Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Work now tells everyone why you’re off? AIBU to think it’s a bit naff?

212 replies

ContactTraced · 13/09/2021 08:14

At work we’ve recently appointed a new senior manager. They’ve brought with them a new sickness policy…

First; no more emailing in; you have to call his mobile directly and explain why you are going to be off.

Second; and this is the bit I think is a bit crap… and email comes out everyday with a list of who is not in the building and why, it doesn’t go into masses of detail but does say if someone is “WFH” “Meeting” or “Sick” for example.

This is supposedly so we can “support” in places where they might have a lot of people off, but AIBU to think this is a little crap; and is actually meant to encourage presenteeism… which is a bit irresponsible considering the pandemic isn’t over yet!

OP posts:
OddSockBandit · 14/09/2021 10:52

@ContactTraced

Sorry I wasn’t clear.

If someone is off with covid or has to isolate it says “Covid”
If someone has a medical appointment it says “Medical”
If someone has just called in sick with anything but covid it says “Sick”

I think they are breaching GDPR guidelines by sharing personal data in that manner without permission and when that is not the purpose for which it was provided? It's completely unacceptable.

As for phoning in for sickness, I do not understand what the purpose of it is? Surely it's less admin for all involved to email. Managers should have better things to do with their time and a poorly employee is unlikely to feel like speaking on the phone. We have always just emailed our direct boss and blocked out the day as unavailable in our shared calendar. I can't see why anything further would be necessary.

OddSockBandit · 14/09/2021 10:48

That is appalling. You'd think with vacancies at an all time high companies would be realising that they need to improve pay and conditions and give staff autonomy, flexibility and respect if they want to retain them.

SarahBellam · 13/09/2021 23:09

I don't have a problem with this. It means you know who you can contact and who you should leave alone. Mentioning Covid is sensible because it means people who were in contact with them can take precautions. As long as it's 'sick' and not 'Sandra's uterus has prolapsed' or 'Geoff has a suspected dose of the clap', then I don't see the problem.

EBearhug · 13/09/2021 23:00

We get emails “Jill is off sick today and Joe has a medical appointment but will be in after lunchtime”. It’s helpful to know when we get phone calls or emails for them from clients. We don’t get details, no breach of privacy.

But it could just say, "Jill is out today. Joe is out this morning, but will be in after lunchtime." You don't need to mention sickness or medical appointments at all.

echt · 13/09/2021 22:58

Sorry, should have said the absence bulletin that goes out to all staff at school would read: echt Personal Leave, All Day.

echt · 13/09/2021 22:57

I'm in public service in Victoria and there is only one description to cover sickness: Personal Leave. It also covers appointments to see solicitors/hospital/long service leave.

The person calls in and says I'm taking Personal Leave and sets their lessons. They have to record the leave in the state's system and upload certificates.

It seems to work.

Mickarooni · 13/09/2021 22:51

We get emails “Jill is off sick today and Joe has a medical appointment but will be in after lunchtime”. It’s helpful to know when we get phone calls or emails for them from clients. We don’t get details, no breach of privacy.

EBearhug · 13/09/2021 19:27

We used to get mails to the department with,"Pete is off with gastric illness" and things like that. Fortunately, these days it's just, "Pete will be out for the rest of the week," or whatever. I was half-tempted to come up with some deeply embarrassing illness before that, but (touch wood), I'm not often sick.

At one point, we used to get a list of why employees in the USA had had their employment terminated, which was a bit of an eye-opener. They have tightened a lot in the last decade or so.

Mind you, when we weren't told why a particular, unpopular manager was out for 3 months, the rumour mill went wild, with some people even wondering if he had to serve a short prison sentence. Which tells you a lot about what people thought of him. (It was something health-related, I think we found out in the end.)

It's useful to know people are out of the office and for how long, and to know if work is covered. Beyond that, it doesn't matter, though I would keep my line manager informed if it was going to be on-going/long-term. But I trust my current manager - the previous one I'd have only shared what is absolutely necessary.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 13/09/2021 19:08

So long as you don't divulge personal information such as "Tom is off with waterworks problems again" or "Angie has been up all night with menopausal night sweats and is exhausted" your not breaking any GDPR rules.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 13/09/2021 19:04

Completely normal in the NHS. Why wouldn't you phone in? Unless you're in a coma you can still talk even though feeling rough.

There is a valid reason and that's making sure your staff are ok. Them phoning you could lead to all sorts of discoveries such as domestic abuse that otherwise might not be noticed.

BetterCare · 13/09/2021 17:16

@BoredZeldaI don't think that the Data Protection Officer with over 20 years of experience miss understood their conversation with the ICO.

The list may not be a problem with a one-day stomach bug. But if you are having, for example, two days off every other week because you are sick from chemotherapy treatment or you have a flare-up of your autoimmune disease, or you are struggling with your mental health or you have really bad morning sickness and for any one of those reasons you are trying to keep it as private as possible and do not want to talk about it you absolute right for it to remain private.

There is Legitimate Interest for a direct manager and colleagues to know. There is, however, no legitimate interest for the whole company to know. It absolutely breaches your personal data for people to be able to work out, from the list being sent, that you may be taking a lot of sick days off or having a lot of medical appointments and then they either ask you about it or start rumours.

This is not about the ICO fining companies or even getting involved. It is not just about looking at the odd sick day. But there may be people who are dealing with a lot and have an absolute right for that information to be kept as private as necessary.

So I am not just spouting GDPR, I am not being ridiculous and yes this person who explained it to me knows their shit.

So in answer to OPs question, unless the company can show a legal basis they have no right to share that information with the whole company.

BoredZelda · 13/09/2021 16:52

That is not me pulling information from my arse that is something I know has been confirmed by the ICO.

