the 10 conditions for processing sensitive information. Explicit consent is one of these conditions but there are 9 others that allow sensitive information to be shared without consent.

Any data related to an indentifiable living individual is classified as personal data, so even flagging that someone is working from home is personal data. However, flagging that someone is off sick is likely to be a breach of GDPR. Revealing the nature of their sickness would clearly be a breach, although, in my experience, many employers share too much information with members of the absentee's team.

It is not true that the ICO don't care about the law. They have imposed large fines on some companies. However, their resources are limited so they can't deal with everything. I suspect they wouldn't do anything more than issue some advice to the employer and they may not even do that. However, individuals affected by this have the right to sue their employer over any data breach.

reluctantbrit · 13/09/2021 10:14

To ring your manager is expected in my office. The one time I had no voice I rang, and put DH straight on the phone to explain what was going on.

Very often we text first thing and then ring when the office opens so we can also explain what work is urgent and need coverage. If you can’t speak then you wrote a short mail.

I would complain to HR about the absence email though. We have a list everyone gets but it only shows the managers and sickness is only shown if it is a long term thing or planned surgery etc so people know someone is out for longer and they then go straight to the other team members instead of emailing or phoning people who aren’t on for weeks.

TakeYourFinalPosition · 13/09/2021 10:09

This used to happen when I worked at a big FTSE company… it was quite useful, to be fair. Knowing if someone is working from home, so available, or sick (and therefore might be off for any length of time) or on annual leave so will have a set return date was quite helpful…

And almost everyone would have that in their out of office anyway, so it wasn’t sharing more than they’d usually know, just putting it in an easy accessible list that helps to reduce how many emails John gets while he’s off so people can see if he’s got a return date or if he’s off sick etc.

TallulahBetty · 13/09/2021 10:08

This is standard I thought. We get an email every day with who is in, WFH, sick, A/L. No one knows WHY you are sick.

KaptanKatanga · 13/09/2021 10:05

I once told my boss I was having my genital warts burnt off when she kept pressing me for my illness.

Grin

OP, does the boss ask why you are sick and want personal details when you call?

ddl1 · 13/09/2021 10:04

I don't think it's so unreasonable of him to request a phone call ; but listing all the absentees with reasons for their absence is totally unreasonable.