Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
CheltenhamLady · 13/09/2021 17:36

@MattyGroves

Faith schools are part funded (to the tune of quite a lot of money) by the church/religion. The state would have an enormous funding gap to fill if they refused to have faith schools..

Nonsense. New faith schools have 90% capital funding from the state plus all of their ongoing costs. But somehow 100% control over admissions. There's a more complicated issue with older faith schools where the land belongs to the church (but often all the maintenance for decades has been paid for by the taxpayer)

Taxpayers, who are also members of different faiths and want their children to be schooled in faith schools?

You use the word 'taxpayer' as if no one who goes to church pays tax!

I don't agree with much of what my taxes are used for but I have no choice in the matter. Ditto those who oppose faith schools.

Rannva · 13/09/2021 17:35

I've campaigned against this for years with the Humanist association. All the schools bar one in my town are discriminatory schools, and as there are far more children than places every school is oversubscribed by 15-20 applicants. No non-religious kid has gotten a place at a faith school since I started following the data about 16 years ago. Therefore all the religious ones can choose the most devout/sharp-elbowed, and the rest of us are stuck travelling 2-3 towns away.

Many parents here fake religion to get in. They discuss at nursery school which church they're attending. The churches demand two years attendance with no grandparents - only parents. The Sunday service looks like a nursery school - buggies up the aisles and nothing but families whipping out crayons for toddlers as far as the eye can see.

Other parents are known to pop into the Greek Orthodox Churches, or the Romanian ones, some of which demand only 2-4 weeks attendance, to have their forms signed. Despite not being Greek, Romanian, or at all religious.

The churches don't want to change it as they know attendance will plummet if it no longer has a bearing on little Tarquin's entrance forms. They will only be left with the genuinely religious, who'll probably be glad of the peace. The government don't want to change it as they know so many thousands of their voters play this game and would be outraged if they can't "choose" the "best" school by spending not money, but time. Not everyone can give up every Sunday for 1-2 years to fake-attend services/Mass, and I would have thought more would be morally opposed to it.

Should have seen one mum slink away when she joined us at the gates saying how worried she was, like us, that her kid had no chance of getting in anywhere, yet when places were doled out she'd been warming the pews at St Fakealot's for a couple of years. Had us all convinced she was one of us and clearly couldn't admit she was playing the game.

mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 17:35

Have you actually seen that happening?

I haven't seen it myself, but the way things are going, all the CF**ery and entitlement, it wouldn't surprise me

MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 17:33

@mustlovegin

This topic has been done to death OP. You seem to want to send your DC to a faith school and benefit from all the advantages but not bother with them adopting that religion? That's taking the P**S, surely
Well they seem to want to take my taxes but not bother with my children 🙄
ErrolTheDragon · 13/09/2021 17:32

@mustlovegin

Even if all faith schools were privately funded, people would still argue that they if they were not admitted because they did not belong to that religion, it was discrimination Hmm
I don't think there's any evidence of that. There are plenty of religious private schools, so if people were going to complain they'd be doing it already. Have you actually seen that happening?
mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 17:29

Even if all faith schools were privately funded, people would still argue that they if they were not admitted because they did not belong to that religion, it was discrimination Hmm

mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 17:25

This topic has been done to death OP. You seem to want to send your DC to a faith school and benefit from all the advantages but not bother with them adopting that religion? That's taking the P**S, surely

ErrolTheDragon · 13/09/2021 17:06

The CofE is a 'broad church', including fundamentalist evangelicals on the one hand and nonrealist theists on the other. SunIsBehind's unevidenced opinion/anecdote probably isn't worth unpicking tbh.

MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 17:02

Faith schools are part funded (to the tune of quite a lot of money) by the church/religion. The state would have an enormous funding gap to fill if they refused to have faith schools..

Nonsense. New faith schools have 90% capital funding from the state plus all of their ongoing costs. But somehow 100% control over admissions. There's a more complicated issue with older faith schools where the land belongs to the church (but often all the maintenance for decades has been paid for by the taxpayer)

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 16:58

@LaetitiaASD my DH doesn't believe God exists.

However, he is always a Jew in the eyes of the world- his name, his hair, his north london accent, the schools on his CV. He was once at a Green Party meeting and he was told to leave by activists for the palestinian cause, he is a colonizer. Despite this, he still votes Green to this day but he knows that he would always be regarded as Jewish no matter how much he claims to be irreligious.

So when our child is born jewish, we decide to educate our child in our faith so that he or she would have a support network when he or she is called a 'filthy jew/colonizer' in future (and that would probably happen at some point). I decided to convert so that our family could share the same religion. Two of my husband's sisters are in the process of moving to israel/have moved to israel, the hebrew learned from their time in Jewish school would put them in good stead.