I suspect someone has misunderstood what the ICO has said told them.

It is not against GDPR to tell people that a member of staff is off sick. It IS against GDPR if the sickness record is shared with staff.

You might argue there is a confidentiality issue, but there is not a GDPR breach.

BetterCare · 13/09/2021 16:30

@boredzelda Yes, it is a breach of personal data because it implies a health issue and it, therefore, requires a legal basis on which to share it. They can't use consent because they have not asked for it. They may be able to use Legitimate Interest, but they would have to show their reasoning for doing so.

That is not me pulling information from my arse that is something I know has been confirmed by the ICO.

BoredZelda · 13/09/2021 15:43

because GDPR and personal data matters. Telling the whole company that someone is sick or has a medical appointment indicates a "health issue" which is personal data as outlined by the ICO.

It is not a breech of GDPR to say someone is off sick. Don't be ridiculous.

PlanDeRaccordement · 13/09/2021 14:58

[quote BetterCare]@PlanDeRaccordement I am bit confused by your response. The OP said they sent around a list. That is what I am talking about.[/quote]
Sorry,
I was just saying we don’t know if the OPs list is in breach just because a list is sent out. The employees could have approved the status “wfh” or “sick” or whatever by their name as releasable information. In addition, by not objecting or asserting the information as personal when they give it to the supervisor, the employees forbearance could mean no violation as well.

BetterCare · 13/09/2021 13:46

@PlanDeRaccordement I am bit confused by your response. The OP said they sent around a list. That is what I am talking about.

PlanDeRaccordement · 13/09/2021 13:38

@BetterCare
Our system doesn’t breach GDPR because each person decides what to put by their status, we have full control over our status and we know it is viewable by anyone. It would only be a breach if the information were given in confidence to another person and that person then released it.

BetterCare · 13/09/2021 13:32

@boredzelda because GDPR and personal data matters. Telling the whole company that someone is sick or has a medical appointment indicates a "health issue" which is personal data as outlined by the ICO.

It may make a difference if it was just sent to relevant people. However, in order to send the list to all employees the company has to have a lawful basis in order to do so.

So I am not just spouting GDPR. If people are private they have a right to have their personal data protected and not for the whole company to know they have a doctors appointment.

ClareBlue · 13/09/2021 12:54

Anything we potentially don't like has to breach GDP. You have been permitted to identify Covid as a reason for absence from the work place due to contact tracing etc, you are permitted to inform colleagues reasons for absence without giving medical details if it is sickeness, you can require a telephone call as long as it is required for everyone
In fact you can actually manage your work force and sickness absence and doing this isn't an attack on your rights or breaches of Data Protection.
It seems to be a default position for anything that people don't like.

PlanDeRaccordement · 13/09/2021 12:44

We have similar policy. You can email that you are sick of you’ve called and its gone to voice mail. I usually let my secretary and my boss know so they can take care of my schedule and so on.

We also do track in real time who is in the building and who isn’t, even visitors. This is because in event of emergency evacuation you have to be able to account for everyone who is in the building. There’s no sense sending in fire rescue for Jacques if he is away at a meeting. This data is similar in that people put whatever they are comfortable with for their status. So “sick” “medical appt” “meeting at location y” or “wfh” are very common.

LBOCS2 · 13/09/2021 12:38

We have a policy for phone calls as well - that's completely normal.

I think reasonableness of the email around saying where people are depends on the situation and the workplace. My team are often out on site and we all WFH as a matter of course, so if someone's off sick it is very useful to know as they won't be chased/no one will assume that they're 'available' in the way we would usually. However I don't think it's appropriate to go to the whole company unless literally everyone in the company could be reasonably expecting correspondence from that team.

godmum56 · 13/09/2021 12:34

[quote amillionrosepetals]**@godmum56*. I think the problem in that particular instance was that my manager was very much a 'by the book' person and often took it to extremes. A colleague who had a lot of health problems used to say 'time for my interview with Dr Smith' whenever she had been off sick.[/quote]
yeah...you can't do much about duff management...it sounds to me as though the "doctor" didn't understand the reasoning behind the practice!

sirfredfredgeorge · 13/09/2021 12:31

BA were fined £20M last year. They did not gain any profit from being non-compliant

I imagine we disagree on the cost of ensuring compliance and security in the system in the first place, I see no penalty in 20 million, that's what it would've cost to have protection in place. I would've at the original proposed 183mill. It's similar with Marriot, the added profit in these cases come from not having to put any security in.

Dontwatchfootball · 13/09/2021 11:41

I would have said this was not ok had I not had the example of my boss being off for some months and being given no info as to why. As he had previous health problems we assumed it was that. Turned out his child had died. He came back to a bunch of cheery people asking him, 1 at a time when they saw him, 'are you feeling better?' I was horrified when he told me why he had been off. And furious that no one in the management line had thought to warn us so that the poor man did not have that experience. Similarly when my mother died. So I am in favour as long as they dont go into a bunch of detail.

LookItsMeAgain · 13/09/2021 11:40

I'd be asking for a bit more privacy to be honest. It really shouldn't matter if you're off sick with a stomach bug, the flu or migraine for example, you're just off and are unavailable.
Just as you would be unavailable if you were on annual leave you're still as unavailable there too.
Imagine if you were in the early stages of a miscarriage, and you phoned your manager to let them know you won't be in work. You wouldn't want anyone to know that you're going through that and you are not unwell in the traditional sense of being 'sick' so I wouldn't want anyone knowing if it were me.
There has to be some privacy thing that they are going very close to being in breach of I'd imagine.
Your manager would have to let your team know that you wont be in but they shouldn't divulge why you wont be in. At least that is what I would expect to happen. If the manager is any good that is.