Eggfriedpower · 13/09/2021 16:55

@SunIsBehindGreySky

CofE gave up being Christian a while back in my opinion. I gather Charles plans to quit Christianity for some new faith, a woke universal morale code, so this is what the CofE is preparing for, a mash up of ideologies, defender of faths he will be. The new state religion will be the international woke ideologies and a kind of mash up with Christianity etc.
The CofE still doesn't allow gay couples to get married in their churches. Hardly "woke".
AlexaShutUp · 13/09/2021 16:53

@MrsColon

Faith schools are part funded (to the tune of quite a lot of money) by the church/religion. The state would have an enormous funding gap to fill if they refused to have faith schools.

I'm RC, I contribute to the collection every week - I want my son to go to a Catholic school. He can't, because there isn't one nearby, but I don't begrudge paying so that other Catholic children can benefit. I'd be pretty annoyed if non-Catholic children were prioritised over Catholics (unless they're vulnerable/looked after etc.).

If faith schools were funded exclusively by the church (or other relevant religious body), then I think you would have a valid point. But as they get a large proportion of their funding from taxpayers, I don't think it's fair that your child should have more options than mine.
ofwarren · 13/09/2021 16:53

@SunIsBehindGreySky

What about the CofE is no longer Christian, exactly?

They stopped believing that God created man and woman and doesn't make mistakes, they now offer multiple baptisms for human (politician, Dr, charity, individual) created man and woman under the ideological belief that God makes mistakes.

I'm confused by this comment. What are you referring to? None of this happens in the church where I live.
TooBigForMyBoots · 13/09/2021 16:46

What is a Jewish child other than an innocent child having nonsense rammed down their throat without being able to give informed consent?

Jewish history, culture and religion is not "nonsense".ShockHmm

LaetitiaASD · 13/09/2021 16:39

@MattyGroves

I also don't think it's unreasonable to want to send your kids to the school that they could literally see into from our house rather than walk a mile.
This
LaetitiaASD · 13/09/2021 16:39

@CayrolBaaaskin

Also *@storminborehamwood* no one is “marking your kid down” because they don’t have priority for a Jewish school. A Jewish school is the most appropriate place for a Jewish child. Sounds like a non denominational school may be the best place for your child.
What is a Jewish child other than an innocent child having nonsense rammed down their throat without being able to give informed consent?
MrsColon · 13/09/2021 16:38

Faith schools are part funded (to the tune of quite a lot of money) by the church/religion. The state would have an enormous funding gap to fill if they refused to have faith schools.

I'm RC, I contribute to the collection every week - I want my son to go to a Catholic school. He can't, because there isn't one nearby, but I don't begrudge paying so that other Catholic children can benefit. I'd be pretty annoyed if non-Catholic children were prioritised over Catholics (unless they're vulnerable/looked after etc.).

SunIsBehindGreySky · 13/09/2021 16:38

EishetChayil

My children are doing the same for my grandchildren for the same reasons. They have seen the consequences of the woke ideologies with their peers, one friend a transwiddow and another a puberty blocked, sterilised adult - now attending Autism assessments. I attended a faith school and they did not, they as I have had our faith strengthen due to woke ideologies over the past few years.

EishetChayil · 13/09/2021 16:17

I'm sending my DD to the school associated with our faith, because at least I can guarantee that she won't be told she's a boy if she shows a preference for trucks and science. Mainstream education is Mermaided up to the gills, and is failing our children.

Wed8pril · 13/09/2021 16:07

@SunIsBehindGreySky

What about the CofE is no longer Christian, exactly?

They stopped believing that God created man and woman and doesn't make mistakes, they now offer multiple baptisms for human (politician, Dr, charity, individual) created man and woman under the ideological belief that God makes mistakes.

Do you have a source for this? I'm not sure what you're talking about.
SunIsBehindGreySky · 13/09/2021 16:06

What about the CofE is no longer Christian, exactly?

They stopped believing that God created man and woman and doesn't make mistakes, they now offer multiple baptisms for human (politician, Dr, charity, individual) created man and woman under the ideological belief that God makes mistakes.

MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 16:00

I also don't think it's unreasonable to want to send your kids to the school that they could literally see into from our house rather than walk a mile.

MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 15:57

Surely if you are not religious, you would prefer a non-denominational school anyway

Of course. But where we used to live, our closest schools were religious and hadn't admitted anyone on distance grounds in years (based on their stats) and the nearest secular school we were too far away from to get into. So ironically, if we had stayed there, one of the most likely outcomes would have been a poorly performing religious school as those ones - for some reason... - are not over subscribed by religious parents..

I don't see why I should get less choice of schools when I get no choice about my taxes going to support schools that won't admit my kids

Wed8pril · 13/09/2021 15:56

@SunIsBehindGreySky

CofE gave up being Christian a while back in my opinion. I gather Charles plans to quit Christianity for some new faith, a woke universal morale code, so this is what the CofE is preparing for, a mash up of ideologies, defender of faths he will be. The new state religion will be the international woke ideologies and a kind of mash up with Christianity etc.
What about the CofE is no longer Christian, exactly?
Swipe left for the next trending thread